Analysis Of Sidgwick's Third Axiom

1207 words - 5 pages

This paper will object to Sidgwick’s axiom that from the point of view of the universe, the good of one is no more important than the good of another on the ground that it is analytic. I present the purpose and content of the axiom with a further explanation of what I take ‘the point of view of the universe’ to mean. I then consider the response of the Egoist to the axiom and Sidgwick’s counter-response to illustrate the tautology of the argument. The tautology of the argument brings it in line with other axioms that Sidgwick rejects as insignificant. Thus, I argue that the third axiom fails to meet Sidgwick’s own standards, making its utility and significance questionable. In response to this, I consider that the axiom may be analytic but in a nontrivial way and thus still valuable. However, given that the axiom is still easily refuted by the Egoist I ultimately conclude that it fails to be significant in a meaningful way.
During his examination of Common Sense Morality, Sidgwick puts forth a series of propositions he believes pass his tests for achieving the highest possible certainty. Additionally, these axioms provide the bases of his argument for the adoption of Utilitarianism. Arguably the most important of these axioms is the third, which holds that “the good of any one individual is of no more importance, from the point of view... of the Universe, than the good of any other; unless, that is, there are special grounds for believing that more good is likely to be realised in the one case than in the other.” What Sidgwick meant by the “point of view of the universe” is not explained in the methods, though in a later paper he suggests that it is “what all rational beings, as such, ought to aim at realizing.” By this, I take him to mean something similar to Rawls’ veil of ignorance; an outside, impartial perspective that has an understanding of good, promotes it, and is a perspective that all rational beings ought to adopt. Thus, the axiom holds that we must regard the good of others as equal to our own good unless, when viewed from an impartial position, it is less due to special circumstances . For example, Sidgwick states that it would be wrong for a man to pursue his own good on any occasion if it would result in another individual having to sacrifice a greater amount of their good.
The problem with the axiom lies in the use of the phrase ‘from the point of view of the universe’. The phrase must be included because without it an Egoist could easily reject the axiom, which would be unacceptable for Sidgwick. However, the inclusion of this phrase could lead one to object to the axiom on the basis that it is analytic. As it stands, the Egoist can escape the axiom so long as he holds his happiness as his ultimate end. He can simply say he is not interested in taking up that point of view and thus it does not apply. Sidgwick acknowledges this to be true, so long as the Egoist does not believe that “his happiness or pleasure is Good, not...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Sidgwick's Third Axiom

Interactional View Theory by Paul Waltzawick

1383 words - 6 pages recognizing “what” she means when she says “clean your room” based on “how” it is said. Based on how it is said, I know if I must do it immediately or if it can wait. Likewise, when she says “I have no money” based on “how” it is said, I know immediately whether to keep asking or just let it go. The third axiom states that the nature of a relationship depends on how much both parties punctuate the communication theory. There are times when my mom is upset

Impact of Gender in Media and Film

1148 words - 5 pages I have to start and apologize for my cynical view. It is difficult for me to separate emotional stimulus from a purely analytical approach. Without using Carl Sagens Baloney Detection Kit at my side I easily diverge from logical analysis approach and immerse myself in my emotional defense. What I want to do is pull two separate and different works together and focus on the impact of gender in media and film. First I will summarize my position

Euclid’s Elements and the Axiomatic Method

2731 words - 11 pages , although because it lacked the candor of the other axioms, it was considered by many mathematicians to be flawed and was even neglected by Euclid himself for his first twenty-eight propositions. (Hofstadter 90) 5. If two lines are drawn which intersect a third in such a way that the sum of the inner angles on one side is less than two right angles, then the two lines inevitably must intersect each other on that side if extended


1703 words - 7 pages ever been achieved in any form of human society, remains open. In the light of that long lack of success, no discussion of the views of the Society of HumanKind on the subject can be either simple or short.On this issue the Society of HumanKind rests on the Axioms and Dogma. The First Axiom says that chance accounts for the origin of our species. The Treatise on Knowledge extends the application of that Axiom to include the range and nature of

Effects of Technological Change on the Human Condition: The Age of Spiritual Machines.

1709 words - 7 pages We cannot know the future, but we see trends happening now that can be projected forward. In 1965, Gordon Moore, co-founder of chip maker Intel, put forth an axiom that became known as Moore's Law. Moore stated that every year since 1959 the number of components on a microchip had doubled. Moore predicted that this trend would continue until 1975. . . He was wrong. The computer industry turned Moore's axiom into a general law. Further

Rational Expectation Theory and Ideological Factor of National Security

936 words - 4 pages Nash Analysis John Nash assets Bargaining theories which might be regarded as undertaking a rigorous and mathematical analysis of social contract negotiation. They show that under certain rationality assumptions, bargaining among rational individuals results in agreements that have interesting structural characteristics that may also result from a certain kind of bargaining procedure. When the characteristics have an ideological flavor, one

Ayn Rand and Today's Business Ethics

1850 words - 7 pages metaphysics states that facts are facts; objectivism rejects any belief in the supernatural and any claim that individuals or groups create their own reality (feelings, wishes, fears, hopes, etc.). The second axiom, epistemology, refers to reason, existence and consciousness are facts implicit in every perception; they are the base of all knowledge, the only guide to action, and men's means of survival. The third axiom is ethics, objectivism theory

Sense and Reference

2020 words - 8 pages introduction of a third realm seems to be presented purely as a result of his theory of sense and reference lacking axiom. It is Frege's tautological claim of sense being objective and shared while holding plentiful variability and what appears to be subjectivity. This lowers the thesis' verisimilitude substantially furthermore with the introduction of his third realm, which appears as an 'invite only' realm, diminishes Frege's entire argument."It really is

René Descartes and Thomas Hobbes : A Dialogue

1467 words - 6 pages that is of prime necessity in discussing matters such as this. In particular, the objections of the well-known English philosopher, Empiricist and materialist, Thomas Hobbes, serve to challenge, and with considerable depth at that, the Rationalism of Descartes. Furthermore, Descartes’ Third Meditation seems by far the most problematic with respect to unspoken assumptions, logical structure and even ambiguities of definition. Consequently

Levels Of Analysis And The Stu

1548 words - 6 pages Three levels of analysis, each with its own distinct strength, reveals three different ways of understanding international relations. The first states that all nation-states behave similarly, the second emphasizes the unique internal factors of a nation-state, while the third level of analysis focuses on the individual deciding a state’s course of action. Each level of analysis is useful in the study of international relations

Treaty between Bolivia and Chile

1839 words - 7 pages , principally in the south American region.The following analysis will attempt to objectify the boundary conflict between Bolivia and Chile. Although the Bolivian claim of right to access coasts that have been lost to Chile for more than one hundred years, the new ideals of continental integration and the desire to create more solid routes of economic channels, Bolivian claims of sovereign access to the Pacific have gained steam in International

Similar Essays

Cost Benefit Analysis Of Third Party Intervention In Intrastate Conflict


Analysis Of Painting "Guernica" By Picasso And The "Third Of May" By Goya

811 words - 3 pages Picasso's "Guernica" (1937) and Goya's "The Third of May" (1814) are paintings that are created to communicate an issue of concern of the artist. In order to truly understand the impact that these paintings have on people, and why that impact is so strong, a person must analyse the content of them.The first reaction of the "Guernica" by Picasso is one of mayhem, destruction, lost souls and death. The entire painting is dark with cool colours and

Analysis Of Mr. White In The Monkey's Paw And Mr. Peters In The Third Wish

1036 words - 4 pages the world, asked for two hundred pounds for his own conveniences. On the other hand, the main character of “The Third Wish” is Mr. Peters. Mr. Peters is a kind-hearted, cautious man. The reader can tell that those are his traits for number of reasons. First of all, the reader can tell that Mr. Peters is compassionate because of his reaction towards a swan trying to extricate itself from a branch. He quickly rushes over and tries to free the bird

A Media Analysis Of The Film 'psycho' By Alfred Hitchcock. Looking Specifically At Voyeurism, Third Person Narrative And The Roles Of Both Male And Female Characters.

974 words - 4 pages changes to create a point of view shot where we are seeing thingsthrough Marians eyes and so we know exactly what she is looking at.In order to set a scene the camera tends to pan around quite slowly so thatwe can take in where a certain character is at any time. Once she gets out ofher car and has tried knocking at the office door with no success, the camerachanges to her point of view looking up at the main house. The whole houseis portrayed in