Analysis Of The Controversial Issue Of Capital Punishment

2444 words - 10 pages

The Controversial Issue of Capital Punishment

    Capital punishment is a declining institution as the twentieth century nears its end. At one time capital punishment was a common worldwide practice, but now it is only used for serious violation of laws in 100 of the world's 180 nations (Haines 3 ). It can be traced back to the earliest forms of civilization. The origins of the movement away from capital punishment are difficult to date precisely. The abolition movement can be heard as early as the religious sermons of the Quakers in the 1640's (Masur 4). In the seventeenth century, the Anglo-American world began to rely less on public executions and more in favor of private punishments. The possible decline in popularity of the capital punsihment system is directly related to the many controversial issues it entails such as: the questions of deterrence, morals and ethics, constitutionality, and economics.


The usual justification for capital punsihment is that it deters crime. It is by no means obvious whether capital punishment deters crime more than life imprisonment. However, a legend says that in Victorian, England, at the site of public hangin gs of pickpocketers, other pickpocketers frequently practiced their trade among the crowd. Although the threat of execution was taking place right in front of their eyes, the deterrence in its strongest form was ineffective (Streib 3). On the other hand , in 1970 and 1971 the Los Angeles Police Department surveyed persons whom they arrested for a violent crime, but did not use their weapon, did not carry a weapon, or carried an inoperative weapon. Of the ninety-nine criminals who responded to the questi on about why they had not killed or put themselves in a situation to kill, these were the following results: 50% were deterred by the threat of capital punishment; of the remaining 50%, 8% were unaffected by the death penalty because of a lack of enforce ment; 10% were undeterred by the death penalty and would kill even if it was regularly enforced; and the remaining 32% were not concerned with the death penalty because they would never carry a weapon in fear of hurting themselves or someone else (Streib 2).


Analyzing the above study closer, one might find that the threat of capital punishment greatly reduces the murder rate. But if that was the case, sociologists could show the effect of capital punishment by statistics, which they cannot do. Schola rs have compared murder rates of the states which frequently practice capital punishment against those states that rarely enforce capital punsihment with inconclusive results.


Investigators have also compared different periods in states which had capital punishment at some times of their history and not at others, but have found no difference in favor of the times and places with capital punishment. Studies have also looked at the number of murders in a particular city just before and...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of the Controversial Issue of Capital Punishment

The Issue of Capital Punishment as in the film Dead Man Walking

1450 words - 6 pages The Issue of Capital Punishment as in the film Dead Man Walking In this essay I am going to analyse and explain how the issue of Capital Punishment is portrayed in the film "Dead Man Walking", a true story acted out. Before I proceed with this essay, I think it necessary to give some background information on Capital Punishment. Capital punishment, also referred to as the death penalty, is the ordered execution of a

Capital Punishment - A Complex Social Issue

3808 words - 15 pages Should the government abolish capital punishment? This is a question that has plagued the United States since its birth, as it is a complex social issue not easily resolved. The law, society, and many religious institutions consider life to be precious. Also, because capital punishment is irreversible, an innocent life could potentially be at stake in the pursuit of justice. Groups that are opposed to the death penalty – such as

The Controversial Issue of Abortion

1422 words - 6 pages Abortion is a very controversial topic. This paper will discuss the opposing sides of the issue as well as my own personal opinion. The basic question is when a developing person actually becomes a person or alive. The following articles: A Defense of Abortion, by Judith Jarvis Thomson and Opposition to Abortion: A Human Rights Approach, by Baruch Brody discuss the opposing sides of the abortion issue. I will be using and summarizing those

Media Analysis of a Current Controversial Issue

1092 words - 5 pages Homosexuality is the current controversial issue that has hit the media. One cannot avoid the topic of homosexuality in the news, movies, books, social media, newspapers, and even in politics. Homosexuality has become a controversial issue around the globe today. After Uganda outlawed homosexuality in its country, the topic has been trending everywhere in the mainstream media, and the social media. Some nations like the US have legalized

The controversial issue of death penalty

1284 words - 5 pages THE DEATH PENALTY"THE DEATH SENTENCE IS THE MOST CONTROVERSIAL ISSUE ACROSS OUR WORLD"the death penalty is a very common controversial socialissue across our world.every time a death penalty case arises, and time comesfor the convict, thousands of people across the countries support the punishment as well as protest the punishment."this issue does not have any proponents of particular group. people are very split on this subject, regardless of

The Controversial Issue of Abortion and Christianity

1124 words - 4 pages The Controversial Issue of Abortion Abortion is a very controversial issue in society today. Some people think that abortion is a good idea to solve problems and that it is justified yet the Catholic Church would argue this is not the case and that abortion is wrong. There are some very strong arguments both for and against abortion. There are two methods of abortion: 1) The Suction Method: This is used for

The Controversial Issue of Religion In Schools

2151 words - 9 pages The Controversial Issue of Religion in SchoolsI was once talking with a man who told me that he did not believe in giving little children any religious instruction whatsoever. His theory was that the child's mind should not be prejudiced in any direction, but when he came to years of discretion, he should be permitted to choose his religious opinions for himself. I said nothing, but after awhile he asked me if I would like to see his garden. I

The Benefits of Capital Punishment

1089 words - 4 pages many arguments in support of capital punishment it is obvious why this method of punishment is so controversial and why it should remain in effect today, regardless of the negative criticism it garners. Capital punishment has been used in the United States since the execution of Daniel Frank of Virginia in 1622. Since then more than 18,000 convicted criminals have been put to death (Crime and Punishment in American History, 1993, p 317). Many

The Unconstitutionality of Capital Punishment

2383 words - 10 pages how mistaken a court decision can be. Capital punishment is not acceptable because it is unconstitutional. Capital punishment was found to violate the Eighth Amendment's "prohibition against cruel and unusual punishment," and the Fourteenth Amendment's "guarantees of equal protection of the laws and due process" (Litardo 1). The death penalty, which was legal with no objections through the 1900's, became a controversial issue in 1972. In 1972

The Abolishment of Capital Punishment

2581 words - 10 pages painless and ethical. Today’s methods are less painful than in the past. All methods result in pain for the criminal; some would say that it is wrong to put them through that kind of pain. Others say criminals who committed acts like rape or murder deserve to suffer like their victims suffered (“Issue”). Those who are in favor of capital punishment believe that all states should use the penalty and sentence criminals to death if they are

The Problem of Capital Punishment

3450 words - 14 pages The Problem of Capital Punishment The issue of capital punishment is a divisive topic that encompasses many moral and empirical aspects of human justice. Ultimately, the key issue regarding the death penalty is as follows: is the death penalty an appropriate form of punishment for the United States of America’s judicial system to impose? This key issue incorporates the empirical and moral claims of the opponents both for and against

Similar Essays

The Controversial Issue Of Capital Punishment

1341 words - 5 pages The Controversial Issue of Capital Punishment Since the execution of James Kendall in 1608, capital punishment “has been an accepted form of justice” in what is now the United States (Smith 2). Capital punishment can be defined as “the penalty of death for the commission of a crime” ( 1). In colonial America, both violent and non-violent crimes could merit the death penalty. Murder was not the only crime punishable by death

The Controversial Topic Of Capital Punishment

1003 words - 4 pages Capital Punishment should be abolishedEvidence suggests that the death penalty does not prevent people from committing crimes. It is a cruel and cold- blooded form of punishment and there have been instances whereby people were sentenced to death then later found to have been innocent.The most common methods of execution are hanging and shooting. Countries like the U.S. use electrocution, gas chambers and lethal injections to dispose of the

Capital Punishment: Main Aspects Of This Controversial Topic

1258 words - 5 pages Throughout history, humans have committed crimes even before they were labeled as crimes. Nowadays, different crimes are punished in different ways depending on where you live in this world. This leads to the main focus of this essay, capital punishment. Moreover, capital punishment, or as it is sometimes labeled a death sentence, is one of the many controversial issues in modern times. For the purpose of this essay, capital punishment could

Capital Punishment: The Social, Moral, And Historical Aspects Of This Controversial Topic

1621 words - 6 pages . Nevertheless, the flaw in such reasoning is that twenty-seven murders can only be planned and cannot be accidental, and a planned punishment is the only solution. Still, there are still those in the society who believe that the only way to stop the worldwide increase in murders is to continue with capital punishment as a means of deterring others who may want to commit these crimes. The issue of whether or not capital punishment is based