Analysing John Rawls' Theory Of Justice And Its Principles, And The Conflicts Which May Arise From Its Implementation.

1651 words - 7 pages

Justice as FairnessThe late John Rawls, in 'Justice as Fairness', acknowledges that society exists for the "mutual benefit of all its members" (Nuttall 2002:223). They should be better off living in a society than not. However, he also indicates that there is a conflict of interest between members within the society, as each tries to accumulate a larger share of wealth and goods available.Rawls' theory of justice is seen as the solution to the conflict of interests in society, and revolves around the adaptation of two fundamental principles of justice, which would, in turn, guarantee a just and morally acceptable society. The first principle guarantees the right of each person to have the most extensive basic liberty compatible with the liberty of others. The second principle states that social and economic positions are to be (firstly) to everyone's advantage and (secondly) open to all.Rawl believes that the first principle (the liberty principle) should take precedence over his second (the difference principle). The liberty principle entails that each citizen should have the right to political liberty (ie to vote and stand for election), liberty of conscience and freedom of thought, the right to hold personal property, freedom of speech and assembly, and freedom from arbitrary arrest and seizure. Rawl wishes to see all these freedoms distributed equally, as he asserts that this is the basis of a just society.The first part of Rawls' second principle of justice states that social and economic inequalities are to be arranged so that they are reasonably expected to be everyone's advantage. Rawls refers to this portion as 'the difference principle'. The difference principle implies two things. First, that those who posses fewer natural assets such as wealth or education, deserve special consideration and compensation. Second, Rawls implies that the rich should willingly give up a portion of their wealth to the poor since they would gain more than they gave up by enjoying the benefits of a mutually co-operative society (Nuttall 2002:226).If Rawls were to consider that perhaps the losses felt by the rich may indeed outweigh the benefits felt in return and also outweigh the gain in happiness of the poor, then I wonder how solid he would feel his argument is. Rawls bases his difference principle on the assumption that wealth is a natural asset, that people gain it by being in the right place at the right time. This becomes believable when examples such as that of David Beckham are cited; while Beckham may work hard for the millions he earns, I have no doubt in my mind that there are others in this country who work several fold harder and longer and receive a tiny percentage of his income. This would give notice to the idea of the natural lottery, which implies that the distribution of such things as wealth and education are arbitrary. If this were the case unconditionally, then Rawls' theory would undoubtedly hold true. The idea that wealth is...

Find Another Essay On Analysing John Rawls' Theory of Justice and its principles, and the conflicts which may arise from its implementation.

John Rawls, Justice. Essay

570 words - 2 pages Rawls opens The Role of Justice with a strong analogy which turns the brain on, justice is the first virtue of social institutions, as truth is of systems of thought. Rawls also gives us the definition we were looking for, the role of justice itself is to insure that the distribution of benefits and burdens is fair.Just is a key center point in a society. Without justice in a society, the society would be ruined. Each person born into a society

The European Court of Justice and its Interlocutors

2356 words - 9 pages what can only be described as ‘agents of EU law.’ Further development of ECJ power came in 1996 in the subsequent joined cases, Brasserie du Pȇcheur and Factortame. In both cases, the national courts requested a ruling from the ECJ concerning the conditions under which a Member State may incur liability for damage caused to individuals by breaches of Community law attributable to that State. Drawing on international law principles, and on its

Discuss and outline the history of the Eureka Stokade its impacts as well as the influence of its implementation

717 words - 3 pages It was revolution - small in size, but greatly politically; it was a strike against injustice and oppression. It was the Barons and John over again; it was Hampden and ship-Money; it was Concord and Lexington; small beginnings, all of them, but all of them great in political results, all of them epoch-making . . . It adds an honourable page to history; the people know it and are proud of it. They keep green the memory of the men who fell at the

The Development of Attachment Theory and Its Strengths and Limitations

1443 words - 6 pages The Development of Attachment Theory and Its Strengths and Limitations English psychiatrist John Bowlby is a leading and influential figure within the history of social reform. His work has influenced social work policies and legislation relating to child psychiatry and psychology. Bowlby was trained as a psychoanalyst, and was influenced by Freudians theories, but became influenced again in his attachment theory by

Theory Of Knowledge And Its Justification

1586 words - 6 pages , scientists to form a new hypothesis, and then the process is redone.The mathematician and the historian, however, differ in their view of the kinds of justifications. The mathematician does not believe that a hypothesis or theory is justified through memory, the levels of perception, and faith. Mathematics justification claims are done through deduction, or logic. Mathematics itself is a axiomatized deductive system. The axioms are deduced from

Discuss the different neoplasms which may arise in the lung. Discuss their staging and grading with regard to prognosis and treatment. Are there any promising new treatment modalities?

2142 words - 9 pages IntroductionThe impact of lung cancer in our society cannot be denied. According to "Lung cancer is the leading cause of cancer death in Australia and most other Western industrialized countries. One in 28 Australians will develop lung cancer by the age of 75, and about 6,700 Australians die from lung cancer each year". Lung cancer is one of the more difficult cancers to detect at its early stages and is one of the more difficult

Race and its Implications in the Criminal Justice System

1276 words - 5 pages witness (Linder, 2000). This was the critical turn of the case from one of murder to one of race. The tables turned and it seemed that the defense finally could make a case for a not guilty verdict. Fuhrman was the detective who found the rubber glove at the scene of the crime and matched it to the glove found at Simpson’s home later that morning. The defense pinned Fuhrman as a racist and asked numerous times had he ever used the “N” word which he

The polluter pays principle and its implementation in the UK and EC law

3725 words - 15 pages ENVIRONMENTAL LAWENVIRONMENTAL LAW- ESSAYDiscuss the following principle and its application within EU and UK law: "The polluter pays".1.IntroductionThe polluter pays principle can be identified as one of the most significant principles that guide Environmental Law. Although it is complicated and sometimes diverse, it appears to be a main requirement for the regulation of pollution prevention and pollution control. However, many difficulties

This paper compares two famous political philosophers John Rawls and Robert Nozick and their approaches to social justice

1612 words - 6 pages activities to people for their own good or protection" (Nozick, 217).The primary difference between the two is in the their views on destributional justice. In case of Rawls' difference principle Nozick proposes an "entitlement theory", according to which individual holdings of various social and economic goods are justified only if they derive from just acquisitions or voluntary transfers. "No safety nets allowed", i.e. acquisitions from social

Elementary Number Theory and its Applications

6103 words - 24 pages -grade primes" (Henri Cohen). In the language of complexity theory, one says for short primes ∈ co-RP . A deterministic algorithm of Adleman, Pomer- ance, and Rumely from 1983, which uses much more theory and a generalization of Fermat's Little Theorem to integers in cyclotomic fields, completely characterizes the prime numbers. The best deterministic algorithm prior to August 2002, it has running time of superpolynomial order (logn)O(log log

Elementary Number Theory and its applications

8820 words - 35 pages rather than discovering and proving of new theorems or problem solving. During my project, I started from reading a book [11], which is called "Elementary Number Theory and its Applications". During reading this book, I learned basic con- cepts and theorems, which are essential for the following discussion. In the meantime, I was aware of the interesting topics in elementary number theory, and then, chose one of them to be my topic, which is

Similar Essays

Rawls' Principles Of Justice Essay

1361 words - 5 pages according to Rawls is “the appropriate initial status quo which insures that the fundamental agreements reached in it are fair.” (Rawls: Justice as Fairness, From a Theory of Justice. pg. 489) What Rawls is trying to do is create a position in which a person removes themselves from all forms of bias. Potential forms of bias are race, color, gender, social status, and things such as our own theory of the good; are what need to be removed from the

John Rawls' A Theory Of Justice

705 words - 3 pages John Rawls' A Theory of Justice John Rawls' "A Theory of Justice" has long been revered as a marvel of modern political philosophy. It's most well-known for the two principles of justice outlined by Rawls: (1) that all persons have an equal right to liberty; and (2) that (a) all inequalities in society should be arranged to benefit the least advantages, and (b) that all positions and offices should be open and accessible as outlined by fair

A Theory Of Justice Presented By John Rawls

1820 words - 7 pages In A Theory of Justice John Rawls presents his argument for justice and inequality. Rawls theorizes that in the original position, a hypothetical state where people reason without bias, they would agree to live in a society based on two principles of justice (Rawls 1971, 4). These two principles of justice are named the first and second principles. The first is the equal rights and liberties principle. The second is a combination of the

John Rawls On Justice Essay

1572 words - 6 pages social status or from obtaining a fortune. If this is followed than people would agree on what a just society is because they have obtained the same principles . In conclusion John Rawls Theory of Justice helped transform political thought in the 20th century with the creation of the Veil of ignorance, what constitutes justice and how to create it. Some of John Rawls ideas maybe delusional or hypocritical such as equality and his plans for