A Comparison Of Us Bill Of Rights And The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

1901 words - 8 pages

Former United States Attorney General Ramsey Clark wrote in the New York Times, "A right is not what someone gives you; but what no one can take away." It is in this vein that a country drafts legislation to protect the rights of their inhabitants. In the United States there is the Bill of Rights, which consists of a preamble and the first ten amendments to the United States Constitution, 1787 . The Charter of Rights and Freedoms is the first part of the Canadian Constitution Act, 1982 . Both of these documents provide for the rights and freedoms that both countries see as inalienable to their respective populations.This is where the similarity between them ends. These documents are vastly different. They were crafted in different centuries and therefore have different emphases. One key difference between the two documents is how they treat criminal law and the rights attached to an investigation. Another interesting comparison is what both documents do not discuss.In Canada, if a person is detained they are required to be informed of their constitutional right to an attorney in accordance to Section 10(b) of the charter and SCR R vs. Therens 1985. The judgment reads:"Where a detainee is required to provide evidence which may be incriminating and where refusal to comply is punishable as a criminal offence,... s. 10(b) imposes a duty not to call upon the detainee to provide that evidence without first informing him of his s. 10(b) rights and providing him with a reasonable opportunity and time to retain and instruct counsel."In the United States, a detainee's right to council falls under amendment six to the constitution . Chief Justice Warren's report reads:"The prosecution may not use statements, whether exculpatory or inculpatory, stemming from custodial interrogation of the defendant unless it demonstrates the use of procedural safeguards effective to secure the privilege against self-incrimination . . . As for the procedural safeguards to be employed . . . the following measures are required. Prior to any questioning, the person must be warned that he has a right to remain silent, that any statement he does make may be used as evidence against him, and that he has a right to the presence of an attorney, either retained or appointed."The difference between the details of these two ideas is great. The Charter makes the reading of the rights mandatory prior to anything that might be incriminating. This includes line ups, breathalyzers, etc . In the United States Miranda only has to be read once the person is custody, under interrogation or arrest. Miranda is the slang term given to the rights that the detainer is obliged to recite to the detainee before their detention. It begins with the lines made famous by cop shows, "You have the right to remain silent. Anything you do or say can and will be used against you in a court of law . . . " In Canada, because we have no Fifth Amendment law the detainee does not need to be warned against self...

Find Another Essay On A comparison of US Bill of Rights and The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

Comparison of US Bill of Rights and The Canadian Charter of Rights

1393 words - 6 pages explicitly ‘reserved’ to the people, supporters of the charter nevertheless appear to give Canadians hope that the possibility may exist. COMPARISON OF BILL OF RIGHTS AND THE CANADIAN CHARTER Whether the American record has great significance for Canada poses a question which reasonable people may disagree. The entrenchment of rights in the Canadian Constitution comes after long experience with a system of parliamentary supremacy. The American

Charter of Rights and Freedoms Essay

2032 words - 8 pages (1) The Charter protects a range of rights and freedoms, but these rights often conflict. In some instances, courts are called upon to weigh competing rights. In your opinion, is freedom of religion or freedom of expression more important? Why? Use case law examples to support and defend your argument. The Charter of rights and freedoms focuses on many fundamental rights of individual, but often these rights conflict with one another. When

The Charter of Rights and Freedoms

1401 words - 6 pages in the following: It is not that groups have achieved policies using the Charter that they could not or have not achieved elsewhere by other means, including in countries that lack anything like the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms as a set of constitutional rights guarantees. Rather, it is that groups are able to use rights claims to produce a symbolic and contentious politics that challenges the previously dominant ‘‘codes’’ of Canadian

The Evolution of the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms and Human Rights in Canada

2009 words - 8 pages Canadian Bill of Rights, the wording of the Canadian Charter of Human Rights and Freedoms, as well as several Supreme Court Cases concerning constitutional questions. Although a "mathematical" approach to equality may prove successful in a homogeneous society, in a heterogeneous society such as Canada, such an idea can restrict, if not violate, equality.ReferencesCanadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms. (2009). In Wikipedia. Retrieved January 17

Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms

1294 words - 5 pages and freedoms. The Charter also effectively protects rights of Canadians in prison. The Charter of Rights and Freedoms doesn’t allow the government to pass any laws that violate the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. For any bill in the Canadian legislature to become a law, it must go to the Supreme Court of Canada. The bill is analyzed by the Supreme Court of Canada and is only made into a law after the seven judges of the Supreme Court decide it

The Inclusion of the Notwithstanding Clause in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms

1587 words - 6 pages The Inclusion of the Notwithstanding Clause in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms The inclusion of the Notwithstanding Clause in the Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms was an invaluable contribution in the evolution of the liberal democratic state. Not an endpoint, to be sure, but a significant progression in the rights protection dynamic. Subsequent to its passage in 1982 it became the primary rights protecting mechanism

Examining Canadian Discrimination within a Society in Charter of Rights and Freedoms

866 words - 4 pages Every individual in society is guaranteed a certain amount of protection and equality from the state regardless of their situation or background. Depending on how the terms discrimination and equality are interpreted in the courts will those rights apply. In the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, section 15 consists of two subsections which will be examined in terms of discrimination within society. As stated in section 15 (1) “Every individual is

Bill of rights vs. Canadian charter

3058 words - 12 pages It is in this vein that a country drafts legislation to protect the rights of their inhabitants. In the United States there is the Bill of Rights of 1781, which consists of a preamble and the first ten amendments to the United States Constitution, 1787. In Canada there is the Charter of Rights and Freedoms, which is the first part of the Canadian Constitution Act, 1982. Both of these documents provide for the rights and freedoms for their

Bill of Rights: Four Freedoms

1519 words - 6 pages The first amendment of the Bill of Rights to the constitution guarantees four freedoms: freedom of religion, speech, press and assembly. The Bill of Rights was passed on December 15, 1791. Since then, the freedoms have been debated, discussed, and fought and died for. Many have immigrated to America to receive those freedoms. The Founding Fathers knew what they were doing because they believed in power of ideas and debate, not censorship. The

How effectively does Canada’s Charter of Rights and Freedoms protect Individual Rights?

1323 words - 5 pages inmates are also allowed to vote in election and practice any of their rights and freedoms. The Charter successfully protects rights of all Canadians even if they are in prison. The Charter of Rights and Freedoms doesn’t allow the government to pass any laws that violate the Charter. For any bill in the Canadian legislature to become a law, it must go to the Supreme Court of Canada. The bill is analyzed by the Supreme Court of Canada and is only

The Development of Canada’s Rights and Freedoms

665 words - 3 pages . They had 3 children together; Justin (1971), Alexandre (1973) and Michel (1975 – 1998). Justin Trudeau followed his father’s footsteps and is now leader of the Liberal Party. Sadly, on September 28, 2000, Pierre Elliot Trudeau died. 2. Which rights or freedoms did they want to change? What were they trying to accomplish? What were the troubles they faced? Pierre Elliott Trudeau wanted to make Canadians proud and satisfied to live in Canada

Similar Essays

The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

629 words - 3 pages The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms plays a major role in Canadian society, and has been a huge part of our country now for 27 years. This being from the Constitution Act of 1982, which makes the charter of rights a part of Canadian constitution. Canadian constitution is described as a set of laws containing rules on the way Canada operates. The Charter recognized the rights of individuals who never had their rights noticed in the past

The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

2319 words - 9 pages Territorial governments and the Canadian people. Being a successor of the Canadian Bill of Rights that was a federal statute, amendable by Parliament, the Charter is a more detailed and explicit constitutional document that has empowered the judiciary to render regulations and statutes at both the federal and provincial levels of government unconstitutional. Although the rights and freedoms of Canadians are guaranteed, Sections one and seven of

The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms

714 words - 3 pages Canada being such a great place to live. Some of the most important point of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms in the country are Equality Rights, Fundamental Freedoms, and Legal Rights. The Canadian citizens have lots of right; the Equality right is one of the important rights. Canada is a country where many people treat their freedom of choice as a right and forget that many other people in the world do not have the option to make many of

The Canadian Charter Of Rights And Freedoms 849 Words

849 words - 3 pages Canada's dedication to human rights makes Canada one of the best places in the world to live. Canada provides freedom of choice for all citizens and Canada is known for the emphasis we put on equality. With both of these points in mind, one must also consider the best and most prominent part of Canada's dedication to human rights, The Canadian Charter of Rights and Freedoms as an influential part of Canada being such a great place to live.Canada