This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Analysis Of Governmental Performance In Australia

896 words - 4 pages

Research and Referencing Assignment
ARTS1840 – Semester 1, 2010

z3332769 
Critical analysis

The Australian Journal of Public Administration’s research and evaluation paper explores the parliamentary scrutiny of government performance in Australia. It observes the processes the Commonwealth Parliament of Australia can use to make ministers and public servants accountable for the performance of their relevant departments. These decisions are made on the basis of performance data that each department is required to provide as well as parliamentary committee inquiries.
Thomas’ article highlights that the publication of performance data is not accountability – rather, there must be consequences following an examination of this data.
To assess parliament’s performance in its ability to scrutinise various government departments, the article draws attention to the two houses of parliament. The House of Representatives is generally under strict government control while the Senate is very rarely controlled by the ruling government, giving it a greater ability to scrutinise government performance. (Thomas 2009: 373)
The article states that there are two primary documents used to represent performance to parliament. These are the required annual reports and the estimate reports from various departments. The annual reports are required to be submitted to parliament by October 31st every year (Thomas 2009: 374). Initially, these documents focused on the financial side of the department in question, but have begun to cover other areas relevant to performance.
The argument presented by Thomas generally provides praise for the Commonwealth Government’s reforms on introducing mechanisms to keep the public service accountable (Thomas 2009: 373). It directly compares the systems in place in Australia to other Westminster based governments such as Canada (Thomas 2009: 396), arguing those governments have not tried to introduce similar scrutiny processes to the Australian government.
The article bases these claims largely two factors. It highlights the senate as a differential from other Westminster systems since it is rarely controlled by the governing party, allowing it to act as a scrutiniser of departmental and lower house parliamentary activity. The second factor in this argument is that Australian parliament requires regular estimate reports as well as the usual annual reports from government departments, which are then reviewed with estimate hearings, where department heads and secretaries are questioned on a wide range of areas. The article however admits that opposition senators will ask the majority of questions in the hope of scoring “political points” (Thomas 2009: 390) against the incumbent government.
It concludes however, that despite the strengths of the Australian system of parliamentary scrutiny, the Senate cannot possibly provide a comprehensive and consistent enough process of observing and reviewing the actions of government...

Find Another Essay On An Analysis of Governmental Performance in Australia

Cultural Analysis of Australia

7230 words - 29 pages . The first European who had contact with Australia was a Dutch in 1606. In 1770 an Englishman named James Cook come to Australia and claimed the country fir the British crown and after that they used Australia as a punishment colony and shipped prisoners to the island.Australia's land area is the sixth largest nation after Russia, Canada, China, USA, and Brazil. Australia has extremes of climate and different climates for different places. They

Analysis of Live performance

721 words - 3 pages some sense of secular pop. The whole choir that is characteristic of the Acapella passages is often rested upon the organ that has some interludes with some ascending scales in terms of the pitches that they give out or in accordance to the exact performance being carried out in the series of the performances. On the very day of the performance on that Sunday at the Westminster Cathedral, the high pitches from the choirs provided an almost

The Importance Of Creating a Performance Measure in an Organization

1590 words - 7 pages Performance measures play an important in all companies and their daily operations. By providing multiple methods of comparison and evaluation, accounting measurements provide a better view of the overall state of a corporation. Not only do investors use certain measures to help decide which companies to invest in, but internal managers use other measures to make sure their company is meeting set standards and that it is not falling behind or

Audit Performance in an Organization

967 words - 4 pages Auditing is performed by an auditor in an organization during a specified financial period that guides that organization. The main objective in requiring audit performance in an organization is to assess whether financial information provided by the organization conform to the Generally Accepted Accounting Principles (GAAP). Auditors are independent professionals in the field of Accounting and Auditing and an organization should ensure that

Analysis and Performance in Cricket

1085 words - 4 pages Analysis and Performance in Cricket Poor form can be defined as a decline in performance level which has persisted over a reasonable period of time, possibly a couple of weeks. Poor form is generally a temporary short-term problem, however, if the issue is not addressed, performance may continue to deteriorate, leading to the athlete becoming disillusioned and distanced from the sport. Within the sporting community

Analysis of Performance Enhancing Drugs

1239 words - 5 pages body. This is has become known as “ blood doping” (Wilson). Over the past several years, the use of performance enhancing drugs has increased dramatically and is now one of the leading problems in sports. “In the United States, an Estimated 1 to 3 million people has used anabolic steroids. Many of these are young adults…” (Cheatham). All athletes’ talk about is getting big and strong, whether they are a professional or playing for their local

SWOT Analysis for Hookah House in Australia

1153 words - 5 pages of serving alcohol hookah and shisha will be served. Overall, Hookah house will offer another option instead of the social norm of drinking and will offer a place for partygoers and other individuals to go and relax. In order to optimize the success of Hookah house the following marketing aspects will be examined; internal analysis, external analysis, market analysis, SWOT analysis, target market selection and positioning strategies and

An important aspect of urban Australia represented in 'Strange Bedfellows' the movie

550 words - 2 pages , help each other out when times are tough, and support each other through thick and thin. These qualities and beliefs make them quintessentially Australian."Brotherhood was never like it; friendship is not the word; but deep in that body of marching men the soul of a nation stirred" Banjo Paterson wrote in his poem 'Australia Today 1916'. Australia had only been settled by white Australians for almost two centuries, yet already a strong nationalism had emerged. An Identity. The words larrikin, mateship, courage, egalitatarism, resourcefulness and independence come to mind. This is all shown in the film 'Strange Bedfellows'.

The business analysis of establishing a new restaurant in Dockland area of Melbourne city, Australia

829 words - 3 pages main theme of the café is cactus (varieties and similar family of s) as Con Christopoulos who got many new projects and one of influential play makes on Melbourne food and wine field. Con Christopoulos is a person who loves espresso so he uses espresso machine to be his unique. Open door is other ideas in summer get some fresh air and umbrellas for sunny day then start evening with warm color lights.From an article in the age newspaper

Analysis of inflation (based on Australia)

3524 words - 14 pages Inflation can be defined as a "sustained increase in the general level of prices in an economy." Like unemployment, inflation is a major issue in economics, closely related to the fluctuating level of economic activity in a region. In Australia, the Reserve Bank of Australia (RBA) attempts to keep the inflation rate in the targeted range of between 2% and 3%.Economists generally recognise four main causes of inflation: demand, cost, imported and

Rise of rabbits in Australia

1888 words - 8 pages six months. In the period of 1870 to 1980, rabbits have established themselves across the mainland of Australia after their introduction from England to Barwon Park in Victoria. [12] Many areas have around 100 warrens per km2, with an average of 15 rabbits per warren. This equates to 1500 rabbits per km2, which represents a significant level of unmanaged grazing pressure. [13] Before the implantation of the myxoma virus, the overgrazing of

Similar Essays

Political And Governmental Issues In Australia

2224 words - 9 pages Australian government are those that reflect the British and North American models and are seen as being uniquely Australian. Being a responsible government, it houses some of the oldest democracies in the world in the sense that it has the commonwealth of Australia which was created in 1901. This happened in a period when the six states had agreed to federate. The first Australian government adopted such measures as one man one vote and suffrage of

An Argument In Favor Of Governmental Intervention Regarding Population Control

1663 words - 7 pages number should decrease in theory.As overpopulation becomes more evident in our daily lives, so does the rising rate of crime. As far as crime goes, I believe in "an eye for an eye". Our jail systems are over crowded with convicted murderers, rapists, pedophiles, and serial killers. Why should the people of the United States suffer? I do not believe in "two life sentences, without a possibility of parole" as a punishment for the act of murder. Why

Hist101 01: Essay #1 An Analysis Of “Documents” In The Founding Of Australia

2067 words - 8 pages An Analysis of "Documents" in The Founding of AustraliaInstructions for a convict colony at Botany Bay presumed it would be both a jail and free. Within this settlement, the Government hoped to instill a notion of brotherhood, by which the settlers-convicts and government officials included-would work together to support each other's preservation, simultaneous with conditions of dictatorial benevolence, a product of the Enlightenment sentiment

Analysis Of Water Sustainability In Australia

1596 words - 6 pages Everything, which exists in the world, requires water. Nevertheless, a lot of different places face crucial problems, which arise as the result of the water shortage. There are approximately seven billion of people on our planet Earth. In fact, each of them requires a liter of water per day to live and thrive; however, many of them are currently facing immense shortitudes. Actually, Australia faces serious challenge in getting sustainability as