American Judicial System: The Death Penalty

1702 words - 7 pages

The death penalty has been part of the American judicial system since the country’s founding [1]. Most people see the death penalty as the fairest way to punish those who have killed, because, in the words of Supreme Court Justice Potter Stewart, “the instinct for retribution is part of the nature of man.” I do agree that the deliverance of justice is an important factor in any public policy. However, it is also important to consider the more pragmatic aspects, like the cost to the state. It is possible that the financial cost could be outweighed by the societal benefit. However, upon researching the death penalty, one would discover that the cost of capital punishment is unreasonably high, particularly in the state of California, especially when we consider how rarely the death sentence is actually implemented. In times like these, times of economic turmoil and scarce financial resources, the state cannot afford a system that is so expensive and also so rarely utilized. I believe that, in the state of California, the death penalty is overly expensive and so rarely implemented that it should be abolished.
The most expensive part of the capital punishment process is the initial trials and pre-trials [2]. During this phase, the person accused of murder is determined either guilty or innocent. It is also during this phase that they choose whether or not to sentence said person to death. According to statistics from the Death Penalty Information Center, capital trials (cases with the possibility of the death penalty) cost approximately one million dollars more than a non-capital case. To put it another way, the amount of money needed to sentence someone to death could pay for 8 years of school at Harvard University. The attribute cost is attributed to a few unique components of capital cases, which we will examine in the following paragraphs.
One of the major contributing factors to the cost of death penalty trials is the larger legal team. Because of the severity of both the crime and the punishment, both sides of the case are required by the American Bar Association to have two attorneys instead of one [3]. They are also required to have a private investigator, and a mitigation specialist (someone who looks for reasons that someone facing death row may not deserve it). Because most people facing the death penalty are extremely poor, they are commonly represented by the Public Defender, a service that is paid solely through taxpayer money [4].
Another unique aspect of capital punishment trials can be found in its specific jury selection requirements. The court goes on an arduous search for a “death-qualified” jury, meaning a jury that has no strong opinion on for or against the death penalty and would thus be unbiased [5]. In a capital case, the jury not only determines if the accused is guilty, but they also decide whether or not he is to be sentenced to death. According to the Connecticut Post, the search for a death-qualified jury...

Find Another Essay On American Judicial System: The Death Penalty

John Marshall's Effect on the American Judicial System

2697 words - 11 pages John Marshall's Effect on the American Judicial System I.Introduction In the early years of the eighteenth Century, the young United States of America were slowly adapting to the union and the way the country was governed. And just like the country, the governmental powers were starting to develop. Since the creation of the Constitution and due to the Connecticut Compromise, there is the Executive, the Legislative and the Judicial Power

Science and the Judicial System Essay

869 words - 3 pages Science and the Judicial System Science and the Judicial System are two concepts that at face value seem to be very distinct and unique in their own nature, but at their cores they share interesting similarities and connections. They each propose a different way of understanding how we comprehend and place order. In this paper I'll address my understanding of both concepts, analyze their theories, backbones and failures, and then bring them

The Death Penalty Debate

1768 words - 7 pages the judicial system. Finally, the most important factual question of the effectiveness is looked at regarding the death penalty’s ability to deter crime. The paper has looked to answer these questions and incite thoughts about the death penalty. The data discovered seems to point toward the fact that the death penalty might not have a future much longer as we progress through the 20th Century. Works Cited Works Cited Berry, III

Abolishing The Death Penalty

650 words - 3 pages .) “You don’t solve violence by committing violence.” (At Issue.) In general the fear that the death penalty is given disproportionately to racial minorities and the poor. “It is rare that a wealthy white man gets executed, if it happens at all,” Mr. McCann said. The goal the judicial system is to reform the ones found guilty of a particular crime. The death penalty contradicts this very aim. (iBuzzle.) The judicial process can determine whether the

Abolishing The Death Penalty

1011 words - 4 pages for an eye; a tooth for a tooth. But what many do not realize is that the death penalty is not without its faults. What makes the death penalty a conscientious issue is the underlying problems that are going on behind the scenes. The death penalty affects everyone and is not applied equally to all, and thus should be abolished to maintain the dignity of the United States and its judicial system. Capital punishment is not new to American

Abolish the Death Penalty

1104 words - 5 pages prove that death penalty decreases crimes. Countries that perform death penalty do not have lower crime rates compared to countries which have only life time imprisonment. Death penalty is the procedure that is irreversible. Our current judicial system is corrupt and abusive of death penalty. We must not implement death penalty because it can lead us to the possibility of wrongful execution. In the past, there had already been many people sentenced

The Death Penalty

607 words - 2 pages become a very strong and common word of the twenty-first century. In all crimes committed in the United States today, murder is the highest rated form of death for civilians. Every state has similar laws their state must abide by, and murder is plainly stated to be against the law. "We threaten punishments in order to deter crime"(Haag). Our judicial system uses the death penalty as persuasion to civilians not to commit crimes. So, our law

Death to the Death Penalty

1371 words - 6 pages inhuman or degrading treatment or punishment” (Human Rights #5 ) The death penalty violates these rights. " The death penalty is not an act of self-defense. It is in fact the premeditated killing of a prisoner who could be dealt with by less harsh means. An execution cannot be used to condemn killing. This would be the mirror image of the criminal’s willingness to use physical violence against a victim. No system can say who should live or who should

The Death Penalty

1710 words - 7 pages should be abolished, while others believe the death penalty should remain a viable option. There are many problems inherent with the death penalty, as a society striving for a perfect solution it should not be abolished rather fine tuned it to a changing society and culture. The effectiveness of the death penalty has been deluded by an inefficient and time consuming judicial system, further undermined by an accommodating correctional institution

The Death Penalty

1378 words - 6 pages proof that any innocent person has actually been executed since increased safeguards and appeals were added to our death penalty system in the 1970s. Even if such executions have occurred, they are very rare. Imprisoning innocent people is also wrong, but we cannot empty the prisons because of that minimal risk. If improvements are needed in the system of representation, or in the use of scientific evidence such as DNA testing, then those reforms

The Death Penalty - 1799 words

1799 words - 7 pages Arabia which are two of the world’s worst human rights violators (Friedman 34). Lauri Friedman quotes, “Executions simply inject more violence into an already hostile American society.” The cost of the Death Penalty is highly expensive. A case to put someone in jail costs on average two million three hundred thousand dollars on average while to put an inmate in jail for forty years cost on average seven hundred and sixty thousand dollars

Similar Essays

Criminal Justice System And The Death Penalty

2334 words - 9 pages ”( The foundation of the criminal justice system is certainly a profound and interesting topic to discuss and debate. In the American criminal justice system, cases of the most severe and heinous nature can be sentenced to the death penalty when appropriate. “The death penalty is a punishment by execution, administered to someone legally convicted of a capital crime” (Farlex). “In most American states, capital crime offenses consist of

The Ineffectiveness Of The Death Penalty In Our Legal System

1140 words - 5 pages that people are willing to fight capital punishment because they see it as a failure in any legal system. In addition, one of the most important developments has been the adoption of treaties that protest the death penalty as an infringement on civil and human rights and freedoms. Amnesty International has listed 4 in existance today, they are: the Second Optional Protocol to the International Covenant on Civil and Human Rights, the Protocol to

Death Penalty: An Effective Element Of The Justice System

741 words - 3 pages What do you think goes thru the mind of a killer, like Jonathan Nobles from Steve Earl’s “A Death in Texas”, who brutally murder innocent people? Killers like Nobles disregard the gift of human life and violate people’s right to live. The death penalty is a necessary element in the judicial system to not only prevent the offender and others from committing a similar crime again, and to relieve the never ending flow of criminals that

Injustices Of The Justice System. Why Do Wrongful Convictions Of The Death Penalty Occur? This Research Paper Describes Many Reasons For Why Wrongful Convictions Occur

997 words - 4 pages For many years there has been a shameful error in the United State's judicial system. Though usually gone unseen to the eye of the media, the wrongful conviction of innocent convicts is rampant in United State's courtrooms. There are many different ways that a defendant can become victim to a faulty verdict. Since these cases are inconspicuous there can only be inconclusive statistics to go along with them. Anything that is run by human beings