This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Argument Against A Presupposition Essay

1740 words - 7 pages

In The American Democracy and Its National Principle, Herbert Croly makes an eloquent and poignant case for adopting a nationalistic frame of mind. According to Croly, we are rapidly approaching a junction where we must choose between the traditional values, measures and mind set of our past or embrace the opportunities of the future. As a people we should realize that the future holds great promise, and that is why we should focus on empowering a centralized system of governance that replaces the antiquated approach to governance: regional centricity whose players are driven by their self-interest rather than the common good. This may sound like nationalism but this is an inadequate assessment. To Croly, nationalism is a much grander thing. Nationalism requires substantially more than “merely” centralizing the government; there must be a shift in how people see themselves, from a collection of states into a single American people. Nationalism is a philosophical ideal that far outstretches any tangible thing. Nationalism requires a unified frame of mind focused on a single point of governance.
Croly’s opinion, while not revolutionary, was still regarded with suspension by many people in 1909 (the year Croly’s essay was published). People who were wary of a nationalistic government and a unified frame of mind had a good argument against Croly’s essay. Much of this essay focuses on this argument against Croly’s presuppositions regarding the “progressive” outcome of nationalization.
First off, Croly bases everything in his argument on the claim that the “national interest” is predicated on democratic principles (as cited in Eisenach, p19). This is why people should have nothing to fear from a nationalistic government: it embodies their own personal ideal of democracy. It is this fact that makes the argument against nationalism an erroneous endeavor as the one thing people will be uniting under, the democratic principle, is the source of their unification. Croly believes that the traditional fear of a strong centralized government is unenlightened and antiquated. Clearly, Croly is placing a lot of faith in the “democratic principles” that will guide the unified nation. It is interesting then that Croly’s own opinion regarding the average person’s abilities is so low. He states that “the average American individual is morally and intellectually inadequate” to comprehend or understand “his responsibilities (as cited in Eisenach, p23).” His pessimistic view of the average person is perhaps well founded, but it does lead into an argument that undermines some confidence in nationalism and democracy.
If the premise of the argument for nationalism lies in the embodiment of the democratic principle, and democracy is a form of government by and for the people, then is nationalism merely a new way to project the ignorance of the masses? If the people are ignorant and inconsistent in their opinions, then how is a democracy capable of...

Find Another Essay On An Argument Against a Presupposition

An Argument Against Auteur Theory Essay

2746 words - 11 pages film by Stanley Kramer as a work of art before they see it, or a film from a European director...but they unloose their ire against low or medium budget Hollywood productions"3Considered one of the greatest of all American directors, John Ford would no doubt be regarded an auteur by those who choose to utilize the phrase. One can imagine Ford carefully weaving beautiful images of monument valley, to fulfill his artistic allegories, or demanding the

An Argument Against Citigroup in China

2287 words - 9 pages An Argument Against Citigroup in China Chinese regulations have historically limited the operations of foreign banks, but with the

An Argument Against Racial Profiling by Police

1117 words - 4 pages Racial profiling; a government activity directed at a suspect or group of suspects, is used by law enforcement officers to reduce violent crimes. Even though racial profiling reduces crime, officers should not engage in it for the reason that it is unconstitutional and a form of discrimination against citizens. Racial profiling typically occurs after a traffic or pedestrian stop, in many cases an officer is accused of singling out a person

An Argument Against Racial Profiling by Police

1612 words - 6 pages mistaken for far more ethnic groups and races such as Jews, Muslims, Mexicans, Native Americans, and many more are racially profiled on a day to day basis. Many people believe racial profiling to be a myth because they see it as police officers merely taking precautions of preventing a crime before it happens, but in reality racial profiling has just become an approved term for discrimination and unjust actions against people of different

Macbeth is a play for all time. Write an argument for or against

3310 words - 13 pages and corporate criminals. This recurring theme has appealed to audiences of all time.Appearance vs. Reality is demonstrated throughout the play and reminds us that things are not always like what they seem to be. Appearance does not always agree with reality. A limited view on an event or a subject will likely lead to a limited or even false conclusion. In the play, the Scottish nobles viewed Macbeth as a bloody tyrant but for the audience, Macbeth

A Non-Pacifist Argument Against Capital Punishment

2756 words - 11 pages morally justified. The main difficulty that I have encountered in using this argument against predominantly religious advocates of the death penalty is that many passages in the Bible actually seem to require the death penalty for certain crimes. Among those specifically mentioned are "adultery (Leviticus), both parties involved in criminal assault in the city, a rebellious son, and an unchaste bride (Deuteronomy), striking or cursing one’s

Argument Against a Ban on Boxing

854 words - 3 pages Argument Against a Ban on Boxing The entertaining sport of boxing, an athletic event consisting of numerous health conflictions, has been receiving some heat from legal and medical advocates, yet “Some of the qualities that have open boxing to attack have, at the same time, been its salvation”(Sammons 235). Boxing, which has been in existence and evolved from other forms of fighting longer than this country has been established, is a

Against Capital Punishment : A Researched Argument

1691 words - 7 pages simple such as marrying a Jew, not confessing to a crime, and treason. It wasn't until 1767 however, that Caesar Beccaria wrote an influential essay that theorized that there was no justification for the state's taking of a life. This came for the abolition of the death penalty in Austria and Tuscany. American intellectuals were also influenced by Beccaria. Jefferson took notice on the issue and proposed a bill that capital punishment should only be

Ineffective Grading Policies: An Argument Against Giving Zeros

1363 words - 6 pages Ineffective Grading Policies An Argument Against Giving Zero’s 5/2/2014 Bryce Wallace   The basis of my argumentative paper will be to take an in-depth look at ineffective grading practices and the use of zeros as a form of punishment. Since this is something I have personally been faced with, I argue that giving students a zero for missed work, whether it be for missing due to illness or being suspended from school, is

An Argument Against Pornography by Andrew Bucklin. Creative Writting / Persuasive

1508 words - 6 pages with their lives. This is an argument that has points on both sides that can go on forever. My belief is that porn is useless and does nothing but destroy the outlook a person has for the opposite sex and how to treat them. Pornography is a vicious tool that constricts and oppresses people to live and think a certain way that causes destruction and ruins lives.

How to Handle an Argument with a Woman

883 words - 4 pages speaking, is the leader of the relationship. Therefore he is responsible for many situations, including handling arguments properly with his significant other. It is much better to come out even and with better feelings towards each other than to be angry at the fact that she won the argument. Handling an argument properly with the female can save one’s relationship by making things smoother. By handling an argument properly, a guy can save his

Similar Essays

An Argument Against Abortion Essay

1025 words - 4 pages . One argument made by people in favor of abortion is an appeal to pity. When one fallaciously argues by appealing to pity, one is arguing that certain actions should be permitted or tolerated out of pity for those performing them when in fact the basis for showing them pity is not a legitimate basis for the action. For example, a woman who argues that she should not receive a parking ticket because her child was crying and

An Argument Against Racial Profiling Essay

1109 words - 4 pages "I don't want to talk about whether or not racial profiling is legal. Racial profiling is not an effective law enforcement tool." -- Eric Holder, 82nd Attorney General of the United States Before any argument can be made against racial profiling, it is important to understand what racial profiling is. The American Civil Liberties Union, defines racial profiling as "the discriminatory practice by law enforcement officials of targeting

An Argument Against Gun Control Essay

858 words - 3 pages Argument Against Gun Control An Argument Against Gun Control As long ago as 1789, the creators of the Constitution realized the importance of guns in American society. The Second Amendment states,"A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State, the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." No loopholes, or legal caches exist in this statement. The Founding Fathers

An Argument Against Gun Control Essay

899 words - 4 pages occur. Guns do not commit crimes alone. It is the irresponsibility and ignorance of gun owners that cause it. Guns do not have a mind of their own and if there are owners, who fail to act responsibly, do not punish other law- abiding citizens who are responsible when owning guns. If a student makes an error in their writing, do we blame the pencil they use to write? Highly unlikely. Gun control would not prevent criminals from