Analysis Of An Author's Argument For Active Euthanasia

1011 words - 4 pages

An Author's Argument for Active Euthanasia"Active and Passive Euthanasia," by James Rachels, takes on the argument of using euthanasia to kill the suffering patient, or, instead, letting the patient willingly die on his own. The type of argument presented is a position because James Rachels takes on the position as an advocate of active euthanasia. His claim is explicitly stated because he argues that "killing is not in itself any worse than letting euthanasia is not any worse than passive euthanasia" (Rachels 526, paragraph 16). The author's tone is intelligent, but also bitter. In the 16th paragraph of the reading, he blatantly states that "it is not exactly correct to say that in passive euthanasia the doctor does nothing, for he does do one thing...he lets the patient die" (Rachels 526). By immediately accusing the doctor of letting the patient die in passive euthanasia, he has set a bitter tone. The author's persona is also presented as an individual who is arguing with doctors that active euthanasia is more humane than passive euthanasia. The intended audience for this selection is educated individuals with no bias toward religion, since the Catholic Church argues against active euthanasia.The author uses case examples as evidence to support his claim because he presents the reader with different types of cases. In the first case, he uses the example of a patient who is dying of terminal cancer to begin his argument. The patient is suffering terribly, and can no longer be helped through treatment. He is expected to die very soon, even if the patient chooses to continue his treatment, but he does not want to go on living for those days because the pain is unbearable, so he then asks the doctor to put an end to it. James Rachels supposes, however, that the doctor follows the American Medical Association's doctrine and withholds treatment because the patient is going to die anyway. He argues that the doctor allows the patient to die, even though the patient may suffer a lot more "than he would if more direct action were taken and a lethal injection given" (Rachels 522, paragraph 3). The author also argues that passive euthanasia can be "relatively slow and painful, whereas being given a lethal injection is relatively quick and painless" (522, paragraph 4).The author believes that the conventional doctrine leads to decisions concerning life and death made on irrelevant grounds. He uses the case of the infants with Down's syndrome as another example. Rachels argues that, "It is the Down's syndrome, and not the intestines, that is the issue. The matter should be decided...on that basis, and not be allowed to depend on the essentially irrelevant question of whether the intestinal tract is blocked" (523, paragraph 7). Rachels says that it does not matter if the doctor were to kill the patient or let the patient die because the intended result is the same for both situations.The author also uses two cases where...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of an author's argument for active euthanasia

An Author's Betrayal of Character Essay

1703 words - 7 pages /conent/1960s-70s-american-feminist-movement-breaking-down-barriers-for-women.html>. Benignetti, Kelly. ""Critical Analysis of "Where Are You Going, Where Have You Been?"" N.p., n.d. Web. 6 Mar. 2014. . Blanton, Amy. “Bob Dylan: An Impact on American Society in the 1960s.” N.p., 10 Apr. 2001. Web. 3 Mar. 2014. . “How the Sexual Revolution

Argument for Euthanasia: Personal Narrative Essay

1205 words - 5 pages crime. Instead, it should be looked upon as a final act of respect for the human being who lived his life well and now knows that it is time to set his life to an end. Works Cited Wolf, Susan. (2008). Confronting physician-assisted suicide and euthanasia: My father's death. Hastings Center Report. 38(5), 23-26. Retrieved from EBSCO Host Database located at the Ashford Online Library Xayne, Angelus Mykeal. (2011). Assisted Suicide. Retrieved from

Comment of “Active and Passive Euthanasia”

613 words - 3 pages euthanasia. Through Rachels’ argument he proves the fact that the AMA should not give any distinction of passive versus active euthanasia any added authority. The author’s argument ultimately proves that as long as the doctor’s decision was the correct one, the method he uses should not be important. A worry I have for Rachels’ argument is weather legalized active euthanasia would go down a slippery slope. Hospitals are teeming places

Analysing the Morality of Voluntary Active Euthanasia

1383 words - 6 pages In this essay I will be analysing the morality of voluntary active euthanasia (VAE). I will focus on the argument that if such an act is considered morally acceptable, it can only lead down a slippery slope in which society becomes grossly unrecognizable in terms of the value of life. This essay will examine the strengths and weaknesses of this argument and the moral principles which underpin it to determine whether or not it remains a

Argument in Favor of Euthanasia

2080 words - 8 pages euthanasia. Then there is physician-assisted suicide, the patient is ending his or her life with a lethal dose of medication requested of and provided by a physician for that purpose (Brock). This method is also known as the active, direct, or positive euthanasia. This method you are also withholding food, water, and other medical treatment. Euthanasia tends to be deemed an act or omission which causes death in order to eliminate a person’s suffering

Argument in Favor of Euthanasia

1909 words - 8 pages euthanasia continue (Uhlmann, 1998).. The argument for legalization of euthanasia is such that an individual has the freedom, liberty, and choice in all situations as long as the rights of another individual are not infringed. In addition, financial motives are advanced in favor of euthanasia. A large sum of money is spent to keep the terminally ill patients alive, and if they eventually die, it will be a waste of resources. The argument against the

1984 Analysis of Author's Use of Satire

867 words - 3 pages reflect on the novel love doesn't exist at all instead it's more of an acceptance like how Winston decides to finally accept Big Brother. Winston didn't accept B.B. because he knew they were right but as a natural instinct that people have when they want to survive. Reflecting on the story overall, he was always thinking "down with Big Brother" and finding himself writing that phrase down. His hatred for Big Brother is first mention or noticed

Benefits of an Active Lifestyle

2760 words - 11 pages and a low cholesterol can be accomplished by exercising and staying active at least thirty minutes per day (Stroke par.1). Exercise should not be limited to any age. In fact “By 2050, the over 65 year's age group will account for approximately one quarter of the population”(Grant 1). This quote shows that the topic of exercising for older adults will be bigger than ever. There’re are so many other benefits that can be achieved from an active

An Argument for Vegetarianism

3766 words - 15 pages An Argument for Vegetarianism ABSTRACT: In this paper I propose to answer the age-old reductio against vegetarianism, which is usually presented in the form of a sarcastic question ( e.g., "How do you justify killing and eating plants?"). Addressing the question takes on special significance in the light of arguments which seem to show that even nonsentient life is intrinsically valuable. Thus, I suggest that we rephrase the question in the

An Argument for Conservatism

1579 words - 7 pages with, I will nevertheless stake an affirmative argument for neoconservatism and write as if I am an actual supporter. This is beneficial as it will allow me to empathize with others and put myself in the position of those with whom I disagree. What follows is an argument for a few of the merits of neoconservatism concerning its stance on economic and foreign policy issues. From an economic standpoint, neoconservatives are supporters, but not

The Fallacies of O'Shea's Argument against Euthanasia

2703 words - 11 pages Assisted Suicide The concept of assisted suicide for the terminally ill, as it is now, is subjected to tremendous controversy. Many people believe that it is morally wrong to commit suicide. As such, in a response to an article in The Seattle Times on euthanasia, Reverend Susan J. O’Shea argues that we should not have euthanasia because it is murder. Reverend O’Shea’s argument starts off with her own personal reasons on why she does not support

Similar Essays

An Argument For Euthanasia Essay

2005 words - 8 pages An Argument for Euthanasia Euthanasia is defined as, "The act or practice of putting to death painlessly a person suffering from an incurable disease." Euthanasia can be traced back as far back as the ancient Greek and Roman civilizations. It was sometimes allowed in these civilizations to help others die. Voluntary euthanasia was approved in these ancient societies. Today, the practice of euthanasia causes great controversy. Both pro-life

Argument For Legalizing Euthanasia Essay

2968 words - 12 pages to end the suffering of others, help patients who have the ability to live a longer life, and decrease the cost of health care. Euthanasia is an act of killing an incurable patient who is suffering or in pain. Euthanasia comes from a Greek expression for “good death” and, in other words, allows the patients to die and easy death without suffering. Euthanasia can be described as voluntary, involuntary or active, and passive. Voluntary euthanasia

Argument For Euthanasia Essay

2311 words - 9 pages Argument for Euthanasia You were in a tragic car accident on your way to work. You have been in coma for years. Your family is not only devastated because of your state, they are also having a hard time trying to pay off all of your expenses. You were not insured, and your family is forced to keep paying the bills needed to keep you “alive”. Your family is going completely bankrupt and you still show no sign of getting better. Your family

Euthanasia, An Analysis Of An Ethical Dilemma

1083 words - 4 pages Voluntary euthanasia is defined as the act of killing someone painlessly, especially to relieve suffering from an incurable illness, with their consent (Collins English Dictionary, 2013). The morality and legal aspect of voluntary euthanasia has been a debate for many years. Voluntary euthanasia is a significant ethical dilemma that impacts nursing practice and other professionals in the healthcare field. With the utilization of ethical