This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Innocent Murderer: The Flaws Of Capital Punishment

1907 words - 8 pages

What would you do if you were suddenly arrested for a crime that you didn’t commit? What if you were taken to the station, interrogated, and booked for murder? Would you stick to your innocence, or possibly take a plea bargain just to get past the constant questioning from authority? Would you write to others to try and prove your innocence? During the course of many years, this has happened to numerous people. Many people have been ripped from their daily lives and thrown into a cell. The individuals are just waiting for the day when someone will prove them innocent. In the past 39 years, 117 people who were serving time on death row have been proved innocent and released from prison (Daily 36). Over time, critics have presented flaws in the judicial system that are leading many to question the use of capital punishment.
One of the most fundamental pieces of a trial is eyewitness statements. However, eyewitness statements can contribute flaws to the judicial system because they often change. The case of Cameron Todd Willingham centered on the idea that Willingham started a fire that killed his own children, making him a murderer. One of the eyewitnesses, Diane Barbee, first told authorities that Willingham seemed absolutely “hysterical”. She also mentioned that the front of the house exploded during the fire. On the other hand, after learning that fire investigators were suspecting Willingham of murder, Barbee’s testimony began to change. Barbee then told authorities that the smoke coming from the house was minimal and not very thick. As critics looked back at the case, they also noticed that Diane Barbee testified differently during the trial than in her eyewitness statements. During the trial, Barbee testified that Willingham didn’t attempt to break back into the house. However, Barbee was also absent for part of the fire because she left to call 911. Both Barbee’s daughter and firemen and police who were on the scene, reported that Willingham was frantically trying to get back into the house. Many testified that Willingham was even handcuffed for his own safety. In addition to Diane Barbee’s testimony, another eyewitness changed his testimony drastically. Father Monaghan, a police chaplain, first testified that Willingham seemed to be a father who was so upset that his children were inside. Nonetheless, as investigators began to suspect that Willingham was an arsonist, Monaghan stated that Willingham seemed too emotional and he believed that Willingham had something to do with starting the fire (Grann 7-8). A cognitive psychologist by the name of Itiel Dror once assessed changes in witness statements and said “The mind is not a passive machine. Once you believe something – once you expect something – it changes the way you perceive something and the way your memory recalls it” (Grann 8.) This rang true in the case of Willingham. Both eyewitnesses, Barbee and Monaghan, changed their testimony after being told that Willingham was being...

Find Another Essay On An Innocent Murderer: The Flaws of Capital Punishment

An Examination of Capital Punishment Essay

1540 words - 6 pages population claims that this consequence is not used enough. Capital punishment is not a problem only here but around the world as well; there is constant arguing and debates, here and around the globe, about the moralities of this punishment. This has been an unsurpassable struggle from the beginning, and now we are left to wonder if there is even a rightful way to end this dilemma. People can be convicted with capital punishment for many things

The Unconstitutionality of Capital Punishment Essay

2383 words - 10 pages . However, capital punishment indeed violates the Eighth Amendment which became a part of the United States Constitution in 1789. Capital punishment is both a cruel and an unusual punishment. No punishment can be more cruel than death, especially if it is applied to an innocent person. Murdering to stop murderers is too cruel! Wendy Kaminer, in her book, It's All the Rage , verbalizes death penalty as, "barbarously cruel .... shocking, unjust, and

The History of Capital Punishment

2147 words - 9 pages retribution, justifying executions even when there is a possibility that the person being executed is innocent due to an imperfect system, and determining the effectiveness of capital punishment in deterring future crimes. All of these issues have arguments from both the retentionists and the abolitionist perspectives, and all regards different interpretations from the same concepts of ethical systems. To answer the question of whether or not

The Ethics of Capital Punishment

1518 words - 6 pages better it is ten freed guilty men than one innocent sentenced to death. Another problem is where the line is drawn for what is considered to in fact be eligible for capital punishment. For in my opinion a mother protecting her children from attackers and defensively committing murder is much different than a cold blooded killer randomly shooting anyone they see. Although they are both murders, a person who commits a crime as an act of passion is much

The Practice of Capital Punishment

1217 words - 5 pages /article.php?id=82 From the above table, it is evident that murder rates are consistently more in states where death penalty is applicable; in contrast, non-death penalty states show consistently lower murder rates. The other strong reason to oppose capital punishment is that it has become an instrument to foster racial discrimination. The crux of the matter is that those who murder whites have more chances of capital punishment

The Benefits of Capital Punishment

1089 words - 4 pages The Benefits of Capital Punishment Justice is about enforcing consequences for one’s own actions to endorse personal responsibility and the notion of capital punishment does just that. Capital punishment is an effective and efficient method of deterring would be criminals and preventing criminals to commit more crimes. It is by far the oldest form of punishment in the world and remains in effect in many nations. Through discussing

The Abolishment of capital Punishment

4707 words - 19 pages strongly influenced by discrimination.2The flagrant racial discrimination that influences the outcomes of capital cases renders the death penalty unconstitutional. The unequal distribution of death sentences between blacks, and whites is arbitrary and inconsistent, and therefore constitutes cruel and an unusual punishment, by means of discrimination. Which encroaches upon section fifteen of the Charter of Rights and Freedoms. Section fifteen states

The Morality of Capital Punishment

2651 words - 11 pages aspects of the morality of capital punishment. The Catechism (1997) #2267 says, in part, "... the traditional teaching of the Church does not exclude recourse to the death penalty, if this is the only possible way of effectively defending human lives against the unjust aggressor...." "Today, in fact, as a consequence of the possibilities which the state has for effectively preventing crime, by rendering one who has committed an

The Death of Capital Punishment

1328 words - 6 pages penalty is simply an illusion of humane professional murder (Zivot). While capital punishment may or may not deter the world of crime, one person at a time, it does so in a manner that not only abolishes a life but also the humanity of those whose believe in it through its violations, financial costs, and faults; therefore capital punishment should be put to death. Supporters of this form of this sanction believe that capital punishment does more to

The Abolishment of Capital Punishment

2581 words - 10 pages absence of the death penalty in a state." Rehabilitation is ineffective, people argue, and capital punishment is often the only penalty that matches the horrific nature of some crimes. Furthermore society has a right to retribution and the finality of an execution can bring closure for victims' families. There has been argument that innocent people are being executed (Pambiancon). No such evidence exists. Indeed, the very study that opponent

The Problem of Capital Punishment

3450 words - 14 pages twenty year period, Illinois had to release more innocent people from death row than they executed (Dieter). This problem is serious and proves that this monetary sacrifice is not trivial. Additionally, many moral claims are significant in capturing the essence of the issues behind capital punishment. To begin, the most controversial claim seems to be that a convicted murderer deserves to receive the death penalty, which is the “eye for an

Similar Essays

Capital Punishment And The Innocent Essay

1238 words - 5 pages This leaves only one-year difference from the average release of the innocent. It should make one think how many more innocent may be released if they moved the average execution up one year or if there was no execution at all ( Keeping a criminal imprisoned on a life term would eliminate the problem of a "murderer on the loose" just as well as capital punishment. Kenneth Cauthen at

Innocent Victims Of Capital Punishment Are Possible

1363 words - 5 pages Innocent Victims of Capital Punishment are Possible Try to imagine yourself being convicted of a crime you did not commit, and even worse being told you have die for that crime. This nightmare is actually a reality for some inmates on death row today. The death penalty should be abolished because the potential for even one death of an innocent man violates all principles of justice. "Can the

The Flaws Of Othello, Murderer Of Desdemona

1733 words - 7 pages , Othello is already brewing with jealousy due to Desdemona’s insistence for Cassio’s reinstatement. He even calls Desdemona an “excellent wretch,” showing his disdain towards her from that moment on. These ideal qualities Othello wishes to be remembered by does not hold true to who he really is. Othello, full of flaws, is not void of responsibility for the death of Desdemona nor is the entire fault Iago’s. In the essay, “Three Green-Eyed Monsters

An Overview Of Capital Punishment Essay

2152 words - 9 pages May 12, 1993.       This possibility of error, where an innocent person might be put to death, disturbs the public more than any other issue posed by capital punishment.  This is the number one concern about the death penalty in our country.  Since 1900, 23 people who we know to be innocent have been murdered by the state and 350 people have been found not-guilty while on death row awaiting execution.       Opposers of the