Analysis Of The Tax Treatment Of Investors

1463 words - 6 pages

Each of the three approaches discussed so far assumes that the present value of a dollar of tax saved by the company is fully reflected in shareholder value. But, in addition to arguments about the validity of each of these methods, there is also some disagreement as to whether the tax rate that should be used in calculating the value of the debt tax shield should be lower than the corporate tax rate because of taxes incurred by investors. The standard way to deal with this issue has been to define a net tax saving variable, T*, that reflects the tax treatment of the investors who hold the company’s debt and equity as follows:
(1-T*) = (1-TC)[(1-TPE)/(1-TPD)], (4)
where TPE is the marginal tax rate of the investors who determine the company’s cost of equity, and TPD is the tax rate at the margin of the investors who determine the company’s cost of debt.
As can be seen from this equation, if the tax treatment of debt and equity is the same, then the net tax saving variable, T*, is equal to the full corporate tax rate, and all the valuation formulas discussed above apply. But if the tax treatment of equity is more favorable than the tax treatment of debt, then T* will be lower than the full corporate tax rate and the valuation formulas should be adjusted accordingly. Specifically, the value of the debt tax shield should be calculated using the lower net tax saving rate, rather than the full corporate tax rate. For instance, in that case equation (2) should be:
PVTS = T*D, (5)
which yields a lower value for the debt tax shield. A value of T* lower than the corporate tax rate would also affect the calculation of the cost of capital, which we discuss below. This completes our brief review of the theory. We now summarize several debates among researchers that are relevant to the practical valuation of debt tax shields. These concern the size of the net tax saving, T*, and what formulas to use when valuing the debt tax shield.

Should you use APV, WACC, or capital cash flow?
The choice between the three methods of incorporating the debt tax shield into a valuation appears at first sight to be important. In one sense it is, because the three methods can give very different values. Nevertheless, they are entirely consistent with one another when the assumptions that each method makes about the company’s tax status and future leverage policy are met. Table 1 summarizes these assumptions and indicates (with an √) which method is likely to work best given a particular set of assumptions, and which methods (marked with X) are inconsistent with the particular assumptions.

The table shows that APV can always be used provided it is applied consistently. However, there are two cases where it clearly makes sense to use the other methods. One is when the company can be assumed to use a constant proportion of leverage. In that case, the WACC method is the simplest. The other is where the future tax saving is risky because, for example, the company may...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of The Tax Treatment of Investors

Increase of the Tax on Cigarettes

1039 words - 4 pages The central issue in the article is whether or not the government should be allowed to increase the tax on cigarettes. Contemporary liberal society is governed on the basis that autonomy, human rights, and liberties will be respected, but also that the government will care for its citizens. Upon careful analysis of addiction to nicotine, the effects this addiction will have on the population, and the obligations of the government, one will find

Tax Consequences of Compensation Essay

2005 words - 8 pages (A) ADVICE FOR MONEYMAN tax consequences of receiving compensation.ISSSUEMoneyman Limited got $600,000 compensation from Allbrand Limited because of cancellation of contract by Allbrand Limited.STATE LAW(1)When there is income out of ordinary course of business, it should be treated as capital.In this case, there is income (but of capital nature), which makes it capital rather than income. The capital has been raised by the cancellation of

The Value of the Tax Shield of Debt

2594 words - 10 pages . Luehrman, Timothy A. 1997. What’s worth: A general manager’s guide to valuation. Harvard Business Review 75: 132-142. Miles, James A. and John R. Ezzell. 1980. The weighted average cost of capital, perfect capital markets, and project life: A clarification. Journal of Financial and Quantitative Analysis 15: 719-730. Miles, James A. and John R. Ezzell. 1985. Reformulating tax shield valuation: A note. Journal of Finance 40: 1485-1492. Miller, Merton H

The Process of Water Treatment

1349 words - 6 pages . In order to produce potable water, water treatment process must be conducted properly. According to Miller (2009), there are six important treatment processes which are coagulation, sedimentation, filtration, ion exchange, absorption, and disinfection. (Refer to Figure 1 in Appendix 1). Firstly, water is allowed to undergo coagulation process. The principle of coagulation process is to remove turbidity from the water, microorganisms, chemical in

The Unethical Treatment of Animals

1870 words - 7 pages “Man is the highest rated animal, at least among all the animals who returned the questionnaire (Brault, 2009).” For years humans have been using animals for experimentation, food, clothing, sport and entertainment, manual labor, and let us not forget man’s best friend. The unethical treatment of animals can best be resolved by deontology contrasted with ethical egoism. Being human indicates the feeling of pain, pleasure, fear, and love; if

Treatment of the Mentally Ill

2204 words - 9 pages would more than likely be shunned. There was, though, one mind who thought differently. Hippocrates was a well known philosopher. He believed that mentally ill people had a disease of the brain rather than the popular belief that they had insulted and brought anger to the gods. He disagreed completely with the treatment of the mental and the punishments they were given, mostly because he believed they had no control over their mental stability

The Ethical Treatment of Animals

736 words - 3 pages I believe in the ethical treatment for all animals is an ethical obligation by all humans. We have come to an era that we believe that all humans should be treated equally and fairly. Well, what about our other living, breathing counterparts? They deserve to live their life as they choose in quality and in the pursuit of happiness. Just as Europeans came and took over Northern America's land and resources on the Indians. We have also taken

The Unfair Treatment of Women

1567 words - 6 pages The Unfair Treatment of Women My mother has always promoted sisterhood and support for women. Growing up, I was taught that women, although we can do anything we want to do, need a support system, because we are traditionally the underdogs, and we should not accept being treated unfairly. My mother likes to tell a story about how, when she was a girl, she told her dad that she had decided to become a lawyer when she grew up. In response to

The Ethical Treatment of Prisoners

2355 words - 9 pages crimes or they may have been convicted falsely, but if God has hope for humanity then the utilitarian relativism of treatment should conclude we treat fellow humans with the hope that they can change and not exploit their labor capabilities. Using their labor as means for profit is not ethically correct. I’m not saying there is an easy answer; it involves many facets of virtues well within the prison system and the individuals themselves. Yet the

The Treatment of Arab Americans

2826 words - 11 pages A stressful month of work has finally come to an end and a long waited vacation with the family is just around the corner. The next morning you finally get everyone’s bags packed and jump in a shuttle to head to the airport. When you arrive at the airport the heavy door to the shuttle opens as you gather your bags and head through the big glass doors to check in. The nice blonde at counter smiles at you and your family and tells you to have a

An Analysis of the Perception and Treatment of Death in Everyman

950 words - 4 pages The title of the play Everyman illustrates the anonymous Author’s reminder to his audience that every man’s soul needs to be saved before death. Additionally, he reminds believers of God that death may be the end of our physical bodies, but it is just the beginning of our spiritual journey with God. The play serves as a reminder to not only live for today, but to strive towards the goal of ever-lasting life in Heaven, by stating, “Look well, and

Similar Essays

The Regulations Of Tax Laws Essay

2033 words - 8 pages The Regulations of Tax Laws Introduction Tax laws rules and regulations change mostly every year and people in the business need to keep up with the fast pace of those

Corporate Governance: Role Of Institutional Investors

2998 words - 12 pages Institutional investors have become predominant players in financial markets and their influence worldwide is growing. The abuse of power by many corporations has prompted increased the need for active institutional participation to enforce governance practices. Only institutional investors will have sufficient stake to be able to hold large corporations accountable. Encouraged by the institutional investors, responsible companies are now

The Treatment Of Phobias Essay

1026 words - 4 pages . Throughout the essay there will be three different treatments with three different phobias in ways to cure a phobia; the first is a trauma-focused treatment approach for travel phobia, assessment and treatment for childhood phobias, and hypnosis in facilitating clinical treatment of injections. Several people today suffer from travel phobia, yet there is little data regarding the phobia. The purpose of this study was to review the usefulness of a

The Treatment Of Whistleblowers Essay

2056 words - 8 pages able to work in their careers again in the same capacity (Shulman, 2007). Many whistleblowers not only lose their jobs, but they lose their families and friends, and much of their money ends up going to attorneys (Shulman, 2007). Indeed, in today’s day and age, there is a surge of whistleblowers prosecutions, and it is quite worrisome (Burghardt, 2011). Are the rights of citizens being eroded in order to protect bureaucratic secrets? Many case