Analysis Of Moral Luck Views Of Aristotle And Epictetus

2268 words - 9 pages

Analysis of Moral Luck Views of Aristotle and Epictetus

Aristotle, the founder of western science, and Epictetus, one of the
greatest stoicists, both has their theories for the issue of "Moral
Luck". To have a basic idea about the topic, I believe we should
describe it from a non-philosophical point of view. After doing that
we can compare both Aristotle's and Epictetus' points of views and
distinguish between them with examples from "Into Thin Air"(ITA),
written by Jon Krakauer.

Moral Luck, if described from general perspective, consists of the
actions that happen by luck and result in moral ends. What I mean by
moral ends is the situations that have something to do with moral or
ethical values. Overall, moral luck deals with all the issues
concerned with assertion of praise and blame, deliberation of
responsibility, and things that are not in our control such as place
of birth, our parents, our nationality and so on. Although they both
have this structure in common, both Aristotle and Epictetus have
different arguments about moral luck.

Both Aristotle and Epictetus have a single point in common. They both
have the idea of luck. Aristotle describes this as things that are not
in our control and Epictetus describes this as things that are not up
to us.

The distinction between them is simple. Something that is not in our
control can be up to us. However, something that is up to us must be
in our control. "One climber's actions can affect the welfare of the
entire team. The consequences of a poorly tied knot, a stumble, a
dislodged rock, or some other careless deed are as likely to be felt
by the perpetrator's colleagues as the perpetrator…But trust in one's
partner is a luxury denied those who sign on as clients on a guided
ascent; one must put one's faith in the guide instead. (ITA, pg47)"
This example illustrates what I am trying to say. Things that are not
in our control are other people's actions, and things that are not up
to us are those actions' consequences.

Moreover, things can be in our control one minute and not the next. In
a car accident, steering the wheel might save you from the accident in
a specific time. After that time, no matter how much you steer the
wheel you can't escape the unavoidable truth. This, as a matter of
fact, concerns the issue of chance. However, since chance is related
to luck, we are concerned with this as well.

Let's concentrate on each philosopher more deeply now. First let's
take a look at some of the issues that Aristotle points out in his
book Nicomachean Ethics. He states that moral luck is concerned with
situations that are not in our control. Moreover, if someone is
virtuous he cannot escape from moral luck. However, you have to be
virtuous to get away from it. That is to say, only the virtuous man
has the greatest...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Moral Luck Views of Aristotle and Epictetus

God of Jews, Christians, and Muslims Vs Epictetus’ God

1774 words - 7 pages God of Jews, Christians, and Muslims Vs Epictetus’ God: One or Two Different Deities? When looking at Epictetus’ work through the Handbook (The Encheiridon) and The Discourses of Epictetus, we find that there can be many interpretations that can be made on Epictetus’ god. One can interpret through these text above that Epictetus’ god is all-powerful, all-good being, answer the prayers of the pious, and watches over people therefore showing

The Joy Luck Club and Its Analysis of Familial Relationships

1528 words - 6 pages Amy Tan wrote her novel The Joy Luck shortly after experiencing a series of events that are similar to Jing-mei, or "June" Woo's experiences through the course of the novel. The original context of the story was to examine her life and the life of her mother in order to forge as stronger bond between them. Instead, Tan's novel takes the mother/daughter dynamic and analyzes it in a way that all women, not just Chinese-Americans, can relate to.Amy

The Rules Of Life: Epictetus View

1083 words - 4 pages ;    Temperance is a sign of moral excellence. Epictetus says that one ought exude self-control at all times. For, it is inevitable that one will find oneself in the face of adversity, rumor, and conceit on numerous occasions in a life span. Epictetus dispenses his insight into this matter: Be silent for the most part, or say what you have to in a few words…Divert by your own talk, if you can, the talk of those with you to

Philosophers Nagel and Kant on Moral Luck

1554 words - 7 pages How can we determine what actions, if any, we're morally responsible for? At first the concept of the control principle was in practice until people came to realize that they didn’t actually practice this to the fullest degree; this lead to the creation of the idea of Moral Luck. Two philosophers with opposing viewpoints on the concept of Moral Luck were Nagel and Kant. I believe Kant has a good base for what he believes, but I don’t think

Aristotle and Plato's Views on Reality

1030 words - 4 pages Aristotle and Plato were both great thinkers but their views on realty were different. Plato viewed realty as taking place in the mind but Aristotle viewed realty is tangible. Even though Aristotle termed reality as concrete, he stated that reality does not make sense or exist until the mind process it. Therefore truth is dependent upon a person’s mind and external factors. According to Aristotle, things are seen as taking course and will

Arroyo Administration: The Plato and Aristotle Views

2842 words - 11 pages Aristotle will form the ground for this evaluation. These philosophers both raised their views of what an ideal society is. Is this the same with the society we have today? The two also gave their ideas of what should be really be the roles and responsibilities of the government. Is the Arroyo administration a representation of their views of what a government should be or is it the complete opposite?Let me begin by describing the society where we belong

Christocentric Panthiesm? Aquinas and Epictetus: Discussions on the Nature of God

1441 words - 6 pages A true interpretation of ethics and morality can only be obtained through the understanding of God and divine providence. Without a correct view of God's nature, man would be helpless to understand his role and position in the order of creation. This theory would presuppose the existence of a supreme being or higher authority. This acceptance of a higher authority then mandates the establishment of moral standards. These standards are the basis

My study notes for final. Brief overview of Epictetus, Augustine, and Thomas Aquinas.

685 words - 3 pages 3. Epictetus: persents nice life without afterlife. Stoics: the essential nature of humans is reason. The universe is governed not only by law or god, but by the law of reason. All that occurs, happens in accordance to Natural Law, God. Their two fundamentals are: 1. Whatever happens is the inevitable outcome of the logic of the universe. 2. Whatever happens, is for reason, and therefore is for the best. The stoic philosophy also says to remain

A Critical Analysis of Plato's and Sartre's Views on Existence

2480 words - 10 pages A CRITICAL ANALYSIS OF PLATO’S AND SARTRE’S VIEWS ON EXISTENCE Introduction In order to understand the meaning of existence in relation to philosophy, we need to discuss its ordinary meaning and the various levels of existence. The Chambers Concise Dictionary (1992, 362) defines ‘exist’ as having an actual being; to live; to occur; to continue to live’ and it defines existence as ‘the state of existing or being’. In other words, the

Overview and Moral of Into the Woods: Play Analysis

3100 words - 12 pages people to talk to their children” which is why he filled the story with so many moral, ethical, and social lessons (Mankin, 66). Lapine felt that parents teaching their children these lessons of being honorable and good not only benefits their children, but the parents as well because they have to understand the same concepts and core values. The original cast of In the Woods on Broadway had a few actors who have had prolific careers in

Aristotle and the Techne of Rhetoric

1433 words - 6 pages modern discourse analysis and rhetorical criticism. (In fact, I am using the book in two of my rhetoric classes today, a true indication of the lasting effects he had on the discipline.) Within that notable work, Aristotle defined rhetoric as, “the energy inherent in emotion and thought, transmitted through a system of signs, including language, to other to influence their decision or actions” (Aristotle 7). In On Rhetoric, Aristotle also went on

Similar Essays

Historical Views Of Leadership: Plato And Aristotle

1780 words - 7 pages What is leadership, and how do we attain the best and most effective leaders? These are questions that are as old as civilization itself. Bass (1974) wrote that, “from its infancy, the study of history has been the study of leaders” (as cited in Wren, 1995, p. 50). Since the study of history in the West is commonly held to begin with Herodotus of ancient Athens, it is not surprising that we should examine the historical views of leadership

The Views Of Reality Of Plato And Aristotle

1015 words - 4 pages The Views of Reality of Aristotle and PlatoIntroductionThe purpose of this essay is to compare and contrast the views of reality of both Aristotle and Plato. Plato and Aristotle, two of some of the greatest philosophers of Ancient Greece, were connected in studies. Plato was taught by Socrates, then Aristotle studied at Plato's Academy. Plato was the first of the two to study, and Aristotle then studied there. And, upon learning this, one would

Aristotle And Islam: Two Views Of Women's Rights

1148 words - 5 pages Aristotle is one of the most famous philosophers around the world. He is Greek; he lived between 384 BC and 322 BC . He wrote in many aspects such as physics, metaphysics, logic, politics, government and ethics . While concerning politics and government, it is clear that Aristotle has some effective ideas to the state and the human society. On the other hand, Islam is one of the religious that take about how the society works and how to keep the

The Notion Of The Good In The Ethical Views Of Plato And Aristotle

1636 words - 7 pages The Notion of the Good in the Ethical Views of Plato and Aristotle 1. Discuss the notion of "the good" in the ethical views of Plato and Aristotle. State which of potentiality would lead to normal life. Plato explored such subjects as beauty, justice, and good government. Plato's ethics were ethics of happiness. He based his ethical theory on the proposition that all people desire happiness although, of course, people sometimes