This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of Howard Zinn's Argument In His Article Dying For The Government

1383 words - 6 pages

Analysis of Howard Zinn's Argument in his Article "Dying for the Government"

In June of 2003, Howard Zinn’s “Dying for the Government” was published in “The Progressive” newspaper. He discusses the government’s claim to military victory in Iraq, and he believes that many innocent people have died for an unjust cause in that war. His claim is that soldiers died for their government, not their country. An important part of his argument is his discussion of democracy, which he says is what our country is supposed to be based on. He also brings up some history of U.S. wars and quotes Mark Twain’s statement about the invasion of the Phillipines by the United States. Even though some of his assertions lack evidence, Zinn uses authority and structure very well to make his argument effective.

Some of Zinn’s assertions are a bit sketchy in his essay because there is no evidence that proves them true. One that really stands out is when he writes, “[they] died for Bush and Cheney and Rumsfeld. And yes, they died for the greed of the oil cartels, for the expansion of the American empire, for the political ambitions of the President. They died to cover up the theft of the nations’ wealth to pay for the machines of death” (159). His argument may seem true to many, but he does not provide us with any evidence that these statements are accurate. He does not say where he got this information, so it may be hard for some to believe this, unless they share the same opinions as him. Another statement he makes is that “[we] have not been given in the American media (we would need to read the foreign press) a full picture of the human suffering caused by our bombing” (159). This is a very strong assertion, but he does not tell us if he actually has read the foreign press. With that statement, I have to assume that he has read the foreign press to believe that he is telling the truth.

To make up for his lack of evidence, Zinn uses strong authority in his essay. He first uses the Declaration of Independence, which he says is “the fundamental document of democracy” (159). He quotes this document when he says “governments are artificial creations, established by the people, ‘deriving their just powers from the consent of the governed,’ and charged by the people to ensure the equal right of all to ‘life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness’” (159). These words are what our country is supposed to be based on, and he strongly feels that the government is violating our trust “when [it] recklessly expends the lives of its young for crass motives of profit and power, always claiming that its motives are pure and moral (‘Operation Just Cause’ was the invasion of Panama and ‘Operation Iraqi Freedom’ in the present instance)” (159). What he is saying is that these so-called “moral” wars are just about power. He feels that if the war in Iraq really was to free them and create a democracy there, then those innocent Iraqi children would not be dead and...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Howard Zinn's Argument in his Article Dying for the Government

Argument analysis of Yvonne Bynoe's article entitled "The White Boy Shuffle"

1371 words - 5 pages In Yvonne Bynoe's article entitled "The White Boy Shuffle", the author is trying to convince his audience that suburban, white youth are undermining what the true essence of hip hop culture is by adopting the characteristics of the culture and using them as a vessel for their own teen angst, social rebellion, and self-expression. The author also implies that this "borrowing" of black culture by young white youths perpetuates certain social

Evaluate Aristotle's argument(s) for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life

1899 words - 8 pages Evaluate Aristotle's argument(s) for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life.In evaluating Aristotle's arguments for his claim that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life, I believe it is important to recognise the true problem at hand, which can be seen to be, does Aristotle succeed arguing that happiness (eudaimonia) is the goal of human life? I believe that overall Aristotle does not succeed in arguing this

Analysis of "Scared to Death of Dying", Article by Herbert Hendin

584 words - 2 pages H.I.V.-positive, but had no symptoms and may not develop them for years, was helped to die. Probably the doctors didn't explain that even if he had a terminal disease he could enjoy the rest of his life with his family and friend that were about to lose him.Doctors aren't trained to do this in medical school and the public doesn't know better. This is because doctors aren' t trained properly in the relief of pain and discomfort in terminally ill

This is an article analysis of Jack in the Box

721 words - 3 pages The article I have chosen to summarize highlights the accounting practices of a San Diego--based company, Jack in the Box, Inc. (NYSE: JBX). In addition to summarizing the article, I will discuss how the concepts of the article relate to my organization The Platinum Company Inc., including, making recommendations for improvement for my organization based on the article. Lastly, explain the importance of ethics in accounting and financial

Democratic America in the Eyes of Howard Zinn

915 words - 4 pages thinks it is the way government works and the way people live because of the government by which they live under at the same time. Zinn has some interesting things to say and he makes some good points but for the most part I find his essay completely ineffective in what he wants the reader to believe with him. The second essay by Sidney Hook is a critical of Howard Zinn’s essay. Hook is a much better writer than Zinn. Hook is able to point

The Function of Analysis in the Government Intelligence Department

1167 words - 5 pages a clear direction for the analyst’s research making it nearly impossible for them to meet their demands (Wheaton 2009). They expect too much from intelligence collated leaving an opening for future intelligence failures to occur (Phythian 2009). At the end of the day analysts need to essentially supply decision makers with a competitive advantage over other government agencies (Treverton et al. 2006). During the analysis process intelligence

Analysis of Argument: Gun Control in America

695 words - 3 pages nationwide gun control. An article published in the Chicago Tribune by Illinois State Senator Jacqueline Collins, entitled “Gun Control is Long Overdue” voiced the opinion that in order for America to remain the land of the free, we must take action in the form of stricter gun laws. On the contrary, Kathleen Parker, a member of the Washington Post Writers Group whose articles have appeared in the Weekly Standard, Time, Town & Country, Cosmopolitan

Reasons for the Downfall of the Manchu Government in 1911

672 words - 3 pages – 1842) and the second opium war (1856 – 1860). These wars and the Sino-Jap war (1844-1895) led to humiliating defeats for China. China was forced to sign unequal treaties which demanded the opening and control of Chinese ports to foreign trades and residence. The foreigners could live in China without interference from the Chinese government as no Laws were imposed on them. This caused a loss of sovereignty for China. The loss of trade, taxes and

The Argument for Reincarnation in Hinduism

1697 words - 7 pages before being conceived in this world. In relation to Hinduism, due to the bad karma acquired in his past life, the man was condemned to pay for his past sins by being blinded (Dunlap). The concept of reincarnation in modern time became more of a possibility with television shows such as Medium and Ghost Whisperer .These shows heighten the public awareness of reincarnation and life after death (Dunlap). There are many methods, such as past life

The Importance of Palliative Care for the Dying Patient

1738 words - 7 pages more effective treatment of depression, better management of symptoms, or less need for hospitalization” (http://www.Web This study is a great tool to show how important the treatment for relief or suffering of pain in the dying patient is. There are some people who try to argue that opiates, such as Morphine, should not be given to a dying patient because it can speed up the dying process by decreasing respiratory and cardiovascular

The Argument for the Existence of God

1710 words - 7 pages The Argument for the Existence of God It is an undisputed fact that some people claim to have experienced God. It is these religious experiences that have been used by philosophers to argue for the existence of God. The main way of expressing the argument from religious experience is as follows: P1 Someone experiences an entity C1 The entity exists P2 Someone has experienced God C2 God exists Those

Similar Essays

Howard Zinn's Essay On The Pequot War

747 words - 3 pages When reading Howard Zinn’s essay on the Pequot war, one might not immediately notice the extreme bias in the writing unless he or she has prior knowledge of the Pequot war. It simply seems as though he is listing the facts, and that the Puritans were to blame for the war. In reality, however, history was different. The Pequots also fought in thewar. The extent of Zinn’s portrayal of the Pequots’ vulnerability is severe, and he even ignores

Critical Overview Of Howard Zinn's A People's History Of The United States

745 words - 3 pages , Howard Zinn's A People's History of the United States ends up being even more skewed and partisan than traditional history texts.Zinn's argument for siding with the oppressed rather than the oppressors is that "in such a world of conflict, a world of victims and executioners, it is the job of thinking people, as Albert Camus suggested, not to be on the side of the executioners."(Page 10) Zinn uses the comparison o executioner vs. executed to

Howard Zinn's A Review Of A People’s History Of The United States

1201 words - 5 pages , one would emerge from Zinn's account believing that the U.S. government had driven the arms race throughout the 1970s and 1980s. In his view the Soviets, it seems, had no role in all of this. Zinn fails to mention that after the end of the Cold War, what emerged from Soviet and then Russian sources strongly corroborated most of the United States views on the Cold War. The Soviet missiles were real; they’re potential to conquer

The Heroism Of Dying For One's Country In Poetry

1589 words - 6 pages The Heroism of Dying for One's Country in Poetry The Volunteer is a Pro-War poem written by Herbert Asquith. Asquith uses roman imagery to invoke a feeling of greatness and honour. Asquith begins his poem by describing the miserable, mundane life of a clerk, working in a 'city grey'. He opens with the words 'Here lies' that are normally used to begin writing on a gravestone. This 'epitaph' - style opening gives the idea that the clerk