Analysis Of Interrogation Methods As A Means To Gathering Information

1756 words - 8 pages

Interrogation is a method commonly used by the Army to acquire information from a suspected individual or groups. The aim of this process is to make the individual to confess or give up information that can lead to recovery of personnel or protect against future dangers. Interrogations can be used in numerous ways to gather information. The U.S. Army has been involved in various Intelligence collection around the world especially since the September 11, 2001 attack, and it has been forced interrogate people for leading information to unravel various security threats. Some of the interrogation methods include deception, torture, suggestibility, and the use of mind-altering drugs. Before any Interrogation technique is used, it should be analyzed through ethical lenses. Interrogation could be viewed as torture but some people would agree that in order to save lives, we must proceed with these types of techniques to gather information. This paper gives an analysis of interrogation methods used and the extent to which these methods can be seen as oppressive.
Since the attacks on September 11 2001, the global out cry about the US Army activities prompted the president Obama to stress the need for the Soldiers undertaking interrogation activities to observe the procedures that were laid down. These procedures have been clearly outlined in the Army Field Manual 2-22.3, Human Intelligence Collector Operations, on interrogation that many of the involved Soldiers have openly defied. The nature of the interrogation activities brings up a debate about the procedure for interrogation because other US government agencies are involved in such activities. The factor that drives the debate about amending the interrogation rules is based on the coercive interrogations that have been labeled against the Army and the intelligence agencies in the recent past (Ishmael, 2010).
When following the Rules Lenses, U.S. military intelligence doctrine states that interrogation is: “The systematic effort to procure information to answer specific collection requirements by direct and indirect questioning techniques of a person who is in the custody of the forces conducting the questioning.” This implies that the Army for its good can use any method that is worthy yielding information. This open definition does not limit the extent to which the Soldiers can practice the activity. However, the field manual requires that the interrogation be carried out in a lawful manner, but limited to the intelligence requirements. It is important to note that the Army establishes the intelligence requirements. According to the Rules Outcome, President Obama has implemented Executive Order, which limits the manner in which the prisoner must be treated humanely. This can cause a problem for the Soldier that is charged with carrying out the mission and the fact that the rules places restraints on mission accomplishment. This can ultimately cause a conflict.
Methods of...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Interrogation Methods as a Means to Gathering Information

The internet as a means of learning

634 words - 3 pages new millennium is its use in research. Don't know the meaning of a word in you textbook or a new phrase you heard, go onto the internet and find out what it means. It has become as simple as learning A B C. The internet has grown so popular in the last decade that teachers have started using it in school to support the traditional style of teaching from books. Research done on the internet allows us access to the newest information and up-to-date

Communication as a Means of Stability

1355 words - 5 pages Communication as a Means of Stability As demonstrated throughout various Native American texts, communication tends to be the Native’s greatest challenge in that they are unable to develop successful relationships with the outside world. Ultimately, broken treaties have become the unfortunate model for miscommunication between the European Americans and the Natives. Granted the white culture and the Natives share very few of the same

Sex as a Means of Agency

1243 words - 5 pages Sex as a Means of Agency “A woman’s harder to conquer than any beast, than fire, and no panther is quite so ferocious.” (Aristophanes 1058) Life for an Athenian woman was marked by her daily occupation to the household and its occupants. This was the sphere of life where she was able to exert the most power and maintain a certain degree of agency. Her domestic duties included attendance to her husband, and his sexual needs. In the

Creation of a Baby as a Means to and End is Objectionable

1518 words - 7 pages We routinely use people as a means to our own end such as in the case of a blood donor. If that is the case, there would be nothing objectionable about using the creation of a baby as a means to an end, if that end is saving another human being. Is this true? There are significant issues with this claim. This essay will explore the analogy between the blood donor and the savior sibling donor. It will show how it fails and, even if it were to

Rule of law in Cyberspace as a means and way to cyber security

1066 words - 5 pages basic instrument to ensure public order, order on the state level and also on international level. The “rule of law" is the authority and influence of law in society, esp. when viewed as a constraint on individual and institutional behaviour; (hence) the principle whereby all members of a society (including those in government) are considered equally subject to publicly disclosed legal codes and processes. 2 Therefore the rule of law is the basic

Response to the prompt "What is a man as described by Ernest Gaines in his book 'A Gathering of Old Men'". Includes quotes with page numbers

553 words - 2 pages A Gathering of Men and BoysWhat is a man? Webster's first definition is: "an individual human being; esp. an adult male human," Not helpful. Perhaps the third part of that definition: "One possessing in a high degree the qualities considered distinctive of manhood." Ernest J. Gaines' comes up with the definition of a man in his novel, A Gathering of Old Men. In the book a porch in rural Louisiana becomes filled with old black men who all claim

Should United States Use Torture as a Interrogation Method?

2146 words - 9 pages traumatic event is by the skilled technique of information extraction known as torture, would it not be the government’s obligation to the people to ensure this method of prevention was exercised? When considering the threat from extremists, the United States government must allow for the use of unorthodox interrogation methods, such as torture, when lives are on the line and time is of the essence. A widely popular argument against torture

Analysis of Methods used by Mary Shelley in Chapter Five of ‘Frankenstein’ and Its Significance to the Novel as a Whole

2155 words - 9 pages using electricity. This idea scared people as they were afraid of what could be achieved by ‘playing God’. Chapter 5 is a very significant point in the novel. This is when the creature is created and comes to life. Throughout this chapter Victor’s feelings are explored in great depth and the reader becomes aware of Victors thoughts towards the creature he spent so long trying to create. Mary Shelley uses a range of methods to convey a sense

Ethical Practices and Values as a Means to Business Sustainability

1706 words - 7 pages how good ethical practices and good values in business can yield sustainability within the business and the society as a whole and in order to do this the concept of ethical business practice and values have to be understood. Decades ago, the perception of ethics and values in business practice has always been associated with business failure as entrepreneurs had the “eat or be eaten” mind set – which in essence means that one must do whatever

Obedience As the Means to a Peaceful Life

1648 words - 7 pages from any terrible thing that happen to her father because she was responsible for performing her role as spy for the Party. Indeed, Parsons seems to find comfort in the fact that he has been able to raise obedient and loyal Party members, fulfilling his role as a good Party member... Winston himself provides the strongest example of obedience by role identification as a means to peace. On the exterior, Winston lives as a conscientious Party

Lincoln: Emancipation as a Means to End War

2376 words - 10 pages , encourage cooperation with the south, and limit the power of the federal government; it was his original solution to solve the issue dividing the country, which would be a fair agreement for both parties. The move also demonstrated a shift in Lincoln's policy, as he took a stance which would support emancipation; however, this stance was chosen as a means to save the union. After his gradual emancipation experienced defeat, Lincoln took a position

Similar Essays

Justification Of Torture As A Means To Save Lives

1690 words - 7 pages is not the way this world works.We cannot depend on saying Hello. To the terrorists and asking them their motives. The only way to get this vital information is to break them. And, unfortunately the only way to break them is to torture them. Full stop. Psychological methods are more humane, Yes but they are too long drawn and time consuming. Most cases have some time limit, evidence for a rape case cannot be found after 2 weeks nor can the body be exhumed which has been burnt. Time is a big consideration.Thus torture can be used as a scalpel of a physician or a machete of a psychopath. The choice is ours.

Analysis Of 6 Articles: To What Extent Do The Public Actually Agree With Imprisonment As A Means Of Punishment?

3679 words - 15 pages effective means of punishment but does not offer an alternative suggestion of what could be put in place to replace sending criminals to prison. Allen used both a qualitative and quantitative approach in order to support his aim. Jupp (2006) suggested that studies may consist of both quantitative and qualitative approaches as this offers a wider explanation. The qualitative approach was that he analysed attitudes and opinions that the public had on

A Gathering Of Voices Essay

1250 words - 5 pages War. Such a short word with so much controversy. There are endless reasons the government will find to use battle. Fighting is a means to gain freedom or revenge. However, history tends to think otherwise. In the Holocaust, the heartless Nazi's tried to banish the Jewish people. The survivors of the Holocaust are still struggling with the disturbing memories and lost loved ones. Although their reminiscences haunt them, the heroes of the

An Analysis Of Percy Bysshe Shelley’s Use Of Personification As A Means Of Connecting Nature And Spirit In Ozymandias And Ode To The West Wind

909 words - 4 pages Nature has always been something that is considered close to the soul. For as long as people have walked the Earth, nature has been a part of nearly every culture. “Man's knowledge of himself complemented his understanding of the universe and formed the basis for a strong and healthy relationship to the creation in which he lived.” (Shankar) Even if people don’t see how, it is almost always incorporated into everything we humans do. Nature, as