This website uses cookies to ensure you have the best experience. Learn more

Analysis Thomas Hobbes?S Claim ?A State Of Nature Is, Or Would Be, A State Of War Of Everyone Against Everyone.?

1422 words - 6 pages

Thomas Hobbes argues that a state of nature will eventually become a state of war of everyone against everyone. According the Hobbes, the main reason behind this change will be the harsh competition over scarce resources caused by the nature of man. Through out this essay Hobbes’s reasons will be explained in greater detail.
     In order to truly understand the logic behind Hobbes’s claim, we must first understand his point of view of human nature. The key element in Hobbes’s view on human nature was the importance of desires. Unlike many other philosophers such as Plato and Aristotle, Hobbes had a different approach to desires. He believed desires were real motive behind human behaviors. (Leviathan, p119) What motivated human actions were not virtues such as wisdom as Aristotle and Plato would claim, nor was it a sense of duty as Cicero would say. It was rather simple desire. Hobbes did not see desire as a harmful feeling, which must be avoided. He rather thought of it as a positive part of human nature, which could drive a person to achieve more and more.
     Hobbes had a definition of happiness closely connected to desires. Hobbes defined happiness as a “continual successe in obtaining those things which a man from time to time desireth” He used the phrase “felicity” for this definition of happiness. (Leviathan, p.129) Important point here is, there is no limit to this attaining of goods and happiness is a continued process of desire fulfillment, which lasts from birth to death.
     It would not be wrong if we claim all reasonable people would like to live a life of happiness or in other words, a life of felicity. Having accepted Hobbes’s definition of felicity, it can be further said that all people would want a life where all their desires are fulfilled.
     Hobbes argued that despite minor differences, all people were close to being the same in both ability and intelligence. (Leviathan, p.183) Hobbes further stated, because people are close to being the same they also have similar desires. This is the point where the problems begin. All people have similar desires for certain goods as well as the same hope of attaining them but unfortunately most of these desired goods are limited in numbers. Because there aren’t enough resources for everyone to fulfill their desires, people must compete with others to acquire the goods they desire. Because of competition people will see each other as rivals trying to avoid each other as much as possible. Eventually diffidence will spread among men. (Leviathan, p.184) From diffidence a state of anticipation fearing other side will make an attack on them. Hatred and distrust will slowly grow eventually resulting in wars to take place among men. However, we must also understand that these wars are not necessarily wars where actual fighting takes place; it can also be similar to “Cold War” between U.S.A....

Find Another Essay On analysis Thomas Hobbes?s claim ?a state of nature is, or would be, a state of war of everyone against everyone.?

Hobbes and Rousseau's view on a "State of Nature"

529 words - 2 pages Why should people try to avoid returning to a ?state of nature?? Critically compare Hobbes? and Rousseau?s answers to this question.?Man is born free, and everywhere he is in chains.? This quote gives us an idea of Two very important philosophical terms are freedom and authority. These are two terms that affect the human nation all over the world. Our cities and countries are run under the laws of a political body. The famous philosophers Thomas

Separation of Church and State Benefits Everyone

1117 words - 4 pages Two of America’s well known thinkers, Thomas Jefferson and James Madison, created the precedent for how political and ecclesiastical groups would exist autonomously in order to guarantee a favorable outcome for both. To allow for proper functioning and success, an entity must be able to act independently without reliance on another. If one party is disadvantaged, those disadvantages way on both sides. If one party is successful but to the point

Hobbes and Rousseau, The State of Nature

1528 words - 7 pages into a world sans government. Most of us would believe this to be ideal, nobody watching over us, deciding for oneself how to go about many aspects of life. Hobbes also believed everyone to be equal, in both mental capacity and physical prowess, this led him to believe that no natural disability is severe enough to warrant any advances on your fellow man. Hobbes saw this State of Nature as being a perpetual battle royal, pitting all men against

The Leviathan by Thomas Hobbes: The State of Nature as an Exemplum

1648 words - 7 pages against other people, and "a war of all against all" (Lloyd 25).Hobbes proclaims that the state of nature is a state of war, where men "through vanity, or comparison, or appetite, provoke the rest" to violence (Hobbes 78). The three natural causes of conflict between people are competition, diffidence, and glory. People in the state of nature will compete for resources; they will distrust one another, and they will seek glory because of their

Thomas Hobbes' Laws of Nature

807 words - 3 pages the question of obligation comes into question. Does one have an obligation to take a chance and follow the laws set forth for them, or should they only think of themselves, and follow the laws of nature? This is a vital question which I will explore. According to Hobbes, the overriding law of nature is kill or be killed. Hobbes believed that, "every man has a right to everything, even to another man's body. And therefore, as long as this

An Examination of Thomas Hobbes' Moral Philosophy with an Emphasis on the Escape from the State of Nature

996 words - 4 pages any means possible to secure their life and prosperity. In essence, natural man has the right to everything, including the bodies and possessions of others. It is this condition which leads Hobbes to describe the state of nature as a war "of every man against every man".The only way out of the brutish State of Nature is the realization and acceptance of the "Laws of Nature". Unlike moral naturalists, Hobbes disagrees that one can simply observe

The State of Nature

812 words - 4 pages with no laws and little or no government interference. A world with out rules is a notion that many people argue would be a better choice for Americans today. This idea is the very concept behind “The state of nature”. A Lord of the Fly existence where we embrace anarchy is a change, but is it a positive change? What effect will this change have on people, resources and society as a whole? Today I will explain the theory behind the state of

Revolution and State of nature

1407 words - 6 pages In the beginning, there was a darker side to the preservation of life. Man lived a life of kill or be killed, without any regard for other than his own. Life was solitary, poor, brutish and short. This barbaric and primitive state is what Thomas Hobbes believed to be the State of Nature. Practical reason dictates that when threatened you either act, give up your property, or anticipate for a sign of weakness to act. This means that all have a

Thomas Hobbes' Idea of the State and Its Relation with the Citizen

1578 words - 6 pages person is a metaphor for the state in total, and Hobbes names this artificial person "Leviathan." Hobbes's description of the construction of the Leviathan draws upon the conclusions made in Book I about the state of nature and repeats its images: The only way to erect such a Common Power, as may be able to defend them from . . . the injuries of one another . . . is, to conferre all their power and strength

Liberal Nature of Indian State

1321 words - 5 pages Discuss the nature of the Indian state according to liberal perspective.The state is being perceived as an "organised structural and institutional whole" epitomizing the power relations of society. The state in a developing society arise from historical factors and interacts with society through its decisive role in the economic process of the nation.To study the nature of any particular state, it is necessary to analyse to relation between

The State of Nature and its Implications for Civilization in Hobbes and Rousseau

1648 words - 7 pages which men may be drawn to agreement . . . .” These Articles of Peace Hobbes calls “Laws of Nature” and argues that while they do not exist in a state of nature they are nonetheless natural laws which potentially exist there. “A Law of Nature (Lex Naturalis,) is a Precept, or generall Rule, found out by Reason, by which a man is forbidden to do, that, which is destructive of his life, or taketh away the means of preserving the same; and to omit, that

Similar Essays

Thomas Hobbes' State Of Nature In Leviathan

1799 words - 7 pages today. It is his examination of people being equal, followed by the state of nature and war, and finally his look at various laws of nature that lead a natural path to his political solution. Hobbes assertion that all people are equal is no small departure from past political philosophy. It indeed is so revolutionary that some of those that follow Hobbes will assert that various races or genders are of a higher standard innately. Hobbes however

Thomas Hobbes' State Of Nature In Leviathan

841 words - 3 pages According to the view Thomas Hobbes presents within the selected passaged in the Leviathan, we live in a narcissistic society where man’s condition is primarily driven by ego and where the achievement of personal goals is deemed paramount. Within the State of Nature that is, outside of civil society we have a right to all things ‘even to one another’s body’, and there would be no agreed authority to ensure the moral grounds of our decisions

The State Of Nature Is A State Of War

1484 words - 6 pages instead consists of the constant awareness that everyone is ready to fight everyone else. To substantiate his argument that the State of Nature is a Sate of War he relies on three assumptions. The first assumption is that nature has created man to be equal in their capacity to use their body and mind. With equal capacities in body, every man is vulnerable to attack from every other man and no single man has a superior advantage. For Hobbes this

State Of Nature And Freedom: Leviathan By Thomas Hobbes

1793 words - 8 pages that John Locke’s theory on the state of nature and freedom is rational, as it applies to man. Hobbes presents an argument that all men are equal in their natural facilities, that there is no natural inequalities so great as to give a benefit to one, that another cannot claim as well. Hobbes construes the state of nature as a continual war of all against all, where a man can do what ever he can get away with, and continue to do for as long as