This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Of Ways Of War And Peace

1258 words - 6 pages

Michael W. Doyle’s book Ways of War and Peace systematically analyzes classic theories like realism and liberalism that try to explain why nations wage war. However, not all theories discussed within the text are equal. In this paper I will try to argue that within the book written by Michael Doyle he paints a picture that the theory of realism is more applicable today then liberalism, even if that was not his original intention. Through careful evaluation I will prove that not only is realism a more pragmatic and realistic approach for the present time compared to liberalism, but I will also argue that fundamentalism is the best of Michael Doyle’s four different forms of realism.
To begin with, there must be an examination of what both of these major theories are. Initially let us look at the paradigm of realism. When Doyle launches into his discussion on realism he makes sure to mention how the Greek philosophical historian Thucydides is considered the father of realism due to the positions he takes in his book History. What Thucydides understood is that nations are always constantly sizing each other up and internally debating how much power they can obtain. When describing Thucydides opinion on international relations Doyle writes, “[i]nterstate relations in his view exist in a condition where war is always possible” (Doyle 51). This view still holds true today. Even allies such as Germany and the United States are currently in a state of apprehension due to the National Security Agency’s blatant disregard for civil liberties. Examples like the one previously stated are littered throughout history and includes political figures who have been considered followers of liberalism. This is a direct reference to Bill Clinton, who Doyle says, “[made] ‘democratic enlargement’ the doctrinal centerpiece of his administration’s foreign policy” (Doyle 205), yet when Clinton was dealing with Bosnia-Herzegovina during his presidency he was hesitant to become to involved due to the detrimental effect it could have on the United States military (Mann). Clinton, like other politicians, still put his country’s well-being above everything else even though he proposed liberalistic policies which helps strengthen my position that realism is a more applicable paradigm then liberalism.
Next, what is Doyle’s belief on liberalism? He states within his text that, “Liberal states [...] founded on such individual rights as equality before the law, free speech and other civil liberties, private property, and elected representation, are fundamentally against war” (Doyle 206). Basically, people who adhere to the liberalist concept believe that by having states who are based on freedom allows for a state of peace to exist amongst different nations. This is in direct opposition to the realist perspective that believes all states are in a perpetual state of war. One vindicator of why I believe that the liberalism paradigm is unrealistic because states who operate...

Find Another Essay On Analysis of Ways of War and Peace

War and Peace: An Analysis of Metafiction in the Post-Modern World

1040 words - 4 pages The diversity summit was an interesting experience in that it presents diversity as a topic that is not only nuanced, but multi-faceted. Prior to the retreat I had anticipated an event which would entail discussion primarily on political correctness and how to respond to and respect issues of diversity. Dr. Cullen managed to counteract my preconceived notions, stating that the increased focus on political correctness—the over analysis of the

The Effects of War and Peace on Foreign Aid

1181 words - 5 pages these countries depend on outside aid from other developed countries and during war become scarce and during peace time aid resumes. The country of Sierra Leone has been through many times of peace, war and rebuilding. The best way to look at how foreign aid has helped or hurt Sierra Leone is to look at the economic growth. It is how much of the world determines if the country is developing for the better of its citizens or is dire need of

A War Ridden Childhood: Analysis Comparing Lord of the Flies by William Golding and a Separate Peace by John Knowles

1133 words - 5 pages their own until rescued. Within Lord of the Flies by William Golding, several hints of war and symbols of war are dropped periodically throughout the time that the Ralph and the boys are stuck on the island. In A Separate Peace by John Knowles, the setting is an school in America taking place during a war. The schoolboys are about juniors in high school and are being directly influenced by the ongoing war such as preparing the seniors into

The Power of Interior Monologues in War and Peace

2740 words - 11 pages        War and Peace probed into the human essence and its search for the truths of life. Tolstoy focused on two men to represent and carry the burden of finding those ethereal values. Throughout the novel, he utilized numerous images, symbols, dialogue, and foreshadowing to advance the progress of his characters. Yet, his most effective use of technical device can be found in describing the psychological thoughts and interior monologues of

Dreams of War and Peace: The Civil Rights Movement

1616 words - 7 pages attendances set by Malcolm’s protests. Nor any protest we have seen since then (Martin Luther King JR.). It is very hard to compare MLK and Malcolm X’s protest techniques, because they are completely opposite. One is based on violence and the other peace. This is why the two are not compared often. So the only logical way to compare the two is to look at the outcome. Both MLK and Malcolm X had a lot of success in their efforts; however, there is

Analysis of Men and War

2785 words - 11 pages often exempt from our world. There are defined enemies, a clear line drawn between good and bad, and we may be powerful and violent for the sake of righteous ideas. "The war story is a way to exemplify good angels and bad, to exercise our fears, and find some comfort in the inevitable triumph of right over wrong," (strangewords.com). There are three main areas that come to mind under the heading "Men as they are portrayed in war". These

The Sociology Analysis of Food and Food Ways

1816 words - 7 pages Sociology is the study of society and people. Food and food ways are often elements associated with particular societies and therefore, studying such a topic can offer valuable insight into the ways of that society and the people who live in it. Although eating is a vital part of survival, with whom, how and where we eat are not. Studying such ways can illustrate and represent the identity of a person or group. The nature of people and their

Tolstoy's War and Peace

974 words - 4 pages Tolstoy's War and Peace Summary War and Peace tells the story of the Rostovs, an upper-class family in Russia, and several people associated with them. It follows the characters through fifteen years during the Napoleonic Wars, from 1805 to 1820. It gives a fictional description of the events in the life of the Rostov family as well as some of the historical events of the time. Analysis Tolstoy is regarded by some as the

war and peace

1123 words - 4 pages waged and fought and when that somehow ended, the United Nations Organization was formed as a forum to find ways and means for a lasting Universal Peace.But, somehow, in spite of all pious intentions the war clouds still hover over the horizons in this part of the world or that and permanent peace seems just a dream worthy to be fulfilled but not fully fulfilled.When there is a war and when it ends, one power is the victor and the other the

War And Peace

840 words - 4 pages The Russian epic War and Peace hails as one of the most highly acclaimed novels ever composed. Written by Leo Tolstoy and first published in 1869, the novel presents itself as a panorama of Russian society during the Napoleonic Wars. Throughout the work, Tolstoy illustrates the divide between the reality of war and the naïve and false perceptions of battle perceived by those who know only peace. War and Peace offers a vast depiction of

War and peace

1139 words - 5 pages The humanity has come into the Third Millenium having lots of non-solved problems, barring and experiencing all consequences and results of severe wars of the previous centuries. It was right said that peace is the period of time between wars and according to the history of humankind those period never last long. We all know and realize what can wars result in further, then why do wars start? Why do people fight with each other at the bequest of

Similar Essays

The So Called 'road Map To Peace' Looks In Many Ways More Like A 'road Map To War'. How Far Would You Agree With This Assessment Of Us Efforts To Settle The Palestinian Question?

2845 words - 11 pages Israel we see an argument over land, between Judaism and Islam, and also between Israelis and Arabs - a conflict of the worst possible kind, fuelled by the conviction of each party that they and they alone are the rightful owners of the 'promised land' It is evident that any peace process must take this into account - one sidedness will certainly only result in war, as has been demonstrated by the 'Road Map to Peace'. It is inadequate to ignore

Dreams Of War And Peace Essay

1156 words - 5 pages attendances set by Malcolm’s protests. Nor any protest we have seen since then (Martin Luther King JR). It is very hard to compare MLK and Malcolm X’s protest techniques, because they are completely opposite. One is based on violence and the other peace. This is why the two are not compared that often. So the only logical way to compare the two is to look at the outcome. Both MLK and Malcolm X had a lot of success in their efforts; however there is one

An Analysis Of Ssr And Sustainable Peace In Post War And Politically Transitioning Countries

1504 words - 7 pages Throughout history, people have desired peace. Whether it be peace after a war, or transitioning from a dictatorship to a democracy, sustainable peace is constantly needed. Not only does sustainable peace refer to the absence of war, it includes the absence of violence as well. In order to achieve reform with sustainable peace, participation from all citizens is necessary. Though most of the peace building occurs among the top political

An Analysis Of Arthur Link's Book, Woodrow Wilson Revolution, War, And Peace

1509 words - 6 pages In his book, “Woodrow Wilson Revolution, War, and Peace” by Arthur Link, Link walks step by step through President Woodrow Wilson’s career beginning from the time he was born and focuses on his role during and after World War I. Through his entire book, Link acts as an apologist for the actions of Wilson as well as argues against the opinions of other historians. Link speaks about Wilson almost as if he idolizes him; as if despite what other