In 1729, a writer from Oxford, named Jonathan Swift wrote the text A Modest Proposal. Swift’s satirical work was to let the people see the poverty level in the Irish country. He adopts a caring personality for the Irish families in order to show how severe poverty is to those outside of Ireland.
The issue presented is the amount of poverty in the country which has not yet been resolved or dealt with. This problem is due to too many Irish families with many children and lack of government interventions to try and help those in need. The observations done by Jonathan Swift seem to target the governments so they can help the many families. The main point is that something should be done about this and have this issue taken care of. Swift’s argument presented is not a logical or morally correct proposal. The purpose is to mock those people into thinking something good to do to help themselves. Swift begins the ...view middle of the document...
He is a credible person because he incorporates himself into the story to better connect with the audience. In Swift’s text, he shows off his good will about the concerns he has for the country and what he is willing to do for those in poverty. The author’s tone is very sincere towards the topic at hand yet very sarcastic too. His way of thinking appears to be good and what he does for the cause is good but the way he approaches his goal to help those is very ironic and inhumane. Swift used the personal observations to describe the poverty in the country. He brings forth killing and eating babies. This would be the best method since there is an abundance of children and their carcasses can be sold for good profits. He also provides numbers and stats to show how the population will decrease and how poverty will diminish greatly. While explaining the poverty in the country, swift stirs up emotions throughout his text. For example, the author want s you to feel pity and sadness when he says “move tears and pity in the most savage and inhuman breast.” When describing the processing of a child into something edible, the diction used very powerful and graphical to make the reader feel the horror and dissatisfaction of his modest proposal. His use of diction throughout the text is what tended to create much discomfort reading it.
In his writing, Swift also takes into account the many opposing views. He knows his modest proposal would stir up negative emotions and conflicting views. So in order to counteract those opposing views, he decides to offer a more humane and ethical approach in resolving this poverty issue. The work shows a clear rebuttal and a more favorable one because he does not want to kill all the babies; rather help those in need become better people. I believe that his modest proposal was taken a bit far in stating that they should kill the babies and then earth them. His second proposal however, is more human and morality right approach to solving the problem.
The proposal at first, full with emotion, statistic and support, was not the greatest and controversial but the use of rhetoric and his satirical ways made the plan more believable and easier to carry out.