This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analyse Madame Roland's Letter Regarding 'the Massacre At The Champ De Mars' During The French Revolution. State What Further Information You Would Need.

893 words - 4 pages

The source provided is a discursive source intended for private use. Madame Roland writes it in letter format to a confidant. The source discusses her opinions and account of 'The massacre of the Champs de Mars'. The source does have a variety of strengths; it was written very close to the event, only one day after the massacre occurred. The fact that it is a letter suggests that it will be a truthful account, as we would not expect anyone to lie to a confidant, especially about such a public matter. However, she may also be inclined to exaggerate events to encourage sympathy for her political cause; using the term 'cut their brothers' throats' in reference to the National Guards. It is not a formal document so perhaps some of the facts have been misinterpreted. The letter, written one day after the event, leads us to question whether she is still shocked and perhaps this response is reactionary. Also as it has been translated there may be vital pieces of information missing or misinterpreted through editing. We are also indecisive whether she attended the signing all day and witnessed this openly or is she repeating what someone has told her? We also only have the one opinion. For a full report on the massacre we would need to combine this with other letters, formal documents and official reports, including that of the National Guards.For a study of 'The massacre of the Champs de Mars' I would want a full understanding of the 'National Guards' and what they were instructed to do. I would also want to see the site to grasp the scale of the massacre. I would also need a copy of the 'petition' that was being signed and I would want to elaborate on what the 'next legislature' specified. I would also want to specify on what the term 'municipality' entailed at the time and what the process was for informing the authorities about such events. The full role of the 'officers' would also require defining - who employed them and what powers did they have? Madame Roland refers to it being 'swelled by large numbers'; I would want some accurate figures as to how many people were there. I would also need to understand who were the 'Ecole Militaire' and what was the full significance of the 'red flag'.Wittingly, this letter informs us of the appalling behaviour of the National Guards under the king's instruction. Citizens had attended the Champs de Mars in order to sign a petition and the obligatory authorities were aware of this and the necessary legal channels followed. From two men caused friction as they were hiding and would not disclose the...

Find Another Essay On Analyse Madame Roland's letter regarding 'The Massacre at The Champ de Mars' during the French Revolution. State what further information you would need.

The Year 1792 of the French Revolution and the September Massacre

1476 words - 6 pages . She accompanied the royal family to the Tuileries; she was the daughter of King at the time, Louis the 16th. This is a description of what happened to the princess during those awful days in September. This is some of the ways people were murdered during the year 1792. Therefore The September Massacre was the most important part of the French Revolution because it had many events leading up to it, the largest number of fatalities during, and had

What made Rousseau's philosophy and David's paintings attractive during the French Revolution?

1309 words - 5 pages The causes of the French Revolution are so complicated that a debate still rages among historians regarding its origins, causes and results. In general, the real causes must lie with the increasing discontent various members of society had for the rigid social structure of the Ancient Regime. As it had been for centuries, French society was divided into three Estates or Orders. The First Estate consisted of the clergy and the Second Estate the

Reign of Terror was during the French Revolution

1810 words - 7 pages The immediate bloody aftermath , was a product of social, economic, and political forces. The spirit of idealism that gripped France during the early phases of the Revolution gave way to mass paranoia and extremism, culminating in Robespierre's cruel regime. In the beginning of the French Revolution, Enlightenment of the French Revolution, known as the Reign of Terrorphilosophy seemed like a panacea for societal woes. Prominent philosophers like

William Wordsworth: Romantic Poet during the French Revolution

1769 words - 7 pages friends with a fellow poet Samuel Taylor Coleridge who lived few distances away from where he was living at that time with his sister. Lyrical ballads which he wrote while living with his sister is mainly about the people he met while wondering around the country side. Literary Movement Wordsworth lived to see the French revolution, “the French revolution was in it’s third year………..”(poetry criticism pg.369) during that time the

What have you learn in this assignment? Do you get any information and gain knowledge regarding the issue?

641 words - 3 pages teaching during her later work and of this assignment will help me to be a master to give opinions and ideas. Information and knowledge that I gained from the issue of this case study is that if a company wants to get a cheap fee for outsourcing, companies need to identify and investigate the first to take outsourcing to assist in the important work in large companies. This is to avoid some of the problems that will occur in the future. Based on

What were the causes of the french revolution? inequality of the state, taxation, Louis XVI weak ruler

1095 words - 4 pages executed and his head displayed on a pole throughout Paris.The rebellion of the French was, among other factors, due chiefly to the social inequality of the state in France. There would not have been an adequate amount of significant problems in France for such a revolution to happen if there had been a sense of equality in the state, with equal rights and privileges for all members of society.BibliographyWittet, George G. and James R. Christopher. Modern Western CivilizationCanada: oxford university press, 1991.Trueman, Schaffter, Stewart and Hunter. Modern PerspectivesMcGraw-Hill Ryerson, 1979.

A three page paper covering the massacre at My Lai during the Vietnam war. (Bibliography included)

724 words - 3 pages , the White House, and Congress to research the matter. The military investigation resulted in Calley being indicted with murder in September 1969, three months before Hersh's story was released to the public.As the gruesome information of the massacre reached the American public, serious concerns arose regarding the behavior of American soldiers in Vietnam. A military committee exploring the My Lai massacre found extensive shortcomings in

"A Choice" assignment: you are a juror at the trial of Socrates. what punishment would you argue for?

1597 words - 6 pages this assembly he established motive. This motive can be further corroborated by Chairephon's brother who also has no reason to lie. Besides, the manner in which he broke the law pales in comparison to some of the other cases we have heard and discussed over the years. And what would be the ultimate effect? Why kill a seventy-year-old man who will probably die of natural causes in a very short time?Incarceration would also be a choice. On the

Discuss one change you would like to see in mental health services or practice. Describe what would need to happen for the change to be achieved a

1935 words - 8 pages requires motivation and lack of motivation and social capital is a symptom of depression so many struggle to complete these programmes (NHS Choices, 2014; 2014a). Also adequate training and empowerment of the service user is essential for self-help to be effective, computer skills may need to be taught and access to computers given. This training depends on available resources within the community at the meso level and also on policies decided

"The French Revolution was a radical political revolution with conservative social consequences". Do you agree? Why?

1721 words - 7 pages to democracy and constitutional monarchy. Not only was the revolution radical in its political theories and debates but also in its social changes from overturning the noblesse d'oblige to liberating slaves and searching for equality between the sexes. This argument corresponds with the Maximalist line of thought, subscribed to by historians such as Albert Soboul, who give emphasis to the power of the French Revolution at creating a social

The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory and Practice during the French Revolution and beyond

1577 words - 6 pages There are different attitudes towards politics The Origins of Totalitarian Democracy, Political Theory and Practice during the French Revolution and beyond J.L Talmon The author, Talmon, states that there are different democracy attitudes towards politics. The liberal approach assumes politics to reach through a matter of trial and error a state of ideal harmony, and the totalitarian

Similar Essays

A Study Of The Massacre Of The Champs De Mars. The French Revolution

637 words - 3 pages A study of the massacre of the Champs de Mars.The source is a letter from Madame Roland to a confident regarding the events that took place at the Champs de Mars on the 17th July 1791. This kind of source has many strengths as a piece of evidence when writing a study of an event such as this and added to other sources provides valuable information regarding the events that took place. Firstly, as this is a letter it can be assumed it was

Plan Of Champ De Mars, Paris 1889

2186 words - 9 pages Plan of Champ de Mars, Paris 1889 This is a twenty-six by forty-eight centimeter plan of the Champ de Mars during the Exposition Universelle of 1889, used by visitors at the time of the fair, a bold political statement on the part of France, as well as an overwhelming success. The Third Republic was established in Paris in 1870, and by 1884, when preliminary studies for the the Exposition Universelle were launched, many political issues were

At What Cost Would You Save The Life Of Another?

814 words - 3 pages “Thou shalt not be a victim. Thou shalt not be a perpetrator. Above all, thou shalt not be a bystander.” (Berenbaum) Would you save lives of others at the consequence of losing your own? Many people faced with this question during the Holocaust became bystanders while very few had the courage to jeopardize everything to rescue others. While Nazi’s were terrorizing others and eliminating their liberties others became bystanders and were

Metadata: Finding The Information That You Need

1394 words - 6 pages In enterprise, there is a massive amount of data that can’t be found, but metadata is one of the alternative solution to find the data that people need to get easily and more efficiently. Metadata contains every data that is in enterprises such as the information of the contents, records that they use. The purpose of using metadata is not only using for finding data that they need, but also used in management of informations. Metadata produces a