Analyze John Hersey's Hiroshima Boston University/Wr100 Essay

1154 words - 5 pages

Justice in Journalism: How Hersey Failed to Capture Emotion in Hiroshima
John Hersey writes on the events immediately following the atomic bomb drop in his 1946 piece, Hiroshima. Hersey uses his journalist background to capture the emotion and utter confusion of the Japanese people affected by the bomb. The goal of Hiroshima was to bring light to the inhumanity of the atomic bomb. However, the events of Hiroshima are a sensitive topic to write about and are tricky to properly portray. This brings up the ethics of writing about the atomic bomb that was dropped on Hiroshima. Dwight MacDonald, an editor, writer, and critic of the time voiced his opinion on the ethics of Hersey’s Hiroshima. He described Hiroshima as “dull, relaxed, puzzling, and lacking any feelings of intensity” (MacDonald 308). Mary McCarthy, a writer and political activist, took her stance on the ethics of Hiroshima as well. McCarthy felt as if the journalistic approach taken by Hersey was not dramatic enough, and she also went on to attack The New Yorker and journalism itself (McCarthy 367). Hersey’s journalistic style and approach to recounting the events of Hiroshima is considered to be dull and inappropriate by many critics. Interviewing the survivors as well as the reporting of facts throughout Hiroshima detach the reader from the feelings of the time and sound scientific. Hersey does include main characters and each of their sufferings to help the reader connect and sympathize with the Japanese, but, Hersey’s undiscriminating tone undermines the reader to character connection. I think Hersey’s style makes his writing seem apathetic and dispassionate. This is why I believe a narrative would have been a better route in showing America the inhumanity and seriousness of the atomic bomb. Thus, Hersey’s Hiroshima does not adequately convey the emotions or turmoil experienced by the Japanese following the atomic bomb drop.
Hersey’s main characters are considered to be safe and normal in order to appeal to the American people he is writing for. Despite this relation, Hersey fails to make a deep, emotional connection between the audience and his characters because he chooses not to do a narrative. The use of multiple characters and interviewing each character diminishes the sympathizing effect on the reader and also does not do the tragic events of Hiroshima any justice. Some of the characters Hersey includes are only seen for a short amount of time. This gives the reader no time to form an emotional bond with the character, further adding to how distant and detached Hersey’s use of journalism makes the reader feel. At the end of chapter 1 in Hiroshima, Miss Sasaki loses consciousness. More specifically, “a human being was crushed by books” (Hersey 16). Hersey does not take the time to further develop Miss Sasaki’s horrific accident caused by the atomic bomb. Rather, he chooses to abruptly end the chapter and not create an emotional bond between the reader and the characters. In a...

Find Another Essay On Analyze John Hersey's Hiroshima - Boston University/WR100 - Essay

John Hersey Essay

1411 words - 6 pages John Hersey was an American child born in China with missionary’s parents. He had a religious upbringing and spoke Chinese. He returned to the United States when he was ten years old and became a well educated man with humanistic views. John Hersey begins his writing career at Time magazine in 1937 after graduating from Yale University in 1936. He was hired by Time magazine after writing an essay criticizing their murky quality. While

The Unnecessary Atomic Bombing of Japan

610 words - 3 pages Hundreds of thousands of innocent Japanese citizens died at the hands of the atomic bomb unleashed by the United States, as told in John Hersey's novel Hiroshima. Hiroshima retells the devastation through six survivors who had to experience the horrendous attack, and the attack's grueling long-term side

Hiroshima

1891 words - 8 pages HiroshimaJohn Hersey was a Pulitzer Prize-winning American writer and journalist. Hersey was born in Tientsin, China. He actually learned how to speak Chinese before English, which is pretty impressive. He came to the United States at the age of ten and attended public schools from then. He eventually graduated from Yale University. His passion was writing and reading, obviously. Hersey was in Japan after World War II, in the year of 1945

Decisions to Drop the Bombs on Japan

850 words - 3 pages conclusion, yet how many would say the bomb was necessary that were near the bomb and experienced the destruction and decay the bomb brought to the land? Not very many.      John Hersey's Hatsuyo Nakamura was written about survivors of the atomic blast in Hiroshima. His work is very powerful in America and after reading his work one can not help feel remorseful for the woman in which Hersey interviews (181). As America being the perpetrator of the

HirosimA

1272 words - 5 pages . Also John Hersey later in the book looks back and talks to the six people in his story forty years after the bomb went off and tells how the explosion and its aftermath effected them, physically and mentally. IV. Theme identification and analysis In this story John Hersey's main theme is about how much a major event in a persons life can change people's lives forever. And in this story the major event is the bombing of Hiroshima on August 6,1945

Hiroshima By John Hersey: A Book Review

1695 words - 7 pages ."John Hersey's Hiroshima is a testament to humanity and its will to survive, to move on,and try desperately to not repeat the tragedies of the past" (Jeffords). Hiroshima shows the besthumanity has to offer in the face of chaos and horror.Works CitedDonaldson-Evans, Catherine, Michael Park, and Amy C. Sims. "City Under Siege." The WarRoom. 23 Feb. 2002 .Hersey, John. Hiroshima. New York: Vintage Books, 1989.Jeffords, Jamie. 12 May 2001. Customer

John Hersey Hiroshima

548 words - 2 pages him, until one day, due to secondary effects of radiation, he passed away.All six people mentioned in John Hersey's book have a thing in common. They all struggled to survive the devastation, and the effects of the atomic bomb. Although they strained to sustain themselves at the beginning of the disaster, they also endured hardships, hunger, discrimination, and bankruptcy. But even so they helped other hibakushas change the courses of their lives, and in doing so they too, changed their lives as well.Reference: Hersey, John. "Hiroshima" Powell books. 1946.1997.

A Sheet of the Sun By Alex Duke

566 words - 2 pages On August 6, 1945, at approximately 8:15 a.m., a "noiseless flash" appeared in the sky over the city of Hiroshima. John Hersey's Hiroshima does a thorough job explaining what life was like just before, during and after "the bomb" was dropped. It also covers what is believed to be the most controversial moral question asked by many around the world: Why did we drop the bomb? Many people have asked this question over the years, but what they don't

Hiroshima and Japan

2312 words - 9 pages Hiroshima on August 6, 1945. Since that date, there have been innumerable accounts of this first use of an atomic weapon. There are Hiroshima diaries, Hiroshima epitaphs, museums and mausoleums to Hiroshima, and Hiroshima notes. But while Hiroshima has left behind records, legacies, and photographs, surprisingly I have yet to discover a history of Hiroshima. In fact, a search of the University of Illinois library holdings in both English and Japanese

Hiroshima: The Right Decision

1036 words - 5 pages the bomb had been dropped, and the war was finished, most Japanese people were in fact “indifferent about the ethics about using the bomb.” Cited in John Hersey's Hiroshima, Mrs. Nakamura, a survivor of the bomb, stated that “It was war and we had to expect it,” later saying “Shikata ga nai,” or “It can’t be helped. Oh, well. Too bad” in English. From these accounts, it is reasonable to inquire, as did Walzer: “If war is hell however it is

Hiroshima, A Journalistic Narrative

2232 words - 9 pages In 1945, John Hersey visited Japan on a journalistic trip sponsored by Life Magazine and the New Yorker to write about Hiroshima and its people. And, of course, the aftermath of the dropping of the Atomic Bomb. When he returned to the U.S. in 1946, the New Yorker was dedicating an entire magazine to Hersey's accounts in Hiroshima. The issue's publication on August 31, 1946, caused America to be in a near chaotic state. Selling out it's entire

Similar Essays

Hiroshima Reaction Essay John Hersey

2401 words - 10 pages not even get to marry the man she loved, a Chinese­American, because she was an A­bomb baby and the father of the man she loved forbid the marriage thinking that she would not be able to conceive and bear a normal child. The Hiroshima incident was not easily forgotten it will always be in their generation. Works Cited: Hersey, John, Warren Chappell, and Edith Goodkind Rosenwald.Hiroshima. New York: A.A. Knopf, 1946. Print.

Optimizing Learning In College John Carroll University Informative Essay

305 words - 2 pages This article is about study habits and the way college students study. Things like time management, effective and ineffective study strategies that students use. It talks about how study strategies such as spacing study sessions and or quizzing yourself. Lots of the things talked about in this article are tip that help you perform better as a student. I am not going to discuss all of the topics in the article but the two points that I found to

John Locke Second Treatise Of Government Analysis Political Science University Of Manitoba Essay

729 words - 3 pages Locke's writing itself, his syntax, word choice, and so on. Oddly enough, John Locke, the great Treatise writer and political philosopher, had a fairly cautious relationship with language. Book III of his very famous Essay Concerning Human Understanding is all about language, and expresses the idea that language should only be used to convey ideas and meanings as simply, clearly, and economically as possible. Locke's Second Treatise is actually quite

Analyse The Relationship Between Hitler And Big Business Liverpool John Moores University Essay

2415 words - 10 pages Analyse the relationship between the Nazis and big business The relationship between the Nazi Party (NSDAP) and big business is one of the most contentious issues of the Nazi regime. The very name ‘The National Socialist Party’ has contributed to many misconceptions of Nazi economic values. This essay will introduce three key arguments. Firstly, during the first three years of Nazi rule, the business boom enabled Hitler to experience a