This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of The Case Law

3355 words - 13 pages

Analysis of the Case Law "There is no prescribed constitutional relationship between the courts
and the executive, but the judges assert their inherent power, derived
from the rule of law, to review executive actions"

The question starts off by giving us an element of the separation of
powers when it says that there is no prescribed constitutional
relationship between the courts and the executives.

The concept of separation of powers propounded by Montesquieu, the
French political philosopher, has three main criteria:

(i) There are three main classes of governmental functions: the
legislature, the executive and the judicial.

(ii) There are (or should be) three main organs of government in a
state: the Legislature, the Executive and the Judiciary.

(iii) To concentrate more than one class of function in any one person
or organ of government is a threat to individual liberty. For example,
the Executives should not be allowed to make laws or adjudicate on
alleged breaches of the law; it should be confined to the executive
functions of making and applying policy and general administration.

The third proposition, which is said to be the most extreme and
doctrinaire, is what the question in hand seems to overrule using the
rule of law, whereby judges are said to use it to assert their
inherent power to review executive actions.

Dicey[1] saw the rule of law as a central feature of the British
constitution. He had his own idiosyncratic ideas of what the rule of
law implied and his ideas were very influential for two generations.

The concept is one of open texture; it tends itself to an extremely
wide interpretations. One can virtually say that the concept basically
implies;

(i) that the powers exercised by politicians and officials must have a
legitimate foundation; they must be based on authority conferred by
law; and

(ii) that the law should conform to certain minimum standards of
justice, both substantive and procedural.

Judges spend the majority of their time deciding individual cases.
Those cases establish the precedents, which collectively constitute a
solid proportion of our law. Nowhere is this more true than in the
case of administrative law. Here the involvement of legislation has
been confined to matters of procedure and practice. The accretion to
the law on a case-by-case basis has proved to be an ideal manner in
which to establish principles of administrative law. It has helped to
maintain the necessary delicate balance between the interest of the
public and administrators.

However, the tensions created by judicial review are acceptable
because it demonstrates that the courts are performing their role to
ensure that the action of the government of the day is being...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of the Case Law

Analysis of 2017 Employment Law Cases - Dublin - Case

2500 words - 10 pages compared to the sanctions of the other two negligent employees. Company: ‘Keelings Logistics Solutions’ - Unfair Dismissal [2014] FACTS: This case was an appeal to the EAT after it was dismissed by the Rights Commissioner, who held that the two employees in question, (Boyne & Moran), were fairly dismissed. Keeling Logistic Solutions operated as a distribution company for the supply of goods to one consumer. The employees were warehouse

Law Enforcement and Miranda Warnings Case Analysis

1284 words - 5 pages interpreter, but the officer could then speak to the subject without violating his 5th Amendments. Miranda vs Arizona is the land mark case that every Law Enforcement agency in the United States goes by. The Supreme Court of the United States looked at four main cases that had to do with custodial interrogations. In these cases the suspect was shut off from the outside world and questioned by law enforcement. Law enforcement did not make sure that these

Employment Law Case Presentation and Analysis

1182 words - 5 pages the EEOC: INsights for employment mediators and counsel. Dispute Resolution Journal, 67(4), 19-38. Kubasek, N., Brennan, B., & Browne, M. (2012). The legal environment of business: A critical thinking approach (6th ed.). Upper Saddle River, NJ: Pearson Education. Maatman, Jr., G. L., & Degroff, C. J. (2012). EEOC-initiated litigation: Case law developments in 2011 and trends to watch for in 2012 Part I. Labor Law Journal, 63(1), 22-54. Remington, J

THE CONTROVERSIAL CASE OF ETHICS VS LAW THERESA MARIE SCHIAVO

883 words - 4 pages Schindlers with petitions emanating from themselves and other political leaders who sought to intervene. The cases lasted for about twelve years and were very controversial. The involvement of Congress in the case transgressed the law of separation of powers. In a similar manner, Governor Bush manipulated his powers through the County Council to enable him make alterations on the case contrary to what the courts decided. He was empowered by the “Terri

The case law study of multi-modal transport issue

2678 words - 11 pages Corporation assessed that the cargo were not maintained at the proper temperature, and rejected as "unfit for human consumption" and returned. Because of the cargo damaged, so there was no commercial value. VMeen Business Corporation is contemplating legal action.Identify the CarriersIn this case, a House Bill of lading was issued covering the entire carriage. The shipper Chopstix Corporation engaged Hasslefree Transporters for the carriage of goods

Supremacy of European Union Law Over National Law: The Factotame Case

1510 words - 6 pages , the Commission, the Council of the European Union or the European Parliament may request an annulment of a law which was passed, which may be in conflict with other laws already in place. Now that we have a little bit of a background information about the European Court of Justice, we are better equipped to analyze a very important court case which was ground breaking, The Factortame Case. The Factortame case transformed the legal relationship

Natural law in the Gideon Case

1261 words - 5 pages Florida State Supreme Court but since the case raised an important issue it went to the US Supreme Court for an answer. In order to make this colossal decision they had to look at different theories such as natural law and legal realism in order to make a right verdict. In the case of Gideon v Wainwright, natural law was the excellent theory to use by the Justices to reach their verdict to overturn the Betts rule because the fundamental value of a

Biotechnology and the Law: Case Studies Pset

1148 words - 5 pages 1. While organisms from nature are not inherently patentable, “human-made microorganisms with markedly different characteristics from any found in nature can be patented as long as the other patent requirements are met” (Bhatia “Patenting” 19). To be patentable, an invention must be new, non-obvious, unique, and useful. Thus, following the conclusion of the case Diamond v. Chakrabarty, which states that as long as the invention meets the above

Barron v Baltimore USSC Case Analysis - Constitutional Law - Legal Case Analysis

996 words - 4 pages under the Constitution to seize Barron’s property? 2) Do the protections given in the federal constitution under the fifth amendment against the government seizing private property without just compensation apply to the state and local government? 3) Did the United States Supreme Court have jurisdiction to decide this case? Rule of Law The law that would be used to decide this case in modern day would be the 14th Amendment of the Constitution

EXPLAINING THE LAW WITH ONE CASE ILLUSTRATION

980 words - 4 pages penalties. ORS, 475.300 (2007). A person who possesses a registry identification card issues pursuant to ORS 475.309 may engage in, and a designated primary caregiver of such a person may assist in, the medical use of marijuana only as justified to mitigate the symptoms or effects of the person’s debilitating medical condition. Id. In this case Terry Turner, who has obtained a registry identification card per the instructions in the Oregon Medical

Ramifications of the Edith Mmusi Case and the Law of Succession in Botswana

2672 words - 11 pages property, and had even taken care of their late mother in the same homestead prior to her death. Their claim was challenged by their half-brother’s son, Molefi Ramantele, who in turn argued that under Ngwaketse customary law, the family home was only inherited by the youngest son and thus he was entitled to inherit as his father’s heir. The case was initially heard by the Lower Customary Court which found in favour of Ramantele. The matter was appealed

Similar Essays

Analysis Of The Types Of Law In A Case Study

2204 words - 9 pages notice near the entrance at Big Deal ltd will be void and thus will have not legal affect. The same applies to Slump Ltd and they will have the ability to claim compensation plus damages.From the analysis of both scenarios in the question, it can be ascertained that there are remedies for both injured parties against Big Deal Ltd.For Slump Ltd, the exclusion clause is not relevant to their case as it does not satisfy the conditions needed to be

Ethical And Legal Analysis Of The Ann Hopkins V. Price Waterhouse Discrimination Law Suit. Focuses On Case Law And Ethics

3145 words - 13 pages CONCLUSIONSBased on the case law that preceded this case it is evident that regardless of the outcome, Price Waterhouse not only knew of Title VII violations but supported them through partner actions. As a matter of fact, the counsel for Price Waterhouse admitted to some degree of sex discrimination on the part of the partners but maintained that it was just one factor in the decision of partnership [3]. Essentially, this is enough to declare that

Workplace Law Case Study Analysis

1745 words - 7 pages necessary indicia specified in the case of Metals and Engineering Workers Union - Western Australia v Centurion Industries Ltd (1996) 66 IR 312. Furthermore, this provision of law also stipulates that the nature of her contract can change (which it has) from that of a casual employee to a part-time one.3. Elizabeth can be classified as a part-time employee. Therefore, her employment contract should entitle her to a provision of sick leave pay

The Case Of Procedural And Substantive Law

2226 words - 9 pages 1. Define the terms takings as it relates to the environmental law and provide one example of a legally resolved taking case. Answer: Taking is a general term of an act of taking something. In an environmental point of view, the taking is ta process that involves taking something of an environmental assets, such as land, from an individual or organization. However, most cases, it involves government taking private property from owners when that