This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of Veiwpoints On Tragedy

866 words - 3 pages

Analysis of veiwpoints on tragedy

The question of what defines tragedy has been an issue addressed by several different literary minds since the day of Aristotle, the first person to define tragedy. When Aristotle first defined tragedy he believed tragedy was something reserved for a person of noble stature. He said this person was eventually brought down by a tragic flaw, hence the term tragedy. Robert Silverberg agrees with Aristotle’s views on tragedy, but other authors don’t accept Aristotle’s view so easily. Arthur Miller for example Believes any common man can be tragic, not just the nobility. And Richard Sewall, takes a view that’s a bit different all together.

Aristotle was, as far as we know, the first person to define tragedy, and his definition has been forced down school kid’s throats year after year ever since. Aristotle said a hero was a person of noble stature that was good, but far from perfect. A tragic flaw in the person’s character then led to misfortune that they didn’t completely deserve, and eventually the character’s complete downfall. Aristotle said that the character accepted his fate, and that it wasn’t all bad. Aristotle’s view that the character’s misfortune was not fully deserved, but that the character was responsible for their downfall seems slightly hypocritical, but who am I to criticize Aristotle’s opinions.

Robert Silverberg describes a tragic character as, “a man (or sometimes a woman) of great capability and attainment and ambition, who attempts great things and ultimately fails in his attempt, overreaching himself and loosing all because of some inherent fundamental flaw in his character” (Silverberg, 6). Robert Silverberg’s opinion of tragedy completely coincides with Aristotle. He doesn’t form any new opinions, and his lack of creativity and originality really makes his article “Roger and John” undeserving of mention in this paper.

Of the four opinions reviewed here I like Arthur Miller’s the most. In Miller’s “Tragedy and the Common Man” Miller states, “I believe that common people are as apt subjects for tragedy in its highest sense as monarchs are” (Miller, 16). While the others who have written their own definition have reserved tragedy for the noble, I like the fact that Miller doesn’t feel that tragedy is something too good for the ordinary man. He defines tragic characters as people, “who are ready to lay down their lives, if need be, to secure one thing – their sense of personal dignity” (Miller, 16). Miller also believes that the character is not brought down by a tragic flaw of their own,...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of veiwpoints on tragedy

The Tragedy of King Lear Analysis

2197 words - 9 pages The Tragedy of King Lear Analysis Lear: By Jupiter, I swear no! Kent: By Juno, I swear ay. In The Tragedy of King Lear, particularly in the first half of the play, Lear continually swears to the gods. He invokes them for mercies and begs them for destruction; he binds both his oaths and his curses with their names. The older characters—Lear and Gloucester—tend view their world as strictly within the moral framework of the pagan

The Tragedy on the Street of Flowers

2628 words - 11 pages José Maria Eça de Queirós, though not worldly renowned, is arguably the greatest Portuguese novelist of his time. In 1877, he wrote a novel titled “The Tragedy of the Street of Flowers” (“The Tragedy”); however, it was not published until many years following his death. The novel is a tragic love story about a cocotte (prostitute) named Genoveva de Molineux and a lawyer named Vítor da Silva. The story follows the love between these two

Analysis of the Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart

1080 words - 5 pages “The Twisted Tragedy Of Miss Natalie Stewart” 1 ) The story “The Twisted Tragedy of Miss Natalie Stewart” is about a 17 year old girl named Natalie Stewart leaving New York City with her 18 year old Jonathan boyfriend to go find answers. At the very beginning of the story it takes place on a train. Natalie and Jonathan are running away from the supernatural demons, spirits, and ghost that seems to follow them everywhere they go. In the very

Analysis of Greek Tragedy Using the Aristotilean Model

1339 words - 5 pages the tragedy is. It cannot be so long, however, as that the memory can not take in the entire performance. Aristotle also gives a history of plays and of the innovations and developments they have undergone. Aeschylus was responsible for the first innovation in classic tragedies, reducing the number in the chorus to 12-15, which previously was around fifty, and introducing a second actor on stage. Sophocles later introduced the third character

Literary Analysis: Arthur Miller’s “Death of a Salesman” – A Tragedy?

1564 words - 6 pages description of a practice as it should be continued” therefore, Aristotle’s definition of tragedy could be considered complex. On the other hand, according to Tony Hunt in “The Tragedy of Roland”, “in the Poetics Aristotle is particularly concerned with capturing the essence of tragedy and its effects. The ergon and teleos of drama, he declares, is its specific pleasure, and this pleasure I identify with what we may call tragic emotion”. However

The Heart of Tragedy Based on Oedipus Rex

751 words - 4 pages tragic play. According to Aristotle, plot is one of the most important components of a tragedy. It must have a clear beginning, middle, and a cascade of events leading to the ending. The incentive moment in Oedipus Rex is when Creon comes back from visiting the oracle at Delphi with news on how to rid Thebes of the plague which starts the search for the murderer of the previous king. The climax of the play takes place when Oedipus realizes he is

Character analysis of Hamlet as a tragic hero in Shakespeare's "Tragedy of Hamlet: Prince of Denmark"

740 words - 3 pages Hamlet is not the usual tragic hero that Shakespeare liked to use in his works. In "The Tragedy of Hamlet: Prince of Denmark" he does not die an evil man, but is complemented by Horatio and Fortinbras. There are many different thoughts on what Hamlet's tragic flaw is; jealousy, inaction, and insanity are all accepted as possibilities. Jealously and inaction are very plausible, but Hamlet was not insane.Hamlet is in love with his mother Gertrude

Analysis of the Prologue in The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet

2061 words - 8 pages Analysis of the Prologue in The Tragedy of Romeo and Juliet William Shakespeare's classical play 'The tragedy of Romeo and Juliet' begins with a prologue. Unlike most prologues this one is in the form of a sonnet. Sonnets usually consist of 14 lines, the prologue of 'Romeo and Juliet' follows this structure. In this sonnet the 14 lines are divided up into 3 sections of 4 lines and the last section is made up of 2 lines

Analysis of Ambition in The Tragedy of Macbeth by Willaim Shakespeare

748 words - 3 pages on the power of ambition. He shows the audience how you can gain something with dark mindset and loose ambition, but also with blameless ambition. Shakespeare does not make the point that ambition is evil, rather that it can be used indefinitely to achieve things in an evil manner. Therefore, Shakespeare teaches us the dangers of unchecked ambition. Because of this the central theme of The Tragedy of Macbeth is the ethic diminishing power of

Analysis of various Greek plays, including Antigone. Discussing the role of Greek Tragedy - Westview/Hillview - Essay

1393 words - 6 pages Ancient Greek Tragedy Every good story that speaks to the human spirit has conflict. The best stories have various kinds of conflict, and some of those struggles are internal, rooted in the psyches of fascinating characters. The Greeks developed internal conflict within their main characters so well that the the tragedies themselves are riveting. Unlike modern literature where characters are typically torn between a choice of what is right

Character Analysis of Marcus Brutus: "The Tragedy of Julius Caesar" by William Shakespeare

766 words - 3 pages William Shakespeare's play, "The Tragedy of Julius Caesar", ismainly based on the assassination of Julius Caesar. The characterwho was in charge of the assassination was, ironically, Marcus Brutus,a servant and close friend to Julius Caesar. But what would cause aperson to kill a close friend? After examining Brutus' relationship toCaesar, his involvement in the conspiracy, and his importance to theplot, the truth can be revealed.Marcus Brutus

Similar Essays

Analysis On Greek Tragedy

883 words - 4 pages Greek Tragedy Greek Tragedy The Ancient Greek Tragedy is a form of art based on human suffring that offers audience pleasure. The word `tragedy' appears to have been used to describe different phenomena at different times. It has being a tradition of drama that has played a unique and important role in history; from its obscure origins in the theatres of Athens 2500 years ago to the more recent `social' realism and tragedy

An Analysis Of The Influence Of Tragedy On The Innocent

2867 words - 12 pages with. They are boys of multiple intelligences. Both boys are much more mature than others around them and being able to recognize and question why different events in life occur is an excellent way to deal with grief. These analytical skills will help Charlie and Holden understand the tragedy in their lives and eventually move on Throughout their respective journey’s, Holden and Charlie meet numerous different characters who touch their lives in

Analysis Of The Tragedy Of "Othello"

981 words - 4 pages Untitled Analysis of the Tragedy of "Othello" William Shakespeare is considered to be among the greatest playwrights that have ever lived. He has written dozens and dozens of brilliant plays, most of those plays have been made into movies. One such play that has been made into a movie is "Othello." The play "Othello" is one of Shakespeare's greatest tragedies. It is about a black general in the

Analysis Of The Tragedy Of "Othello"

981 words - 4 pages Untitled Analysis of the Tragedy of "Othello" William Shakespeare is considered to be among the greatest playwrights that have ever lived. He has written dozens and dozens of brilliant plays, most of those plays have been made into movies. One such play that has been made into a movie is "Othello." The play "Othello" is one of Shakespeare's greatest tragedies. It is about a black general in the