A Comparison Of The Mill On The Floss By George Eliot, Passage To India By E.M. Foster, And When We Were Orphans By Kazuo Ishiguro

2966 words - 12 pages

A Comparison of The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot, Passage to India by E.M. Foster, and When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro

The three extracts I have chosen are all written in a relatively
similar style, I am rather partial to this style, ergo the motive for
choosing them. This will however, make contrasting them a little
harder, however I believe that the consequent refined subtleties will
provide a more interesting essay. Let us hope so.

To provide a suitable structure from which to analyse less obvious
comparisons, something of the author's contextual intentions must be
made apparent. Style lends itself well to this.

When observing the three extracts we conclude that all three have a
similar style. From this we mean that they have the same approach and
method of conveying their intensions, whatever they may be. The three
extracts vary in the amount of description they use; they do this in
relation to their period, the earliest using the most and so forth, at
first indicating a difference in style. A more convoluted language
used with Tmotf (The Mill On The Floss) becoming sparser through Pti
(Passage to India), and then Wwwo (When We Were Orphans) although this
is true and a contrast is observed we also note that they are three
very descriptive passages, not only from their own periods but also,
in subtle comparison to each other. Tmotf is a descriptive extract in
its own right, an extensive use of adjectives proving this.

'stretching their red-brown sails close among the branches of the
spreading ash'

However, the other two extracts are equally descriptive. They both
give the reader an unnecessary amount of information for the extract
to progress as a narrative, thus meriting it description and allowing
it to compare on a stylistic level with Tmotf.

Another stylistic contrast is the amount of factual information made
use of. EM Forster greatly outdoes Eliot and Ishiguro in the substance
of fact he writes. He extends a large amount of information to the
reader, occasionally slipping them a point of view.

'two hundred years ago it lay on the road between upper India, then

This use of information gives us an insight as to the objective of
Forster. Not only does he wish to give us a picture of India, he
wishes to give evidence of his opinion of it; he does this from a
historical aspect and a social.

'So abased, so monotonous is everything that meets the eye,'

As he views India from the perspective of an Englishman, he sees it in
a very English light this being the reason for the judgments he tries
to justify. Wwwo and particularly Tmotf do not use this amount of
information. On the one hand this is because they are not dealing with
such a subject, India, and on the other hand because they are more
concerned with detail in narrative and...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot, Passage to India by E.M. Foster, and When We Were Orphans by Kazuo Ishiguro

E.M Forster’s novel A Passage to India

1237 words - 5 pages . The fallibility of this friendship suggests that even if friendship were possible between the English and Indian races, it will be hindered through external circumstances. The portrayal of the British in India is more of a favourable representation by Forster to the English. They are presented superior whereas Indians are shown as superstitious and irrational giving a stereotypical view of the race overall. The narrator of A Passage to India

George Eliot’s The Mill on the Floss: The Construction of Gender Roles

3446 words - 14 pages . This attitude gets ripened with the passage of time and a day comes when it becomes the natural behaviour a child. Beauvoir says in The Second Sex, that boys are taught to behave in a manner; different from girls and vice versa, for example: “A man doesn't look at himself in mirrors...A man doesn't cry” (298). He is, in a way, convinced to be a “little man” i.e. superior, strong and courageous unlike girls. Similarly, in The Mill the on Floss

Relates to "When we were kings", "Bowling for columbine", and "Do the right thing"

1108 words - 4 pages with. Ali was loved in Zaire and in the United States. George Foreman was not a favorite in Zaire. Violence is a force used in When We Were Kings. One of the ways it was used was in a constructive manner; the fighters were doing it for the sport and to help the country of Zaire. They also had some of the best black musicians in the business perform during the fight They had performances by B.B. King, Brian McKnight, James brown and many

The Remains of the Day, by Kazuo Ishiguro

1149 words - 5 pages The Remains of the Day is a fictional novel written by Kazuo Ishiguro. Ishiguro was born in Nagasaki, Japan in 1954 and moved with his family to England in 1960. The Remains of the Day contains several literary techniques such as tone, flashbacks, symbolism, and foreshadowing used to emphasize the core themes of dignity, regret, and loyalty. The Remains of the Day is a first person narrative of an English butler named Stevens on 6-day trip to

When we Were Kings Analysis

933 words - 4 pages When we were kings directed by Leon Gast is a documentary on the famous "rumble in the jungle" heavy weight championship between George Forman and Muhammad Ali. The fight took place October 30, 1974 in Zaire, Africa.Rumble in the Jungle was the title match between world Heavyweight champion George Foreman and his challenger the former champion Muhammad Ali. The fight took place in Zaire; where it was promoted by Don King, This event was one of

The Quintessence of Humanity in The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood and Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

3013 words - 12 pages The Quintessence of Humanity Often in life, people take their freedoms, a gift that allows them to express their individuality, for granted. However, in the dystopian societies of The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood and Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro, people are reminded of just how easily their freedoms and humanity can be stripped away. Attwood and Ishiguro urge people to never lose sight of the core values that define who they

Differences and Similarities Between Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood

2393 words - 10 pages The purpose of this essay is to analyse and compare the narrative situations proposed by Franz Stanzel in the dystopian novels Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro and The Handmaid’s Tale by Margaret Atwood. For this aim, I am going to focus on the aspects focalization (reflection), relationship reader-narrator, narrative distance, knowledge, and reliability and demonstrate that they affect the interpretation of the novel by readers in a

Unreliable narration in The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro and Love and Death in Long Island by Gilbert Adair. Vanderbilt.

1443 words - 6 pages 4/15/03Different Strokes for Different FolksPeople make friends and acquaintances with similar backgrounds and similar viewpoints. When a story is told, the audience takes it for granted that the storyteller values the same things as they do. If the person has different beliefs and values, does that make the story less valid? The narrators in The Remains of the Day by Kazuo Ishiguro and Love and Death in Long Island by Gilbert Adair are both

"what To Do With The Remains Of Your Day?" Analysis Of The Book: "the Remains Of The Day" By Kazuo Ishiguro.

3006 words - 12 pages differently, how these were perceived by our peers and how they affect our future interactions in similar situations. Basically, our social and empathic skills and also help us fine-tune our relations to other people, our emotions, and thus our personality. Reflection is how we evolve as human beings. Without reflection at the end of the day, we continue to tread the same waters, never realizing that these waters are merely a single drop in the

A Passage to India by Forster

1069 words - 4 pages India that limit women. In E.M. Forster’s novel A Passage to India, Forster exposes derogatory stereotypes of women and portrays women as inferior to men to uphold the view of women during the time period. In the novel A Passage to India, written by Forster, he is bias towards the women in the novel. The society when Forster wrote the novel in the 1920’s had different views on women than it has today and is for that reason why he uses

Never Let Me Go by Kazuo Ishiguro

2274 words - 9 pages her donations, her final wish is to consent to Tommy and Kathy’s relationship, “I glanced at Ruth beside me. There was no anger in her eyes, just a kind of wariness. There was even a sort of hope, I thought, that when the poster appeared, it would be perfectly innocuous – something that reminded us of Hailsham, something like that” (Ishiguro, 229). Ruth gazes upon the posters on the highway as Kathy drives back to the donation center. Ruth’s final

Similar Essays

The Mill On The Floss By George Eliot

1813 words - 7 pages The Mill on the Floss by George Eliot It is said that George Eliot’s style of writing deals with much realism. Eliot, herself meant by a “realist” to be “an artist who values the truth of observation above the imaginative fancies of writers of “romance” or fashionable melodramatic fiction.” (Ashton 19) This technique is artfully utilized in her writings in a way which human character and relationships are dissected and analyzed. In the

A Passage To India By E.M. Forster

2985 words - 12 pages A Passage to India by E.M. Forster Upon a most rudimentary evaluation, A Passage to India is simply a story, a tale of two countries through which we follow a handful of

"A Passage To India" By E.M. Forster

1184 words - 5 pages Essay talks about cultural misunderstandings in the book "A Passage to India" by E.M. Forster between the British and the Indians. Some sentences don't read well, but overall clear and easy to read.Cultural MisunderstandingIn his novel A Passage to India, E.M. Forster uses a series of repeated misunderstandings between cultures, which become solidified into social stereotypes, to justify the meaningless attempts to bridge the cultural gaps. In

The Assault By Harry Mulisch, The Remains Of The Day By Kazuo Ishiguro And 1984 By George Orwell

2420 words - 10 pages however also symbolizes Winston’s downfall when it is “smashed to pieces on the hearthstone,” (223) by the Thought Police as they arrest him. Winston then thought “how small it always was,” (223) just like his hopes of escaping the wrath of Big Brother always were. Winston is ruined because of his refusal to accept the Party’s lies about history. Winston continues for a short period of time to deny Big Brother’s ideals and