Analysis On Descartes' God Existence Proof

893 words - 4 pages

The objective of this paper is to examine Descartes' argument for the existence of God. To do this we firstly have to review Descartes' proof of God existence. And after this we will see what objections can his theories hold.Descartes set out to build a set of arguments designed to prove God's existence. His goal in proving God's existence had to be incontestable, there could not be any doubt. Descartes started by renouncing all his beliefs, so that he would not be shrouded by any misconceptions from reaching the truth. He notices that he has to doubt all of his established ideas, so he needed a starting point, from which he can base his theories. Descartes resolved that he could not doubt that he doubted, he could not doubt that he thinks. Then he could come up with the "Cogito ergo sum", (I think therefore I am), now he was able to proof his own existence. So the next point was finding out what he was, he knows he exists because he thinks, so at least I must be something that things a "res cogitans". Descartes employs another interesting rule for his judgement. That objective reality cannot exist without formal reality; that is to say that an idea cannot originate without a cause. And that ideas can be less perfect than their cause but never more. Does that mean that according to Descartes, it can not be any concept without its form on the reality (cause)?Descartes, now try to proof god's existence, so god will make sure that the reality that it is in front of us is true, so no "evil being" can makes us wrong. After establishing those rules, he realizes that he is not perfect. He knows that because he doubts, and therefore he can come up with the idea (the form) of perfection. According to this Descartes determines that such an idea must have a formal reality, a cause. If something made me think on the perfection as a Supreme Being this idea must exist because there must be as much reality on the cause than on the effect, therefore god must exist. According to this theory, anything that I came up with on my mind should exist. This does no have much sense to me.Another important point on Descartes explanation is the one based on the perfection concept and its consequences. God is perfect, and the existence is a perfection, therefore if god is perfect, god exists. How do we know that god is perfect?, we assumed that its perfect because its definition says so, and how do we know if the definition is right, does it mean that if...

Find Another Essay On Analysis on Descartes' God existence proof

Descartes Third Meditation: Proof of Gods Existence

1350 words - 5 pages prove the existence of God. The purpose of this essay will be to state and explain Descartes' Third Meditation: Proof of God's Existence by identifying relevant concepts and terminology and their relationship to each other and examining each premise as well as the conclusion of the proof and finally to comment on the significance of the proof in the context of the Evil Genius assumption. In order to begin explaining the meaning and significance

Proof For the Existence of God

1531 words - 6 pages Proof For the Existence of God From the diversity of men and creatures on this earth, there has always been one unifying link. At the root of humanity’s existence, lies the root of all things natural and infinite, a hint of something supreme and purposeful, something incomprehensible; a glimpse of what is real and what is possible. Inspired by wonder one can easily be surprised by the doubts presented as to the existence and identity of this

Descartes and the Existence of God

1181 words - 5 pages Descartes and the Existence of God Once Descartes has realized that he can know with certainty that “I exist” is true, he continues to build on his foundation of truths. The truth about the nature of God, proof of God’s existence, and the nature of corporeal objects are considered, among others, after Descartes proves his existence. Descartes’ principal task in the Meditations was to devise a system that would bring him to the truth. He

Descartes Argument for the Existence of God

1209 words - 5 pages existence of God and the existence of a mountain. Finite things, says Descartes, have possible or contingent existence. For example, a finite thing such as a mountain relies on volcanic forces and weathering to bring it in and out of existence. Necessary existence on the other hand is contained in the idea of God. Therefore, God does not need anything to bring him in and out of existence. Descartes goes on to say that if God’s existence was

Descartes: The Father of Modern Philosophy on the Existence of God

1137 words - 5 pages reality must come from an infinite source or a formal reality: a God [3].After he discovers his ability to doubt and to understand, he is able to substantiate his necessary existence as a consequence. What we doubt or understand may not ultimately correspond, but we can never be uncertain that we are in the process of thought. This idea is a major component in Descartes' proof of the external world.He relies on the existence of a non-deceiving God to

Rene Descartes In Proving the Existence of God

1332 words - 5 pages by using reason, and it is near futile todeduce that the human existence is separable into two different parts.The first argument Descartes gives for the proof of God's existence relies on the content and cause of ideas. He contendsthat ideas have to come from somewhere. Do they come from within oneself, from the outside world, or are they innate? Sincehis idea of God was an infinite being, the cause of the idea must also be infinite. The more

Existence of God. A look at Rene Descartes' theory

1307 words - 5 pages with all the modern technologies and the development of sciences, we still do not have a definitive answer to the question 'does God exist?'Among many philosophers and scholars who have tried to answer this question, we shall look upon Rene Descartes' theory on the existence of God. In terms of believers and non-believers, Descartes would be one of the believers. Before we go any further, we must ponder upon several questions. What is God? Does God

The Existence of God: the Arguments of Locke and Descartes

1366 words - 5 pages in more far-reaching explications than Descartes. Locke proves the existence of God in the way the mind forms ideas from sensation and reflection and in the overt manifestation of man's will. Conclusion: I understand and accept both treatises of Descartes and Locke on the existence of God. Both philosophers have tried to establish God's existence from the most basic and elementary preponderance of proof--starting with the absolute

Criticisms of Descartes Meditations Concerning the Existence of God

2406 words - 10 pages option is that God is the creator, and is thus the proof of his existence. Additionally, in respect to the malicious demon thought to corrupt Renatus’ ideas, because a deceiver depends on defective traits, and because God is free of imperfections, he therefore cannot be a deceiver (52). In the fifth meditation, another proof for the existence of God is put forth. Descartes says that because he can envision the existence of God in the same manner

Descartes' Fifth Meditation This essay provides insight into Descartes' Fifth Meditation and the existence of God

629 words - 3 pages belief in God relies upon the fact He is perfect. Descartes' says that he cannot think of God in any other manner. He is incapable of thinking of God as not existing, hence God must exist. The idea of God is that of a supreme and perfect being, He is perfect in every single infinite aspect, and thus must exist, as existence is one of His perfections. Subsequently, just the thought of God, Descartes' argues, is proof enough of his existence.In a

Analysis of St. Agustine´s View on the Existence of God

1221 words - 5 pages reasoning capability. St-Augustine argued that there is nothing more exalted in human beings than “reason”. He describes that if anything can be found exalted than our nature to reason, is nothing except God. His philosophy portrays that existence of God is related to faith, which our reasoning nature may fail to conclude on its part. The reason of this failure is further elaborated by St. Augustine; he states that everything changes in this world

Similar Essays

Descartes Proof For The Existence Of God

1542 words - 6 pages whole are undeniable. In his work he was very modest, always states himself no more gifted than anyone, but we can feel arrogance in his conclusions. For example, only his method would deliver humanity, he will complete the debate of God’s existence, his judgment is right to describe characteristics of God, etc. I think Descartes succeeded in some parts of his proof for the existence of God, but failed in proving God’s existence from a logical point of view. The fact that there are educated men of all religions proves that anybody can be right in his own description of existence of God. Rene Descartes, Discourse on Method and Meditations on First Philosophy.

Descartes' Proof For The Existence Of God

4707 words - 19 pages . There is, at the least, the distinction between ininite and finite substance; among finite s ubstances souls are presumably higher on the Chain than bodies; and then below bodies, one has modes and accidents. Even such an abbreviated Chain of Being is sufficient for the purposes of Descartes' proof for the existence of God. Representation -- Am I alone? Descartes next takes up the nature of representation. He is considering the possibility that

Descartes Proof Of God. This Examines Descartes' Argument For The Existence Of God

1282 words - 5 pages we perceive the idea of God, for if it was not clear and distinct then it would not necessarily be true. But the clarity and distinctness of our thoughts depends on the existence of God. This seems to me a very circular argument and can hardly survive as a proof. Descartes said right from the beginning of the meditation that he has the idea of a perfect being and that he is imperfect. This leads into the second problem I have with Descartes

Assignment 1: Sketch Briefly Descartes’ Proof For The Existence Of God. What Possible Objections Can You Raise Against This Proof?

880 words - 4 pages 1. Introduction Descartes’ argument for the existence of God relies on the untenable notion of a substance of perfection and that it can be predicated of God. In this essay Descartes’ arguments for the existence of God will be briefly expounded, and then objections against his methodology employed in order to establish the proof of God, will be discussed. 2. Proof of God God takes on a crucial place in Descartes’ philosophy. He was certain of