Amy Tans Two Kinds And Maggie Scarfs” The Beavers Scale Of Family Health And Competence

1060 words - 5 pages

Why are children, pianos, and bad mothers a recipe for disaster? Maggie Scarfs essay” The Beavers scale of Family health and Competence” may be able to answer this question that haunts many families. Maggie Scarf compared and contrasted many families and was able to come up with the Family scale that puts these families on 5 different levels. Level 5 being the worst while level 1 being the most docile and best family unit. Using Scarfs essay we will be able to help the reader understand the level 4 family type to explain Amy Tans essay called” Two Kinds” were Jing-Mei battles her mother for self-control and her own social freedom. Scarfs assertions from her essay will help us understand why the tyrant in level 4 families eventually loses control and why there is never any healing done on both sides of these types of families.
According to Scarf” [Polarized families] have nothing but inflexible black and white rules- rules designed not only to control the actions, but the thoughts and feelings of everyone within the intimate system” (4). In other words, there is no gray area or bending the rules. The family members are forced to follow with no ability to be themselves. In polarized families there is no way to fight back due to all the family members are emotionally like puppets on strings.
Scarf's passage about how Level 4 families help the reader understand Jing-Mei's resentment towards her mother. Jing-Mei has already shown that she is not talented or a genius but, Jing-Mei's mother insists that there is one thing that her daughter is good at. Jing-Mei asks her mother why she can’t be loved for who she is. Her mother responds stating that she only wants her daughter to be her best for herself. The word “inflexible” in Scarfs essay shows how constricted and rigid she is with her daughter. Her mother is unable to see what is in front of her, a sad girl who just doesn’t have the talent or want to be a piano player and forces her child to piano lessons against her will.
Scarf other claim is “Borderline families live in a polarized world of either/or: You're either in control or you’re out of control; you're either all bad or you're all good; you're either all right or you're wrong entirely” (4). Likewise, Families in this state are dominated or untamed. There is no middle you are either on the wining team or the losing team. In these families it’s either stick together or be left out. Almost like a pack of wolves it’s a very primal style of family.
This assertion about “polarized” families by Scarf explains the relationship between Jing-Mei and her mother and how eventually all this controlling would lead this family situation to be out of control. The experience of Jing-Mei fighting back after being forced to go back to play the piano even though she had failed at the talent showing us that Jing-Mei was “all bad” in her mother’s eyes. Jing-Mei also fought back demanding never to return...

Find Another Essay On Amy Tans Two Kinds and Maggie Scarfs” The Beavers scale of Family health and Competence

The Relationship Between a Mother and Daughter in Two Kinds by Amy Tan

964 words - 4 pages "Two Kinds" by Amy Tan is about the intricacies and complexities in the relationship between a mother and daughter. Throughout the story, the mother imposes upon her daughter, Jing Mei, her hopes and dreams for her. Jing Mei chooses not what her mother wants of her but only what she wants for herself. She states, "For, unlike my mother, I did not believe I could be anything I wanted to be. I could be only me" (Tan 1). Thus this "battle of wills

Two Kinds by Amy Tan Essay

2014 words - 8 pages believed that you could be anything you wanted to be in America. The domestic dispute, on the other hand, was caused by the cultural differences. It focused on a mother from China and her American-born daughter. In Chinese culture, children are expected to be obedient. II. Analysis/Discussion In classroom situation, it is better if the discussion starts with the life of Amy Tan as reflected on the story Two Kinds. This will make students more

Two Kinds by Amy Tan

653 words - 3 pages In “Two Kinds,” Amy Tan explores a theme of independence. Jing-me is an impressionable nine year old girl living in an apartment with her parents. She struggles with the high expectations of her mother, to become a prodigy. The conflict results in a rebellious independence. Tan develops Jing-me’s character as willful, defiant, and insecure. To begin, Tan demonstrates that Jing-me’s willfulness stands in the way of her success. For

"Two Kinds" by Amy Tan.

933 words - 4 pages For many of us growing up, our mothers have been an integral part of what made us who we are. They have been the one to forgive us when no one else could. They have been the one to comfort us when the world seemed to turn to evil. They have been the one to shelter us when the rain came pouring down. And most importantly, they have been the one to love us when we needed it the most. In "Two Kinds," by Amy Tan, Jing-mei is a young daughter of a

Critical Analysis: Comparison/Contrast Of Amy Tan's "Two Kinds" And Flannery O'Connor's "Everything That Rises Must Converge"

643 words - 3 pages Most children rebel against their mothers at some point in time.The characters in Amy Tan's "Two kinds" and Flannery O'Conner's "Everything That Rises Must Converge" were similar in this aspect. Although the way felt about their mothers, the reasons they rebelled, and the way they went about it are very different. On the other hand, in the end of the stories, both characters had similar feeling towards their mothers.How Ni-Kan in "Two kinds" and

Point of View in Amy Tan’s Short Story, Two Kinds

1125 words - 5 pages Point of View in Amy Tan’s Short Story, Two Kinds In her short story "Two Kinds," Amy Tan utilizes the daughter's point of view to share a mother's attempts to control her daughter's hopes and dreams, providing a further understanding of how their relationship sours. The daughter has grown into a young woman and is telling the story of her coming of age in a family that had emigrated from China. In particular, she tells that her mother's

Mother-Daughter Relationships in Everyday Use, by Alice Walker and Two Kinds, by Amy Tan

1876 words - 8 pages No two mother and daughter relationships are alike. After reading “Everyday Use” by Alice Walker and “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan I realized that the two stories had the same subject matter: mother and daughter relationships. These two stories show different cultures, generations and parenting methods. Although the two mothers act differently, they are both ultimately motivated by the same desire: to be a good parent. In

A Mother/Daughter Conflict in Amy Tan's "Two Kinds" and "Best Quality".

2068 words - 8 pages , Waverly gets the best of June, embarrassing her in front of her friends and family. Even worse, June remembers her mother telling Waverly, "True, cannot teach style. June not sophisticate like you. Must be born this way." June laments not only is she humiliated, but "betrayed" by her mother (Tan 232). This bitter and oppressive remark strengthens the mother/daughter conflict. There are moments of redemption in both stories, however. In "Two Kinds

this essay is about how america suppreses minorities and how its evident in the Amy Tan story "Two Kinds" and the story "The Lone Ranger and Tonto Fishfight in Heaven"

1307 words - 5 pages The Land of Opportunity?"My mother believed you could be anything you wanted to be in America. You could open a restaurant. You could work for the government and get good retirement. You could buy a house with almost no money down. You could become rich. You could become instantly famous." These are some of the dreams that Jing-Mei's mother in Amy Tan's Two Kinds has of America. She is not alone. Millions of people come to America to make these

Parents Who Push their Children in relation to Amy Tan's "Two Kinds"

714 words - 3 pages Amy Tan's "Two Kinds" is a story about a mother who is pressing her daughter to become a prodigy. In the story the mother forces her daughter to try everything from becoming a Chinese Shirley Temple to trying to stand on her head without using her hands. After watching the Ed Sullivan Show, the mother decides the daughter is going to learn to play the piano. The mother sets up lessons with Mr. Chong a deaf piano teacher, everyday. Because Mr

Diversity and Cultural Competence in Family Therapy

2007 words - 8 pages Diversity and Cultural Competence in Family Therapy A therapist will face problems, issues and client troubles everyday. The professional must understand how their client relates to the world around them. These feelings and ideas affect how the client sees the problem and how they respond to their situation. Their actions, in turn, have bearing on individual thoughts, needs, and emotions. The therapist must be aware of the

Similar Essays

Pretentious Mothers In Williams’ The Glass Menagerie And Amy Tans’ Two Kinds

1421 words - 6 pages In the play The Glass Menagerie by Tennessee Williams and the short story “Two Kinds” by Amy Tan, a theme of embattled control is established through the association with their children. William’s long-winded Amanda is an overpowering, delusional Southern belle mother. Dead set on finding her slightly handicapped daughter Laura a suitable husband, and dictating how her creative, yet bored, son Tom should conduct himself in life. Amanda

Amy Tan's "Two Kinds". Essay

533 words - 2 pages In Amy Tan's short story "Two Kinds" we see the strained relationship between a Chinese immigrant mother and a first-generation American daughter. Throughout the text, Jing-mei's mother continually pushes her to become a prodigy. She is so obsessive of her daughter's excellence, that she does not see the emotional damage she creates. Jing-mei reacts negatively to the pressure. She becomes indifferent, angry, excited and hopeful; her emotions

Amy Tan's Two Kinds And Julius Lester's Spear

1357 words - 5 pages Amy Tan’s “Two Kinds” and Julius Lester’s “Spear” are two short stories that manifest themes of pressure amongst the main character and internal conflicts concerning their identity. Most people feel pressure some point in their life, especially if a lot is required of them. Some stand strong and don’t let the pressure weigh them down. On the other hand, there are those that cave in and let others define their identity for them. There are many

The Mother Of "Two Kinds", A Book By Amy Tan

575 words - 2 pages , resulting in the lack of concern for what her daughter really wanted. "Only two kinds of daughters", she shouted in Chinese. "Those who are obedient and those who follow their own mind! Only one kind of daughter can live in this house. Obedient daughter!" (Page 380) She was pessimistic, discouraging, and even demeaning if her daughter didn't set the standard, with "…[her] disappointed face once again." (Page 375) Finally, the reader gets a very important message from Amy Tan's "Two Kinds": No matter how strong you believe in something, you can never enforce it on anyone without their consent or approval. Jing-mei's mother went too far.