This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Analysis Of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

4432 words - 18 pages

An Analysis of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

ABSTRACT: Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion (1779) may be read in the way Cleanthes (and Philo as well) reads Nature, as analogous to human artifice and contrivance. The Dialogues and Nature then are both texts, with an intelligent author or Author, and analogies may be started from these five facts of Hume's text: the independence of Hume's characters; the non-straightforwardness of the characters' discourse; the way the characters interact and live; the entanglements of Pamphilus as an internal author; and the ways in which a reader is also involved in making a dialogue. These and other analogies should reflect upon the Author of Nature as they do upon Hume's authorship: They do not prove the existence of their respective authors, but may well shed some light on the nature of these disparate beings.

The bulk of Hume's Dialogues concerning Natural Religion is given over to two discussions of "the" so-called argument from design. (1) In Part 2 Cleanthes succinctly states an "argument a posteriori" that attempts to "prove at once the existence of a Deity, and his similarity to human mind and intelligence." According to this argument, the world and its parts are (like) intricate machines or human contrivances, implying "by all the rules of analogy" that their cause, "the Author of Nature," is a designing intelligence (all 2.5.Cleanthes to Demea and Philo). Philo then subjects this argument to various and withering criticisms in Parts 2-8, although he later ends up confessing, more than once, (2) his inability to deny the powerful attraction this form of argument and its natural theological conclusion has for everyone, himself included.

In Parts 10 and 11, following an interlude considering Demea's "simple and sublime argument a priori" (9.1.Demea to Cleanthes and Philo), Cleanthes again attempts to use an argument a posteriori to prove the moral (as opposed to the natural) attributes of God, in two versions: the first must "deny absolutely the misery and wickedness of man" in order to infer a completely benevolent Deity (10.31), the second works from mixed (good and evil) phenomena and supposes "the Author of Nature to be finitely perfect, though far exceeding mankind" (11.1). Again, Philo states numerous objections, and ends up proclaiming a sceptical "triumph" concerning the first version (10.36) and judging an indifferent Deity more probable than a benevolent finite one concerning the second version (11.15).

Because it is so prominent, everyone notices that a central concern of Hume's Dialogues is empirical natural theology—how one can discern from Nature, using empirical facts and "experimental" forms of inference available to anyone, the existence and nature of an Author of Nature. But few connect this concern to the simple fact that the Dialogues is itself authored. It is a text with an author, David Hume. At the very least, then, on Cleanthes's approach,...

Find Another Essay On An Analysis of Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

Dialogues conceringing natural religion Essay

903 words - 4 pages exists than they are only creating an irrational and inconsistent argument. He goes on to continue another argument about a disfigured building. In any normal situation, the architect would be blamed for any complications in the engineering of the building. If God created the universe, than he should blamed for any flaws that are existing in it along with the fact the fact that God was not adequate enough to create a perfect universe. In the end

Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality

3251 words - 13 pages Critique of Hume's Analysis of Causality Hume's analyses of human apprehension and of causality were the most penetrating up to his time and continue to have great influence. Contemporary Spanish philosopher Xavier Zubiri (1893-1983) has examined both and identified three underlying errors: (1) the failure to recognize that there are three stages of human intellection, and especially that the first, primordial apprehension, has quite unique

An Analysis of Religion by an Athiest

2490 words - 10 pages . Morals and ethics allow one to make a knowledgeable and responsible decision. One’s religious and spiritual beliefs shapes and molds the mind, body, and spirit of the person. Each religion has its own unique principles, a list of do’s and don’ts that set the foundation for their moral and ethical beliefs. Everyday people are presented with situations in which that person must arrive at the solution through weighing each possible option morally

An Analysis Of The Jehovahs Witnesses Religion

925 words - 4 pages An Analysis Of The Jehovah's Witnesses' Religion      When the name of Jehovah's witness arises, most of the public of differing religions, a picture of an overly nice person or group of people all dressed in suits and nice clothes, arrive at your door and offer a sampling of pamphlets, (large or small). To most of the general public, the religion is a far cry from Christianity, but this is untrue, as a visit to one

An Analysis of Harriet Byrd From The Natural

758 words - 3 pages In movies there is always a villain or bad guy to ruin someone’s life or career. The only reason why they go after that person is because of jealously, money, or hatred. It is not always easy for villains or temptresses to get their targets, so they have to come up with clever ideas to lure their victims in. In the movie The Natural Harriet Byrd’s killing spree started off as jealously towards people who are very experienced in what they do and

An Enquiry Concerning The Principles Of Morals

1518 words - 6 pages> From: <> To: <> Subject: School Sucks The following form contents were entered on 19th Dec 96 Date = 19 Dec 96 03:24:49 subject = School Sucks resulturl = name = Samir Sandesara email = publish = no subject = Philosophy, Hume title = An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals papers = An Enquiry Concerning the Principles of Morals &nbsp

Political Analysis concerning the legalization of Marijuana

2925 words - 12 pages Amendment 64 states: “Shall there be an amendment to the Colorado constitution concerning marijuana… permitting a person twenty-one years of age or older to consume or possess limited amounts of marijuana: providing licensing…”(64th Amendment of Colorado Constitution). Although some states have been successful many conservative states are pushing for tougher regulations banning such a drug. With such a tough divide between states approving and

Content Analysis on Locke's An Essay on Concerning Human Understanding

2059 words - 8 pages book Essay Concerning Human Understanding. In his doctrine, Locke assessed one would be conscious with innate ideas if they exist prior to having experiences. However, for people like savage, the untutored ones, and even children are unaware with innate ideas; they gain knowledge through experiences during their lifespan. It is unfeasible for anyone to have knowledge of some sort in which he is unconscious about. Moreover, with notion of God and

Nutro Natural Choice Advertisement: An Analysis

974 words - 4 pages Have you ever thought if your puppy is getting high quality ingredients in his or her dog food? There are many varieties of dog food on the market, but that does not mean they are all good for your dog. This advertisement for Nutro Natural Choice for puppies appeals to consumers’ need to nurture and escape. This ad convinces consumers that with this dog food their puppies can grow up to be healthy and more. This ad appears in the February

The True Future of an Illusion: An Analysis of Freud's Critique of Religion

1788 words - 7 pages In his book Future of an Illusion, Sigmund Freud critique uses his method of psychoanalysis on religion. By comparing the relationship between human and religion to that of a child and his parents Freud effectively demonstrates that religion is a product of the human mind. After exposing religion as a an illusion Freud concludes that humanity will be better off when it has forgone religion. This paper will argue that Freud's assertion that

An Analysis of Robert Frost’s Use of Natural and Rural Depictions in his Poetry

926 words - 4 pages The Great In and Out Doors (An Analysis of Robert Frost’s Use of Natural and Rural Depictions in his Poetry) Edward Abbey once stated: “Water, water, water....There is no shortage of water in the desert but exactly the right amount , a perfect ratio of water to rock, water to sand, insuring that wide free open, generous spacing among plants and animals, homes and towns and cities, which makes the arid West so different from any other part of

Similar Essays

David Hume's Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion

1737 words - 7 pages David Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion provide conflicting arguments about the nature of the universe, what humans can know about it, and how their knowledge can affect their religious beliefs. The most compelling situation relates to philosophical skepticism and religion; the empiricist character, Cleanthes, strongly defends his position that skepticism is beneficial to religious belief. Under fire from an agnostic skeptic and a

Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion Essay

1342 words - 5 pages an existence, therefore when explaining the essence and nature of God, there are no such beings or deities in the entire world who possess all three qualities. If this was possible, then that would have to be from a high level of intelligence that no human would be able to comprehend in any fashion of known existence, thus refuting there being and existence of a supreme being all together. Works Cited dialogues concerning natural religion

Commentary Of Evil In Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Part X

861 words - 4 pages In Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion, Part X, Philo have questioned how it is possible to reconcile God's infinite benevolence, wisdom, and power with the presence of evil in the world. “His power we allow is infinite: whatever he wills is executed: but neither man nor any other animal is happy: therefore he does not will their happiness. His wisdom is infinite: he is never mistaken in choosing the means to any end: but the course of

The Problem Of Evil In Hume's Dialouges On Natural Religion And "Candide"

1398 words - 6 pages each address this issue in Candide and Dialogues on Natural Religion, respectively. Voltaire does so in a more lighthearted approach typical of the philosophes, employing his wit to address weighty issues of philosophy and at the same time entertaining his readers. Candide makes this point with an amusing story and its brutal satire; Hume does so in a more pedagogical style. However, the Dialogues do employ a sort of plot that helps to draw the