This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of A People´S History Of The United States

3352 words - 14 pages

1. Zinn's purpose for writing A People's History of the United States is to write about American history from the viewpoint of the people, and not from the rich or the men that made the decisions, but from the people who lived through those decisions and whose lives were affected. His purpose is not to make the people who were in charge look bad, but to see what they did from all perspectives.

2. Zinn's thesis for pages 1 to 11 is to tell the arrival of Columbus as it really happened from the point of view of the Indians. He doesn't try to hide the things that Columbus and other Europeans did to the Indians and talks about how the Indians were not inferior as the Europeans had thought they were.

3. In traditional history books Columbus is often portrayed as the hero who discovered new land. These books do not mention the massacres of the Indians that took place, and if they do, they only say so briefly, and focus on all the positive about Columbus.

4. Zinn disputes Kissinger's statement because in Kissinger's book, he discusses how from the viewpoint of the leaders of nineteenth century Europe that everything was peaceful but he ignores the working class and those who suffered from the decisions made by these leaders. Kissinger claims that "peace" had been restored in Europe, but for the lower classes, everything was far from peaceful.

5. Columbus oppressed the indigenous peoples initially because he was under the impression that they knew where the gold was and by capturing them they would eventually lead him to where it was. After discovering there was not as much gold as they assumed, Columbus began taking the Indians as slave workers by force back to Spain to make up for the lack of gold.

6. Powhatan said, "Why will you take by force what you may have quietly by love?" as a plea to John Smith. He said this to try to stop the violence between the two peoples after so much fighting and death. This is significant because it shows that Indians were open to peaceful co-existence, but the Europeans just killed them off instead of living with them.

7. John Winthrop, the governor of the Massachusetts Bay Colony created the land he wanted to take as a "vacuum." The Indians, he said, has not subdued the land and therefore had a natural right but did not have a civil right to it, legally. Also, the Puritans appealed to the Bible (Psalms 2:8) to justify taking the land because God had allowed for them to and also had justified their use of force to take the land (Romans 13:2).

8. Zinn attempts to prove the Indians were not inferior by saying how they had developed into egalitarian communities, larger populations, more divisions of labor among men and women and had built irrigation canals, dams, were doing ceramics, weaving baskets, and making cloth out of cotton. A culture known as Moundbuilders had built enormous sculptures out of the earth that were miles long and many other tribes had tool makers, potters, jewelry makers, weavers, copper...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of A People´s History of the United States

An analysis of seemingly imperialistic behavior by the United States in Latin America (late 1800's); was the US guided by economic or political incentive to intervene?

789 words - 3 pages The interference of the United States in the Latin American countries of Cuba andMexico was primarily motivated due to American desire towards economic expansion and resulted in the U.S. supporting revolutionary factions, helping overthrow governments and creating of dictatorships in Mexico while in Cuba the U.S. took a more active role, physically invading the country, instituting pro-American provisions in the Cuban constitution and forcing

A Search for Truth - United States Healthcare Debate: Government vs. the People

1741 words - 7 pages American citizens help keep the United States government in line. Today, a majority of the Presidential Candidates share the common interest of universal healthcare. They have heard victims' pleas, they're cries for help. It is time for the government and the people to carefully consider, propose, and put into effect the best and most successful form of universal healthcare.Works Cited ("Special Interests Deny

How did the 14th and 15th Amendments help African Americans in the late 1800's - AP United States History - Essay

627 words - 3 pages The African American populations have been crucial to the development of the United States for hundreds of years since their arrival in 1619 in Jamestown, Virginia.  Their role in the country was simply to serve their masters, but as the US grew, so did the controversy surrounding slavery, and the country was split as the Missouri Compromise and other similar laws were passed, hoping to keep balance between the slave and free states.  After the

What reasons motivate people to immigrate to the United States

1145 words - 5 pages of people around the globe and refugee and asylum policies that extend relief to some non-citizens fleeing political, ethnic, religious, and gender persecution. This is but a short list of the different reasons to mass immigration to the United States today. Evaluating the causes of U.S. immigration can reveal a great deal about recent immigrants, their homelands, and America's image abroad.Daniel Tichenor from the Rutgers University states in

Agree or Disagree: "The Western European and United States policy of appeasement during the1930's significantly contributed to the development of World War II."

2264 words - 9 pages the supplies. All of these Neutrality Acts further promoted appeasement because the United States desperately wanted to stay out of the next world war. The fifth step toward World War II was the Spanish Civil War. In the 1930s, Spain held democratic elections for the first time in its history. A Socialist government was elected during this time of crisis, but the church and the military felt threatened by this, so Francisco Franco, leader of

Why the Stock Market Crashed, the effect this had on the American People and how it affected the economic structure of the United States

690 words - 3 pages The 1920's were a time of unbelievable prosperity. The stock market was going through the roof and the United States seemed to have the formula for limitless prosperity. However, the same formula that generated all of that profit would also be the cause of Black Tuesday. For five years prior to 1929, the stock market had been characterized by rising prices; there was an enormous "bull market."One of the causes for the stock market rising was the

A People's History Of The United States

852 words - 3 pages Declaration of Independence, adopted by the Congress on July 2 and proclaimed July 4, 1776. By now most colonials had already experienced their feelings of independence and welcomed it. The Declaration included a list about the king holding a tyranny over the states. Some people, though, were omitted from the Declaration: Indians, blacks, slaves, women but in the phrase all men are created equal, they were not deliberately included but included by the

History and Analysis of the United States Pledge of Allegiance

923 words - 4 pages United States of America. The words “to the flag” means to the symbol of the country, while the words “of the United States of America” means each state that has joined to make The United States of America. The words “and to the Republic” means a republic where the people choose the government to make laws forthe people. The words “for which it stands” means the flag of the country while “one nation” means that America stand as a single country. The

The 1940’s as The Most Influencing Decade in the United States

1588 words - 6 pages For many years there has been a discussion about the best decade and the best era in the United States of America. People are convincing each other that twenties were the Golden Age or 1990’s were the most influencing but there is no clear and nationwide agreement in that case. In fact, according to different authors and publishers there was no year that actually resolved all problems in the United States. From some people’s point of view

Analysis of A People’s History of the United States by Howard Zinn

836 words - 4 pages This book has proven to be an enlightening read. It both teaches and inspires. Howard Zinn has offered us a perspective of the real story of American history heretofore unavailable to us – history from the perspective of real people – immigrant laborers, American women, the working poor, factory workers, African and Native Americans. A People's History of the United States, originally published in 1980, as a work of non-fiction by the political

The Columbus Day, as celebrated by people in the United States annually, is a total joke, as you will consent to after reading the article below

774 words - 3 pages the people he encountered in the Caribbean "Indians". It was not his love for the sea that induced Columbus to set out for the land of unknown, but three other motives. In return for bringing back gold and spices, Columbus would receive a reward of 10 percent of the profits, governorship over all new-found lands, and the fame of a title, "Admiral of the Ocean Sea". Power, wealth, and fame motivated Christopher Columbus. This was perfectly natural

Similar Essays

The History Of He United States From The Viewpoint Of The People: 1492 Present

3158 words - 13 pages often do. As he goes through history, Zinn describes events he feels are monumental to the people of the United States. American history cannot start without first discovering America. Columbus began the history of European invasion of the indian settlements in the America’s 500 years ago. History books portrayed it as a heroic adventure, with no bloodshed, and celebrated it with a day in his honor (7). The Arawak indians show us the first

The United States President´S Rights To Veto A Bill

1745 words - 7 pages The President of the United States holds ultimate authority over any piece of legislation. This right is given by the U.S. Constitution through the power of the Presidential veto. The Constitution states that after a bill is passed through both the House of Representatives and the Senate, it is to be given to the President for what is essentially the final OK. If the President approves of the bill and its contents, he is to sign the bill within

The Territorial Sxpansion Of The United States In The 1840’s

1491 words - 6 pages The Territorial Sxpansion of the United States in the 1840’s Throughout 1815 to 1860, the USA changed faster than in the previous 200 years. It was seen as the land of opportunities and masses of Europeans migrated to the USA. Population figures doubled every 25 years. The number of states rised from 18 in 1815, to 30 by 1860. The agrarian society was soon replaced by a growing capitalist and commercial economy and

The Influence Of The Student Protest Movement On United States' 1960's

1315 words - 5 pages hearts of the people.”(Unger 208) Works Cited Loeb, Paul Rogat. Generation at the crossroads apathy and action on the American campus. New Brunswick, N.J: Rutgers UP, 1994. Print. Unger, Irwin. Movement, a history of the American New Left, 1959-1972. New York: Harper & Row, 1974. Print