This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Difficult Scenario Essay

1281 words - 5 pages

In Rottenberg’s text we are presented with a difficult scenario.
Task: A series of environmental catastrophic events has virtually wiped out human life on earth. The only known survivors in your vicinity are the eleven listed… There are resources to sustain only seven. Choose seven…people to survive. List them in the order in which you would choose them. (220)
If this scenario which I have been presented with were something I had to face in reality I would probably leave the group and try to find other resources. I would not want to be part of anything that would lead to the destruction of another human being, even for the purpose of the survival of other human beings. I believe that in life there is always a choice and I hope that I would make the moral choice. However, since this exercise is only an assigned task and does not affect the life of any actual person I will do it as if there were no other option. Each person is valuable but I have chosen 7 to survive based upon what they can contribute to the existence of the others in the group, to themselves, and perhaps to other survivors that they might encounter later.
The first person that I chose to survive is Mr. Newton. I have limited information about Mr. Newton. Rottenberg states,
Mr. Newton – twenty-five, black power advocate, starting last year of medical school, suspected homosexual activity, music as a hobby, physical fitness buff. (221)
In order to be diplomatic I will only focus my attention on the skills or qualities that each person can offer. What I immediately note about Mr. Newton is that he is young, healthy and has medical knowledge that under the current circumstances will be useful to the group and possibly other survivors that they may encounter. For example if someone were to cut their arm or otherwise injure themselves he would definitely have the knowledge to treat them with needed first aid or even determine if they are likely to survive their injuries. Next, I chose Father Frans. Rottenberg states,
Father Frans—thirty-seven, white Catholic priest, active in civil rights, former college athlete, farming background, often criticized for liberal views. (221)
I chose Father Frans simply for his farming background. As we know from the text there are limited resources and having the ability to farm would be extremely helpful. Father Frans is also fairly young and because of this likely to survive. After Father Frans I chose Mr. Blake. Rottenberg states,
Mr. Blake – fifty-one, white, Mormon, BS in mechanics, married with four children, enjoys outdoors, experienced in construction, quite handy, sympathizes with antiblack views. (221)
Mr. Blake’s description leads me to believe that he would be in good physical condition, his enjoyment of the outdoors would make him more likely to survive and his skills in construction could be beneficial to the group. He would likely possess the knowledge and skills needed to construct shelter if it were...

Find Another Essay On A Difficult Scenario

Healthcare Role Play Essay

966 words - 4 pages situation that should be acted out and plan the scenario. It should be familiar enough that the students understand the purpose and can decide how to act out their particular part of the scenario. The observers should be able to understand what will be acted out so they can analyze it properly. A short description of the scenario should be written with a minimum of two parts to be acted out. The instructor should decide whether one group or multiple

Logistics Management Scenario Essay

734 words - 3 pages Summary The scenario depicts Wonderful Widgets, a firm specializing in the manufacturing and distribution of a single product, widgets. The company is able to produce widgets using its current equipment, facility, layout and materials and is able to procure the product through various suppliers. Recently, it has been noted that operational costs have been rising each month. Problem at Hand In the scenario, the Supply Manager is

Supply And Demand Simulation

1271 words - 6 pages rental rate was increased to $1,475.Scenario SevenIn the seventh scenario, the increasing rental rates over the past two years had been significant and finding affordable housing had become difficult. The City Council imposed a rent control at $1,550 for two-bedroom apartments. At a price ceiling below equilibrium, GoodLife was only willing to supply 2,275 apartments causing a shortage of 875 apartments. Due to the price ceiling, market forces could

An Automated Requirements Traceability: Managing Evolving Requirements Using Ontology-based Approach

1058 words - 5 pages ) requirements knowledge is informal and (2) it is difficult to transform informal into formal model and to maintain it, due to its complexity [5]. Therefore, The aim of this work is to support requirements knowledge traceability with requirements knowledge acquisition from the scenario. This work also aims to identify the relations among sources of the requirements using ontology-based approach. Ontology is a widely known approach with a purpose to

Hate-Crime Legislation

1379 words - 6 pages ) prominent by distinguishing various freedoms and liberties in their constitutions such as freedom of expression and freedom of thought. Mill’s idea of liberty would not exist if this scenario would take place(hate speech could exist), Mill supports absolute freedom within the constraints of harm inflicted to people“…the only purpose for which power can be rightfully exercised over any member of a civilized community, against his will, is to prevent harm

The Pros and Cons of Various Teaching Methods

1223 words - 5 pages Role play: In role play, the learners are assigned roles which they act out within a scenario given by the lecturer. The lecturer must choose a scenario for a role play that gives the learners an opportunity to prepare what they have been taught. The role should also keep the learners interested. A scenario for a role play can be found by things they have encountered in their lives, from a book or a movie. After choosing the scenario for a role

The Professional Relationship

1699 words - 7 pages termination is because of dual relationships between the professional and their client (Meyer, 2005). The scenario presented in this paper will discuss a dual relationship between a college professor, who is also a psychiatrist and one of the professional’s students. The student seems distraught and the professor asks if everything is all right. The student explains the situation and the professor speaks with the student for a few minutes and

First Impressions and Human Behavior

1439 words - 6 pages is the power of first impressions and demonstrates how first impression affect perception. In the first scenario, the observer’s first impression was very positive in nature. When the observer sees John in a less positive situation, it may become difficult for them to put the first impression aside and see John for the person he really may be. Likewise, a person observing the two scenarios in reverse order might find it difficult to set aside

Why does Two Wolves by Tristan Bancks give meaning? - Book Review

311 words - 2 pages is on the surface. The novel ‘Two Wolves’ written by Tristan Bancks, deftly captures the sense of betrayal children may feel while being deceived by those they trust and care for. Furthermore, it demonstrates the difficult choice that people are constantly torn between, to follow universal ethics or your own. Over the course of the novel, the protagonist Ben dreams to become a detective, however he never expected to be investigating crimes

Evaluating Fiscal Policy Alternatives Simulation Paper

1197 words - 5 pages percent.Scenario OneIn the first scenario a decision needed to be made whether to increase or decrease government spending, taxation, or both; as well as the magnitude in the fiscal policy measures to do away with the recession and move the economy to its long-run potential real GDP. Prior to implementing fiscal policy, some of the economic indicators were:Real GDP - 39.70%Inflation - 5.00%Unemployment - 6.32%Budget deficit - 2.50%A decision was made to

How Child Trauma Affects a Relationship Attachment

959 words - 4 pages , perhaps, may use the relationship bond to make them be able to build up their coping skills. However a child that gets mixed messages from a guardian can find it difficult to try and calm them down by distancing themselves from others.  Some children can use their caregivers to prepare them for how they can respond to events. An example of a scenario would be if you stopped a child from participating in something which is unsafe they in

Similar Essays

Scenario Planning Essay

1086 words - 4 pages environment variable than computer simulation programs, because it is difficult to reflect them quantitatively data. Many approaches support Schoemaker, According to Wack (1985), Bunn and Salo (1993) Van Der Heijden, (1996) Wollenberg et al (2000) scenario planning process is qualitative process of scenario development. O’Brien (2004) stated that scenario planning as a qualitative approach which does not mention traditional hard methods such as

The Effectiveness Of Scenario Planning In Determining The Future Strategies (A Study On Hospitality Industry)

2548 words - 10 pages School of Sport, Performing Arts and Leisure LI4000 (Strategic Applications) “An Essay on the Effectiveness of Scenario Planning in Hospitality Industry for Determining Future Strategies” THE EFFECTIVENESS OF SCENARIO PLANNING IN DETERMINING THE FUTURE STRATEGIES (A STUDY ON HOSPITALITY INDUSTRY) Scenario planning is a practice of predicting many, reasonable and uncertain futures (Hiejden et al., 2002).Scenario planning, which

Supply And Demand Essay

657 words - 3 pages instead of apartments. That means a decrease in demand and no change in supply. Rent was lowered to meet that change. This made it more attractive for people to rent instead of buy.In the beginning, this scenario was relatively easy. As more variables were thrown into the equation, it became more difficult. The imposition of a price ceiling, the increase in apartments, the apartment conversions, etc. was a little confusing. This paper discussed

Other Scenarios Essay

740 words - 3 pages freedom.” says Nash. I believe if any scenario that Nash wrote about compromised human freedom. He would have a difficult time convincing the world that these scenarios can keep the wilderness safe and from our cancer-like tendencies to self destruct. Island Civilization is an excellent idea for a science fiction movie, but as for a legitimate plan for the future of our planet the idea is simply unachievable. Roderick Nash appears to have been as