This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

An Inward Corruption Of An Outward Justification

995 words - 4 pages

Circumstances are perhaps one of the most powerful tools one could use in the art of persuasion. The “what if’s” that define such circumstances could go on endlessly into the night, as far as one’s imagination can creatively escort them. When considering circumstances of war (which can essentially be described as murder), it is important to note that one’s moral compass will be indefinitely intertwined with one’s actions, as well as one’s justification of those actions; one is also capable of talking one’s self into the acceptance of otherwise “forbidden” acts of violence or morally inappropriate acts.
In order to understand the conflict between one’s moral compass and an assumed incongruous act, one must understand the roots of one’s moral compass. In the short story “Guests of the Nation”, Bonaparte seems to have adopted his moral compass from religion, as interpreted through this quote: “I alone of the crowd saw Donovan raise his Webley to the back of Hawkins's neck, and as he did so I shut my eyes and tried to pray” (O’Connor 4). The fact that Boneaparte closed his eyes shows the reader that Bonaparte in no way wanted to witness the execution, and that his moral compass disagreed with the thought of murder. The mention of prayer hints at his affinity for religion, implying that his moral compass is rooted there.
O’Connor makes an interesting observation about the impending execution of Bonaparte’s hostages: “And all that time I was hoping something would happen; that they’d run for it, or that Noble would take over the responsibility from me” (4). Before the execution, Bonaparte was simply scared. He did not want to take part in this execution, supposedly because he felt it was immoral. This is a perfect example of one’s moral compass in action while under the intense pressure of an approaching breach of one’s sense of morality.
According to Dr. Shira Maguen and Dr.Brett Litz, who both hold PhD’s (one is Psychology and one in Mental Health, respectively), acting against your morality, or moral compass, is not remotely healthy. This transgression of the conscience can even be considered a disease or illness. As stated in a cohesively written article that was published in the PTSD Research Quarterly: “An act of serious transgression that leads to serious inner conflict because the experience is at odds with core ethical and moral beliefs is called moral injury.” The article goes on to state that these transgressions may come in many different forms, not just pulling the trigger of a gun or being directly associated with the immoral act. “Moral injury” can also come about via acts of commission/omission, witnessing someone else commit what one would consider a moral transgression, or watching intense acts of violence against other human beings. All three of these circumstances were present in “Guests of the Nation” with relation to Bonaparte’s morality. This article makes it abundantly clear that one can never completely...

Find Another Essay On An Inward Corruption of an Outward Justification

An Analysis of An Adolescence

1035 words - 5 pages manage time efficiently or plan for the future. A partial reason for this awkward and unbalanced management is their dance with childish innocence. It is a constant whirlwind with the thoughts of a child and an adult. However, depending on your placement of this stage of development; there could have been the possibility of an already planned future. The best and most practical image for this stage is a puppy fighting within itself. Whether to

An Analysis of Religion by an Athiest

2490 words - 10 pages to hell upon death. In hell the soul rests under excruciating pain. Hell is the worst possible place that anyone could imagine. While heaven is depicted as being serene and beautiful, hell is depicted as a world full of pain and suffering. When one’s soul enters hell, the soul lives an eternal life of pain and suffering for their sins. “The sacred and transcendent” are those areas in religions that are not tangible or visible. Rather, “the

Euthanasia, an Analysis of an Ethical Dilemma

1083 words - 4 pages Voluntary euthanasia is defined as the act of killing someone painlessly, especially to relieve suffering from an incurable illness, with their consent (Collins English Dictionary, 2013). The morality and legal aspect of voluntary euthanasia has been a debate for many years. Voluntary euthanasia is a significant ethical dilemma that impacts nursing practice and other professionals in the healthcare field. With the utilization of ethical

An overview of Hajj

1337 words - 5 pages Hajj is a holy pilgrimage which all Muslims must try and take at least once in their lives. It is meant to be a journey to get closer to Allah and to help you understand your religion in a more spiritual way.The Hajj is described as "an inward journey to the Ka'bah of the heart and soul" in one passage of a book, Hajj is also described in a Muslim dictionary as "the fifth pillar of Islam is a pilgrimage to Mecca during the month of Dhu al-Qadah

An Interpretation of Zephaniah

4466 words - 18 pages in, then the book, testament, other testament, and finally the entire message of the Bible. When looking at these different sections, it is essential to research the historical and literary components of the passage. Below is an example of the hermeneutical process being put into practice on a passage from the book of Zephaniah. This student has spent time looking into the context and background of the passage and has come to an individual

Parts of an airplane

995 words - 4 pages As pilot I often get asked many questions about airplanes and their nature; I happily comply with their little heart’s desires for the thirst of knowledge about aviation. What does this do? How does this work? What in the world is that thing? People are rather inquisitive about the parts of an airplane. An airplane can be broken down into four easy simple categories, the fuselage, the wings, the empennage (tail section), and the engine. The

Spouse of an Alcoholic

872 words - 3 pages Alcoholism is sometimes called a family disease. An Alcoholic can cause much turmoil within a family. In fact, alcoholism is the single leading cause for family problems in the United States; seventy six million American adults have been subjected to alcoholism in the family. The spouse of an alcoholic is affected by his or her partner's problem in many ways. He or she may gain more responisbility for any children, become the sole bread-winner

An Apologia of Xenophon

1285 words - 5 pages of the Greeks’ discipline, leadership and courage during their journey home. Xenophon’s narrative offers an insight of the character and their political life of a Greek army. Although Xenophon seems to write about the account between the Greek and the barbarian, he presents himself as an important role in the Greek army throughout the rest of the books. He uses a third-person form when describing his own actions as a character. It might suggest

Story of an Hour

819 words - 3 pages In the short story "The Story of an Hour", Kate Chopin describes an hour of a woman, a new widow seems to be who incidentally recognizes a new free life and enjoys it just in a short moment; one hour right after getting a news of her husbands death in an accident. She has everything and nothing all in the same moment "an hour." At the beginning of the story, we know that Mrs. Mallard has a heart trouble. Why the author builds the central

Story of an Hour

1074 words - 4 pages "Story of an Hour" When I read Kate Chopin's, "Story of an Hour" I am reminded of a Edgar Allan Poe horror poems. The narrator has a "divine transformation" yet it kills her. This puzzles me, so I will search for the true meaning of this strange story (marriage, as I believe). To accomplish this task and to truly understand this short story, I will first learn about Kate Chopin's life and experiences. Later, I will investigate her use of

Story of an hour

946 words - 4 pages Kate Chopin’s “The Story of an Hour” tries to shed light on the conflict between women and a society that assign gender roles using a patriarchal approach. Specifically Margaret Bauer highlights, that most of Chopin’s works revolves around exploring the “dynamic interrelation between women and men, women and patriarchy, even women and women” (146). Similarly, in “The Story of an Hour” Chopin depicts a society that oppresses women mostly through

Similar Essays

An Inward Collapse Of The Human Perspective In Forster's A Passage To India

4013 words - 16 pages describes the English residence as having "nothing hideous in it, and only the view is beautiful; it shares nothing with the city except the overarching sky" (Forster 5). There is an overall sense of absence that is associated with the English residential area in both an inward and outward perspective. Even though there is nothing overly "hideous" in the English area, there is also nothing extraordinary in the area either. Yet, Forster hints

Empty Canvas: An Outward Perspective On The Picture Of Dorian Gray

2591 words - 11 pages the only true good; he declares, “The only things worth pursuing in life are beauty and fulfilment of the senses” (Wilde). This outlook is tempting for many persons, including that of the title character, Dorian Gray. In contrast to Lord Henry is an artist named Basil Hallward, whom perceives Dorian to be his muse; serving as inspiration, and purpose. Basil has many moral traits including trust, compassion, and kindness. His infatuation with

Shark Hunting: The Loss Of An Apex Predator, And The Corruption Of The Ocean Ecosystem

2588 words - 10 pages Shark Hunting: The Loss of an Apex Predator, and the Corruption of the Ocean EcosystemSharks are, without a doubt, one of the world's top predators. With a keen sense of smell, agile tactics and speed, and the ability to devise and recall attack plans, they are highly capable hunters. However, these top hunters now fall among the top hunted. Overfishing is pushing many shark species to the brink of extinction, and this inherent vulnerability is

Scientific Management Is Sadly Underestimated As An Approach In Modern Organisational Life. Provide A Detailed Justification Of Your Agreement Or Disagreement Of This Statement. (I Disagree With It)

1899 words - 8 pages To question whether scientific management is underestimated in the organisation of modern businesses is to misjudge the complexity of modern-day work practices. As scientific management is simply defined as 'an approach ...emphasising the scientific study of work methods to improve worker efficiency' (Management: A Pacific Rim Focus, 2001, p.36), it can be concluded that such a simplistic, inhumane approach does not belong in the 21st century.A