This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Ethical Evaluation Of Peer To Peer File Swapping

3323 words - 13 pages

An Ethical Evaluation of Peer-to-Peer File Swapping


The last few years has seen an explosion in the use of the Internet as a means for exchanging, free of charge, digital media by way of Peer-to-Peer (P2P) file sharing technologies. Initially, the practice was primarily limited to the swapping of music, in the form of MP3 files. The pervasiveness of broadband, the advent of newer file types, and the creation of more sophisticated technologies has subsequently made possible the exchange of other types as well – including movies, television shows and software. Again, for free.

In this paper, we will explore the ethical considerations of this practice as it relates to Intellectual Property (IP) – whether protected by copyright law or not. We will concentrate primarily on music, but where appropriate, other media will be considered, as many of the issues are common across the different types.

Taking a global perspective, one must keep in mind that the term “copyright” is not universally defined, accepted, or enforced. We must therefore use the term with the United State’s definition as a basis. However, absent U.S. law, we must also consider the creator’s intent as it relates to the distribution and use of his or her work. This exploration will lead us to a universal position – one that claims that the wide-scale, free exchange of Intellectual Property by means of P2P technology is unethical.

The Technology

The P2P model gained wide scale notoriety with the success of Napster in late 1999. Almost overnight, P2P and Napster became household words. There are essentially two variations of the P2P model – the Napster model and the Gnutella model. Both follow the fundamental principle of P2P sharing – individual hosts interact with one another when transmitting information. Intermediary servers have no role – information does not pass through them and the files are not stored there. This is an important aspect because it means there’s no central authority controlling what is transmitted where – ultimately, only the user’s hosts are involved in the transfer transaction.

There is one key distinction between the two models. Napster does store a listing of what users are sharing which files and provides the appropriate client connection points. This is to facilitate searching – users wishing to know who has what simply ask the Napster server. The Napster server searches it’s own index on behalf of the user. When a file of interest is located, the Napster server provides the connection points and the peer hosts engage in conversation.

Gnutella’s model has no such central directory or index server. Instead, Gnutella (and others) builds a web of hosts, each communicating with one another – not only when it comes time to transmit files, but search requests as well. Therefore, it is argued, this model merely contributes to user interaction with one another and plays no role when it comes to the file being...

Find Another Essay On An Ethical Evaluation of Peer-to-Peer File Swapping

"Peer-to-Peer File Sharing Networks" This paper outlines the history of P2P file sharing networks such as Napster, Gnutella and Kazaa, and discusses their impact on society and the music industry

3226 words - 13 pages The P2P File Sharing NetworkRobert MarcellinoCLST 311 Spring 2010Peer-to-peer file sharing networks (or "P2P" networks) are Internet networks which allow users with the same P2P networking program to connect with each other and utilize search functions to directly access and download files from one another's hard drives. The nodes (or peers) function as both suppliers and consumers of shared media, as opposed to traditional client/server

Classes of Decentralized Peer-to-Peer Networks Essay

2061 words - 9 pages first Gnutella specifications. This overlay classifies peers into Superpeer or Ultrapeer (SP) and Ordinary-Peer (OP). SPs have usually superior performance or knowledge than OPs and can provide discovery services for OPs, thus reducing the number of messages generated to find resource. OPs connect to only one SP at a time, for sharing their resources and participating in the network, while SPs form an unstructured P2P overlay network and maintain

Napster Peer to Peer Technology

1877 words - 8 pages slipping away and realize there is revenue to be made in the area of peer to peer network (every computer in a sense becomes a server and a client looking for data). If a decision granted by the courts is given to the record companies, they will eventually in due time capitalize on the innovations of Napster which in turn would be an infringement on Napsters rights. Copyright law has always been a bargain (Italics added to stress the word

Peer-to-Peer Technologies in Distance Learning

2432 words - 10 pages asymmetrically, i.e. a central server will wait for incoming connecting requests from a client, and then provide service accordingly. In contrast, the peer-to-peer system can act both as a client and a server, depending on the tasks. For instance, an end-user device in the peer-to-peer network can respond to a search request, acting as a server, and also forward the request to other systems, acting as a client (ref.). Due to the nature of the peer-to

Solutions to Peer Pressure

1114 words - 5 pages . Most of the time we do whatever it is they want us to do to either entertain them or make them happy. Yet that doesn’t mean after the teenage years that peer pressure is completely gone from an adults life. Many adults are continually peer pressured even into old age although it may be a bit more difficult to recognize the peer pressure because it isn’t always defined as peer pressure. In Shooting an Elephant by George Orwell the main character

Effect of Peer Pressure

660 words - 3 pages someone else. Taking Troy as an example, when his friends pressured him into doing something he struggled with it left him in a situation where he could of hurt someone or himself. Sometimes peer pressure though can be done in an effective manner for the right reasons. Positive peer pressure can be really helpful to a person who lacks the motivation to do something that they need to get done or doing something that will benefit the person being

Anthill: A Framework for the Design and Analysis of Peer-to-Peer Systems

1170 words - 5 pages projects however conventional algorithm techniques to resolve these issues are deemed inappropriate. Therefore Anthill is proposed as a framework to support researchers in the design and the analysis of new P2P algorithms. The Anthill project builds upon the similarities between P2P systems and social colonies of ants. Anthill provides an evaluation framework, based on the implementation of ant algorithms in simulated networks of nests that

Role of Peer Coaches

1155 words - 5 pages effects in teaching environments. Peer coaching helps teachers to develop their confidence as an instructor and it provides them with techniques and teaching and assists them to improve their classroom performance. For example Richard (2003) notes that coaching, which was part of a broader package of reforms, was producing test score improvements in the San Diego School District. Although Neufeld and Roper (2003) found that peer coaching alone

Dangers of Peer Pressure

883 words - 4 pages Have you ever done something that you didn’t want to do, but you somewhat felt obligated to do it? Peer pressure is a day to day thing that a lot of people deal with. Everyday people get forced into doing drugs and drinking alcohol, and things they really wouldn’t do any other time. This is a powerful and dangerous thing called peer pressure and kids, teenagers, and even adults cannot

Perils of Peer Victimization

1788 words - 7 pages heart, producing psychological injuries. From literature, it can also be identified that a bully may also suffer from similar psychological pain as a victim, but struggles to find a way to deal with their pain, resulting in an endless chain of peer victimization. Understanding from both a victim and bully’s perspective, it can be finally understood that these very different characters have personalities that essentially parallels. Being bound by the

Peer Production: An Agent of Good or Evil?

2077 words - 9 pages Peer Production: An Agent of Good or Evil? A Comparative Essay in the Context of Wikipedia Traditionally, centralized organizations such as governments, religious institutions and universities were responsible for information production and sharing. However, over the past decade, the Internet has decentralized the process and promoted open-source software (OSS). OSS is software that is freely used, edited, and shared by anyone. As a result of

Similar Essays

Peer Evaluation Essay

1156 words - 5 pages Duke, N. K. (2012) who further explains that rich vocabulary instruction provides a student with the ability to define, make personal or textual connections and have conversations involving examples or non-examples as well as a planning of “specific encounters” with new terms over a course of several days (p. 63). All signs lead to vocabulary instruction being effective when it is presented richly so as to develop an awareness and interest

History Of Peer To Peer File Sharing. Technology To Prevent It, And The Future Of It

981 words - 4 pages Peer-To-Peer File SharingThe rise and fall of Napster in the late 90's brought file sharing over the Internet, and peer-to-peer technology, to the attention of the world. Napster's demise led to the creation of companies such as KaZaA, Morpheus, and Audio Galaxy, whom all learned a valuable lesson from Napster. Avoid copyright infringement and elude record companies. So far they have been pretty successful, but record companies are getting

Peer To Peer File Sharing Hurting Music And Movie Industries

607 words - 2 pages People who download music and videos using peer-to-peer file sharing don't think that what they are doing is illegal, but according to the government, it is. Downloading files on the internet by anyone, including children, should not be tolerated. Millions of people are doing it and it's hurting the music and movie industry by the billions. The government should make more of an effort to put an end to file sharing between computer

Peer Review Evaluation Of Exploratory Argument

803 words - 4 pages The essay states that physical education is necessary without examining any contrary opinions or sides making the essay in effect an opinion paper rather than an exploratory argument. The clarity of ideas suffer from poor sentence structure, misuse of words, none sequential sentence structure and non sequiturs. When it promotes flexibility the confusion about context and its use makes it hard to understand. The idea expressed is reasonably