A Comparison Of Two Paintings From The Renaissance Period

939 words - 4 pages

A Comparison of Two Paintings from the Renaissance Period

     This paper will compare the themes found in the paintings “Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist and an Angel” by Domenico di Bartolomeo Ubaldini (Puligo) and “Madonna Enthroned” by Giotto. Both paintings deal with fables from the Christian faith but were executed during different periods in art. The Giotto painting was created around 1310 and the Puglio painting was executed between 1518 – 1520. Here, these two paintings have similar themes both at the extreme beginnings and endings of the Italian Renaissance, and as such they serve to present an exceptional example of the developments in art that occurred within that time. This paper shall compare these two paintings through addressing a series of questions on the subject.

Subject Matter or Iconography
     “Madonna Enthroned” is the earlier of the two works to be surveyed in this paper, and as such there is a great deal more popularity surrounding this work. The image is simple: The subject matter is religious and concerns a host of holy figures surrounding the Madonna with an infant figure of Christ on her lap. “Madonna and Child with St. John the Baptist and Angel” is similar in that other holy figures are gathered to pay their respects to Christ but the scene is more open and less focused on just the two central figures. “Madonna and Child…” in my opinion is therefore a more complex composition, where instead of having two recognizable figures in the Christian religion, there are three and an angel. In “Madonna and Child…”, the other religious figure of St. John the Baptist is also allowed to stand near the holy mother and child, and an angel is present. Because of this, the viewer contends with a literal story rather than a simple image as in “Madonna Enthroned”. Also in Puligo’s image, where the central figures are larger and better seen, there are religious symbols used. The same might be true in Giotto’s work but the details are harder to distinguish.

Visual Form and Style
     The style and the form of these two paintings reflect the development of the artistic techniques during the Italian Renaissance. While both reflect a Biblical theme with a central focal point of the Madonna and Child, “Madonna Enthroned” has a key image that is best viewed from a central position and “Madonna and Child…” has a greater degree of importance over the majority of the surface of the canvas. In “Madonna and Child…” the viewer does not perceive that an image is being forced upon them as is found in the work by Giotto. A use of light and space is also key to preventing the Puligo piece from being “forced”, where the organization of distance visibly removes the viewer from “Madonna Enthroned” while drawing the viewer into the painting in...

Find Another Essay On A Comparison of Two Paintings from the Renaissance Period

Patrons and Artisans of the Renaissance Period

1013 words - 4 pages The Renaissance period (1400 to 1700) covered art, literature, philosophy and government. Renaissance culture spread outwards from Florence, to other Italian cities and then, over the following centuries, to the rest of Europe. It is widely understood that it was a unique combination of several different influences that led to the Renaissance, with the social and political conditions of the era, combined with great wealth and the large number

Theatre from the Middle Ages through to the Renaissance Period.

989 words - 4 pages that paid their actors.The next development of theatre through this period came from the common people. They gradually performed less and less of the religious plays and created a new style of medieval drama referred to as "The Folk Play". One of the first in this style was "The Legend of Robin Hood". The significance of these folk plays is that they stressed drama as pure entertainment as apposed to the religious plays that had a moral purpose

A Comparison of Two Extracts from Films Portraying Vampires

1186 words - 5 pages A Comparison of Two Extracts from Films Portraying Vampires In this essay I will compare two extracts from films portraying vampires. These extracts were taken from 'Nosferatu' a film made in the 1920's and 'Bram Stoker's Dracula' a film produced in the early 1990's. I will describe how the films are similar and are different in the media language used, the representations of the vampire and the woman and the narrative

A comparison of two curricula from English education system

1284 words - 5 pages assessment board consists of the course tutors, the teaching team and OxCON moderator. Students are expected to complete 28 units, with each academic subject carrying a weighting of 6 units each (maximum of 3 academic subjects from one of the above boxes; Figure 1) with students making up the extra unit requirements from Key Skill units. However students can pass the course with 20 units with at least 15 units at level 3. The course awards three types of

A Comparison of the Medieval and Renaissance Eras

1019 words - 4 pages annunciation, a religious event in which many Christian churches commemorate theannouncement of the incarnation of Luke. As shown in these examples, painting took avery secular turn in the Renaissance from the religious-based paintings that were found inthe Middle Ages.Perhaps the greatest and most evident way in which the Medieval and Renaissancetime periods differ is found in the opposing premises of philosophy. Again, the theme ofprogression from

A Comparison of The Renaissance and Baroque Periods

1294 words - 5 pages of history. In this essay, I will explore the relationship, style, and influences of the Renaissance and Baroque periods and will also compare and contrast a work of art from both periods to further explain the relationship between the two eras. The Renaissance period started in Italy and took place between the 1400’s and the 1600’s. In French, the term Renaissance means rebirth, which is an accurate way to describe that period since it was then

Was the Renaissance a true period of change, or solely a 'PreRenaissance'?

840 words - 3 pages Renaissance came about due to urbanization, departure from traditional monarchy and the formation of city-states, creating a sense of individualism. Even so, the contrast between the Renaissance and Medieval thoughts isn't as simplistic as it appears. Moreover, when looking at contrasts between periods they are gray at best. Calling the Renaissance "light" and the Middle or Medieval ages "dark" is like calling WWII advanced and WWI unsophisticated or

Are The Brachiopods And The Bryozoa Two Of The Most Abundant Species From The Ordovician Period?

1039 words - 4 pages actual species history must be analyzed in order to verify the lab results.When an examination of the species history was completed two of the most interesting and similar of all the species during the Ordovician period were the brachiopoda and the bryozoa. The Ordovician was a time of vast change, with several mass extinctions. New Paleozoic fauna emerged including bryozoa and articulate brachiopods (Kazlev, 2002). The bryozoans appeared in large

The Renaissance as a transitional period in Europe

691 words - 3 pages The Renaissance was the transitional period between the Dark Ages and the Age of Enlightenment. It's meaning, rebirth, symbolizes human, cultural, political, and economic regeneration. Events at the end of the Middle Ages, beginning in the 12th century, started a reformation of these ideals. The Renaissance started in Florence, Italy in the beginning of the 14th century. The Renaissance was earliest expressed through Humanism. The effect of

Carvaggio adn the Renaissance Period

1188 words - 5 pages his life, artwork. and an analysis on the renaissance time period. I believe that Caravaggio was a true renaissance artist. He used the same techniques as other renaissance artist. He also painted realism and humanistic into his paintings. Works Cited n.p. Carvaggio Gallery. Studio of the South. 2014. Web. 9, Feb. 2014 Retrieved from: www.caravaggiogallery.com n.p. Bio.com. A&E Television Networks, LLC 1996-2013. Web. 3, Feb

The Foundation of Understanding Human Anatomy During Renaissance Period

953 words - 4 pages Our understanding in anatomy and physiology today will be deadened without the knowledge from the Renaissance period. Let take a short step to look at what is Renaissance? Based historian, Renaissance means rebirth because “it [is] believed that the human spirit [has] to be reawakened as it [is] in the classical (Greco-Roman) times” (). During this time, the new conception of human emerges as individualism which means a man can create his own

Similar Essays

Comparison Of Two Paintings Essay

609 words - 2 pages certainly lots of visual differences in them.From the paintings one can tell the period of their creation. Somnambulist Mall Walking seems to have all the modernized images such as high-rise buildings and new technology invention such as, rocket, helicopter. In Golconda, the apparels that all the men wear suggest to me that this took place at a time before the Somnambulist Mall Walking. From the style of the outfit the men wear, they seem ancient

Comparison Of Two Paintings Essay

830 words - 3 pages are representational in which the artist is trying to convey a message. This paper discusses the two types through the comparison of two paintings, Abaporu and Portrait of a Lady. The painting are from two different time periods. Abaporu dates from 1928. The name of the artist is Tarsila do Amaral from Brazil. The painting is oil on canvas. Portrait of a Lady dates from 1490 by Domenico Ghirlandaio from Italy. Portrait of a Lady is tempera

The Renaissance As A Distinct Period Of Time

638 words - 3 pages known as; renaissance men. This means they are not only successful in one type of art but in all types of art, as well as math, science, and literature. The Renaissance was a distinct period in time that was separated from the Middle Ages and began a new era. The writers and thinkers of the fifteenth sixteenth centuries believed that they took part in a completely different era than the Middle Ages. They believed that they were part of a more

The Renaissance Was A Revolutionary Period

3025 words - 12 pages In history, revolution is the reason for constant shift in society. Many eras have come and gone and only some have left a significant impact on the world. In order for an era to be revolutionary, it has to leave a long lasting influence through social, economic and political means. Historians debate whether the Renaissance was considered a revolutionary period of history or not, however the Renaissance means “rebirth” and laid the foundation