This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Analytic Summary Of “Hobbesian Political Order” By Russell Hardin Political Thought Assignment

2044 words - 9 pages

An analytic summary of “Hobbesian Political Order” by Russell Hardin
In his work, Hardin aims to analyse Hobbesian political thought in light of contemporary interpretations in the field of social and political theory; namely, in this case, the Prisoner’s Dilemma. Hardin disagrees with what he defines as a “newly established consensus”[footnoteRef:1] that Hobbes’s vision of the state of nature should be seen as “plagued with Prisoner’s Dilemma”[footnoteRef:2]. Specifically, he argues against the interpretation that sees Hobbes’s theory of social contract as itself a large Prisoner’s Dilemma. Instead, Hardin makes the case that Hobbesian theory relies heavily on coercion rather than contract, reminding the reader of just where and how Hobbes’s Leviathan got its name. According to Hardin, Hobbes often denies that men consent “in any meaningful sense”[footnoteRef:3] to be ruled by their sovereign; rather, all men need to do is submit. To Hardin, the modern over-emphasis on the value of consent in Hobbesian thought is a misinterpretation of the original text, a frequent mistake when it comes to contemporary interpretations of classical thinkers as often contemporary scholars “tend not merely to translate, but to transmute”[footnoteRef:4]. [1:
Hardin, R. (1991). Hobbesian Political Order. Political Theory, 19(2), 157. doi:10.1177/0090591791019002002 ] [2: Ibid., p. 157.] [3: Ibid., p. 159.] [4: Ibid.]
Hardin sets forth to argue his claims by firstly detailing Hobbes’s understanding of the structure of exchange and contracting that is at the basis of the Dilemma; then further exploring Hobbes’s “potentially misleading”[footnoteRef:5] dualistic focus on both the laws of nature and the importance of sovereign authority. Hardin believes that laying out these first two arguments is particularly important, as they are the main contributors to the popular understanding that sees Hobbes as a contractarian first and foremost, and his conception of social order as a large-scale real-life version of the Dilemma – both claims that Hardin refutes. Next Hardin describes the role of the Dilemma in Hobbesian natural law, aiming to demonstrate that Hobbes fully understood such a concept even if by other terms, and that he implicitly denied the interpretation of his state of nature based on the Prisoner’s Dilemma in his works. [5: Ibid.]
In the introduction of the essay, Hardin illustrates Hobbes’s role as a precursor to both utilitarianism and contractarianism. He calls attention to the fact that the modern-day animosity between contractarians and utilitarians doesn’t prevent the two theories from coexisting under certain circumstances – in fact, he makes the case that men may agree to what produces the greatest welfare, thus satisfying both the conditions for utilitarianism and contractarianism. Still, Hardin reiterates, the two theories “are not equivalent and may be contrary”[footnoteRef:6]. This ambivalence inherent in Hobbes’s thought also extends to the...

Find Another Essay On An analytic summary of “Hobbesian Political Order” by Russell Hardin - Political Thought - Assignment

Karl Marx's Influence on Sociology and Political Thought

2603 words - 10 pages subsistence. Without the means of subsistence, humanity would fail in all other activities and functions. Marx rejected Hegel’s dialectics based on a movement of human thought and ideas, and argued that dialectics involved contradictions based on an economic system, otherwise known as dialectical materialism. Therefore, the dynamic for change eventually created by a process of dialectics lies in the conflict between two opposing factors (Lee and Newby

Key terms for political science class - Political science - Assignment

1365 words - 6 pages understanding of the facts presented by the two disputing parties. U.S. Code A compilation of all the laws passed by the U.S. Congress. U.S. Supreme Court The court of last resort for conflicts over the U.S. Constitution and national laws; in addition to its appellate jurisdiction, the Court also has limited original jurisdiction. Writ of certiorari Latin for “a request to make certain”; issued by a higher court, this is an order for a lower court to make available the records of a past case it decided so that the higher court can review the case.

Antidiscrimination: between beliefs and feelings - Faculty of Political sciences - Assignment

1681 words - 7 pages the political, economic, social and cultural life, without any privileges and discriminations, by being equal in front of the law and of the public authorities”[footnoteRef:1]. [1: Extract from “ The international report regarding the situation of respecting the human rights in Romania from 2014” - http://romania.usembassy.gov/2014-hrr-ro.html ] In fact, the Romanian penal code includes stipulations meant to fight against discrimination and

International Political Economy Essay – China and The New Economic Order

2989 words - 12 pages particular outcome in China, but we must have an open mindin terms ofseeing where itisgoing. Giovanni Arrighi 2009, 84 If the political economy of communication as an academicfield counts the 'blind spot" debate, initiated by Dallas Smythe, as one of the deftning moments in its development, political economyofcommunication as apraxis witnessed a histori- cal encounter of an entirely different nature and magnitude, also initiated by Dallas Smythe, in an

Indonesia's Economy: Socio-Political Challenges in the New Order

1821 words - 7 pages Socio-political challenges post- New Order Suharto’s New Order regime was blatantly corrupt and filled with nepotism, this mixed with the aftermath of the Asian Financial Crisis left a legacy of socio-political challenges for subsequent reformasi governments. These challenges include the legacy of authoritarianism, corruption, depoliticised civil society, a powerful military and an inefficient judiciary and government. (Pohlman) The different

A review of the political economy of Africa(chapter 2) by Claude Ake - Obafemi Awolowo University /200l - Assignment

470 words - 2 pages Olanipekun John Dolapo HIS/2015/111 History Review of Claude Ake's political economy of Africa (chapter 2) In the chapter 2 of Claude Ake's political economy, the author deals with the penetration of western capitalism into Africa and the subsequent integration of African economies into the World capitalist system, he further opined that the dependence of African economics is as a result of the integration of Africa into the world capitalist

POL 302 ASSIGNMENT WHICH MAKE AND PRESENTED BY MUSTAPHA MUHAMMED OF POLITICAL SCIENCE DEPARTMEN - FEDERAL UNIVERSITY BIRNIN KEBBI - ESSAY

3162 words - 13 pages FEDERAL UNIVERSITY BIRNIN KEBBI NAME: MUSTAPHA MUHAMMED DEPT: POLITICAL SCIENCE ADM NO: 1410108009 COURSE TITLE: WESTERN POLITICAL THOUGHT 2 COURSE CODE: POL 302 LECTURER: Dr, I.M SAMA PhD ASSIGNMENT: “NECESSITY IS SOMETHING IN THE MIND NOT IN OBJECTS.” EXPLAIN WHAT THIS MEANS AND WHAT HUME’S REASONS WERE FOR HOLDING IT. DATE: 01/08/2017 INTRODUCTION David Hume (1711-1776) is one of the British Empiricists of the Early Modern period, along with

A brief summary of the Liberal approach to international political economy

1828 words - 7 pages following will present a brief outline of the history behind today's Liberalism, Liberalism's view of the role it should play in international political economy (IPE), as well as a critical evaluation of the policies enacted by its current practitioners.Before beginning, it seems necessary to define the main term in the discussion - Liberalism. The word itself means many things to many people, but for the purposes of this essay Liberalism refers to an

Title: An Analysis of Primary Sources from Hurricane Katrina, Assignment: Write and argumentative essay on a political contraversy using only PRIMARY SOURCES

1406 words - 6 pages communication was the government's largest breakdown. On the night of the hurricane, an e-mail message from FEMA's public affairs staff was sent to the chief of staff of Homeland Security Secretary Michael Chertoff, which said that conditions "are far more serious than media reports are currently reflecting. Finding extensive flooding and more stranded people than they had thought..."1 Chertoff then called the Whitehouse to update the Hurricane's

It isn't always what it seems - Political importance of Assignment in Brittany

903 words - 4 pages Corlay and France for personal gain, as well as her arrogant demise. Analysis of the characters reveals their symbolic political importance, which provides greater insight into psyche of the nations fighting for survival. The historical context of Assignment in Brittany is vital to uncovering meanings within the novel. It was written in 1942, when conquest of Britain by the powerful German armies was a distinct possibility. The book uses

Reaction Assignment for Political Science - 2021 - Reaction Paper

649 words - 3 pages task of providing health care for the people. This is astonishing as the United States has the best schools which provides the best educated doctors, nurses, medical technicians to work at the best equipped hospitals in the world; and yet the United States is unable to provide the people with the power of healing and the gift of life (Reid 28). This leads into a fact that is even more shocking in that the U.S. is ranked last, by the Commonwealth

Similar Essays

How Far Did Changes In Political Thought 1642 1690 Reflect The Reality Of Political Developments?

1955 words - 8 pages single government known as the Cavalier government that controlled Parliament between 1661 and 1679. This long period without an election led to a lack of political opinion outside Westminster (Jones in Jones 1979 p49). This is a clear example of where a political development has actually stifled the growth of intellectual thought. However, one opinion was made clear with the restoration, the dislike for the aggressive central government of the

Theodore Roosevelt's Contributions To American Political Thought

2960 words - 12 pages affairs of neighboring nations from time to time. If a nation shows that it knows how to act with reasonable efficiency and decency in social and political matters, if it keeps order and pays its obligations, it need fear no interference from the United States. Chronic wrongdoing, or an impotence which results in a general loosening of the ties of civilized society, may…ultimately require intervention by

I Have A Thought; The Usage Of Media In Changing Political Ideology

1227 words - 5 pages not be further from the truth. All expressions are herein protected and allowed, whether spoken or not, blatant or not, or even popular or not. Focusing on modern America, this protected expression of political thought is a powerful dynamo, changing the laws, the society, and even the country in its endeavors. Many different media work to influence the political thought or opinion on an issue on an unprecedented scale. Unlike any time in human

Why Karl Marx Thought Communism Was The Ideal Political Party

1054 words - 4 pages Why Karl Marx Thought Communism was the Ideal Political Party Karl Marx was brought up in a Jewish community and society in his early years. His father was a lawyer, although he was descended from a long line of rabbis. As opportunities for Jews decreased Karl Marx's father, Herschel, decided to convert from Jewish to Lutheranism, which was the Prussian states religion. The Marx family was very liberal and often held