This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Essay On Shopping Malls And The Power Struggles Going On Within Them: A Critical Analysis Of Fiske's "Shopping For Pleasure", From "Reading The Popular".

1533 words - 6 pages

An essay on shopping malls and the power struggles going on within them.In this essay, I have given a critical analysis of Fiske's "Shopping for Pleasure", from"Reading The Popular". In this analysis, I will be examining the main points in this chapter and discussing Fiske's explanation for including each one. I will also be examining counter arguments from other sources on his theories.There are five distinctive sections within this chapter: 'malls, power and resistance', 'consuming women', commodities and women', 'conspicuous consumption', and 'progress and the new.' I intend to look at each section separately, finally connecting the whole chapter at the end of my analysis.The first section from this chapter is titled 'Malls, Power and Resistance'. This section discusses shopping malls or "cathedrals of consumption" as described by the author, and the power struggle between the consumer and the distributor. As shown above, the author, in this section uses the metaphor of consumerism as a religion, the 'icons of worship' being the commodities. This seems a reasonable metaphor, the consumers as a congregation and the manufacturers or distributors being the 'Authority on High', however the author dislikes this metaphor, preferring to swap it for a metaphor of warfare later on in this section, when describing the tricks used by consumers to baffle and display pseudo-power over the authority of the malls.Basically, this section is describing the power of the capitalists by means of the shopping mall and the tactics of the consumer to counter this. The tactics including window shopping, using the mall as a place to hang-out (consuming space in the mall, rather than commodities), and generally exploiting the mall for the use of its controlled climate for example, walking in bad weather and letting young children play in the warm. However, as Fiske points out, the owners of the shopping malls may even encourage the passive users in the hope that they will become 'real economic consumers', but they have no control over whether they will. Fiske describes this power struggle in malls as " where the strategy of the powerful is most vulnerable to the tactical raids ofthe weak."In the next part of the text, 'Consuming Women', the author finds three two emphases: gender difference, (female gender and shopping versus male gender and success) and work versus leisure. These seem to be the main points within this section, with the gender issue being the principal issue. Fiske demonstrates this by the slogans in cards and shop windows and the different cultural visibility that the two sexes receive, for example for the masculine attributes are competitive and tough - public success, whereas the women's attributes are (within the patriarchal society and concept of the 'nuclear family') 'household managers', and although are too expected to be successes this is within the confined and private space of home and family life. The work versus leisure theme is...

Find Another Essay On An essay on shopping malls and the power struggles going on within them: A critical analysis of Fiske's "Shopping for Pleasure", from "Reading The Popular".

A Critical of Awareness of Social Issues within Popular Culture

850 words - 4 pages John Harris’s article “Pussy Riot: The Power of Punk” explains that social change can occur rapidly in popular culture than in politics. The popular cultural process of change is rather a process of creating awareness to social issues than an immediate action. Popular culture, in its various forms, is the essential motivator of awareness of social issues leading to an increase of discernment amongst the masses and lay about the foundation for

Identifying Significant Conflicts or Power Struggles within Your Organization

1339 words - 6 pages Identify significant conflicts or power struggles within your organization. What are the issues? What are the biblical implications? Currently, the most significant struggle at Stryker is the challenge for the integrated manufacturing team to make a profit. The primary cause of this problem is the sudden increase of operating expenses associated with The American Healthcare Act. Under the new guidelines of the American Health Care Act all

This is an essay on Norelco's shopping cart investment plans. Its was for a marketing class

642 words - 3 pages stores under the Norelco name.The director of marketing for the North American Philips Lighting Corporation (NAPLC) was John Hays. John Hayes worked for the Westinghouse Electric Company for 12 before taking this project on in 1978. Everyone from the marketing department to upper managers thought the program was going to be a huge success in introducing the Norelco light bulbs to the grocery store area. When the shopping cart project was started

The Advantages and Risks of Online Shopping

958 words - 4 pages should be raised: what is the advantage of online shopping? Why people shop online? In following paragraphs, the advantage of online shopping for the consumer and consumer’s motivation to shop online will be reviewed and discussed. The main advantage of online shopping is convenient. Online shops open 24/7. People who live in remote areas do not need to speed long time on the traveling to the stores. Consumers who come from other cities

Analysis of Walt Disney's Impact on Our Nation's Shopping Centers

1773 words - 7 pages prevalent in a typical turn of the century Main Street. Disney used lighting to his benefit and created a dazzling arrangement of rim lighting in Main Street USA, something that would probably not have been found on a typical main street. Francaviglia states that developers use Disney's Main Street as a prototype for modern shopping centers. His main argument is that Main Street USA's lack of realism has indirectly affected our nation's malls and

The Benefits of Shopping Online

1213 words - 5 pages being able to try the clothes on. I asked those in favor of shopping online to tell me what they dislike about the process. Pierce, a double major in English and teaching, passionately exclaimed, “I hate shipping and handling charges. Jen, you cannot tell me it costs that much to put a shirt in a box!” I had to agree with his point. Costs for shipping and handling charges are approximately ten to fifteen dollars for an order that ranges from

Discuss the advantages and disadvantages of online shopping for consumers in Hong Kong.

889 words - 4 pages those products’ information and buy them. Moreover, air transportation and transshipment are supporting logistics: products can be transport to Hong Kong from far away easily. Thus, Internet solve the limitations on shopping time and place, consumers might purchase more convenient. The next argument in favor of online shopping is that consumers might enjoy a lower selling price. A recent survey conducted by Giunipero and Sawchuk (2000) shows that

Close reading and analysis of Sherman Alexie's "On the Amtrak from Boston to New York City."

651 words - 3 pages really is. However, his Native American upbringing has instilled in him a deep respect for elders. A characteristic that our culture lacks teaching to its young sometimes. He, like many of his kind, is very honorable and respectful of those who deserve respect."On the Amtrak from Boston to New York City" was honestly one of the best poems I have ever read. It is about a subject that I have not put much thought about. However, after reading this

Shopping for a Special Emotion An essay about a significant event that changed my life

969 words - 4 pages SHOPPING FOR A SPECIAL EMOTIONThe rush of the crowds, the dinging of cash registers, and the instant gratification of six little words: thank you, have a nice day. These everyday bits and pieces were my way of life. Unlike everyone else, shopping for me was not just a hobby; it defined whom I was and how I was feeling at that moment. For me, shopping was an escape from situations that I could not handle. All the sounds and smells, were somehow a

The "Flip-side" of Power An essay on the conflict of power and safety in Macbeth

935 words - 4 pages other, and a similar phenomenon is found in our everyday lives. This relates to William Shakespeare's Macbeth. The protagonist is lured to murder King Duncan by the desire for power, an appetite whetted by the witches' prophecies and his wife's encouragement. But when he obtains the thrown, he finds himself insecure. He attempts to remove threats that decrease his security. In the play Macbeth, despite appearances of paradox, Shakespeare uses the

The First Shopping Mall

1379 words - 6 pages revenue malls often sell off the farthest areas of their parking lots; typically for chain restaurants to be built. Not exactly what Gruen had in mind. In this essay, I will be focusing on the Mall at Partridge Creek. Though I acknowledge that Partridge Creek is still not what Gruen had envisioned, I think that it is trying to set itself apart from the traditional shopping mall and provide more of a community feeling to the shopping experience

Similar Essays

This Essay Was For A Geography Retail Class, And I Was Supposed To Gather Three Article's And Compare And Contrast The Idea's Of The Aritcle With The Main Topic Which Was Shopping Malls In N.America

2242 words - 9 pages no one would want to travel to the suburbs for a shopping mall.Both Dr. Jones and Smith see eye to eye on the fact that shopping malls should not be located within the suburbs, because of the traffic and noise it creates. Dr. Jones states the Canada should and will follow the US's approach, having a shopping mall integrated into the community that surrounds it. These Urban Mall will offer a more pleasurable experience of shopping, not a

Popular Culture: Is Kowinki's Theory Regarding Shopping Malls Having An Iconic Image Valid?

933 words - 4 pages After reviewing Kowinski's notion that shopping malls enjoy an iconic status, I definitely agree with his philosophy. Over the past five years, many new malls have been constructed in the Central Ohio region. For instance, some newer malls in this area are Easton Town Center, Polaris Fashion Center, and Tuttle Crossing Mall. Being an avid shopper, I have visited many of them. Each mall is designed very uniquely and each varies in style

Shopping Within The Convience Of Your Home

1221 words - 5 pages Harvey 6Jaylond HarveyMeteorology MajorENG 104-14Mrs. Shelia SalinsCompare and Contrast EssayOctober 21, 2014Shopping Within the Convenience of Your HomeShopping is the act of buying products from stores. Shopping is a part of everyday life. Some customers use shopping for only necessary purposes while others love to shop. Shopping is a fun activity and reduce stress. Two forms of shopping are online and traditional shopping. Traditional

Going Into A Store Verses Online Shopping

833 words - 3 pages product. It is also a way to get out of the couch, away from the television, or off the computer. Another feature is you can see and examine what you are going to purchase, helps in the decision making for most people. You know the minute the salesperson ring you up the product are yours to take home and use right away. It also makes return on items simple, take it back to where you bought, and get an exchange or a refund if needed. Variety is