Research Cloning Where To Draw The Line?

903 words - 4 pages

Charles Krauthammer, the author of ?Crossing Lines: A Secular Argument Against Research Cloning?, claims that research cloning is a dangerous practice that could open the door to severe exploitation of human life. Krauthammer thinks that even if boundaries and guidelines surrounding the issue are in place, there is no guarantee that unethical practices would not occur. He strongly believes that we should be aware of and careful to prevent less than ethical actions that may arise from certain individuals conducting such research.Krauthammer uses effective arguments when supporting his claim on research cloning. He explains the processes involved in stem-cell research, research cloning, and reproductive cloning. He then elaborates on his stance regarding the issue by breaking his argument down into four objections. Krauthammer tries to reason with his readers in a manner that may persuade a reader to see things his way. For this reason, he appeals more to logos (reasoning) when trying to persuade his audience. He doesn?t use quotes from creditable sources or try to make you feeling sorry for someone. Instead, he uses logic and reasoning to make his point.Krauthammer stated that, ?many advocates of research cloning see nothing but thingness. That view justifies the most ruthless exploitation of the embryo. That view is a very dangerous one? (221). He then goes on to explain four main reasons why research cloning is dangerous. Krauthammer titles his objections Intrinsic Worth, The Brave New World Factor, The Slippery Slope, and Manufacture. While explaining his objections Krauthammer uses a passive yet informative tone and addresses his audience as a group of reasonable people who are capable of understanding the argument at hand. He then persuades his audience by reasoning with them and elaborating on three main examples that cause the audience to get involved or take a stance on the issue.The Brave New World Factor states that, ?research cloning gives man too much power for evil? (221). This is a very effective argument because Krauthammer gives examples of things that have happened in the past and then relates them to hypothetical situations that could occur if research cloning takes place. For example, Krauthammer informs the readers that, ?in 1995 researchers in Texas produced headless mice? (222). He then goes on to support his objection by drawing the readers into a hypothetical situation. Krauthammer states that, ? one can envision, in a world in which embryos are routinely manufactured, the production of headless clones ? subhuman creatures with usable organs but no head, no brain, no consciousness to identify them with the human family? (222). When reading this passage the reader automatically imagines the scene described and becomes open to the ideas of the author. Krauthammer then closes the...

Find Another Essay On Research Cloning Where to Draw the Line?

Euthanasia- Where the line is Drawn. Classical Argument

2286 words - 9 pages Martin 1Billy MartinProfessor MuradEnglish 2000April 14, 2014Euthanasia; Where the Line Is DrawnThe long-term debate about issues surrounding passive euthanasia or non-voluntary euthanasia dates back to the 5th century B.C. Passive euthanasia is defined as the ending of life in patients, who cannot make a decision or cannot make their wishes known, by the deliberate withholding of drugs or other life-sustaining treatment (

Should morality be included as an essential part of law? At what point to do we draw the line between what is legally morally acceptable and what is not?

724 words - 3 pages Should morality be included as an essential part of law? At what point to do we draw the line between what is legally morally acceptable and what is not? The moral views of a society should be incorporated into the laws of society to a degree that represents the best interest of the people. It is far fetched to say that we should remove entirely moral views from our legal system, while on the other side of the spectrum it wouldn't seem right to

Cloning-The Challenge to Originality

880 words - 4 pages Along with the many great discoveries being made in the field of genetics, many controversies are also accompanying these discoveries. One branch of genetic research that shrouded in mystery is the ever-growing field of genetic cloning; reproductive cloning being one that contains a great deal of interest. This field of research is highly controversial, as one would expect. One side of the argument is that this will allow for us to stop species

Fossil Fuel versus Solar Power: Where the Line Meets the Circle

2174 words - 9 pages Fossil Fuel versus Solar Power: Where the Line Meets the Circle There are a number of benefits to building a house that utilizes direct solar energy as compared to current conventional designs, which are largely powered and heated by energy from fossil fuels. According to a number of estimates, it is actually cheaper in the long term to incorporate solar energy into building design. Solar energy is far cleaner than fossil fuel derived energy

"The media can be trusted to act responsibly and reflect community standards and values. Where the media fail to do so, the courts or other regulators pull them into line."

1514 words - 6 pages use the phrase "publics right to know" in their own dis-gression, and own terms, is when things can get a little out of hand.With the way the media is run, so many areas where information can be leaked to the public and many different organisations running their own media outlet, I believe the courts and regulators have too much work cut out for them and cannot pull media that step over the boundary, straight back into line. That is if they have

How does Harper Lee Manage to Draw Together the Stories of Boo Radley

1043 words - 4 pages How does Harper Lee Manage to Draw Together the Stories of Boo Radley and Tom Robinson? Do you find her Way of doing this Effective? There is a strong literary motif running through Harper Lee's novel 'To Kill a Mockingbird'. The stories of Boo Radley and Tom Robinson are drawn together by the way they are both mockingbirds in their own way. Both men are on the outskirts of society and are misunderstood by the predominantly white

Genetics, Genetic Research and Cloning The Human Genome Project

1996 words - 8 pages Eight page paper outlining the Human Genome Project, a research study and project involving cloning of DNA for medical and research use. Written as an ethical issues paper from a nurse's standpoint. It includes the history of the project and uses today and in the future. Also includes potential ethical issues regarding cloning. Complete with references in APA format.Running head: GENETICS, GENETIC RESEARCH AND CLONINGGenetics, Genetic Research

What are the essential ingredients to a successful military leader? Please draw your essay from the Taylor/Rosenbach text.

1268 words - 5 pages THIS WAS LIMITED TO A 1-2 PAGE ESSAY ANSWER (TIMED) FOR A MIDTERM EXAMQuestion: What are the essential ingredients to a successful military leader? Please draw your essay from the Taylor/Rosenbach text. Please use the specific ideas outlined in the chapters by Ridgeway and Marshall. is in the DescriptionNote: My Answer is VERY personal with a first-person approach. Not the "norm" for college level essay, BUT in this particular case, with my

What's the Bottom Line to a Healthier Lifestyle?

1012 words - 4 pages What's the Bottom Line to a Healthier Lifestyle?The danger posed by lack of attention to employees' physical health has been the focus of the Michigan Surgeon General since the appointment of the office has shed light on a serious problem. Michigan's own governor has also addressed important issues contained in the report from the Surgeon General that affect long-term health that will ensure the workforce remains productive. "The Surgeon

Cloning: Right Or Wrong? Should cloning be legal? What are the pros and cons of cloning? What can cloning lead to? What should be done?

563 words - 2 pages clones will behave like any other human being would behave as it will have all the characteristics of a normal human being, as long as the individual who was cloned had human characteristics, it wont really matter.In conclusion I would like to say that, as you've seen above, cloning could be used in various ways to benefit the lives of humans .It is inevitable that cloning, at some stage, will play an important, if not vital, part in our lives therefore it is about time that society accepts this fact and lifts all constraints upon cloning so that more research can be carried out and help eliminate any risks associated with cloning.

Cloning: What is the right thing to do?

1363 words - 5 pages . This is where things get controversial. It would be possible to use stem cell research to grow a new organ for a dying person, you would be able to give the recipient a perfect match without having to worry about rejection of the organ, which is fatal in most cases. In medical research cloning could give deep insights into problems concerning spinal chords, heart muscles, or brain tissue that will not regenerate after an injury. Finally, it may

Similar Essays

Cloning: The Benefits And Where To Draw The Line

2257 words - 10 pages . Currently, the use of cloning is increasing rapidly and the issue behind what laws should be enacted demands attention. Human therapeutic cloning research needs to be continued in order to improve medical abilities; however, the science behind cloning and the view of society regarding the process are not prepared for a world where reproductive cloning in humans is legal or encouraged. Therapeutic cloning can provide treatment and even cures for many

Time To Draw The Line Essay

941 words - 4 pages There are many mixed reviews on the topic of immigration. Should we continue to allow immigrants to come into our country, both legally and illegally? As a country, should we tighten the borders? Should we require every person living in the USA to be registered with a new National Identity Bureau (Park)? At some point something needs to give. Our economy is in the worse shape in that has been in years. The unemployment rate is at the highest

The Addictive Draw To Tattoos Essay

1727 words - 7 pages tattoos because we desire to define ourselves as unique individuals. There are different reasons as to why tattoo artwork accomplishes this. For many, low self esteem is the driving emotion that lands a person in the tattoo parlor. Shelley Twyman confirms this idea, stating that “many people feel better about their self image after engaging in a type of alteration of the body.” In actuality, Shelley’s research measured the self esteem of tattooed

Research Assignment: Cloning 1.         What Is Cloning? Cloning Is The

810 words - 3 pages Research Assignment: Cloning 1. What is cloning? Cloning is the technique of creating a copy of a cell or group of cells. There are three main ways to clone a cell; Splitting off a cell from an embryo, the Roslin technique (used for Dolly), and the Honalulu technique. Each way is very complicated and requires a vast amount of research and experimenting before completed. A bill has been passed to ensure that no cloning can be done. The