A Review Of Responses To The National Endowment For The Arts Report, “Reading At Risk: A Survey Of Literary Reading In America”

2290 words - 9 pages

During the past twenty years there has been much debate over topics regarding literacy and literature in America. In June 2004, based on their comparison of literary reading surveys from 1982, 1992, and 2002, the National Endowment for the Arts released the following statement.

The accelerating declines in literary reading among all demographic groups of American adults indicate an imminent cultural crisis. The trends among younger adults warrant special concern, suggesting that – unless some effective solution is found – literary culture, and literacy in general, will continue to worsen. Indeed, at the current rate of loss, literary reading as a leisure activity will virtually disappear in half a century. (NEA, “Reading at Risk”)

In recent years, access to the Internet has become available to Americans of all ages and cultural backgrounds. Some authority figures in academia see this as a threat to the perpetuation of printed literature. Other authorities view the Internet as an additional medium for advancing literacy. Another problem authorities face is one of definition. Some authorities want a broader definition of what constitutes literature while others insist on a standard of quality for literary works. What follows are some thoughts and opinions on these related topics and others.

Some critics feel the NEA survey’s narrow definition of “literary reading” is the NEA’s feeble attempt to designate genres of literary importance. The “Reading at Risk” study defines literary readers as those who read short stories, poetry, and plays in their leisure time, excluding any reading done for work or school or on the Internet (NEA, “Reading at Risk”).

Stuart Moulthrop, co-author of the online dialogue, “New Literacies and Old,” questions the NEA’s use of such a conservative definition.

Why [doesn’t the NEA] include biographies, memoirs, or non-fiction books about history, science, economics, or even popular philosophy? I'll agree that most Americans know very little about fiction and poetry, even recent work in their own language. But most of us are yet more profoundly in the dark about the natural and social sciences. Which is the more serious problem? (Moulthrop and Kaplan, “New Literacies and Old”)

Excluding computer-based reading from a literary survey during a technological boom significantly reduces the scope of the NEA’s study. Moulthrop reminds us, “Reading has never been exclusively tied to the book” (Moulthrop and Kaplan, “New Literacies and Old”). During the Gutenberg era, books were too expensive, even for highly literate people. Literature dispersed through “pamphlets, posters, broadsides, letters, sermons and newspapers…had just as profound a cultural influence as novels and volumes of poetry” (Moulthrop and Kaplan, “New Literacies and Old”).

Erik Jacobson, of the National Institute for Literacy, questions the NEA’s proposal of a national decline in reading “for the first time in modern history” (Jacobson, “RE:...

Find Another Essay On A Review of Responses to the National Endowment for the Arts Report, “Reading at Risk: A Survey of Literary Reading in America”

Choose a form of literary Criticism to which 'Paste' by Henry James can be giving a succesful reading.

2037 words - 8 pages -mother or indeed himself.Though perhaps it can be argued that merely highlighting the tendencies of the human condition are arbitrary observations at best and do little for the furthering of understanding of the human condition, it surely is the first important step a writer can take in trying to change such social conventions as honour.) Matthew Arnold said (see William A. Madden) in the realms of reason there are the analytic, which is the

Review of Margaret Sonser Breen’s Reading for Constructions of the Unspeakable: Teaching Kafka’s Metamorphosis

745 words - 3 pages According to Margaret Sonser Breen’s Reading for Constructions of the Unspeakable: Teaching Kafka’s Metamorphosis, “One of the most challenging issues confronting secondary and university teachers is how to teach subjects that have been labeled “off limits,” either by school boards or institutional policies or, more pervasively if vaguely, by cultural norms (pg.1 paragraph 1).” She argues that discussions of “unspeakable themes” have been muted

Reading Report

1067 words - 5 pages consumption impulses. In order to examine the main question, this journal demonstrated the literature review of the definition of the four factors and two empirical studies. The implications for advertising researchers and ideas for future research were also discussed at the end. According to Moore and Lee, imagery visualization was the foundation to achieve the hedonic advertising appeals and directly triggered the occurrence of anticipated

At Risk Students and Reading Proficiency

1180 words - 5 pages Chapter II Review of the Literature Introduction It is a “reading world” we live in and students should be guaranteed every opportunity to succeed in this information driven society. Children today are overwhelmed with more reading material than ever before on billboard, television, the Internet and at school, causing reading to become a relevant and essential need in the life of every child (Lumpkin 1972). Being able to read has become the

Heavy Versus Light Reading: The Decipherment of Literary and Non-Literary Texts

1782 words - 7 pages text, he/she is forced to choose a new transitory reading. It is not the "literary" text itself which is ephemeral, but rather the reading of such a text. Conversely, the "non-literary" text is "light" in that its meaning is literal and singular, and that it allows for only one kind of reading. The reading of such a text, though, is actually quite heavy, in that all of its repetitions will necessarily hold the same pre-determined decisions, the same

On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High

965 words - 4 pages On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High In his poem, "On Reading Poems to a Senior Class at South High", the author, David Chapman Berry, has relied on metaphors and similes to carry out his view of a typical literature class and a teacher's view of teaching. The setting of the poem is in a senior literature class, at South High School. The speaker in this poem is a teacher, who tells the reader about his or her students and about

"Reading Journal: The Scarlet Letter" Analyze the major literary aspects of THE SCARLET LETTER.

2596 words - 10 pages Hester and Dimmesdale shared, allowing his hate and judgment of the sinner to cultivate within led him to depravity.Ambiguity:Throughout the story, ambiguity brings into question the nature of evil. The reader is left to decide for his self who is at fault in the story and who has redeemed his self. Hester becomes a stronger character in the end directly because of the trials attributed to her sin. Dimmesdale struggles with his sin, holding it

Andy Warhol: A review of His Time Capsules - Shown at the National Gallery of Victoria: Andy Warhol exhibition

1671 words - 7 pages that were very disturbing; pictures of naked young men and one that I believed that looked like a naked transsexual. He also created "films", that is, motion pictures that stayed stationary or repeating the same actions over and over again for minutes on end. I was very bewildered and confused at first to see this, but I reflected upon the fact that Warhol lived in a very different time and place from my own. I asked to myself that, as a child

The Use of English Subtitled Anime in Enhancing the Reading Skill of Selected Gade 8 Students of Lecheria National High School, A.Y. 2013-2014

6122 words - 24 pages material. The fourth is the family-based risk factors or the external forces specifically, at home. The last is the neighborhood, community and school-based factors which includes the influence of the environment to the reader.These factors of reading are all present in the schools of Calamba, specifically, Lecheria National High School. It all depends on how these factors appear to the student himself-may it be positive or negative.In this study

English Reading Report Assignment

904 words - 4 pages main characters, Felix and Zelda. The book Then is set in Poland during the period of the Holocaust and Nazis in 1942. The book is about the two orphans, Felix and Zelda, who escaped from a train that travel to a Nazi death camp for Jewish people. They struggled to survive without food or water. They met Genia, a farmer who became their guardian and provided a shelter and kindness to the two children. Felix and Zelda embarked on a terrifying

Report on local or national provision of Arts and Entertainment

3698 words - 15 pages productionpersonnel· The National Art Gallery 13· BA London Eye 14Public Relations and Advertising within theorganisations· The National Art Gallery 15· BA London Eye 16Conclusion 17Bibliography 18Appendix 19IntroductionIn this assignment I have been asked to produce a report that focuses on the provision of either local or national, Art and Entertainment venues. Within in this assignment I have been asked to explain my

Similar Essays

Eliminating The National Endowment For The Arts

2620 words - 10 pages The National Endowment for the Arts is an independent agency of the federal government specifically designed to support and enhances the art community for minority groups. The NEA was founded in 1965 and has controlled the art community ever since. This has aided in censoring works of supposedly obscene and controversial art. The elimination of the NEA, or making it a private organization, would free much needed public tax dollars to go to more

Finely V. The National Endowment For The Arts: One Battle In America's War Over The Arts

1647 words - 7 pages described as a political compromise, Finely v. the National Endowment for the Arts has already affected at least two cases. In the case of Esperanza Peace and Justice Center v. San Antonio, the city government ceased funding of an arts group and made the mistake of announcing it was because of dislike (Hamilton, 22). Most recently in New York, Mayor Giuliani was stifled and censured for an attempt to halt funding for the Brooklyn Museum for indecency

A Review Of The Article "Introducing Percents In Linear Measurement To Foster An Understanding Of Rational Number Operations" A Critical Reading

550 words - 2 pages struggling to master a complex set of procedures that might seem foreign to them.A second advantage of this instructional approach is that by beginning with percents, we allow children to make their first conversions among the different representations of rational numbers in a direct and intuitive fashion and to develop a better general understanding of how the three systems are related. At the time of the lesson, the students had been working

Synthesis Of The Reading Writing Connection And Literary Borrowing

1749 words - 7 pages prominent teachers and researchers to support the connection between reading and writing and states, “the primary reason for exposing children to quality literature is for its aesthetic value; a secondary benefit is its influence on student writing” (p. 1). Olness continues by explaining the ways students develop literary skills and awareness, expansion of vocabulary, and overall literature experience by hearing the language of good writers, which