This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Exposition Of Kant’s, Arendt’s, And Mill’s Moral Philosophy

2792 words - 11 pages

An Exposition of Kant’s, Arendt’s, and Mill’s Moral Philosophy
Immanuel Kant adheres to Deontological ethics. His theory offers a view of morality based on the principle of good will and duty. According to him, people can perform good actions solely by good intentions without any considerations to consequences. In addition, one must follow the laws and the categorical imperative in order to act in accordance with and from duty. Several other philosophers such as Hannah Arendt discuss Kant’s moral philosophy. In her case study: “The Accused and Duties of a Law-Abiding Citizen”, Arendt examines how Adolf Eichmann’s actions conformed to Kant’s moral precepts but also how they ran of afoul to his conception of duty. In contrast, John Stuart Mill adopts a teleological view of moral philosophy. He exposes his view of consequentialism and utilitarianism to argue that an action is morally right only to the extent that it maximizes the aggregate happiness of all parties involved regardless of the motive. In the present paper, I will expose Kant’s moral precepts and the importance of duty in his Deontological principles. Then, I will evaluate Arendt’s report on Adolf Eichmann to analyze the ways in which his actions were in accordance to or against Kant’s moral philosophy. I will conclude my discussion with an evaluation of Mill’s approach to morality in order to examine the differences between his teleological philosophy and Kant’s ethical principles.
Kant’s moral philosophy is based on the categorical imperative (CI), good will, and duty. According to the CI, it is an absolute necessity, a command that humans should accord with universalizable maxims to treat people as ends in themselves and exercise their will without any concerns about the consequences or conditions of their actions. This concept can also be expressed in systematic terms by the two following formulations. The first form of the categorical imperative prescribes that we must act only according to that maxim whereby we can at the same time will that it should become a universal law (Kant, P.102). The second one states that we ought to treat humanity, whether in our own person or in the person of another, always at the same time as an end and never simply as a means (Kant, P.105). In order to obey the categorical imperative, people have to act on a maxim that can be universalized. For instance, Kant argues that a lying promise is bad since it does not pass the universality test. Whenever a person makes a promise knowing that he will have to break it, he violates the first formulation of the categorical imperative. He intends to make use of another man merely as a means to an end which the latter does not likewise hold (Kant, P.105). In other words, Kant does not believe that lying promises are bad due to the fact that they generate bad consequences but because they result in a practical contradiction. According to him, people can’t lie since they can’t act for the results. Considering...

Find Another Essay On An Exposition of Kant’s, Arendt’s, and Mill’s Moral Philosophy

Taoism and Western Moral Philosophy Essay

3909 words - 16 pages moral philosophy deal with desire but Taoism deals with it directly and western morality often only tries to stem the effect of desire. Both systems see in man that he does not naturally desire the good and true or the Way. Desire is the root of evil. Only when we desire something bad do we act bad. Thus, as in western moral philosophy, we can provide an incentive to not act on ones desire or, as in the case of Taoism, desire can be eliminated

Moral Philosophy of Global Peace Essay

3441 words - 14 pages Moral Philosophy of Global Peace ABSTRACT: Global Peace is the summum bonum, so we must know its negative as well as positive meanings. Simultaneously peace must be understood in all its interrelated but theoretically differentiated dimensions as personal, social, national, international and global. Today, humankind is suffering from multidimensional crises such as terrorism, population-explosion, denial of human rights, economic inequality

Journal Review - Incoherence of the moral "ought", an analysis of a paper by Elizabeth Anscombe entitled, 'Modern Moral Philosophy.'

642 words - 3 pages The Incoherence of the Moral 'Ought,' a journal article by Duncan Richter, is an analysis of a paper by Elizabeth Anscombe entitled, 'Modern Moral Philosophy.' In this analysis, Mr. Richter is only concerned about Anscombe's second thesis, which states as follows:The concepts of moral obligation and moral duty (what is morally right and morally wrong, and the moral sense of 'ought,' ought to be jettisoned if this is psychologically possible

Exposition and Critique of Divine Command Theory

853 words - 4 pages key categories are source, selection, definition of good, scope, objective or subjective, and principle of right action. The source of core morality for divine command theory is God's commands. The selection of this moral principle can be done by consulting a religious text, religious leaders, or through prayer. Goodness under this given theory is what God orients us towards through his commands because God represents goodness. The scope, or the

An exposition of Plato's analogy of the cave

778 words - 3 pages Plato was a philosopher living in Athens during the Hellenistic period. He was an aristocrat, but did not venture into politics, instead having a love of philosophy instilled in him by his tutor, Socrates. Plato thought and taught philosophy his whole life, and unlike Socrates wrote his ideas down in the form of dialogues. One such work is the Republic, in which the analogy of the cave is expounded.In the analogy of the cave, Plato describes

An Examination of Thomas Hobbes' Moral Philosophy with an Emphasis on the Escape from the State of Nature

996 words - 4 pages The word "leviathan" has come to mean the largest or most massive thing of its kind. Thomas Hobbes's Leviathan fits that description perfectly, as the audacious scope of his 1651 treatise on philosophy, politics and religion has few equals. It was at once the birth of political science, an indictment of the prevailing scholastic tradition, and a groundbreaking piece of moral thinking. Despite the grand scale of the work, Hobbes maintains a

Moral, Social, and Political Philosophy Comparison

870 words - 3 pages as an individual person. Within moral philosophy there is also the use of egoism which is putting your self-interest in front of everything else. The pursuit of pleasure is hedonism. (Moore-Bruder, 2005) Knowing how to seek put pleasure and embracing it is a description of this type of moral philosophy.There is also what is called social philosophy which goes hand in hand with moral philosophy. In social philosophy we bring up questions about

The Moral Philosophy of John Stuart Mill

1124 words - 4 pages foundation of the most influential moral theory of the 19th century) is crucial, as its effect on Mill's moral outlook as a whole is impossible to overstate.It is imperative at this juncture to contrast the metaphysical naturalism of a figure such as Hobbes with the metaphysical and ethical naturalism one finds in Mill. Mill does not believe in the "naturalistic fallacy" which caused Hobbes such grief, and is therefore free to move from an empirical

An Examination of Deontology and Utilitarianism in Deeply Moral Situations

1305 words - 5 pages An Examination of Deontology and Utilitarianism in Deeply Moral Situations Samuel Adams (1722 - 1803), an American patriot and politician, once stated, "Mankind are governed more by their feelings than by reason"[1]. This statement is significant, as it undermines two of the primary ethical doctrines in philosophy - the deontological perspective defended by Immanuel Kant (1724 - 1804) in Foundations of the Metaphysics of Morals

The Financial and Moral Empowerments of an Education

1151 words - 5 pages through having an education. There is a lot of competition in America for a good job and for getting certain positions, and having an education will empower a person to be picked for the positions. It will also allow a person to secure the job they get so they do not have to worry about starting all over again. John Taylor Gatto argues that school systems “cripple our kids.” He says “We have been taught in this country to think of “success

Hemingway’s Exposition: Inevitability of Old Age and Death

2054 words - 8 pages the interactions of an old man, a young waiter, and an older waiter in the setting of a clean, well-lighted diner and their views on life and death in the 1920s. The waiters reflect on the life of the deafened old man and ponder their own notions about their own life and existence. Ernest Hemingway creates a motif of deafness within the story through the lack of adjectives and specific indication to the speaker of the dialogues to display the

Similar Essays

Mill’s Objection To Kant’s Moral Theory

1373 words - 5 pages wrong regardless of ends, and so the ends should be irrelevant in the maxim statement. It may be, however, that the action always undermines (when universalized) any end to which it would be used. That is sufficient to make an action wrong in all circumstances, and it is likely the case with any action which is only effective if it is the exception. Given this discussion, it is now apparent that Mill’s objection to Kant’s moral theory is

Kant’s Moral Philosophy In Readdressing The Is Ought Problem

1558 words - 7 pages purpose of this paper is to readdress and further clarify the Is-Ought problem with respect to Kant’s Moral Philosophy. Deontology refers to a general category of ethical or moral theories that define right action in terms of duties and moral rules. Deontology is defined as the study of duty, moral obligation, and right action. The slogan of much of deontology is that the right is independent of the good. Deontologists focus on the rightness of an act

Justification For Kant’s Moral And Ethical Views

1976 words - 8 pages In A Grounding for the Metaphysics of Morals, Immanual Kant, unlike David Hume, aimed to establish an absolute system of morality based upon reason. Kant’s conceptions regarding what is moral and how someone should behave ethically, are often seen as contradictions to those proposed by Hume, who holds an empirical stance. As mentioned, Kant emphasizes the necessity of basing morality on a priori principles; he puts faith in the power of human

Mills And Kant Moral Philosophy Essay

704 words - 3 pages be able to trust anyone. In the end, our world would just be a mess because nothing is certain and the value of truth diminishes. Kant would say that lying is ultimately wrong. This is a vantage point to show how Mills and Kant would disagree. I personally am inclined to Kant’s moral philosophy. I like how an action is only worthy to deemed moral if it is done out of a good will and only that. I also agree with the categorical imperative process