This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of Thompson's Article, A Defense Of Abortion

1997 words - 8 pages

Pro-Choice: Analysis of Thompson's Article, A Defense of Abortion
Works Cited Missing

In Judith Jarvis Thompson’s article “A Defense of Abortion” she explores the different arguments against abortion presented by Pro –Life activists, and then attempts to refute these notions using different analogies or made up “for instances” to help argue her point that women do have the right to get an abortion. She explains why abortion is morally permissible using different circumstances of becoming pregnant, such as rape or unplanned pregnancy.

Thomson’s main idea is to show why Pro-Life Activists are wrong in their beliefs. She also wants to show that even if the fetus inside a women’s body had the right to life (as argued by Pro – Lifers), this right does not entail the fetus to have whatever it needs to survive – including usage of the woman’s body to stay alive.

To help argue her point, Thomson first begins with an analogy comparing an acorn of an oak tree to the fetus in a woman’s body. She begins by giving the view of the Pro – Lifers; “It is concluded that the fetus is…a person from the moment of conception” (page 113). She then goes on to say, “similar things might be said about the development of an acorn into an oak tree, and it does not follow that acorns are Oak trees…” (Page 113). This analogy helps illustrate how much she disagrees with this Pro –life argument. She calls it a “slippery- slope argument” and goes to say, “…it is dismaying that opponents of abortion rely on them so heavily and uncritically” (page 113). Although Thomson makes it clear that she disagrees with the notion that a fetus is a person (…I think the premise is false, that the fetus is not a person from the moment of conception. A newly fertilized ovum, a newly implanted clump of cells, is no more a person than an acorn is an Oak tree” (page 113)), She will not discuss any of it, but instead allows this “premise” for the sake of the argument. In this argument it has been established then, that a fetus is a person from the moment of conception. Thompson now introduces her “violinist analogy.” This is a key term in her argument. In this analogy she asks the reader to imagine you wake one morning and find yourself in bed with an unconscious violinist. He has been found to have a fatal kidney ailment, and you alone have the right blood type to save him. You have been kidnapped in the middle of the night, and the violinist’s circulatory system is now plugged into yours. The director of the Hospital is now telling you “Sorry, the Society of Music Lovers did this to you – we would never have permitted it if we had known.” To get unplugged from the violinist will kill him, but in nine months he will be totally recovered from his ailment and you can be safely unplugged from one another. Thompson then asks, “Is it a moral responsibility for the kidnapped person to agree to this situation?” This situation she has concocted...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Thompson's Article, A Defense of Abortion

An Explication of Judith Jarvis Thomopson's "A Defense of Abortion"

3269 words - 13 pages , for the sake of argument, that the fetus is a human from the time of conception. Thompson's famous argument for the right of women to an abortion goes like this:But now let me ask you to imagine this. You wake up in the morning and find yourself back to back in bed with an unconscious violinist. A famous unconscious violinist. He has been found to have a fatal kidney ailment, and the Society of Music Lovers has canvassed all the available medical

In defense of abortion review

1042 words - 5 pages groups. The population, theoretically, would decrease so much so that it would become an annihilation of that population which would probably be concentrated in one ethnicity or demographic—ultimately eugenics. Therefore regarding the legality of abortions, there needs to be some requirements in place to limit the amount of abortions that occur to prevent possible yielding of these negative effects such as eugenics. In the article A Defense of

Analysis of a quote from Shelley's A Defense of Poetry using Wimsatt and Beardley's article "The Intentional Fallacy"

2869 words - 11 pages ESSAY TOPIC:Analyse the following statement from Shelley's A Defense of Poetry using Wimsatt and Beardley's article "The Intentional Fallacy". Your essay must contextualise the quote, demonstrate the quote's relationship to the broader theory of Romantic authorship, and provide a definition of intention and why it is central to the Romantic conception of authorship."A man cannot say, 'I will compose poetry.' The greatest poet even cannot say it

Analysis of a Boxing Article

1271 words - 5 pages Analysis of a Boxing Article The headline does what headlines do. It grabs the readers attention, and suggest what we expect to find when we read on. “NO ONE IS FORECED TO FIGHT” is a sharp phrase that goes straight to the point. The bias of the editorial is clear from the headline, and we expect to read something in favor of the boxers right to box, especially since they are not “FORCED”. As expected it is told with

Evaluate Judith Jarvis Thomsons' defense of abortion

2968 words - 12 pages Evaluate Thomson's defence of abortionAbortion is not a new topic by any means and is yet still one of the most controversial subjects of our time, with Judith Jarvis Thomson's 1971 article entitled "A defence of Abortion" being one of, if not the most discussed articles with regards abortion in the last 50 years.In this essay I will attempt to evaluate the arguments put forward by Thomson by examining them and considering whether they are sound

A Defense of Polyamory

1563 words - 6 pages once; however, there are many distinctions between the terms. The most blatant difference is that polygamy specifies the participants are all married to each other, whereas polyamory encompasses a spectrum of relationships ranging from casual to committed. Furthermore, polygamy has its roots in religious and highly patriarchal systems, such as the Abrahamic faiths or the notorious Fundamentalist Church of Jesus Christ of Latter Day Saints. Quite

A Defense of Euthanasia

1482 words - 6 pages More than likely, a good majority of people have heard about euthanasia at least once in their existence. For those out there who have been living under a rock their entire lives, euthanasia “is generally understood to mean the bringing about of a good death – ‘mercy killing’, where one person, ‘A’, ends the life of another person, ‘B’, for the sake of ‘B’.” (Kuhse 294). There are people who believe this is a completely logical scenario that

A Defense of Justice

1256 words - 6 pages Have you ever thought about if the person next to you is a killer or a rapist? If so, what would you want from the government if the person had killed someone you know? Should they receive the death penalty? Murderers and rapists should be punished for the crimes they commit and should pay the price for their wrongdoing. Having the death penalty in our society is humane; it helps the overcrowding problem and gives relief to the families of the

Critical Analysis of a Systematic Review Article

2246 words - 9 pages their methods lead to positive project outcomes, improved performance is not consistently realized. The authors argue that the associations’ one size fits all approach to best practices is insufficient for project success and thus conducted systematic research (SR) to determine if something else is the cause of project success. The current paper will present a critical analysis of the 2011 article, “Now, let’s make it really complex

Analysis of a News Article on Economics

1935 words - 8 pages ). The United States’ national budget and the reforming of America’s budget were explored (Mallaby, 2011). Many important economic principles are also discussed in the article. Many of these economic Principles will be examined in this paper. General Economic Principles In the Article, “You Are What You Owe,” the first general economic Principle that was discussed in the article was the idea of markets. Markets are described as a group of

Critical Analysis of a Published Article

1197 words - 5 pages The main point of this article is facts about arranged marriage. This article has addressed to the audience of British society apart to British Asians. Because the writer, intended to present them the real meaning, about the arranged marriages and how it works. In addition, it gives a clear method to the part of British people who an arranged marriage is different from their viewpoints. The writer gave this article an obvious title, which

Similar Essays

A Defense Of Abortion Essay

998 words - 4 pages Abortion is a very controversial issue in Western society. Not only is it a strong legal issue, but an ethical/moral issue. When is abortion okay and is it really "murder?" When is a fetus operationally defined as a human by the law? Judith Jarvis Thomson points out many key issues on the abortion debate and discusses them in detail in her A Defense of Abortion report. Thomson's first - the "extreme view" - and last - "conditional abortion

Judith Jarvis Thomson: A Defense Of Abortion Analysis

1491 words - 6 pages the connection that there are three other morally relevant factors involved in abortion in certain cases: the fetus depends on the mother’s body for survival, the mother has not consented to the use of her body and pregnancies are demanding on the body and limit what mothers can do. Hence, the violinist has a kidney condition, which he can only survive if he is attached to our body, we are kidnapped and attached to the violinist without consent

In Defense Of Abortion Essay

1639 words - 7 pages For hundreds of years women helped each other to abort their pregnancies. Without legal prohibitions, women in Europe and the United States provided abortions and trained each other to perform the procedures. In the past century different states had begun to outlaw any procedure that would terminate or avoid pregnancy. In 1973(?) the United States Supreme Court asserted a woman's constitutional right to abortion in determining Roe v. Wade

Analysis Of An Article On Abortion

1063 words - 4 pages decisions. Following Mcclanathan’s thesis, she sinks in discussing arguments that others argue. While displaying her facts to defend her counterargument, she describes two types of abortion; medical and surgical. Mcclanathan states “For the sake of simplicity this article will discuss the side effects of a surgical abortion”. “Although the emotional side effects are generally the same for both.” (Mcclanathan 1). As Mcclanathan begins to describe