Analysis Of Turner And Bloch's Differing Theories

767 words - 4 pages

Alexandra Harvey
ANTH 425
3/24/2014
Turner vs. Bloch Analysis
For many cultures, rituals take part of everyday lives and provide purpose and meaning for life. Simple ceremonies such as a prayer before a meal, a Bar Mitzvah for an adolescent, or even marriage for a loving couples fill our lives with such meaning, but never receive a second thought about the depth behind such rituals. Anthropologists, Victor Turner and Maurice Bloch have both created ritual models that describe the obtainment of higher social statuses. Turner discusses ideologies about liminality and how this relates to the rites of passage for humans. Whereas, Maurice Bloch describes his ideas of rebirth and how they relate to the rituals within various cultures.
According to Turner, the period of transition for humans is a fixed state within one’s culture. As Victor Turner states, “ We are presented, in such rites, with a ‘moment in and out of time,’ and in and out of secular social structure, which reveals, however fleetingly, some recognition of a generalized social bond.” (VT: 96). Thus meaning, liminality is an important concept of transition with regard for social power structures. In Turner’s model of initiation he describes rituals as being a kind of formula consisting of behaviors and relationships, which ultimately result in social change. For Turner, such rites of passage and rituals are not the core structure of life, but rather exponential opportunities within one’s life.
In Turner’s analysis of the Ndembu tribe he found that a man’s transition from childhood to adulthood (Mukunda) that ritual practices are not the foundation of a boy’s adulthood, but rather a transition of possibilities and potential. In the beginning of the three step process of Mukunda all the adolescents start together in the wilderness together eating, singing, and hunting; away from the norms of their society. As the boys continue practicing rituals to gain their rights of passage they go through a period of liminality. During this time of liminality, they are secluded with others which is referred to as “communitas”. This period of liminality is not a basis of social structure, but rather an option to gain potential and ultimately raise one’s status within a community. (VT: 98-103)
In contrast, Maurice...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Turner and Bloch's Differing Theories

An Analysis of Theories

1036 words - 5 pages There are many theories that cover specific moral believes. The following theories relate either to the consequentialists that belief that, “the rightness of an action depends on the amount of good it produces,” or the non- consequentialists that belief that, “the rightness of an action does not depend entirely on its consequences” ( Vaughn, 2010 , 67 ). My belief is, that life is a mix of both beliefs and their conjoining theories. Also, I

Frederick Jackson Turner and the Question of American Exceptionalism

1784 words - 7 pages into a rapidly modernizing world. Progressive historian Frederick Jackson Turner wrote less and influenced his own generation more than any important historian. In his works, Turner spelled out his version of a New History in the modern spirit. Although his writings were few and limited, Turner promoted westward American expansion as unique and the conditions settlers faced in settling the frontier as the exception. The thing of first

An Analysis of Nozick and Held's Political Theories

1976 words - 8 pages . In particular, Nozick has had a major influence on the analysis of personal identity, as well as the analysis of political right-wing contributions. So, in order to understand why Held introduces claims against the current system, it is essential to consider her social and political views and compare those with the contractual political theories, supporting that the government should serve as a moralizing tool for the community first. While the

The Life, Works, Theories, and Analysis of Plato

1809 words - 7 pages about Plato's own views. Socrates still appears as a lead part in a significant number of these dialogues, but it is widely believed that they are the ideas of Plato. The middle periodincludes Gorgias, Meno, the Apology, Crito, Phaedo, The Symposium, and the Republic. The later period includes Theaetetus, Parmenides, Sophist, Philebus, Timaeus, and the Laws.One of Plato's most notable theories is the theory of forms. Part of the theory of forms is

European Union: Theories and Analysis

1671 words - 7 pages member countries. Analysis the question is, have the trade and economic theories that formed the EU been effective? Or are the benefits overblown polled by the media and by the EU itself? This question can be answered in two ways; as a whole, Europe has probably been better off with the formation of the EU -- but by the same token, individual member states may be not have fared quite so well. For example, before the EU was formed, some small and

Semiotic Theories and Terminology Analysis

1142 words - 5 pages The notion of semiotics involves the study of the relationship between symbols and signs and interpretation. It is through the work of semiotic that theorists such as Ferdinand De Saussure, Roland Barthes and Charles Peirce, which has essentially enabled the relationship between signs and the creation of meaning to be examined. Through this essay, I will be applying numerous semiotic theories and terminology to analyse the meaning, function and

European Union, Theories and Analysis

1233 words - 5 pages As a whole, the EU seems to be doing quite well -- but analysis of each member state is somewhat different (Letiche, 2002). the EU region and has also become less dependent on external demand and more dependent on the Euro-area domestic economy (Letiche, 2002). in addition, this type of regionalism has helped to maintain peace, as well as maintained reasonable economic growth rates as well as stronger monetary stability (Letiche, 2002). this is

An Analysis of the theories of Neoclassical and Political Economy and the practicality of each

1547 words - 6 pages Paradigms of NeoclassicalAnd Poltical EconomyIn our society today, there are great disparities between different groups of people. The gaps exist between those in every segment of the world, from those of different religions or nationalities, those of rich or poor families, to those who may or may not be educated. The ways in which economics and societies intermingle dictates virtually every part of our lives, from what we wear and eat, to what

Similarities between the music of Debussy and the painting of Turner

752 words - 3 pages Similarities between the music of Debussy and the painting of Turner      The music of Claude Debussy and the painting of J.M.W. Turner are, in most people's minds, two entirely different things. However, each man was considered the founder of impressionism in his own artform. Impressionism was a movement in late 19th century European art, which was a reflection of the realizations in physics about the properties of

The Differing Methods And Aims Of Malcolm X And Martin Luther King

895 words - 4 pages The Differing Methods And Aims Of Malcolm X And Martin Luther King The methods of Malcolm X and martin Luther King were very different but they shared the same basic aim, to improve the lives of black Americans. Possibly these differences in both aims and methods comes from the differences in the way they were raised, Malcolm X was born Marcus Little in Omah, Nebr. Malcolm X's father was a follower of Marcus Garvey

Theories and their Differences: Analysis of Robert Dahl’s Who Governs, and Robert Michels’ Political Parties

2114 words - 9 pages . Standing in disagreement to Dahl’s conclusions, Michels uses a rather social/psychosocial approach, in order to demonstrate what he though was the true nature of governmental politics, the unavoidable elite-mass relation, and the inevitable sociological tendency towards oligarchy (Michels 1915, 384). Granted, both thinkers have the concept of power embedded at the core of their respective work, a brief analytical analysis is enough to demonstrate

Similar Essays

Nat Turner: A Man Of Courage And Wit         Nat Turner

824 words - 3 pages Nat Turner: A Man of Courage and Wit         Nat Turner is by far one of the most well known slaves in American History. Most people know Nat Turner as the man responsible for a large slave revolt, which took place in August 1831. However, after reading and analyzing “The Confessions of Nat Turner and Other Related Documents,” one is able to get a better picture of Nat Turner himself. In my opinion, Turner has many significant

Turner And The Glorification Of Westward Expansion

1668 words - 7 pages In 1893 when Frederick Jackson Turner delivered his famous essay “The Significance of the Frontier in American History,” the United States had recently fulfilled the goal of Manifest Destiny by finishing its conquest of the West. Westward expansion had been an integral aspect of the American identity and its citizens were left wondering what would continue to propel the United States into the future. At the same time, people were also looking

Symptoms And Diagnosis Of Ullrich Turner Syndrome

646 words - 3 pages Turner’s syndrome (TS) also known as Ullrich- Turner syndrome, is a genetic chromosomal disorder that affects roughly about 1 in 2,000 live born female infants. This disorder is caused by the absence genetic material from one of the sex chromosomes during fetal development, other developmental problems occurs after birth. Sex chromosomes are: X and Y, which are responsible for developing either (XY) male or (XX) female. A male fetus inherits the

Motivational Theories And Analysis

1254 words - 5 pages Introduction: In this literature review, assess, discuss the body of knowledge available for motivational theories and analysis in the same order of their importance in our current study. In this case, we tried to provide an overview of research in this respect and the gaps in the sequence, where to find the way for future studies in this area. We will strengthen existing research on what managers can do to write their employees and the factors