This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Analysis Of Cell Phone Technology, Security, And Individual Rights

1056 words - 4 pages

An Analysis of Cell Phone Technology, Security, and Individual Rights

In this technology driven era, I question what effect cell phones are having on our lives as American citizens? To investigate this, I read two articles. The first reading was “Mobile Phone Tracking Scrutinized” by Nikki Swartz originally published in the Information Management Journal for March/April 2006, and the second reading was “Reach out and Track Someone” by Terry J. Allen, originally published by In These Times on May 15, 2006. In her article, Swartz questions the legality of using a cell phone’s GPS system as a tracking device in situations when crimes are involved. She argues the potential violation of Fourth Amendment rights and describes loopholes our government avoids when the data is as a surveillance device. In her article, “Reach Out and Track Someone”, Allen shows the conspiracy theorist’s view of cell phone data tracking use. She suggests the government uses of warrantless wiretapping, and argues the communications companies and government have been involved in questionable activities (p1). Swartz and Allen question the government’s practices using cell phone data; Swartz sees the issue as practical is some cases, where Allen sees an overt violation of privacy. Both of the articles brought up two important questions. How do we define our expectation of privacy, and when does the government’s need take precedence, and even violate an individual’s expectation of privacy?
Swartz and Allen both agree the government’s use of cell pone surveillance is questionable, however they disagree on where the line should be drawn. For example, Swartz’s view is objective when prosecutors make the argument that having access to such crucial data is important to locating and verifying a suspect’s whereabouts (p2). She is concerned however, about the government not being required to report publicly when it requests the right to obtain cell phone tacking data on a moving suspect form the courts (p1). She is concerned about defining the line where obtaining the data becomes relevant and material to the ongoing investigation in comparison to just probable cause.
In contrast, Allen’s passion is to protect citizen’s privacy. She is eager to blame capitalism of the telecom companies. Allen presents a good argument about a case when a young woman was murdered and the cell phone tracking record of the suspect’s activities on the night of the murder, led to his arrest, not an actual call. She also has difficulty with the Justice Department warrantless wiretapping because getting a search warrant can mean dangerous delays (p1). Her concern is that the government can track a cell phone anywhere, even if not during an actual call.
Swartz and Allen both question how much information cell phone companies should store. Swartz seems to appear more accepting of its use where Allen fears the location information can be released easily, possible without regard to privacy. I find...

Find Another Essay On An Analysis of Cell Phone Technology, Security, and Individual Rights

Cell Phone and Radiation Essay

1251 words - 6 pages Cell phones, most everyone has one. They have evolved from a large, heavy device that you would carry in a shoulder bag to a small device that can be easily slipped into a pocket. Back then they were just used for calling and not many people had one. But now millions of people would not be able to go a day with out a cell phone. They range from models that just call and text to models that are basically mini computers that can fit in the

Texting and Cell Phone Essay

1461 words - 6 pages The question of young people and cell phone use and texting causing young people to be less able to concentrate and focus has always been a difficult one to answer. Technology gives teenagers so much but includes many drawbacks. Cell phone use and texting has it’s advantages such as teachers embracing tech,uses for educational purposes, and easy to use;however,some drawbacks are as socializing,time away from homework,and bad communication skills

Cell Phone Waves and Cancer

2212 words - 9 pages magnetic field. Now with this technology, scientists should be able to create an accurate 3-D model of a human brain. So in conclusion, after the findings of the Hardell group, one can conclude that there is a small risk of being diagnosed with brain cancer or brain tumors. The evidence supports that one is more likely to be susceptible to these risks when in high or frequent use of a cell phone. So the longer and the more frequent we use our cell

Cell Phone Use Of Teens

1107 words - 5 pages cancer from calling from cell phones to not getting enough sleep at night. The amount of radio frequency energy a cell phone user is exposed to depends on the technology of the phone, the distance between the phones antenna and the user, the extent and type of use and the users distance from cell phone towers. Cell phones give off radio frequency energy (radio waves), a form of non-ionizing radiation. Tissues nearest to where the phone is held can

Comparison of Top Cell Phone Plans and Providers

926 words - 4 pages an unlimited everything package! Straight Talk offer two plans which require the consumer to bring their own phone and the option to keep the same telephone number. The smaller plan is $35 a month. It covers 1000 talk minutes, 1000 text and pictures, and 1000 MB of data. Their attention grabber, standard setting, unlimited plan offers UNLIMITED talk, text, and data for one low prepaid price of $45 month. When the company first began, coverage was

Evolution of Individual Rights and Liberties

685 words - 3 pages The Nevada Constitution has many similarities to the U.S. Constitution and some of the concepts and provisions of the Nevada Constitution have roots that go back to English common law. I will attempt to analyze the evolution of individual rights and liberties in England and in the Colonies and States of the Confederation during the years preceding the Constitutional Convention held in Philadelphia in 1787.The historical and philosophical roots

An Analysis of Human Rights

1087 words - 4 pages as ideologies that serve a higher purpose. What he does not mention is that the opposite can be also true. Protecting human rights might become an "evil ideology" as well that serves a higher purpose. It can be a mere excuse to interfere with others' issues and achieve personal goals.Nelson Mandela stated in his 1993 speech: "But we must warn against the language of rights being used to conceal attempts to maintain, in one form or another, the

An Analysis of Setting Up The Phone Recorder

862 words - 4 pages glow, I checked the area of the room where the phone was located to determine whether the red indicator light was dimly flashing—a signal, which can only be recognized in the darkness, that a message had been left. After determining that no one had called the lab and left a message, I flipped on the light switch and set out to work. I rid myself of my heavy backpack by placing it down near the corner of the room and hung my warm jacket on the back

Technology of Bluetooth Ear Phone

1511 words - 7 pages 1 Timeline Factors Bluetooth is a kind of technology which can connect the devices in a low energy in a limited area and this technology was first developed and created by Sony Ericsson (Labiod, Hossam,Santis 2007.) I still remember when I was 13 years old. I owned my first mobile phone and it was by Motorola, my friend and I always use this technique to send the funny pictures. After then, when I was a high school student, my mom bought my

Dangers of Cell Phone Use While Driving

1579 words - 6 pages Over the last few decades, the use of cell phones has become a very common tool. Furthermore, Technology has certainly advanced, and the cell phone is becoming the most preferred mode of communication. The demand for a cell phone is growing every day. In addition, the use of wireless technology is affordable, and anyone can buy a cell phone at a reasonable price. They come in all shapes and sizes. They range from black to bright metallic

The Evolution of the Cell Phone

1571 words - 6 pages used by most persons. As time has progressed and technology has evolved the primary use of phones to be that of more complex features, types of cell phones are more prominent in the marketplace today. The two-way radio cell phone, one that is comparable to the function of a walkie-talkie, uses Push-to-talk technology, which allows instant communication rather than dialing another cell phone user and waiting for an answer. The use of this type of

Similar Essays

Social Construction Of Technology: Cell Phone Development

1555 words - 6 pages The Social Construction of Technology (or SCOT) is a new research tradition rooted in the sociology of technology. SCOT provides a multi-directional model based on the property of interpretative flexibility, and emphasizes on social influences on the technology design and development. This paper will apply SCOT principles to explore the development of cell phone, define the development of cell phone into three different stages historically, and

Negative Effect Of Cell Phone Technology

1024 words - 5 pages have cell phone. Cellular technology in which enables people to call beyond any border and share unlimited information at any moment. Cell phones, which primarily were used to make phone calls, have transformed in to devices that turn simple communication into distracting, privacy invading and removing the essence of communication, as we know it. The all in one device started out as being convenient for those moments in case of an emergency or

Individual Rights Vs. National Security Essay

878 words - 4 pages nothing but erode the very purpose for its existence and become a self-defeating pursuit.OVERVIEW:I offer an overview against the affirmative case. In order for the affirmative to affirm, (s)he has to prove three things. Firstly, that security is able to be achieves, secondly, why there is an imperative need to sacrifice individual rights, and thirdly, (s)he must address all instances and types of military conflicts. Failure to do any of these things

The Demands Of National Security Vs. Individual Rights

716 words - 3 pages against loss, attack, or harm to the citizens.Ought to supersede means that there is a duty or obligation to take the place or position of something.Conflicting means not able to be followed or acted on, because each requires different and incompatible actions.Claims of individual rights are demands for entitlements, freedoms, or privileges a person has.Before I begin, I have an observation about the resolution. The demands of national security and