Analysis Of 'democracy As A Universal Value' By Amartya Sen

1527 words - 6 pages

In his article, Democracy as a Universal Value, Amartya Sen asserts that democracy is a universal value. In order to develop his argument Sen needs to state his definition of democracy and define what he means by universal value. In the course of Sen's argument he gives his view of the relationship between democracy and the economy. He then defends his view of democracy as a universal value against a main argument that deals with cultural differences between regions.
Amartya Sen uses a maximum definition of democracy. Sen believes that a democracy has more qualities than just rule by the majority. "Democracy is a demanding system, and not just a mechanical condition (like majority rule) taken in isolation" (Sen 5). Sen believes that democracies must have fair elections along with the guaranteed protection of freedoms and liberties. He states, "Democracy has complex demands, which certainly include voting and respect for election results, but it also requires the protection of liberties and freedoms, respect for legal entitlements, and the guaranteeing of free discussion and uncensored distribution of news and fair comment" (5). Sen asserts that elections can be defective and unfair if they are held in the absence of freedoms that allow opposing sides to present their views and allow the electorate to hear them and discuss their opinions. When democracy is practiced properly, Sen believes there are three different ways that it can enrich the lives of its citizens. "First, political freedom is a part of human freedom in general, and exercising civil and political rights is a crucial part of good lives of individuals as social beings" (5). Second, democracy increases the level of government acknowledgement that people get "in expressing and supporting their claims to political attention" (5). Democracy gives people the power to keep their government responsible and accountable. Third, the practice of democracy requires public discussion and exchange of information, views, and analyses; this exchange of information helps a society form its values and priorities (5).
Sen considers something a universal value if "people anywhere may have reason to see it as valuable" (6). Some people have argued that democracy is not a universal value because not everyone agrees that democracy is valuable and important. However, according to Sen, complete, unanimous approval by all people is not needed for something to be considered a universal value. Using this definition Sen successfully defends his claim that democracy is a universal value, despite the fact that some people may not agree on the value of democracy.
In his argument on the universal value of democracy Amartya Sen discusses the relationship between democracy and economic development. He notes that it is often claimed that nondemocratic systems are better at bringing about economic development than democratic ones. Sen disagrees with this claim. He asserts that this hypothesis...

Find Another Essay On Analysis Of 'Democracy As A Universal Value' By Amartya Sen

"What is Democracy" This is an essay written about democracy. It a reaction of an average person as to what democracy means to them. This is not a step by step definition of the political system

1354 words - 5 pages ironies of these facts is that most citizens of democratic countries do not know what the word democracy means and what it represents. "A citizen of America will cross the ocean to fight for democracy, but wont cross the street to vote in a national election." Bill VaughanThe Oxford dictionary defines democracy as government by the people, direct or representative. In Canada we have a representative democracy that allows us to pick our political

Contemporary Value of Religion as Viewed by Kearlee Gregory

1641 words - 7 pages than is necessary. Also, as our knowledge of how vastly miniscule our planet is increases; humans begin to feel the pointlessness of our evanescent lives. As stated in an article posted by Indiana University Northwest: “In general, Daoists/Taoists could be described as hermits or recluses who doubted the human wisdom to present a social order that surpassed the order given by nature. Dominant in their philosophy is the belief that everything

Access to Healthcare as a Universal Right

665 words - 3 pages implementing them in our own country would logically provide at least as promising of results as are seen in these other places which are among the healthiest nations in the world. Going along with the definition of right, “morally or socially correct (Merriam-Webster)”, we are presented with the one of the main focuses of why there has been an outcry for the demand of universal healthcare: morality. Government healthcare is demanded by a large

An Analysis of Democracy

1174 words - 5 pages freedom to name a few. Contrast President Bush's depiction of democracy with these words from a member of the American Anti-Socialist League (AASL): "The inherent morality of democracy claimed by its champions is a figment of the human imagination. It derives not from a logical analysis of democracy, but from a vague, instinctual feeling that justice and the protection of rights are linked to majority rule. Nothing could be further from the

The Value of Human Capital as a Sustainable Advantage

3052 words - 12 pages understands the universal core components of PM which have been identified as: i. establishing congruence between the jobs as represented by the job descriptions and the organization's goals; ii. measuring performance at both the level of the team and the individual focusing on both the behaviours and the results; iii. providing the necessary training on PM; iv. using a strengths based approach to deliver feedback on performance; v. and linking

It is a review and analysis of a play "As You Like It" by William Shakespeare

1512 words - 6 pages Untitled Theatrical Analysis As You Like It � Play Review As You Like It was one of the most unusual plays I had ever seen. Even though it was my first time seeing a Shakespearean play performed on stage, I was able to make some sense out of it. Since the play was a comedy, I expected surprising events to happen as in the The Merchant of Venice. Even though, there was no loss in the possessions or supernatural events, the main

Analysis of Liberalism and Democracy

1550 words - 6 pages Analysis of Liberalism and Democracy Liberalism has an ambivalent relationship with democracy, as liberals are against collective power, but support political equality. In the nineteenth century liberals were often opposed to democracy as they saw it as a threat to individual rights - the people are not a single entity but rather a collection of individuals with different opinions and interests, and so it is impossible

Revising Democracy : Civic Duty, as A Citizen

1799 words - 8 pages inevitable for the state of democracy to evolve once more. The people of these democratic states will always have a new demand and a new vision in mind. By incorporating civic duty as a citizen, for all citizens, democracy will be better for all, in regards to representing the peoples voice and further strengthen the respective nation, possibly world. Civic duty will include the people into the nature and operations of their government in ways intended

Universal Acceptance of Hamlet by William Shakespeare

1976 words - 8 pages Universal Acceptance of Hamlet by William Shakespeare The tragedy and situation in the play ‘Hamlet’ has been commented on as ‘universal.’ Audiences of many different cultures can enjoy ‘Hamlet’ even though it is set in an alien culture to them. The reasons for this are that many people can relate to the play, they feel that they are living though a profound experience, even if nothing in the plot of Hamlet has ever happened to them. The

Value of a Dystopia

2527 words - 10 pages value in the attempt. In the novel “Lord of the Flies”, one can get an understanding of just how difficult it is for the foundation of a utopia. Ralph was the leader of his utopia in which the system of ruling was considered to be very democratic. Ralph had been voted in by the majority of the group which gave society a voice. The idea of democracy was farther demonstrated through the representation of the conch which said that whoever had it

The Kite Runner: An essay analyzing Hosseinis illustration of Bad Parenting as a universal problem of society

1679 words - 7 pages Faruq. Sometimes Rahim Khan came over and Baba let me sit in his study and sip tea with them" (87). Baba's lack of concern for his son's needs creates a hole which Amir was finds himself able to fill with his kite. At the expense of his half-brother Hassan, Amir holds on to this kite. In a time of need for Hassan, Amir chooses to retrieve his kite, rather than to help his brother because of the emotional value of the toy. Baba's poor parenting

Similar Essays

Amartya Sen – The Idea Of Justice

721 words - 3 pages , as long as injustice is reduced, this is more ideal than wanting to create a ‘just’ society. Although it is obvious that Sen preferred the nyaya-approach, undoubtedly both niti and nyaya matter, which is why Sen recommends judging justice by comparing and reflecting on different policies instead of just focusing on the ‘ideal’. Works Cited Sen, Amartya. "An Approach to Justice." Introduction. The Idea of Justice. Cambridge, MA: Belknap of Harvard UP, 2009. 1-27. Print. "Wages." U.S. Department of Labor. N.p., n.d. Web. 24 Feb. 2014. .

The Economic Contributions Of Nobel Prize Winner, Amartya K. Sen

2788 words - 11 pages that inspired Sen; and provides a brief analysis of the issues discussed.IntroductionEconomist Amartya K. Sen of India received the 1998 Nobel Prize in economics for his contributions to welfare economics. Born in 1933, Sen studied in Calcutta and Cambridge (where he received his PhD) and has held teaching positions at Oxford, London, Delhi, Calcutta, Harvard, Berkeley, Stanford, MIT, and Cambridge. He holds honorary doctorates from more than 25

English As A Universal Language Essay

1327 words - 6 pages English language as a universal language and it is very important. Every people are urge to learn English language. Especially for university students who are going to enter society after graduation, English is perceived to be crucial for communication at work with regards to employment. But in Malaysia, the proficiency of English language among youth is declining. Start in the 70s, many concerned stakeholders from employers, linguists and

Democracy As A Myth Essay

1552 words - 6 pages senior management is by no means new. Organizations, if one can call them that, in the early years of the industrial revolution consistently reflected an absolute minimum number of layers. Indeed, a face to face relationship often existed between ownership or management and the employee or worker. As methods of production grew increasingly complex and the principles of scientific management were applied, more and more layers of organizational