Analysis Of Wal Mart's Approach To Employee Management Using Shrm Boxell/Purcell Model

2426 words - 10 pages

In the past it was noted by Snell, Youngy and Wright (1996:62) that organisations would purposely 'take human resource out of the strategic equation'. Today it is widely accepted that linking HR to strategy because of a shift in ideas concerning competition and firm advantage (Snell, Shauder and Wright (2001:3)). This shift was identified by Quin (1992:241) "with rare exceptions, the economic and producing power of the firm lies more in its intellectual and service capabilities than in its hard assets"Wal-Mart are aware of this and so by examining Wal-Marts practices using the 'best fit' perceptive will give a better understanding as to why they have adopted their various practices by linking them to their key organisational strategy and will also help to explain their stance on unionisation.The 'best fit' school (Boxell & Purcell (2000), covers a range of ideas, perspectives and models that are based on the practice of fitting HR Strategy into the organisations surroundings.This school has been broken into two groups identified by Baird and Meshoulam (1988). The 'external fit' deals with integration with the organisation competitive strategy and 'internal fit' which concentrates on the idea of using a combination of factors that should work together forming consistency within HRM.Miles and Snow (1994) developed an 'external fit' framework which linked HR Strategies to competitive strategy. They defined three types of strategic behaviour and I would suggest Wal-Mart are 'analyzers' (A mix of prospectors and defenders). They concern themselves with innovation (Wal-Mart were one of the first organisation to use stock-based-ordering and have the largest organisation IT system in the retail world) and succeed through new market opportunities (Wal-Mart aim to enter a new country every financial year) like 'Prospectors' while still maintaining a core base (Wal-Mart brand), a trait of 'Defenders'. In terms of HR 'analysers' are concerned with recruitment as well as development. Wal-Mart has had to be concerned with their recruitment because of their high staff turnover (between 44%-66%). However this is balanced by having development programs for both employees and graduates (70% of their store management started in hourly positions and developed into a managerial role ( (2005))).Schuler and Jackson (1987) have developed a more widely cited model. Their work deals with connections between organisation strategy and desired employee behaviour. They argue that companies should generate HR strategies to reinforce desired behaviours that relate to organisation strategies outlined by Porter (1985) (Competitive advantage through cost leadership or differentiation).Despite criticism from people such as Miller (1992) and the large number of examples (Crinshaw, Davis and Kay (1994), Murray (1988)), that many of the most successful firms in their sectors are 'all-rounders' (Good at both Porter's (1985) differentiation/cost leadership skills), I...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of WalMart's Approach To Employee Management Using SHRM Boxell/Purcell Model

Analysis of Greek Tragedy Using the Aristotilean Model

1339 words - 5 pages several terms, as well as an analysis of tragedies by Aristotle, a philosopher who experienced them firsthand. By knowing the structural basis of tragic works before reading them, one is able to better understand them and appreciate them more fully for the prized trophies of classic literature they are. First of all, one must realize that tragedies were first written for the stage. Although the exact atmosphere of an ancient performance is rarely

Management of Employee Relations Essay

2647 words - 11 pages senior management ever had appraisals. Therefore the HR Department suggests changing from the currently dominating Shannon-Weaver model to Ober's communication approach in order to provide the possibility of feedback. It is vital to communicate with our employees with the same reasonable care as we operate with our clients.3.2 Employee involvement and participationA more and more common managerial control technique is 'employee involvement and

Supply Chain Management Approach Analysis

964 words - 4 pages This case study discusses a supply chain management approach analysis and describes how project managers should implement business processes to understand the importance of a successful project implementation. The case analyzes the “topics related to financial management, accounting, procurement, sales, marketing, contracts, manufacturing, distribution, logistics, the supply chain, strategic planning, tactical planning, operations management

Using Scaffolding Approach to Teaching Literacy

1642 words - 7 pages literacy should be done in steps, similar to the concept of scaffolding. Rodrigues and Smith (2014) claim that using a scaffolding approach to teaching literacy provide learners with a foundation, and prepares learners for the next step. Learners should be provided with modeled, guided, and independent teaching. In modeled teaching, scaffolding is direct and teacher led (New South Wales Department of Education and Training, 2009). Modeled teaching

Case Analysis Using the Eight-Step Model

1509 words - 7 pages Case Analysis Using the Eight-Step Model The eight-step module is a framework tool used to help analyze and assist you in thinking through an ethical dilemma. After Koch Industries acquired Georgia-Pacific, they immediately took steps to transfer its unique and highly ethical culture to their new “family member.” Tom Butz along with a few other Koch employees and Georgia-Pacific employees were in charge of getting the transition started

Model of employee involvements in decision making

1038 words - 4 pages for me because there were some parts that I was not very skilled at. I had to make a decision on whether I should hold another meeting to talk about the distribution of work and re-assign these critical parts to the persons who knew more about it than I.Causal AnalysisThe model that I will be using to analyze these events is the model of employee involvements in decision making. The model will explain that the level of employee involvement in

An assessment of the BEST model and its approach to teamwork:

1761 words - 7 pages Table of Contents 1. Introduction: 2 2. Nature of the project: 2 3. An assessment of the BEST model and its approach to teamwork: 2 3.1. An overview of the BEST model in respect of teamwork: 2 3.2. Comparing the components of management quality to the BEST model: 2 3.2.1. Employee Development: 2 3.2.2. Communication: 2 3.2.3. Performance Measurement: 2 3.2.4. Employee participation: 3 3.2.5. Integration: 3 3.2.6. Delegation: 3 3.2.7. Direction

A Model-Driven Architecture Approach to the Efficient Identigication of Services on Service-orientated Enterprise Architecture

1288 words - 5 pages little research into an effective approach to identifying the right services to be implemented in the SOEA using approaches such as Model Driven Architecture (MDA). Our research emphasizes the importance of defining the 'right' service because poor design decisions made here can result in compromises affecting the entire service–oriented enterprise. The ‘right’ service is assumed to provide an optimal level of granularity that does not interfere

Why Strategic Human Resource Management (SHRM) is so important? How is human resource management (HRM) strategic to gain competitive advantage?

2924 words - 12 pages quality, customer service, productivity, employee involvement, and teamwork and workforce flexibility.(Source: the shift from personnel management to SHRM was required by the need for a more professional approach, and increasing demand of organizations for more strategic, integrative and accountable approaches to HR activities. And also the further development of SHRM concepts is to equip

Using Environmental Fit Model to Analyze Client

3237 words - 13 pages sons (i.e. food, clothes). Through her challenges, she has been able connect with her own therapist as well as work with me through weekly family psychotherapy. In essence, I have been able to help them to improve their level of fit by doing some of the following:Assisted them to develop more adaptive behaviors (i.e. develop an individual and family time management plan, create activities to improve in their communication).Encouraged them to be

A Servant Leader’s Approach to Employee-Centric Operations

2234 words - 9 pages . As uncomfortable as it may be to sit close to someone, that someone is a teammate. Moreover, we have a difficult mission to execute which requires the support and interaction of those sitting next to one another. This focus on relationships to accomplish missions echoes Fielder’s Leadership Model, which favors employee-centered leadership orientation (Lussier & Achua, 2012). Not because he elevates his personnel over the primacy of the mission

Similar Essays

Simulation Of Apparent Heat Release Rate In Dici Engine Using Load Correction Factor In Double Wiebe Function Model –A Generic Approach

895 words - 4 pages to premixed and diffusion combustion phase. Figure 5 - Comparison of fuel energy release between premixed and diffusion combustion phase. Figure 6 - Comparison of premixed combustion fuel energy between earlier and present simulation. Fig – 7 Comparison of simulated heat release rate curves. 6. CONCLUSION Heat release rates are synthesized by applying load correction factor in double Wiebe function model for all power outputs. They have

Analysis Of Marks And Spencer's Overall Approach To Employee Relations

2292 words - 9 pages IntroductionIn this report I will be analysing Marks and Spencer's overall approach to employee resourcing. In particular its approach to human resource planning, its recruitment and selection methods, and its reward and performance management practices and how issues of diversity and health and safety are managed. Firstly, I will be introducing the company's background, strategy, structure and culture.Company BackgroundWith more than 120 years

Walmart's Ethics Or Lack Of And Employee Dissatisfaction

1708 words - 7 pages leads to the unethical practices Wal-Mart has in place such as their “Open Door Policy” which encourages employees to take their complaints straight to management. This may essentially seem like a good idea, but many argue that it opens the door (no pun intended) for repercussions from management. Without no third party representation, an employee could find themselves out of the job and without any means to defend themselves. The associates joke

Analysis Of William Wallace Using The “Psychoanalytic Approach”

714 words - 3 pages William Wallace Hero or Herod?An Analysis of William Wallace using the "Psychoanalytic Approach""William Wallace, a murderer, a runaway, a patriot, or a thief?" William Wallace led one of the first Scottish revolts against the English in the early 14th Century. His army defeated a much larger and much more powerful English army at Stirling Bridge, they captured Stirling Castle, and then ravaged northern England, for which Wallace was knighted