This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

A Compare And Contrast Of Thomas Moores Utopia And Machiavelli?S The Prince

1468 words - 6 pages

Just vs. Viable
     To be just is to be fair and honorable. Kids are taught that if you are kind and just you will excel and be successful. But life’s not fair and being just doesn’t necessary mean that a society will stand the test of time and be able to grow. The two different societies introduced in More’s Utopia and Machiavelli’s The Prince are very different and although More’s Utopian society would be considered more just then Machiavelli’s society. Machiavelli’s society is more realistic and more likely to be viable.
     Leadership is a major issue when it comes to whether or not a society is going to be viable. It seems that if the leader is a good leader, a leader that puts his people first and wants the best for his country, then the land and the society should flourish. But if the leader is a bad leader, a power driven leader, a leader who puts himself first, and lets his people starve while he and his nobles live in excess, then the society and land will not flourish. This idea is not demonstrated to us in Utopia or The Prince; it seems like the exact opposite.
Utopia has a more democratic government. Each set of households elects someone and then those elects elect others, and although there is a prince they still have the power to throw him out of office if he’s involved in any wrong doing. And although their prince doesn’t have as much power as a prince in Machiavelli’s writing the prince in Utopia serves a different purpose. The prince in Utopia is there to provide stability. With the syphogrants and tranibors changing annually the stability of a constant figure head is needed. More describes the government as follows
          “Once a year, every group of thirty households elects an official,
Formerly called the syphogrant, but now called the phylarch. Over
Every group of ten syphogrants with their households there is another official, once called the tranibor but now known as the head phylarch. All the syphogrants, two hundred in number, are brought together to elect the prince. They take an oath to choose the man they think best qualified; and then by secret ballot they elect they prince from among four men nominated by the people of the four sections of the city. The prince holds office for life, unless he is suspected of aiming at a tyranny. Though the tranibors are elected annually they are not changed for light or casual reasons. All other officials hold office for a single year only. ”

Any one can be a syphogrant or tranibor. And once you have a chance to be one you can not be re-elected. This prevents the same people from always being in office. And although you can campaign for office it is looked down upon. They believe the if you want the office that much you must have ulterior motives fueling you, so you wont be elected. They also had a rules whose purpose was to “prevent the prince and the tranibors from...

Find Another Essay On A Compare and Contrast of Thomas Moores Utopia and Machiavelli?s The Prince

Compare And Contrast Thomas Be Essay

1956 words - 8 pages prepared for his death. Both Job and Becket return to their people in prayer.      Joseph Campbell’s hero journey interpretation outlines the sequences of Job’s and Thomas Becket’s heroic circumstances. Each character progresses through the hero journey stages even though they do not necessarily follow the pattern. Job and Becket have similarities in their journeys: both experience a lifestyle

Comparing Thomas Mores Utopia and Machiavelli’s The Prince - Macquarie University Politics - Essay

1828 words - 8 pages Thomas More’s Utopia and Machiavelli’s The Prince are both concerned with the  fundamental issues of how society works in hand with virtue in order to maintain itself. The goals behind the two works, however, differ considerably. The aim of Utopia is to exemplify the maintenance of a perfect society (More 1516, p. 32) and the goal of The Prince is to instruct a prince, or ruler, on how to sustain his state (Machiavelli 1532, Chapter 16). From

Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs

2464 words - 10 pages Compare and Contrast A Withered Arm by Thomas Hardy and The Monkey's Paw by W.W. Jacobs In this essay I am going to explain the similarities and differences between 'The withered arm' and 'The monkeys paw'. Both of these texts were written before 1914 by two different people. Thomas Hardy wrote 'The withered arm' and W.W. Jacobs wrote 'A monkeys paw'. The withered arm is a short story about a milkmaid who had an affair with a high

Compare and Contrast the Philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes, and Karl Marx

772 words - 3 pages In the idea of human nature; origin of state, the nature of government, the rights of regulation can be drawn as the reflection of insightful philosophies of John Locke, Thomas Hobbes and Karl Marx. By understanding this within the context of human nature, we can see their ideas play to how they perceive a modern philosophy. Karl Marx's Communist Manifesto illustrates the desire to build "a society without economic classes". John Locke's

Compare and contrast Michael Jackson vs Prince - Essay

494 words - 2 pages similar traits while being unique in their own way. Both men took elements of funk, R&B, and disco and put that into their music and created a unique sound that defined the music. Prince was a musical innovator and known for his flamboyant stage presence, extravagant outfits and makeup, and wide vocal range. His music is mix of a wide variety of styles, including funk, rock, R&B, new wave, soul, and pop. Michael Jackson has been described as the King

Thomas More' s Utopia, In what ways does Utopia function as a critique of More's time?

891 words - 4 pages slaves. And they show their regret to the servants f the embassadors because of their normal wear.And also ın the story, Thomas More shows that he gives very improtance to labour and effort. In Utopia farmers are the most improtant people and farming is the most improtant job in the city. At the end of the story, in the conclusion; there is a paragraph that compares about these farmers and city workers with the bankers and other workers. The

Machiavelli's "The Prince": This paper was written to summarize "The Prince" by Machiavelli and to pull the deeper meanings out of it. We also had to compare it to previous literature in its genre

1104 words - 4 pages deal.Machiavelli shows little concern for the moral or material betterment of the people. There is no concern about getting rid of their sinfulness or making them better citizens. They seem to be only considered as tools for manipulation that help a prince in establishing or keeping power over a principality. With this treatment of the people Machiavelli is valuing political unity and power over a more traditional utopia where the ruler tries to

Risking it all for the things we long for... - A Compare/Contrast essay on Thomas Merton and Langston Hughes and their works regarding the Birmingham Bombings of 1963

1415 words - 6 pages depending on the author's background, motive, experiences, and point of view. Langston Hughes and Thomas Merton were surprisingly similar in backgrounds, yet different in location, race and education. Both had great parental problems earlier on in their lives; Hughes later would enter the army and then travel worldwide. Merton joined a hermit monastery and also traveled the world. In this way they were running from their problems and using the

Compare and contrast w/Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Edison

1062 words - 4 pages Long ago there was time where, the room was lit by candle light. In everything one could do one needed a candle next to them to make it possible for it to be done. It was not until the birth of Benjamin Franklin and Thomas Edison that this was changed forever. These two great men's inventions are what make our world today and without it, we would not be as advanced that we are. This will prove that there are many seminaries (interested in

Compare and Contrast of Henry O Tanner’s painting "The head of a Jew in Palestine” wit"h Alice Pike Barneys´s painting " The head of a Negro Boy"

1033 words - 5 pages is dressed in a dark green shirt or robe. The expression on his face looks as if he is fatigued and apprehensive. The majority of detail in the picture is within the man’s face and eyes. His face is a very high contrast in comparison to the dark background and clothing the painting is exceedingly realistic. The Head of a Negro Boy is an oil painting by Alice Barney. Barney used most of the canvas for the depiction. The portrait includes the

Compare and Contrast: iPhone 3G S and Blackberry Bold 9700

1364 words - 5 pages Untitled Contrast and Compare: iPhone 3G S and Blackberry Bold 9700 Salahuddin Nasir ENG 4UO April 5, 2010 The mobile phone market is crowded with hundreds and hundreds of phones and gadgets but at the top are the iPhone 3G S and the Blackberry Bold 9700. These phones demonstrate outstanding achievements in a whole variety of categories such as speed, design, usability and display. The iPhone 3G S is a very impressive phone

Similar Essays

Utopia By Thomas More And The Prince By Machiavelli

819 words - 3 pages Utopia by Thomas More and The Prince by Machiavelli Thomas More’s Utopia and Machiavelli’s The Prince both concern themselves with the fundamental issues of how a society works and maintains itself. The goals behind the two works, however, differ considerably. The goal of Utopia is to illustrate the maintenance of an “ideal” society and the goal of The Prince is to instruct a prince, or ruler, on how to maintain his state. On

Visions Of A Perfect Society Illustrated In Machiavelli's The Prince And Thomas More's Utopia

518 words - 2 pages When people think about the ‘perfect’ society, all will have a different idea on the topic. For example, Thomas More wrote in ‘Utopia’ of a society where all of the cities were exactly the same. Whereas Niccolo Machiavelli wrote about how a society should be ruled in ‘The Prince.’ Both works paint a portrait of leadership and laws, as well as life and society. In ‘The Prince’, Machiavelli isn’t describing the aspects of a perfect society, he is

Machiavelli Vs. Thoreau (Compare And Contrast Essay)

1040 words - 4 pages The way one should govern and the way for one to be governed will always be an ongoing struggle. How can a government maintain order and the safety of its people yet at the same time preserve its citizens' natural right to be free? The ideas from Niccolo Machiavelli, an Italian aristocrat, who published "The Prince" in 1513 for a Medici prince as a guideline on how to rule a country, gives a conservative approach to how one should govern. Henry

Utopia By Sir Thomas More This Is Sort Of A Comparison Essay On More And Machiavelli But It Is Moer About More And His Book, Utopia

1061 words - 4 pages Would you like to see a society in which police would be unnecessary, politicians would be honest, and money would cease to exist? Or would you like to see a society in which political conduct operates independent of ethics, thus disregarding moral authorities such as classical philosophy and Christian technology? In retrospect the choice then comes down to Sir Thomas More or Niccolò Machiavelli. During a time where classical Greek and