A Dilemma Of The Jury Selection Process?

1875 words - 8 pages

Have you ever been asked to serve as a jury member? Usually, most people have a negative feeling toward juror duty. Some of them might lack a full understanding of the important role of the jury, as they are not specialists in this professional field. The jury selection process also causes people to be impatient because, once prospective jurors are summoned in order to verify their impartiality, they have to be examined by both judges and lawyers. Potential jurors feel inferior during the selection process because they are excused with or without reasons. In fact, serving as a jury member is very important because every citizen has the responsibility to contribute to society by participating in civil activities. However, there are some potential problems in our jury selection process, such as the difficulty of the court to summon a certain group of people. Furthermore, the question of prospective jurors is not effective enough to eliminate incompetent jurors. Also, lawyers abuse their peremptory challenges, which allow them to dismiss potential jurors without reason. Subsequently, the jury pool is not representative enough and this hinders the court's ability to deliver justice.Jury summons is the first stage in the jury selection process. Potential jurors are notified by mail and they have to appear on a certain date and time. The main sources for jury summons come from voter registration lists and driver license lists (Baum 192). The sources of jury summons are so limited that they exclude minorities and others, and thus these groups of people are excluded from the judicial process. Obviously, people who don't register to vote may miss being selected by the jury pool center. According to voter statistics, only 67.1% of eligible citizens registered to vote in 1988 (Internet 1). In other words, more than 30% of people who possess eligibility didn't register. This indicates that a large group will be excluded from the jury selection process during the summons stage. Additionally, people who move a lot and do not change their information in the state office or Department of Motor and Vehicle (DMV) may miss their jury summons. This makes it difficult for the court to contact this group of people. Minorities are likely to be in these excluded groups since they cannot afford to buy a house or apartment (Internet 5). Therefore, they do not have a fixed address and are more likely to have an inaccurate DMV or state office record. Moreover, minorities change jobs more often; consequently, depending on their new workplace, they need to move to a residence by their workplace. Hence, the court will have difficulty trying to contact these minority groups who move frequently.Another problem with the summons process is that upper income people often excuse themselves from attending jury duty. It is true that jury duty pays little to jurors. People who earn a lot of money would not sacrifice their salary and holidays to serve as a jury member since many...

Find Another Essay On A Dilemma of the Jury Selection Process?

Selection of the supplier for a property company "North Eastern Property Managers", Supplier selection process in purchasing

2965 words - 12 pages IntroductionIn this research paper, we are told to make a "selection" of the plumbing items supplier for a property company named "North Eastern Property Managers" (NEPM), the property companies main functions are assumed as "fixing and installing the plumbing part of the property only" in this paperwork.NEPM has spent over 400,000 a year for the purchase of various kinds of plumbing supplies such as: pipes, tees, elbows, and many small

The Value Of A Jury System

1651 words - 7 pages bicameralism: Just as the legislature comprised two equal branches, an upper and a lower, juries and judges constituted the lower and upper branches, respectively, of the judicial department. The Supreme Court has reinforced the linkage of jury service and voting as part of a "package" of political rights. For example, in a 1991 case challenging race-based exclusions in jury selection, Justice Anthony Kennedy observed in his majority opinion

The Selection Process and the Importance of Involving the Employees

2230 words - 9 pages questions that may arise and acquire a further understanding of who the candidate is as an employee. Following this discussion is an explanation of how important it is to involve employees in the selection process. In addition, decision making strategies and methods are explained to allow a further understanding on how to select the right employee for the position available. Every company is different and can use a variety of tactics to be successful

Improvements to the Selection Process

1185 words - 5 pages the guidelines as it lessens the probability of having adverse impact as with other evaluation tools which require ranking of scores or individuals independently of a standard. I selected this as my second behavior because the clerical test is required and it modifies the procedure to one that is formal and scored. It is also a good practice as it aids in the selection process by ruling out applicants who do not meet the standard score. The

The Jury Selection Procedure in the English Legal System

1718 words - 7 pages the decision-making process. In part A of this essay, I will describe the jury selection procedure as it stands in the English Legal System. In part B, I will consider alternatives, suggest improvements to jury selection procedure, and discuss how representative it is of English society. PART A The method of jury selection in the English legal system is for a computer to arbitrarily pick individuals from

The Selection Process of District Judges and Lay Magistrates

1142 words - 5 pages The Selection Process of District Judges and Lay Magistrates Lay magistrates in England and Wales are appointed by the Lord Chancellor on behalf of the Queen. In the Duchy of Lancaster they are appointed by the Chancellor of the Duchy of Lancaster. The procedure is as follows: Individuals make an application to the Local Advisory Committee, which consists of magistrates and other local people. People or

The theme of Susan Glaspell's "A Jury of Her Peers".

519 words - 2 pages FeminismThe theme of a story is expressed in many different ways. Things such as the title, characters, plot, and setting are all means in which a theme can be developed. In Susan Glaspell's "A Jury of Her Peers," she examines the theme of feminism by her use of the title, the characters and the plot.First, Glaspell uses the title to let the reader know that ultimately Minnie Wright's fate will be decided by a "jury of her peers." Minnie's

A Jury of Her Peers

1125 words - 5 pages ). The popular author and play right Susan Glaspell was inspired by this court case. In her play "Trifles" and her short story "A Jury of Her Peers", she used two average, underrated housewives in the early 1900s to show a different perspective of the Iowa crime. Through many symbols, amusing irony, and illuminating dialogue, Glaspell shows how powerful and intellectual women could be despite the suppressive culture of their time.The most predominant

The Selection Process when Getting Hired

592 words - 3 pages Before the selection process took place, the criteria’s that applied to pick an employee to the organization must be discussed. A). FORMAL EDUCATION: Formal education presumes the use of scholastics’ certificates and training courses that applicants had before, as academic evidences for getting admitted to the job. It’s said; it refers to the classroom training an individual has received in public or private schools and college, university

The selection of a Landfill Site

3053 words - 12 pages Very Technical Too TechnicalThe Choosing of a Landfill SiteThere is currently much debate on the desirability of landfilling particular wastes, the practicability of alternativessuch as waste minimisation or pre-treatment, the extent of waste pre-treatment required, and of the most appropriatelandfilling strategies for the final residues. This debate is likely to stimulate significant developments in landfillingmethods during the next decade

The Dilemma of Cloning

1549 words - 6 pages The Dilemma of Cloning         Man is quickly approaching the reality of cloning a human being. Once regarded as a fantastic vision dreamed up by imaginative novelists, the possibility of creating a person in the absence of sexual intercourse has crossed over the boundaries of science fiction and into our lives. While genetic engineering has helped improve the quality of life for many people, it poses many ethical and moral questions that

Similar Essays

The Selection And Role Of A Jury In A Criminal Trial

946 words - 4 pages The Selection and Role of a Jury in a Criminal Trial This assignment focuses on how a jury is selected and its role in a criminal trial. The advantages and disadvantages of using a jury to decide the outcome of a criminal case will also be considered. A Jury is chosen at random, by a computer using names on the electoral

The Process Of Natural Selection Essay

1546 words - 6 pages of once-related living forms as distinct entities on one or many levels of classification. The process occurs as a species varies slightly over the course of numerous generations. Through inheritance, natural selection preserves each variation that proves advantageous to that species in its present circumstances of living, which include its interaction with closely related species in the “struggle for existence” (Darwin 62). Darwin states

To What Extent Does Random Selection Of Jury Members Create Bias And Would Jury Selection Provide A Solution?

1556 words - 6 pages To what extent does random selection of jury members create bias and would jury selection provide a solution? The theory behind the UK system of random selection is based on many assumptions. Firstly that randomness produces a representative sample of the population, which will provide verdicts, representative of the general public. It is assumed that if one juror has an apparent prejudice, then those in other jurors

The Selection Process Analysis

1056 words - 5 pages check, etc. Nowadays it’s become very important process to make sure of the validity and reality of the information that provided by the applicants and to secure better selection of the employees. In fact, conducting a background check has largely become an expected practice, and non-conducting one can be considered evidence of negligence in hiring (Gomez-Mejia, Balkin & Cardy 2012, p. 215). G). THE FINAL DECISION: Finally, the best