This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Analysis Of Nozick And Held's Political Theories

1976 words - 8 pages

In the critical studies of Held (1987), the political activist and philosopher argues that a contemporary society is now influenced by the contractual patterns of relations. Held argues, “we are told that modern democratic states rest on a social contract, that their economies should be thought of as a free market, where producers, employers, consumers, and employees make contractual agreements” (Held, 1987, p. 782). In this context, society perceives a culture as a free market, as well. Therefore, various philosophers and political activists consider that morality itself could also be perceived from contractual terms. In response to these assumptions, other political theorists also contribute to understanding of a contractual society. Despite the fact that Robert Nozick was not considered to be a political activist and philosophy, his contributions to political frameworks are evident. In particular, Nozick has had a major influence on the analysis of personal identity, as well as the analysis of political right-wing contributions. So, in order to understand why Held introduces claims against the current system, it is essential to consider her social and political views and compare those with the contractual political theories, supporting that the government should serve as a moralizing tool for the community first.
While the both theorists’ contributions have outstripped the boundaries of the political philosophy, Nozick managed to provide new political models for building social medium and consolidating communities (Hoffman & Graham, 2013). Nozick did not believe that a function of the government is to make individuals moral and adhere to moral and ethical principles. Nozick’s liberal outlook provided the analysis of the conditions that existed for individuals to identify the good path form themselves (Hoffman & Graham, 2013). In this respect, the two ideas differ significantly from the conservative views on the political structure because Nozick’s political views do not directly refer to tradition or custom in general. Nozick suggests that there is nothing strange about the authority and principles in his political theories. At the same time, if the government is used for suppressing individuals’ freedoms to match the traditional societal norms, Nozick opposed these norms because it is considered the intrusion of the government into private lives.
Another important issue about Nozick’s political theory is confined to the relationship between capitalists and the restricted role of governmental action. Nozick believes that an individual’s rights are empowered, and his theory will demand extreme efforts for the government to oppose the individual rights (Hoffman & Graham, 2013). According to Nozick, the government’s proper task is to protect individuals and their rights. But in the same instance, the government is not liable for taking holdings and encouraging the welfare of the poor.
In response to these policies, Held still believes that...

Find Another Essay On An Analysis of Nozick and Held's Political Theories

An analysis of the economical, political and psychological causes of homelessness

2427 words - 10 pages in structural and individual factors such as economic instability, political barriers and psychological disorders.This issue will be studied through a disciplinary analysis. It will focus on the economical, political and psychological causes of homelessness. In addition, certain theories and concepts will be analyzed to increase the understanding of this social issue.The first discipline that will be integrated is economics. The related theory

This paper compares two famous political philosophers John Rawls and Robert Nozick and their approaches to social justice

1612 words - 6 pages positions that maximize the prospects for the wost off, i.e. feed and house the poor in case they happen to become one (Rawls, 197-199)..Nozick, however, suggests that "the fundamental question of political philoshopy" is not how government should be organized but "whether there shouls be any state at all". He states "the state may not use its coerciv e apparatus for the purpose of getting some citizens to aid others, or in prder to prohibit

Analysis of Turner and Bloch's Differing Theories

767 words - 4 pages Alexandra Harvey ANTH 425 3/24/2014 Turner vs. Bloch Analysis For many cultures, rituals take part of everyday lives and provide purpose and meaning for life. Simple ceremonies such as a prayer before a meal, a Bar Mitzvah for an adolescent, or even marriage for a loving couples fill our lives with such meaning, but never receive a second thought about the depth behind such rituals. Anthropologists, Victor Turner and Maurice Bloch

Political Persuasion Ethics: An Analysis of The Daisy Girl Ad

1811 words - 8 pages political persuasion, ethical standards for commercial advertising and the advertisers’ use of intentional ambiguity and vagueness. Although previous analysis of the “Daisy Girl” ad has supported the content of the message as it relates to the functional meaning; instead I will focus on the unethical use of persuasive tactics presented in this ad, to enable the consumer to be a more informed voter. Responsibility in Advertising Responsibility

Political Frame Analysis of an Organization's Effective Management

2101 words - 9 pages companies as jungles and focuses on the powerful members in an organization who negotiate and influence others. The political frame also looks at the dynamics of alliances and opponents and how they interact.1 In terms of the political frame, the employer’s job is to influence and negotiate with people inside and outside of the company. If done correctly, these strategies give the employer access to key players in the industry by building strong

Compare and contrast Nozick and Rawls approaches to the issue of Indigenous Australians land rights

4314 words - 17 pages person has the fundamental right to self ownership, Nozick extends this autonomous right to legitimately held property, arguing that property is an extension of the individual self. Thus, holdings of property and ownership are central to Nozicks' idea of distributive justice.The question of just ownership is elucidated in Nozicks' 'Entitlement Theory,' comprising of three major components. The first centres on the initial acquisition of holdings for

Theories and Methods in Political Science: Sanders

1210 words - 5 pages In Chapter One of “Theories and Methods in Political Science”, Sanders focuses on a central question of “why do people behave in the way they do?” In behavioral analysis, it is important to focus on observable behavior. Observable behavior is crucial because it centers in on why people do what they do, not what people think internally. Any explanation of this behavior is subject to empirical testing; meaning any actual experience is worth far

Motivational Theories and Analysis

1254 words - 5 pages Introduction: In this literature review, assess, discuss the body of knowledge available for motivational theories and analysis in the same order of their importance in our current study. In this case, we tried to provide an overview of research in this respect and the gaps in the sequence, where to find the way for future studies in this area. We will strengthen existing research on what managers can do to write their employees and the factors

Analysis of political situatio

1485 words - 6 pages how economic statecraft positioned the US so that the hostages were returned home safely, and American resolve was kept firm.By the14th of November, economic sanctions against Iran included: cutting off exports of military spare parts and imports of Iranian oil, and freezing over 12 billion dollars of Iranian assets. Baldwin begins his analysis by stating US primary objectives with regard to economic statecraft. The first was to demonstrate US

An Evaluation of Information Security and Risk Management Theories

2183 words - 9 pages An abundance of information security and risk management theories are prevalent; however, it can be difficult to identify valid and applicable theories. In the reading to follow, several information security and risk management theories are evaluated. These theories are presented and employed via various frameworks, models, and best practice guidelines. An assessment of sufficient research pertaining to these theories is addressed, along with

The Life, Works, Theories, and Analysis of Plato

1809 words - 7 pages interested.Around 428 BC, Ariston and Perictione had a child, Plato. Ariston, who descended from the early Athenian kings, and Perictione, who was related to Solon the early lawmaker, were a wealthy and aristocratic family. Prior to Plato reaching adulthood, his father Ariston died. Perictione decided to remarry an associate of the statesman Pericles, Pyrilampes.Plato fought in the Peloponnesian war from around 409-404 BC, but did not want a military career

Similar Essays

An Analysis Of The Theories Of Neoclassical And Political Economy And The Practicality Of Each

1547 words - 6 pages we do and think. To explain these phenomena, there are two main theories: Neoclassical, and Political Economy.The Neoclassical approach is based on how goods and services are exchanged, and that relationship with supply and demand. Neoclassicism defines a successful market as one with many buyers and sellers, thereby creating competition. The idea being that with sufficient competition the economy will be controlled by market forces, which in

An Analysis Of Theories

1036 words - 5 pages There are many theories that cover specific moral believes. The following theories relate either to the consequentialists that belief that, “the rightness of an action depends on the amount of good it produces,” or the non- consequentialists that belief that, “the rightness of an action does not depend entirely on its consequences” ( Vaughn, 2010 , 67 ). My belief is, that life is a mix of both beliefs and their conjoining theories. Also, I

Political Analysis Of An Organization

1799 words - 7 pages hinder of facilitate the success of the change to the front end/back end design (Dynacorp Revisited, 2005: M-2, 85). POLITICAL ANALYSIS Stakeholders The political analysis of an organization begins with the identification of the stakeholders “groups that have a shared ‘stake’ that is affected by what the organization is and how it carries out its activities (Ancona et al., 2005: M-2, 35)” The CEO of Dynacorp is ultimately responsible for

Theories And Their Differences: Analysis Of Robert Dahl’s Who Governs, And Robert Michels’ Political Parties

2114 words - 9 pages that the similarity between these two generally ends there. In point of fact, the purpose of this paper is to critically asses Robert Dahl’s Who Governs, and Robert Michels’ Political Parties to exhibit the dissimilarities of their respective theories. In Who Governs, Dahl takes aim on New Haven, Connecticut, as a test case of the degree to which the American political system, at least on the local level, is undemocratic because of its