Analysis Of Rathenau Paper On Policy And The Evidence Beast

1439 words - 6 pages

The aim of this paper is to reflect upon the quality of knowledge of a research paper published by the Rathenau Institute concerning evidence-based policy (Staman & Slob, 2012). In order to conduct the analysis three main knowledge claims are identified which are subsequently analyzed with the positivism, critical rationalism and social-constructivism view on science as described and defined by Benton and Craib (2011).
Diagnosed problems regarding evidence based policing
Evidence-based policy can be defined as policy that is based on scientific evidence (Staman & Slob, 2012). The interaction between policy makers and the scientific world seems however to face some disruptions. To identify these obstacles Staman and Slob (2012) start their analysis by reviewing the classical model of the interaction between science and politics, which states that scientists seek the neutral truth and policy makers seek for ways to turn ideas into effective policies. The underlying assumption in this way of thinking is that effective policies can be achieved with studied facts, thus based on scientific knowledge. Staman and Slob (2012) identified several problems that arise with this classical model from which three are summarized below and further referred to as knowledge claims (kc).
kc1. If policymakers desire to apply evidence-based policy there is a need for true facts. The knowledge provided by scientists is often considered as close to the truth due to the scientific method involved in reaching a conclusion. However, Staman and Slob (2012) point towards the viewpoints of Daniel Sarewitz, who believes that science can never reach a cohesive viewpoint. Jeroen Dijsselbloem confirms this by mentioning contradicting reports passing his desk often. This all means policy makers will always feel the hindrance of the lack of cohesion between scientists and it remains a question weather theoretical claims hold in practice for policies.
kc2. The expectations policy makers have towards scientists can often not be fulfilled. Policy makers often face time constraints and cannot afford to deal with doubt and uncertainty. Consequently, they are in need for a high level of certainty, which cannot always be guaranteed by scientists.
kc3. The third problem claimed by Staman and Slob (2012) is that evidence-based policy is not always possible due to the way scientists often seclude themselves in established their conclusions, it is often advisable for scientist to hear the opinions of all parties involved in order to understand how complex politics can be.
Testing knowledge claims through positivism principles.
The positivism perspective is an extension to the empiricism view on knowledge that states that knowledge comes from induction and observable experiences and that this knowledge is used to explain social phenomena (Benton & Craib, 2011). Nevertheless, the empiric view of knowledge on which positivism is based has long been subject to limitations. Immanuel Kant...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Rathenau paper on policy and the evidence beast

"Evaluate the Psychometric evidence underlying Herrnstein's and Murray's Analysis on Class Structure in American Life".

3410 words - 14 pages national policy implications that in their analysis has shed light on.The Bell Curve defines 'Intelligence' as; "a general capacity for inferring and applying relationships drawn from experience" and "a person's capacity for complex mental work". However, the authors measure 'Intelligence' as the article that, "...intelligence tests measure" (Boring 1923; Jensen 1927). The authors' suppositions arise from two main domains of evidence. Firstly

Analysis of evidence essay

883 words - 4 pages Analysis of Evidence AssignmentDear Members of the Dallas Regional Hospital Board,As you all know, we have been faced with an ethical dilemma regarding patients Zandro White, and Magdelena Erwin, who are both awaiting a liver transplant. I have reviewed the background of each patient in detail and have made the following decision. We will change our current policy effective immediately. The first person on the waiting list will no longer be the

Policy Analysis Paper 2

1347 words - 6 pages that allow for appeals with the supreme courts being the final arbiter of state cases. The local level consists of courts that consist of minor offenses like misdemeanors, local ordinances as well as traffic violations. The judicial branch becomes a political actor in the policy process when decisions are handed from the upper courts. Bureaucracies “Bureaucracies are the agencies found on the federal, state and local levels that carry out or

Policy Analysis Paper

1007 words - 5 pages for decades. The same institutionalized model of care dictates resident care plans, activities, structure, routine and goals. This institutional model focuses on tasks, efficiency, and uses a hierarchical method of management. There is a great deal of emphasis placed on risk aversion, usually by limiting choices and opportunities for residents and staff. This model disempowers the individual receiving care, because the individual’s needs are

The Vixen And The Beast

1799 words - 7 pages Sex. It is what sells in today?s society. Looking at both men and women in today?s pop culture of music videos and racy magazines, this common theme is seen throughout everything, from the clothes models wear, to how they look. Men and women of today?s society have become obsessed with the image of the femme fatal and the masculine hero. The media has a profound impact on every person in America, from magazines and television to even the songs

A Comparison of Beauty and the Beast with Toy Story

1980 words - 8 pages lighting is also important, Andy's room is bright and colourful compared to Sid's bedroom which is dark and gloomy. Andy's room uses bright colours well such as the blue for the walls. Sid's room has a dark green light on and appears to be black, there are lots of luminous posters on the well too. There is a clear contrast between the two characters and their environments. Beauty and the Beast is similar, the prince/beast

Stereotyping: Nature of the Beast

1549 words - 6 pages . There are hundreds of behavior patterns that are considered stereotyping. In all reality it is our perception of others based on typical behavior. It is human nature for everyone to pass judgment and to categorize one another. As humans we need to continuously learn to thrive and embrace the changes of life around us. Even though stereotypes will always be around, knowing what to expect and how to react to them effectively will

Prevention and care of pressure ulcers - evidence based paper

2514 words - 10 pages , and others are more concentrated on treating the problem after it occurs, without paying much attention to prevention. In XY hospital, patients at risk do not receive the necessary preventive care, and many patients' existing wounds often become infected, and instead of healing, they deteriorate. This paper will review the research regarding the best prevention methods, as well as the best evidence based treatment of pressure ulcers, followed by

Policy Analysis of The Runaway and Homeless Youth Act

2476 words - 10 pages parenting youth. Here they will learn smart decision making as well as parenting skills. The Transitional Living Program was designed to promote a transition for these clients to self sufficient living and prevent long-term dependency on social services. Another strength of this policy both micro and macro is that in 2008 when changes were occurring to the preliminaries of the act, the length of stay was increased in the shelters from 14-21

Essay On The Evidence That Supports The Theory Of Continental Drift And Plate Tectonics

783 words - 3 pages have been joined together.This possible idea was then proved to be almost certainly true when fossils of similar plants, animals and similar rock types of a corresponding time period were found on the east coast of South America and the West coast of Africa.This could be viewed by many as being an explanation but animals have been known to cross oceans and seeds of plants have also been known to travel great distances such as coconuts to other

Psychological Evidence Into the Effects of Day Care on Children's Cognitive and/or Social Development

1222 words - 5 pages Psychological Evidence Into the Effects of Day Care on Children's Cognitive and/or Social Development Effects of day care on cognitive development - cognitive development is the changes that take place throughout (in this case) a child's life, referring to his/her mental abilities. This includes memory, perception, language and intelligence. The strong bond between caregiver and child promotes this development as it allows

Similar Essays

Animation Of 'beauty And The Beast'

1128 words - 5 pages wrong turn taken by Maurice, Belle's father, causes the two to meet. In order to break the spell placed upon him and his servants, a beast (an enchanted prince on the inside) must learn to earn the love of a village girl or risk remaining in his animal state forever.BEAUTY AND THE BEASTIn the opening sequence of the film it shows the Beast falling into despair. He claws a portrait of himself (in human form).The scene beast is the famous ballroom

Beauty And The Beast Essay

994 words - 4 pages From Cupid & Psyche to Cocteau’s film and finally to Disney’s portrayal of this classic theme, not much has changed in the idea of Beauty and the Beast. All versions of this story have stressed the importance of being good and have even dwelled on the importance of looking behind appearance to see a person’s true nature. In order to convey his ideas and themes, Cocteau uses the beast as a lurking figure whose lack of appearance on the

Beauty And The Beast Essay

1354 words - 5 pages within this story are the Beast, Belle, Maurice, Gaston, and the villagers and the servants of the castle.The movie begins with a selfish and unkind prince refusing to allow an old woman to shelter from the cold within his castle. The old woman was an actually a beautiful enchantress who curses the prince into the form of a beast and places a spell upon the castle and all who live there. The servants are turned into items that represent their

Absence Of Evidence, Or Evidence Of Absence; A Paper On Animal Consciousness

2045 words - 8 pages Absence of Evidence, or Evidence of Absence? A paper on Animal Consciousness      Consciousness is a difficult term to grasp; so much so, that many scientists will not even attempt to define the term, much less search for it’s evidence. Most however, do agree that consciousness must include certain aspects; specifically cognition, self-awareness, memory, and abstract thought.   &nbsp