An Evaluation Of Direct To Consumer Testing And Need For Integrative Genetic Counseling

2057 words - 8 pages

As of 2011, more than 250 health conditions can be genetically tested, and more than 27 different companies offer genetic testing services.1 Direct-to-consumer testing (DTC) is increasing in popularity and prevalence in our modern health care society.2 DTCs are genetic tests that are available to the general public, through phone or web, and are issued without the help of a health practitioner.1 Eventually, DTCs will be used to evaluate a wide variety of diseases.1 Currently they can be used to trace cancer, Alzheimer’s, diabetes, and heart disease.1,3 DTC testing has become part of a thriving healthcare marketplace.4 A variety of companies offer DTCs, like Myriad, one of the most popular product lines.4 The prevalence of DTCs is becoming controversial in health care, primarily because of the possibility of consumers misinterpreting and having trouble coping with the tests they receive, especially without any assistance.4 DTCs work by analyzing single nucleotide polymorphisms.4,5 Common techniques include karyotyping, polymerase chain reaction, and DNA sequencing and microarray.1
Given the widespread and increasing use of DTCs, it is eminent for both upcoming health professionals and consumers to be aware of the full benefits, risks, and limitations.6 One method to cope with DTC results and queries may be through the use of genetic counseling.6 Genetic counseling is the process of seeking advice from a health professional about risks and predispositions associated with genetic disorders.6 While considerable studies have been done on various aspects of DTCs, the psychological outcomes of using these services have not been widely studied.1
The goal of this review paper is to further explore the use of DTCs and evaluate the importance of genetic counseling in conjunction with them. In order to accomplish this task, this paper will cover client motivations for undergoing DTC testing and the anticipated benefits. Physician awareness of genetic testing will be explored. Further, major drawbacks and limitations will be discussed, including issues with control of DTCs. The use of genetic counseling in conjunction with DTCs will be analyzed to see the potential contribution of counseling. Along with these main ideas, psychological outcomes will be considered in regards to both DTCs and genetic counseling. Research reports as well as two review papers and two case studies were studied and consulted while writing this review.
User Motivation and Public Perception
Five main reasons were cited for consumers electing to take DTCs: health, research purposes, curiosity, genealogy and recreation.1 While the most common reasons noted health precautions, the existence of many cases primarily for recreational use calls for caution and evaluation.1 DTCs are stressful in their nature, but without understanding the implications or taking the test seriously, unexpected results can lead to even further anxiety.2 Two types of consumers were identified in...

Find Another Essay On An Evaluation of Direct-to-Consumer Testing and Need for Integrative Genetic Counseling

Pros and Cons of Genetic Testing

1572 words - 7 pages life of others’. For example, a brother or a sister who carry a gene alteration, like cancer, and one sibling has an increased potential for diagnosis, the other sibling will feel guilty for escaping the increased risk. Not only can a negative genetic testing result affect your well-being, but also your ability to obtain health and life insurance. “Genetic testing may permit a much more complete and refined classification of people into risk

Genetic Testing and The Diagnosis of Genetic Diseases

1389 words - 6 pages movement and decrease in cognitive function. However, they only determine probability, which isn’t an entirely reliable means of knowing whether or not symptoms will arise. It is patients’ right to opt for genetic testing on their own DNA, although they are accepting a great risk by doing so. DNA is unique to each individual, present in each individual since conception, and influences who each individual is, so the information contained

Biotechnology and Genetic Testing

1701 words - 7 pages ; however, direct-to-consumer tests (those that are available to the public) are not as regulated (GHR, 2014). Thus, it is difficult to determine the reliability of genetic testing. Genotyping technology, such as those utilized by companies like 23andme, only looks at different parts of the genes and makes predictions based on small segments (PBS, 2012). These results may not be conclusive. Since the technology is still being researched and is in no way

Genetic Testing and Screening

3102 words - 12 pages order to develop an informed decision-making client, counseling for genetic disorders becomes necessary (Headings 1982). Genetic counseling involves the advisement of patients on the difficulties that may arise from genetic disease. Patients must be informed of the medical facts, severity and prognosis of the genetic disorder, the risk of its reoccurrence, and the options available for the management of the disorder. Indications for referral to a

Genetic Testing and Screening

2660 words - 11 pages fetal cells in the mother's blood [8]. Debate on Genetic Screening Developments in genetic screening and the social response to these developments vary widely. General international opinion about programs of genetic testing and screening is represented by the recommendations of the UK Nuffield Council on Bioethics. These include the requirement for informed consent and that all written information should be s supplemented with counseling

Genetic Testing and Screening

2093 words - 8 pages daughter is lucky and won't develop the breast cancer until maybe a cure for the disease has been found? This is a very tough situation to be in. This is just one situation of many that deal with a new era of a new concept called genetic screening or testing. Genetic screening is the testing of cells to check for certain kinds of genes, or for potentially damaging changes to those genes. It may be defined as a systematic search for persons with a

Genetic Testing and Screening - 1868 words

1868 words - 7 pages Many things are changing at an extremely rapid rate in our society. The new advances in the areas of science and biotechnology are raising many ethical and moral dilemmas for everyone. No one will be left unaffected. Everyone will have to make a decision and take a stand on these issues. I will discuss advancements of genetic screening and testing. The first step to any ethical problem is to understand the topic. It is difficult to formulate

The Need for Policy Makers to Regulate Human Genetic Engineering

1449 words - 6 pages other traits and cause accidental mutations. Thus extreme caution and research needs to be undertaken in order to avoid unintentional consequences when working with HGE. These safety risks are a main reason policy makers need to regulate what tests scientists can perform on test subjects, at least until scientists acquire more information. Another major concern with HGE is the potential for an eventual loss of genetic diversity in the human

Genetic Testing and Screening - 1427 words

1427 words - 6 pages will be susceptible to something. Maybe no one will be susceptible to anything and we will live forever! I find that just as scary as "designer babies". "Five years ago, most Americans rejected the Clinton Administration's proposals for a larger government role in managing health insurance. But if genetic testing starts to have a real impact on their health-care coverage, they could have second thoughts, and may seek refuge in some form of

An Overview of Counseling and Psychotherapy

1297 words - 5 pages treatment of people with milder psychological problems or to advice given on vocational and educational matters. Counseling psychologists usually work in schools or industrial firms, advising and assisting people. Today the distinction between psychotherapy and counseling is quite blurred, and many mental health professionals use the terms interchangeably. III. Presentation and Discussion Psychotherapy is an important form of treatment for

Different Categories of Genetic Testing

1196 words - 5 pages , “more than 1,000 genetic tests are currently in use, and more are being developed (Genetics Home Reference, 2014).” There are three different categories of genetic testing which include gene tests, chromosomal tests, and biochemical tests. Gene tests, or molecular genetic tests, pinpoint any deviations or mutations in individual genes or short lengths of DNA and RNA that can lead to a genetic disorder. Chromosomal tests check for a genetic

Similar Essays

The Need For An Adequate Evaluation Of Organization Behavior

1610 words - 6 pages As organizations truly affect almost every aspect of our daily lives, it is vital for us to understand the what, how and why of organizations (Buchanan & Huczynski, 2010) . That is why an adequate evaluation of organizational behaviour is needed. This essay is going to analyse the application of a critical model of thinking to studying organizational behaviour. It is going to do so by first setting clear definitions of key terms, describing

Direct To Consumer Pharmacuetical Advertising Essay

1422 words - 6 pages pharmaceutical market research and consulting firm, quotes “Our 1995 survey of direct to consumer ads show that they are having the impact sponsors (drug companies) have hoped for. Patients are asking doctors about advertised drugs more often, and they are more likely to get the product they asked for” (Sasich 4). If you ask a doctor for a certain medication, he won’t give you any medication you don’t need, right? If you agreed, you couldn’t be more

Medicine And Drugs Direct To Consumer Pharmaceutical Marketing

1634 words - 7 pages reduced need for more extensive medical care (New York Times, 2001). Doctors appreciate having patients who are already briefed about current drug therapies, which saves time in a medical system that often requires doctors to see as many as thirty patients per day (New York Times, 2001).   Critics of direct-to-consumer drug ads, including the American Medical Association, insurance providers, and many physicians cite increasing healthcare

Synopsis Of A Current Business Research Paper: Direct To Customer Advertising Of Pharmaceutical Products: Issue Analysis And Direct To Consumer Promotion

1167 words - 5 pages conduct an issue analysis of DTCA. It examined the development and growth, as well as the political, economic, and public health impact of DTCA emergence in the United States.Explanation of the Business Problem Under InvestigationThe DTCA has become a major force in the pharmaceutical world and affects all stakeholders: drug companies, physicians, and consumers who may need anything from arthritis medication to athletic foot powder. Arguments for and