An Integrative Approach To Teaching Writing

1102 words - 4 pages

An Integrative Approach to Teaching Writing

If you have come to help me you are wasting your time. But if you have come because your liberation is bound up with mine, then let us work together.

Aboriginal Activist Sister

Teachers of writing have begun to move from thinking about writing as a product with rules, to writing as a process with an authentic, individual voice, to writing as a system of social and political actions. Many feel the need to align themselves with one perspective against the others, but, "Unless we take into account these differences in perspective, we will be unable to establish sufficient common ground for moving the discussion forward" (Lindemann 288). Rob Pope, in his English Studies Book, explains that, "Most undergraduate English courses now have a considerable variety of emphases—Literary, Linguistic, and more broadly Cultural" (1). But how do we decide which emphasis to make? The answer lies in how we see the world, and why we teach writing in the first place. Borrowing indirectly from Physics, I want to examine a quote that may shed some light on what kinds of thinking are behind these different emphases:

A unit of experience can be viewed as a particle, or as a wave, or as a field. That is, the writer can choose to view any element of his experience as if it were static, or as if it were dynamic, or as if it were a network of relationships or a part of a larger network. Note carefully that a unit is not either a particle or a wave or a field, but rather can be viewed as all three. (Young, Becker and Pike 122)

Thus, the way we see the world has enormous influence over the way we see the teaching of writing. Some see writing as a product (static particle), some as a process (dynamic wave), and others as a system (interconnected web of relationships), but it is most important to remember that none of these views are complete. They inform each other, although one is usually dominant in the way one thinks of writing. Which one is deserving of top position depends upon what we believe to be the role of writing and education in society.

What is it we are trying to do? Do we teach writing to help our students learn proper form and style, to help students discover their true selves, or do we help them to better understand themselves and their relationship with the world around them in order to make a difference in that world? Do we want them to accept the world they are thrust into upon graduation or do we want them to be conscious shapers of that world? I argue that these should be some of the central questions not only in composition programs, but also in all of education. Anne Ruggles Gere, in her Introduction to Into the Field, discusses teachers and theorists "reconceptualizing the discipline, deconstructing received boundaries, and reconstructing relations between theory and application" (3). It is this kind of reconceptualization I hope to propose.

Many have been struggling with...

Find Another Essay On An Integrative Approach to Teaching Writing

Balanced Literacy vs Whole Language Approach to Teaching Reading

821 words - 3 pages just one component of the whole language classroom. Problems associated with whole language include a lack of structure that has been traditionally supplied by the scope and sequence, lessons and activities, and extensive graded literature found in basal readers. Whole language puts a heavy burden on teachers to develop their own curriculum. Balanced Literacy is an approach for teaching literacy that is widely used in classrooms across the

A Problem-Based Approach to Teaching about Pollution

2138 words - 9 pages students will likely forget much of what is taught. A terrific way to get students to retain more of what they learn about pollution is to use a problem-based learning approach. The method of choice for teaching pollution to middle school children should be learning by working through the actual problem of pollution in our environment. However, the research shows that there is often much reluctance on the part of seasoned teachers to such an

An Attempt to Identify the Personality Approach

875 words - 4 pages An Attempt to Identify the Personality Approach In an attempt to identify the personality approach of an incest victim in a recent magazine article, I have estimated that the approach is behavioral/social. Numerous occurrences of childhood incest made Deborah Mays (Bergner, 2000, p. 119) experience a cycle of depression well into her late thirties. Because she was a helpless child subjected to ongoing accounts of physical and mental abuse by

An Analytical Approach to Truth and Religion

6399 words - 26 pages An Analytical Approach to Truth and Religion ABSTRACT: I discuss some of the problems of the application of the notion of truth to religion. After introductory remarks on the problem called truth and religion to show the peculiarity and the actuality of the problem discussed, I examine the different meanings of the notions of truth and religion, in order to formulate some comments on the different concepts of the truth of religion. I name

An Indigenous Approach to Water Conflicts

1970 words - 8 pages harmonizing water stressed basins. As an example of a different approach to shared water resource, Wolfe (200) shares his experience about the Berber and Bedouin people who reside in the Negev desert, which is a part of present day Israel. Although one of the driest region in the world, Wolfe ( 2000 ) describes how the Berbers and Bedouins managed to avoid water conflicts and live in harmony. In this context, the Berbers and Bedouins practice

An Approach To Alternative Fuel Vehicle Rentals

1674 words - 7 pages An Approach to Alternative Fuel Vehicle Rentals As one of the leading car rental companies, Lotus car rental is in a position to take advantage of a great opportunity. This is an opportunity to be one of the first car rental companies to provide our consumers with alternative options to fuel-powered vehicles, and to rise above the competition. Adding alternative fuel vehicles to our car rental fleet will increase our car rental turnover and

An Evaluation of Direct-to-Consumer Testing and Need for Integrative Genetic Counseling

2057 words - 8 pages these main ideas, psychological outcomes will be considered in regards to both DTCs and genetic counseling. Research reports as well as two review papers and two case studies were studied and consulted while writing this review. User Motivation and Public Perception Five main reasons were cited for consumers electing to take DTCs: health, research purposes, curiosity, genealogy and recreation.1 While the most common reasons noted health precautions

Many homeschoolers are teaching their children through an approach called unschooling.

1060 words - 4 pages Many homeschoolers are teaching their children through an approach called unschooling. As the name implies, it is opposite to all that traditional schools do. Some people believe that unschooling is unchristian. I dont think so. Let me explain why.When people ask me what unschooling is, I tell them that it is where we "create a learning rich environment and then let the kids go." Kids are naturally curious. I believe God made them that way. Let

Teaching to the Test Gets an ‘F

1049 words - 4 pages In the article “Teaching to the Test Gets an ‘F’” by Steven Slon, Slon, discusses the issue of creativity in schools and how student creativity and futures are in jeopardy. Slon talks about how he, himself, has witnessed the destruction of creativity firsthand with his own son. Slon also brings up a conversation he had with Sir Ken Robinson about the current status of American education such as needs, wants, and expectations of the adult world

Article reflection: Word building: A strategic approach to the teaching of phonics.

584 words - 2 pages independently as time progresses. Mr. Gunning described very simply the technique of word building. Teachers must not adhere to only one method of teaching reading. If one manner of teaching reading does not work, others must be tried until the teacher finds a single method or set of several methods which promote success for those he is entrusted to instruct.Reaction.I feel this article suggested an explicit approach to word building. This

Computer Games: An Approach to Increase Critical Thinking in Mathematics

2565 words - 10 pages computer game to enhance their mathematical critical thinking skills for a period of 12 weeks. The expected results should demonstrate an increase of scores in the post-test from the treatment group compared to the comparison groups. Computer Games: An Approach to Increase Critical Thinking in Mathematics In recent years technology has changed the way people interact with one another. The advancements of technology have also increased the

Similar Essays

Individualized Approach To Instructions Versus Traditional Approach To Teaching.

1841 words - 7 pages their fullest capability. The student will be more relaxed and he or she will enjoy the learning experiences more.While with the traditional approach to teaching method, teachers have an invisible and unconscious assumption that they have thirty clones sitting in front of them. Most teachers will tend to teach at one strategy and pace without diversity. As a result any child who varies from the norm will suffer. Even if the teacher alters the

My Holistic Approach To Teaching Reading

1083 words - 4 pages My methodology of teaching reading would be the Holistic approach. This approach includes whole language and look & say. I like that the emphasis is placed on teaching reading, writing, listening, and oral language. Emphasizing these skills gets students to maximize their comprehension of text, identify relevant and non-relevant information, and tolerate less than word-by-word comprehension. In the classroom I would place more emphasis on

Using Scaffolding Approach To Teaching Literacy

1642 words - 7 pages combination of techniques and methods based on individual need. Literacy includes reading, writing, speaking, and listening. Children begin learning these skills typically before entering school, and will continue to learn and use these skills throughout life. Each and every individual develops a literate identity and builds personal theories of literacy (Beach & Ward, 2013). This literate identity is built and created based on how an individual is

Teaching Writing To Students With Autism

2393 words - 10 pages as writing. Every student develops at his or her own pace, so instructors need to create an environment where each student is given the help or challenges necessary. Instead of teaching material that seems focused towards the average level of the class, instructors should create an environment that stretches to allow students that are ahead or behind to get the instruction they need (Kluth and Chandler-Olcott 56). Some students with autism need a