An Interview With Bernard Lonergan What Is "Critical Realism?" This Essay Delves Into The Theory Of Cognition Posed By Lonergan, Who Was A Jesuit Philosopher.

4315 words - 17 pages

PART I: Questions addressed to Lonergan1. Father Lonergan, you name your philosophy "Critical Realism."a) What is Critical Realism?Critical Realism is the philosophical position that states that the real is that which is known by the 3-fold process of attentive experience, intelligent inquiry, and responsible judgment. Reality is that which is known by totality of correct judgment.b) Thomas Aquinas is a Realist philosopher. Can you name one way that you see Critical Realism related to Thomistic Realism? Or is it totally different?Thomistic Realism is the philosophical position that states whatever exists can be known, or in other words, "Being is intelligible." Thomistic Realism also says the object known corresponds to the thing (object) existing in the world, and the proper object of the human intellect is the nature of the material thing. However, the essence of the object can only be grasped in the mind through the Thomistic cognitional process that relates to the 3-fold process employed in critical realism. The three steps that provide the framework to Critical Realism are attentive experience, intelligent inquiry and reasonable judgment. These three steps are analogous to the sense experience, abstraction, and judgment that St. Thomas describes in his process of cognition. In other words, Critical Realism and Thomistic Realism correspond with one another very closely and are very complementary with one another. In addition, both of these giants of philosophy (Lonergan and Thomas) admit that we must first experience the data through our senses before we can truly know the object. In the two compatible steps of Thomas' abstraction and Lonergan's understanding, we must come to know the nature of the material thing by asking questions and ignoring particulars. Finally, we may make a judgment as to whether or not our "bright idea is a right idea," comparing our ideas with reality.c) To help my understanding of your position, could you state one way that it would differ from Plato's Idealism?My philosophical fellow, allow me to explain it to you in this way. Plato held that knowledge deals with things that cannot be perceived by the senses and can only be generated by thought. In Plato's mind, opinion resulted from experiencing the ever-changing and dynamic things of the physical world. Ergo, Plato's idealism sharply contrasts my critical realist philosophy because Plato does not believe that attentive experience is how we come to know the real. Instead, he considers that sense experience is solely opinion-based and has no place in the quest for true knowledge.2. a) Would you give us an example of the occurrence of "insight"?Well, my sources tell me that in your case, insights are something that you rarely experience in Organic Chemistry, are they not? Just teasing old chum, please forgive me. An insight could be that moment when you are reading a difficult and complex passage then unexpectedly, you finally understand. In this sense, an insight...

Find Another Essay On An Interview with Bernard Lonergan What is "Critical Realism?" This essay delves into the theory of cognition posed by Lonergan, who was a Jesuit philosopher.

"What is Democracy" This is an essay written about democracy. It a reaction of an average person as to what democracy means to them. This is not a step by step definition of the political system

1354 words - 5 pages democracy, ensures that one person who voices the opinions of the majority represents a large number of people in the government. Unfortunately in modern politics this does not usually work the way it was intended to. In theory representative democracy is a logical and practical way to deal with large populations and limited time. But with political corruption being a widespread problem, the voice of the majority is not always heard and their

This was a descriptive essay about a job we have. This essay is what it takes to be an EMT on the firedept.

1079 words - 4 pages example of a crises situation would be an emergency involving children. Being able to arrive on the scene of a 'child choking' call and remain calm when everyone else around you is screaming and shouting takes incredible self-discipline. Knowing that the child who was thrown into your arms as you stepped out of the ambulance will live or die depending upon your actions in the next few minutes requires a calm demeanor. This is essential in order to

Critical Analysis of Interview with the Vampire

1417 words - 6 pages Interview with the Vampire. Unlike other vampire novels, Interview was the life account of Louis du Pointe du Lac as an interview conducted throughout the night with a reporter recruited by Louis himself. Louis unlike the common stereotype is not a vicious killer. In fact, his tale is of his struggle to keep his humanity intact, to battle his nature and his thirst for blood. In reminiscing he introduces us to the colorful and vibrant vampire world

This essay explains the benefits of recreation in society and on the body. It is in full MLA format alond with works cited page. It was a graduation requirement, so i put alot of time into it.

1279 words - 5 pages adults are employed by Rec. agencies in many of the following ways: lifeguards, sport officials, playground leaders, and maintenance workers. Park and Recreation programs provide economic benefits through the purchase of supplies and equipment, and increasing the work force. This increase in the tax base is a key component of general funds that are used to fund public safety (CPRS).The youth aspect of public safety is enormous. 40% of youth's time is

The Atomic Bomb: Necessary and Just. This essay delves into justifications for the use of Atomic Weaponry during the second World War.

1533 words - 6 pages Many questions lie within the history of the United States of America. Was there a second gunman involved in the assassination of JFK? Did we really go to the moon? Who really framed Roger Rabbit? All of these questions, valid or not, can be proven by facts and logistics. One of the harder, philosophical questions we must ask, however, is the use of the Atomic Bomb during World War II. True, there are many facts to bolster each side of this

What is an Interview?

4066 words - 16 pages What is an Interview? An interview is a conversation, which is held between two or more individuals where some questions are asked by the interviewer to obtain information about the interviewee. When the assignment Conduct a Job Search was given to us, we were excited. This kind of project was not only to help graduating students, like ourselves but anyone who is entering the workforce. An interview can be one of the best experiences. The

"The Struggles of an Individual" This essay compares two books, October Sky, and Into thin Air. This leads the author to a few conclusions about his life and what he is becoming.

880 words - 4 pages , however, is not what I directed my focus on when reading the books. Instead, I examine the effects of two different protagonists in two different novels. The characters both directly and indirectly provide fuel for a dream canonizing by the demonstration of success. Indeed, these are inspirational in teaching how one should continue to pursue one's goals despite adversity or lackluster intensity.John Krakauer, author of Into Thin Air, introduces the

A Brief History of the Jesuit Reduction

1199 words - 5 pages A Reduction is a mission town set up by Jesuit missionaries. The Jesuit Reduction started in the 16th century and was an idea of making missions for the native people of Central and South America to reduce the spread of the native population. This Reduction was started by the Spanish government the help Christianize, tax, and govern them also this made it easier for Spain to use the natives they captured as slaves to the crown. The Spanish

Savagism and Civility. This is a book review on the book Savagism and Civility by Bernard Sheehan. It was for my American History I class.

969 words - 4 pages Bernard Sheehan, Savagism & Civility (32 East 57th St., N.Y.: Cambridge University Press, 1980).U.S. History IThe book Savagism & Civility is a book by Bernard Sheehan that explains the tension between the Native Americans and the English colonists in Virginia. His book is an explanation of why there was mistrust and eventually violence between the natives and English colonists. He has taken many quotes from known English colonist and

This is a essay that was written a few years ago about the pros and cons of going into computer technology as a major in college.

2020 words - 8 pages the old Lowry Air Force Base it is expected to become a new technical school for robotics and laser technology (59). These are computer training programs. From this type of technology one can easily assume that computer technology really is the wave of the future.To go even further, in an interview conducted with Mr. Frank Buck, computer service technician and instructor, (personal interview, 4 April 1997) he too, spoke of computer technology as

An interview with someone who lived during WWII, the essay illustrates several questions one might ask, and responses I recieved, as well as an analysis of the responses.

1721 words - 7 pages into power if France had not burdened the German economy so heavily. He also felt that Japan was responsible for the war in the east, but the United States could have prevented the war from escalating by lifting its embargo on Japanese products.7.Question: Did you suffer any deprivations because of the war?Answer: During World War II, Bill's father worked with radars as an electrical engineer and was sent oversees to North Africa in 1943. Bill

Similar Essays

Socrates: A Revolutionary Philosopher Who Posed A Threat To The Government And Society

628 words - 3 pages in frustration at the end of the dialogue. However it can safely be said that most Athenians would agree with Euthyphro’s opinion of the gods and to disagree could most certainly be punishable by law, as Socrates was. Socrates’ search for the definition of piety is a difficult one that tests Euthyphro’s patience and ultimately leaves the characters and the reader without an answer. Every time Euthyphro proposes an answer, Socrates is quick to

Critical Review: Bradley A. Thayer, Bring In Darwin: Evolutionary Theory, Realism, And International Relations

1203 words - 5 pages In Thayer’s article, he makes an attempt to incorporate Darwin’s Evolutionary Theory into the international security studies. The article tries to answer a central question that what are the implications of Evolutionary theory to realist theory of international security and in what way can peace be achieved if warfare is part of human nature? This paper agrees with Thayer that Evolutionary theory provides a scientific theory foundation for

This Is An Essay Describing The Themes Of Freewill Versus Fate Within The Play Of Oedipus. The Title Is "Freewill Versus Fate" And It Delves Into It Effects Of Such Themes Upon The Reader.

779 words - 3 pages Greeks were definitely hooked on irony, and this large portion is what led his play into such success.Oedipus seeks the truth about himself despite the warnings that they will not bring him happiness. It is expressed that the dilemma was self evident for Oedipus to succumb to his own fate and never break through to the creation of his own life. Freewill is an abstract ingredient to fate, in which we all must believe that freewill is upon us, but that fate is in control. His search for truth was clear, only he had no choice in the matter. The story is a true testament to fate and predestination, which is why is has been, and will be, respected in time.

This Is A Mid Term Exam Answering Question Posed By The Professor On The Sociology Of Poverty

5437 words - 22 pages deeply imbedded in social institutions whose effect is to discriminate on the basis of race, religion, gender, age, or some other factor. Solutions only come with the changing the structure of societal institutions. Within the structural perspective one theory that comes close is the "critical race theory" which states that while race has a prominent role - class is the essential construct in understanding American life. "This theory sees race as a