Analysis Of The Bioethical Issues In Gattaca

1039 words - 4 pages

Analysis of the Bioethical Issues in Gattaca

Biology is the science of life. Technology uses science to solve problems. Our society has progressed in its understanding of life to the point that we are able to manipulate it on a fundamental level through technology. This has led to profound ethical dilemmas. The movie Gattaca explores some important bioethical issues that are currently the focus of much dispute. The underlying thematic issue presented is the question of the extent to which biologically inherent human potential determines the true potential of a person. Perhaps the most controversial issue in Gattaca is the use of genetic engineering technology in humans to create a more perfect society; this is, essentially, a new method of Eugenics. Another related issue seen in the movie is that of pre-natal selection. Through the use of the same or similar technologies, parents are able to choose the characteristics with which their children will be born.
The controversy of these issues stems from the immense potential in genetic sciences for both positive use and harmful misuse. Though the questions and fears of critics reflect the wisdom of caution, the potentially unlimited benefits mandate that we pursue these technologies.
The central subject of Gattaca’s plot is human potential. This is an important bioethical issue and is basically an example of the classic argument: Nature v. Nurture. The debate is of the role of nature compared to the role of environment in the shaping of personalities and other mental and physical characteristics. Psychologists have argued on this issue extensively. In the context of genetics and the movie Gattaca, the debate is of the respective roles of original genetic makeup and environment in determining the true potential of a person. The movie’s theme is “There is no gene for the human spirit.” The main point asserted by the movie is that determination, human spirit, and other factors not genetically inherited substantially affect a person’s abilities and potential for excellence. This is shown through the accomplishments of the genetically inferior main character, Vincent. Vincent was naturally conceived and born, leaving flaws in his genetic code that could have been eliminated through engineering. Notwithstanding, he is able to outperform his genetically engineered colleagues in the Gattaca space program. The movie is primarily about the difficulties he faces because of discrimination that results from judging a person’s worth based only on their genetic profiles. Many fear that this sort of discrimination could become a reality in our future. Legislation has already been passed to prevent discrimination based on genetic testing. In the movie this sort of legislation existed but was ignored. Obviously, the plot would have been much different if such legislation were adequately enforced.
Eugenics is the name given by Francis Galton to a theory for improving humanity through "judicious matings... to...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of the Bioethical Issues in Gattaca

Contemporary Issues in The Merchant of Venice

1085 words - 4 pages Contemporary Issues in The Merchant of Venice     Shakespeare's The Merchant of Venice is still relevant today because it deals with issues which still affect us. Throughout the play a distinction is made between how things appear and how they are in reality.  The issue of appearance versus reality is demonstrated in varied ways, mainly by the use of real-life situations.  The first representation of this is Shylock's

The Issues of Women in Sport

1141 words - 5 pages The Issues of Women in Sport Race, gender, history and sexual orientation play major roles in women's participation in sport. Through out the history of women in sport, opportunity has increased. Many athletes and coaches are presented with the issue of sexual orientation throughout their sporting career. Regardless of sexual orientation, all female athletes are affected by heterosexism. One's racial or ethnicity background greatly shapes

Unresolved Issues in The Merchant of Venice

1018 words - 4 pages enormous complexity. In The Merchant of Venice, the contrast between the tragedy of Shylock and the comedy of the other characters raises many issues that are left unresolved for the thoughtful reader.             As the action begins Antonio, a wealthy merchant who deals in overseas trade, is sitting on a bench preening. The character of Antonio is clearly written as full of affection and

Gender Issues in "The Tale of Genji"

1251 words - 5 pages The Tale of Genji is a classic work of Japanese literature attributed to the Japanese noblewoman Murasaki Shikibu in the early eleventh century, around the peak of the Heian period. It is sometimes called the world's first novel, the first modern novel, the first psychological novel or the first novel still to be considered a classic. While universally hailed as a masterpiece, its precise classification and influence in both Western and Eastern

The Issues of Breast Cancer in Nigeria

1616 words - 6 pages “Mrs. Claire Anyanwu has visited her doctor everyday for the past week. She was at the convention last month. Women were encouraged to go for medical checkups. She was luckily diagnosed early enough to be treated of ‘mild breast lumps.’ It is an ailment that could lead to breast cancer. We are happy to see women respond to our awareness programs.” said Dr. Rosa Phil (1). In her article, Dr. Phil commends Mrs. Anyanwu for taking action against

Discussion of Whether Gattaca Portrays A Realistic View Of The Future And Gene Manipulation

2408 words - 10 pages the big bang, and not a creation of God; that God does not exist. Doing so could finish the meaning of God. In my opinion, the director of Gattaca- Andrew Niccol wanted the audience to empathise with Jerome, Vincent and also with Irene. In the movie many issues were brought up. One was about being a God child or gene manipulated child. The film showed that the gene manipulated child was looked upon, as superior and

Issues in the Workplace

1994 words - 8 pages This paper entails discussions of some common issues in the work place. We will touch on just a few of the everyday issues that most people face and are effected by. We will begin by examining common difficulties we face with co-workers, explain how to identify a difficult person, and then give pointers on possible techniques on dealing with that person. We will then discuss communication and effective listening skills in the work place

Issues in the workplace.

2453 words - 10 pages Issues in the workplace - the situation analyzed from a behavorial point of view and discusses possible solutions to the problems or issues for PSY 200.ThesisIn this paper we will briefly discuss some common issues in the workplace. We will touch on just a few of the everyday issues that most people face and are effected by. We will begin by discussing common difficulties we face with co-workers, we will explain how to identify a difficult

Eating Issues in Schools: A Journal Analysis

728 words - 3 pages important issue. This article’s purpose is to provide school counselors with a resource for assessing and managing eating issues in the schools, including when and how to consult with outside human service professionals. A recent epidemiological research indicates that the highest incidence of anorexia nervosa occurs in females between the ages of 15 and 19. (keski-Rahkonen et al.,2007) The highest documented cases of bulmia occur in females

Issues of the Internet

771 words - 3 pages As computers advance, society is coming together steadily through the rising use of the Internet. We interact with one another every day by using the Internet as a tool of communication. Through the evolution of the global electronic era, certain ethical, security, and productivity questions arise. As electronic communication becomes essential in the daily interactions of many people, regulatory issues also become crucial. How do we determine

Issues of the Elderly

1765 words - 7 pages within the system to reform or support existing programs. Activists work for fundamental social change. They use methods such as protest and scrutiny of corporate practices to bring about change.Issues raised by our aging population receive special attention by policy makers due to a majority of the participation and lobbyist, and will continue to be influence as the elder population as it grows in numbers. I think issues raised by older adults

Similar Essays

Gattaca Film Analysis On The Final Scene

532 words - 2 pages The Final ScenePersonal ResponseThe final scene of GATTACA had an unexpected twist that triggered mixed emotions of confusion, sorrow and happiness. The irony of Vincent finally fulfilling his life's mission and Jerome no longer having one was heart wrenching, after all that they went through together to defy the odds and expectations of perfection set by Society. However, it was Jerome's choice to end his life having finally come to peace with

Vincent Is The Hero Of Gattaca

1056 words - 4 pages ! Gattaca Clearly, Vincent is the hero of Gattaca. Do you agree? ! ! Ambition. Conquest. Determination. Andrew Niccol's captivating film, Gattaca comprehensibly explores these three potent terms which defines a hero in a deeper meaning throughout the character of Vincent Freeman. Gattaca, a science fictional film set in the not-too-distant future, explores the life of Vincent as he has been categorised by society as inferior. Despite the fact

Describe The Advantages And Disadvantages Of Living In A World Such As That Depicted In "Gattaca"

865 words - 3 pages Describe the advantages and disadvantages of living in a world such as that depicted in GATTACA. Secondly, imagine that you live in this world. Describe how you envisage your life, including the good and bad. Include the kinds of issues that people living in this world would have to deal with everyday.The film Gattaca is based on the theme of a eugenic society in which science and medicine are imperative in the running of the world. Medicine in

Genetic Tecnology (And The Future Portrayed In Gattaca)

576 words - 2 pages Families want their kids to be happy and healthy, but parents can be the source of unhappiness or unhealthiness of a child because of the genes they give them. Technological advances in genetics can give parents what they always wanted, a child who is perfect in every way. This possibility raises some serious concerns. Would parents use the technology to make children healthy? Or would they use it to create a better child than their neighbors