This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Analysis Of Leo Tolstoy’s Definition Of Art

1450 words - 6 pages

In his paper ‘What is art?’ (1897), Tolstoy states that art is not the mere expression of beauty or emotion; it provides no pleasure nor is that its sole purpose. Art is not an opportunity for catharsis or an activity to occupy the minds of idle beings. Instead, "art is a human activity consisting in this, that one consciously, by means of certain external signs, hands on others feelings he has lived through and that other people are infected by these feelings also experience them" (Tolstoy). In essence, the concept of art is an artist’s depiction of morality based on experience. Tolstoy’s essay on art sparked quite the reaction from the public because it openly criticized some of the ...view middle of the document...

Personal experiences verify the necessary condition prescribed by Tolstoy. Art allows the audience to empathize with artist because of the art piece evokes the artists emotions. For example, when I read the poem Invictus by William Ernest Henley, I empathized with the poet's despair, persistence and acceptance of fate. However, the emotions that were experienced by me were distinctly different from that of the poet. On a personal level, the pain of an amputated leg as well as the miserable and painful period faced by the poet are unfamiliar experiences. Furthermore, these emotions were only felt upon enlightenment of the poem's context. Without fully understanding Invictus, it was difficult to identify the emotions felt by the poet. Although the poem did evoke emotion, they were not identical to that of the poet and in accordance to Tolstoy's criteria; Invictus cannot be defined as an art form. Almost certainly such a statement would be highly contested by society. The inability to transfer some kinds of emotion (e.g., despair) between individuals is a significant issue that Tolstoy's definition faces. Whereas the phrase ‘a smile is contagious' may bear truth, it is impossible to know exactly how the artist felt without adequate knowledge about the context of the poem. Evidently, one cannot truly understand the feelings of an artist who fought in the Second World War, if that person has no knowledge about the events that transpired during the Second World War. Since some emotional responses are specific towards some event, it is highly unlikely that every single person shall be able to resonate with an art piece. This would result in the definition of art being categorized differently for members from different generations. Clearly this would deprive certain generations of experiences with immaculate pieces of art and exposes the subjective nature of the definition of art.
In reality, art is not only created purely based on the artist's emotions. Artists are often hired to create graphic advertisements. Such creations cannot be disproved as being art because they require artistic talent to produce that are created to instill the notion that a particular product is better than another into the consumer’s subconscious mind. The artist sometimes bears no emotional attachment to the art piece, as it is based solely on the design outlined by the marketing team. Advertising presents an instance where emotion is completely unnecessary in the creation of art.
Tolstoy wholly disregards beauty as a necessary condition of art. He reasons that beauty cannot be defined objectively; people regard it differently everywhere. Art is not as subjective and does not have to be aesthetically pleasing for it to be deemed as art (or good art); However, consideration of the art produced during the renaissance (14th-17th century); Michelangelo's David statue, Leonardo Da Vinci's painting of the last supper prove otherwise as they are globally renowned for their...

Find Another Essay On An Analysis of Leo Tolstoy’s Definition of Art

An Analysis of the Renaissance and Romanticism Art Periods

1270 words - 5 pages A1. Earlier Historical Art Period In the early 1300s, Europeans began to shed the dark and oppressing mindsets of the Middle Ages. This sparked a revolution that would begin in Italy and spread throughout Europe, and is known today as the Renaissance. The word Renaissance literally (and fittingly) means ‘rebirth’ – making it a fitting title for a period where interest in learning, philosophy, and the classical arts were ‘reborn’. Where the

The Art of Losing is Hard to Master: An Analysis of "One Art"

734 words - 3 pages In Elizabeth Bishop’s poem “One Art,” she talks about the art of losing things throughout her life. Her poem expresses the force of circumstance that life contains and that there is nothing anyone can do about loss (Diehl 498). The poem suggests that people lose things both significant and insignificant in their everyday lives. She almost makes it seem as if losing something or someone is easy, whether it is significant or not. Bishop seems as

The Ideology of Leo Burnett

829 words - 4 pages “There is an inherent drama in every product. Our No.1 job is to dig for it and capitalize on it.”– Leo Burnett One of the most famous men in advertising is the master of creativity, the inventor of the most captivating ad campaigns, and performed one of the most risky moves in ever done in advertising. This wonderful man goes by the name of Leo Burnett. He is the creator of multiple advertising campaigns including; Tony the Tiger for Frosted

Definition of Beauty and Its Portrayal in Art and Fashion

2115 words - 8 pages what fashion ‘is’ is value. Amongst all the change of fashion, value remains ever present. Different Impacts of how values influence beauty in art. Historically the idea of feminine beauty has reflected the standard and values of that era, “from the Rebenesque women of the 17th century to the contemporary symbols of fashion, different body shapes have been selected for, and associated with, desirable social statues”(GARNER et al. 2011) An

Critically analysis Stear's definition of tourism

1045 words - 5 pages essential character of flexible time and revenue in assisting travel, and the desire for an individual or group to escape their daily routine. The changes between pre-modern tourism and modern tourism are due to the technological changes and ‘technology will continue to revolutionize the tourism industry, pose new challenges to tourism managers and restructure tourism systems at all levels.’ The definition of tourism will continue to change and

Analysis of Excess in Sexuality According to Sigmond Freud and Leo Bersani´s Theories

1397 words - 6 pages , the notion of excess spawns from the inevitable interconnection of morality with modern sexuality. Such an interconnection emotionally enables desire to push the limits while granting shame the capacity to retain normative boundaries. Therefore, whether it is Sigmund Freud’s idea that excess is surplus stimulation or Leo Bersani’s contention that excess is a structure-shattering experience, both rely on the otherness of sexuality. Upon analysis

The Life of Leo the Lefty

966 words - 4 pages Leonardo DaVinci, arguably one of if not the most talented man of all time. Leonardo was brilliant and creative. DaVinci was an artist before his time. He grew up in the Renaissance but, is known as a realist. He did some of the best research that contributed to the inventions that we enjoy now. During his life he painted two of the most famous realistic paintings ever, Mona Lisa and The Last Supper. Leonardo DaVinci is one of the greatest

The Characters of Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina

1816 words - 7 pages The Characters of Leo Tolstoy's Anna Karenina       By examining the character list, one immediately notices the value Tolstoy places on character.  With one hundred and forty named characters and several other unnamed characters,  Tolstoy places his central focus in Anna Karenina on the characters. He uses their actions and behavior to develop the plot and exemplify the major themes of the novel.  Tolstoy wishes

The Definition of Death: An Ethical Issue in Organ Donation

644 words - 3 pages understand the contemporary problem with the definition of death. In this paper, I will discuss several experts in terms of their differences over two aspects: the failure of circulatory and respiratory function, and the malfunction of organismic “wholeness,” to determine “brain death.” In 1968 at the Harvard Medical School, in an attempt to make the definition of death comprehensive, a committee of physicians, a lawyer, a philosopher, and a

Definition of Living in a Foreign Country as an Immigrant

637 words - 3 pages Living away from your country can be a really interesting and unforgettable experience, but at the same time it has very important influence on one's life. The purpose of this essay is to discuss what is to live in another country and being called an immigrant.The main idea of being an immigrant, and also a very common one, is that once you start a regular life away from home, you miss everything. This fact doesn't mean that you are unhappy but

Intertextual Analysis of Works of Art

3639 words - 15 pages . Contemporary art is created in the here and now and which makes it contemporary to us. Contemporary art are works of art made from the 1960's or 70's up until the present and it is an ever-evolving art style. I will analysis three contemporary works of art and how different philosophers and theorists would interpret each one. The first work of art ‘Surreal’ by Marcus A. Jansen is an oil enamel collage on canvas done in 2009 hanging in the MW Gallery

Similar Essays

An Analysis Of Narrative Style Of Leo Lionni's Frederick

586 words - 2 pages An Analysis of Narrative Style of Leo Lionni's Frederick Frederick, a children’s book written by Leo Lionni, is considered a classic in this genre. It received the Caldecott Honor, was an ALA Notable Children’s Book, and was a New York Times Best Illustrated Children’s Book of the Year. The book is a fable of a mouse, Frederick, who is the dreamer in a group of tiny field mice. Frederick, the main character, demonstrates the importance

Original Definition Of Art Essay

1611 words - 6 pages My definition of art is imagination and passion expressed by creating a visual feature. I consider art to be a figurative of the imagination because everything starts with thought. People create life by thinking of ways to develop; this then creates art. It is as simple as watching a child draw a picture. I can recall imagining a picture in my head and expressing my thoughts on paper. The drawing did not come out as I imagined but it took me

The Definition Of An American Essay

1291 words - 5 pages Throughout the course of history the definition of the term “American” has changed repeatedly. The changes in the definition of the term between 1865 and 2011 coincide with political, social and economic trends during any specific time during this period. Originally the term “American” was not an inclusive term and even though the Constitution states that all men are created equal, many “Americans” did not practice what they preached. However

Feminist Analysis Of Anna Karenina By Leo Tolstoy

1862 words - 7 pages Anna Karenina is a novel by the prominent Russian author Leo Tolstoy. It was published in serial installments between 1873 and 1877. Tolstoy himself claimed that Anna Karenina was his first novel. Despite criticism that the novel was indeed two separate novels, there was much acclaim. Fellow Russian author Dostoevsky hailed it as “a flawless work of art” ( Despite the criticism that Anna Karenina is actually two novels, Tolstoy