This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of Photographs: The Controversy

3078 words - 12 pages

"The word photography, which is derived from the Greek words for light and writing, was first used by Sir John Herschel in 1839: the year the invention of the photographic process was made public" (Camera Canada, 2005). Photography, ever since its invention, has been an important part of the visual culture. One of the interpretive tools used to analyze photographic images is semiology, which is also referred to as 'the study of signs' (Rose, 2001: 69). The semiotic approach takes a photographic "image apart" into parts such as iconic, indexical and symbolic signs, and "traces how it works in broader systems of meaning" (Rose, 2001: 69). This is where "interpretive debate among semiologists over the status of signs in photographic images" arises (Rose, 2001: 82). While some semiologists believe that the signs present in every photograph are solely adequate to understand its meaning, others argue against that by stating that there are some points in certain photographs that elude analysis (Rose, 2001: 82). I agree with the latter and believe that there are some things in a photograph that escape the objective, analytical scrutiny and yet, leave an impact on its viewer.John Tagg and Roland Barthes, respectively, represent the two unique schools of thought pertaining to the analysis of photographs using semiology. John Tagg is an advocate of the view that photography can be only given meaning by studying them within "certain institutional apparatuses" whereas Roland Barthes, one of the pioneer semiologists, is an exponent of the view that "there are points in some photographs that shock the viewer with their intractable reality" (Rose, 2001: 82, 167). One major difference between the two is that Tagg's approach towards interpretation of photography is objective and focuses on producing meaning of an image only within the realms of an "institutional framework" (Tagg, 1988: 3), whereas Barthes' approach is "subtle, poetic, and at home with both imagination and imaginative language" (Price, 1994: 9). Therefore, Tagg is in constant opposition with Barthes in relation to the "intended use of a photograph" (Price, 1994: 10). Barthes believes that photography communicates reality - the truth - without the interposition of any external agencies of power. According to Tagg, on the other hand, the use intended by a photograph through the "power of representation" of visual objects is always suspended in institutions of power, which "cannot be articulated" (Price, 1994: 11). Keeping that in view, Tagg rejects Barthes' assertion that "from a phenomenological viewpoint, the power of authentication exceeds the power of representation" (Barthes, 1982: 88) in photography when he says that "what exceeds representation, however, cannot, by definition, be articulated" (Tagg, 1988: 4). In addition, Tagg also refutes Barthes' claim that a photograph is "an emanation of past reality: a magic" (Barthes, 1982: 88) when Tagg states that "the photograph is not a magical...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Photographs: The Controversy

The Controversy of Animal Testing Essay

1302 words - 5 pages normally would to the drugs and chemicals. Animals are also not identical to humans, so no one is sure whether the effects will be the same on humans (http://www.aboutanimaltesting.co.uk /controversy-of-animal- testing.html). After many animal tests, the animals are euthanized. Again, they are not able to give consent for this as would be required of a human. Other animals have to endure the rest of their life in captivity or

The Controversy of Huckleberry Finn Essay

1912 words - 8 pages   Over the 129 years for which the book has been in print, Mark Twain’s The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn has been regarded with much controversy, for many different reasons. As it has progressed, the subject of this controversy has been almost constantly changing. This essay will explore some of the claims and explanations of the controversy, as well as a discussion on whether the book is even that controversial. While everyone is entitled to

The Controversy of Media Imperialism

1336 words - 5 pages The Controversy of Media Imperialism The controversy of media imperialism questions us as to whether a certain medium (in this case, the newspaper – tabloid, broadsheet, hybrid) is controlled by the publication owner or the managers/editors-in-chief/journalists. They both deliver news and make it possible to be accessed by the reading-public. Proprietors own publication companies and administer the content of the media

The Controversy of Marcel Duchamp

1112 words - 4 pages negative way; however, these two pieces alone, brought about the greatest amount of controversy. In 1917, Marcel Duchamp submitted his urinal, the Fountain, to the American Society of Independent Artists . The urinal was taken from J. L. Mott Iron Works in New York City, rotated ninety degrees and signed “R. Mutt.” The name “R. Mutt” was an alias he created to sign the piece. “R” stands for Richard was slang for a rich man, and “Mutt” refers to a

The Controversy of Artificial Intelligence

1495 words - 6 pages Throughout its history, artificial intelligence has always been a topic with much controversy. Should human intelligence be mimicked? If so, are there ethical bounds on what computers should be programmed to do? These are a couple of question that surround the artificial intelligence controversy. This paper will discuss the pros and cons of artificial intelligence so that you will be able to make an educated decision on the issue.What is

The Controversy of Standardized Testing

1519 words - 6 pages The Controversy of Standardized Testing “No issue in the U.S. Education is more controversial than (standardized) testing. Some people view it as the linchpin of serious reform and improvement, others as a menace to quality teaching and learning” (Phelps). A tool that educators use to learn about students and their learning capabilities is the standardized test. Standardized tests are designed to give a common measure of a student’s

Of(f) Museums Issues concerning the presentation of some photographs in the open-air

1220 words - 5 pages The shot shows a male figure viewing photographs. We see the person from the rear, look over his shoulder, past him, as he passes along the collection of images, and at the same time we look into some of the faces that are visible in the photos and which seem to be looking at us outside of the picture frame rather than at the person in the picture viewing them. We are dealing here with black-and white photographs from the late 1920s, which

Summary of Stephen Shore book, The Nature of Photographs - Photography 151, USC - Assignment

720 words - 3 pages Photo 151 Reading Response 1 · All photograph prints determine how this world in front of the camera transformed to a photograph. I believe that photographs interpret our minds and they show how we want to frame the world in front of us. · The physical level of a photographic print refers to its base, edge, and its physical dimension, which determine the visual qualities of the image such as hue and tonal range. Also, the type of base

The Controversy of the Manipulation of Advertising

1411 words - 6 pages The Controversy of the Manipulation of Advertising Is advertising manipulative; can it be controlling, or is it fueling the demand of the American economy? The exhaustive battle of what advertising is and what it’s not is never-ending and both ends of the spectrum can only battle with statistics, words, and opinions on the fact of the matter. Many arguments have arisen since the establishment of the advertising industry and everyone

The Controversy of Approving the Dream Act

1378 words - 6 pages Over the past few years the controversy of approving the Dream Act has been a topic that seems to not have an end. About ten years ago, young Ivan Nikolov immigrated from Russia with his mother, and missed a court date a year after they arrived. Nikolov's mother was married to a U.S citizen, yet she was deported back to Russia. Charged for an immigration violation Nikolov sat in prison for three months, however he did not commit a single

Why Did A.J.P Taylor’s Analysis of the Origins of the Second World War Cause Such Controversy Among Historians?

1043 words - 5 pages Why did A.J.P Taylor’s analysis of the origins of the Second World War cause such controversy among historians? It was broadly considered that the Second World War began in 1939 because of Hitler’s plan for world domination; many historians validated this view at the time until A.J.P. Taylor published his book ‘Origins of the Second World War’ in 1961. A. J. P Taylor was the first historian to examine the war with a completely open mind

Similar Essays

The Relationship Of Photographs, History, And Memory

5350 words - 21 pages The Relationship of Photographs, History, and Memory Abstract: This essay reflects on the relationship of photographs, history, and memory based on a found and mutilated photo album. Photographs provide opportunities for disrupting and restructuring history with their attraction to memory; they privilege the subjective, creative power of the personal explanation and provide an emotional and even ideological grounding for memory

Ansel Adams Life And Two Analysis Of His Photographs

852 words - 3 pages Ansel Adams was born February 20, 1902, in San Francisco, California. Ansel took an interest in music at an early age. He taught himself how to play the piano and enjoyed the surroundings of nature. In 1916, he and his parents went on a trip to Yosemite National Park where he received his first camera, the Kodak Box Brownie. His first photographs recorded their vacation. Ansel fell in love with Yosemite National Park and would return every

An Analysis Of The Death Penalty Controversy In America

1848 words - 7 pages the 1970s, no statistical study supported this theory. Isaac Ehrlich published a study in 1975 that made a case for deterrence. His sophisticated model looked at many different variables such as arrest rate in murder cases, conviction rate of murder arrests, the rate of labor force participation, the unemployment rate, per capita income, and also the murder rate and the number of executions (Hanks 81). Based on his analysis, Ehrlich concluded

Summary Of "The Boston Photographs" Summary And Response Paper. This Essay Is About "The Boston Photographs" By Nora Ephron

554 words - 2 pages Summary of "The Boston Photographs"In "The Boston Photographs," writer Nora Ephron writes about three very controversial pictures taken of a rescue attempt that failed. The photographs were taken by Stanley Forman of the Boston Herald American. He was using a motor driven camera, which allowed him to take three frames per second. The first shot showed a fireman that was rescuing a woman and a child. The next picture showed the fire escape