Analyzing Historical Documents: The Haitian Revolution, Eyewitness Accounts

2051 words - 9 pages

The Declaration of the Rights of Man and of the Citizens in 1789 was a key incentive for the Haitian Revolution of 1789-1803. This declaration was pivotal in defining the rights that all men were entitled to. For instance, the framers of the declaration proclaimed that “men are born…free and equal in respect of their civil rights…” and that all men were entitled to liberty, rights to own property, security, resistance of oppression, freedom of speech, and protection under the law. The declaration was perceived by members of society very differently. For example, the people of color view the declaration as a tool for demanding their rights. For the slaves, the declaration was a motivation to ...view middle of the document...

His account is very important because it is one of the few firsthand accounts that shows us the ambiguity of Ogé’s rebellion. René Verneuil’s document itself does not explain why he produced it, however, we can say that this document was part of Verneuil’s testimony and conclude that it also shows ambiguity on the part of the white society towards free people of color. The degree of familiarity of the Verneuil’s with the subject discussed in the document is to some extent limited. First, as a white property owner in St. Domingue, Verneuil, like other white property owners had a limited relationship with people of Ogé group. However, during captivity, Verneuil had the opportunity of knowing Ogé. The author of his narrative was a direct observant of the event because he was the one taken captive for a few days. I believe that we do not have any reason to believe that what Verneuil described is not what he believed.
Verneuil accounts describe how he was captive and what happened during his captivity. First he mentions that while he was at Laroque’s house with three other persons, Ogé and his men’s arrived at the house on horseback and armed, took them prisoners to the presbytery. During captivity, he was treated very well, since he was allowed to keep his weapons and offered food. It is precisely this that make us conclude that Ogé rebellion was vague. On the one hand he is fighting to gain political rights for free people of color. Since, according to Verneuil, Ogé motivation for the uprising was to take control over the colony since “he was the commandant of Saint-Domingue” (46). Yet, at the same time, he wanted to maintain the institution of slavery since he owns slave and his wealth depended on slave labor. It is clear that Ogé had more in common with Verneuil, since they were both property owners with interest in maintaining the institution of slavery, than with the slaves that were helping him. That explain his preferential treatment towards Verneuil. From his accounts, we learned that Ogé was willing to “raise the plantation slaves” if it was necessary in order to gain control over Saint Domingue, even if that caused greater troubles. Meaning that gaining political power, even if it causes the dissolution of the institution of slavery, was more important.
“The Battle in the Harbor: The Testimony of a Man of Color” is the narrative of Francois Lapierre, a free man of color. In this narrative, Lapierre described his experience when he was captured by white men. Lapierre gave this testimony on August 12, 1793, to the Civil Commissioners of the Republic. Lapierre is very familiar with the subject discussed in this document because his testimony was based on his experience with the French sailors. The information provided in this document comes from a direct observer and was obtained first hand. We do not have reasons to believe that Lapierre does not believe what he is describing. The intended audience of “The Battle in the Harbor” is...

Find Another Essay On Analyzing Historical Documents: The Haitian Revolution, Eyewitness Accounts


799 words - 4 pages was to compile transcripts of occurrences for the historical recounting of key events, figures; and, biographies from battles, wars and the transformations of Egypt. The compilations derive from historical documentation and eyewitness accounts of events. The original text for The Accounts contained a series of biographies. By the sixth century – the time of Ibn al-Muqaffa – many significant events occurred, the record grew longer, was expanded and


776 words - 4 pages purpose for the patriarchs of the Coptic Church to compile transcripts of occurrences was for the historical recounting of key events, figures; and, biographies from battles, wars and the transformations in Egypt. The compilations derive from historical documentation and eyewitness accounts of events that detail the conquests of Egypt. The original text, which was written in the tenth century, contained a series of biographies. By the sixth

Five Extremely Important Figures of the Haitian Revolution

804 words - 3 pages -------------------------Toussaint-L'Ouverture was born in 1743, in the city of Cap Francais, Saint Domingue, to slave parents. Toussaint was self-educated. He acted as physician to the army and became a leader of the Haitian slave revolt, which is a 1791 black slave uprising against French colonial rule. After France abolished slavery in the territory in 1794, Toussaint supported the French rulers of the country against British invaders and was

Historical Analysis of The Industrial Revolution

1166 words - 5 pages The Industrial Revolution was one of the most impactful eras in the history of the world. It changed the way we worked, lived, owned, and generally thought. With advent of economic philosophies like capitalism and communism, the way we worked and lived was written down and itemized, and western civilization was never the same. The concepts of jobs, urbanization, and credit might have allowed the world to progress into a veritable economical

Any historical event with-world changing consequences will always have two sides to the story. What most Americans refer to today as the American Revolution is no different

6411 words - 26 pages Any historical event with-world changing consequences will always have two sides to the story. What most Americans refer to today as the American Revolution is no different. As Americans, most of us view eighteenth-century England as a tyrannical power across the ocean, and see men like George Washington as heroes who fought against the oppressor. If history and wars were that simple, everyone would understand them, and the need for wars would

Historical Factors of the French Revolution

1389 words - 6 pages The three main contributory factors that I am going to focus on are the aristocracy, rising debt levels and inequality amongst the people of France. The role that King Louis XVI and his wife Marie Antoinette had before and during the revolution was a key factor in starting the revolution. His attitude towards his role as king was poor. He was shy, indecisive and disinterested in politics from a very early age and this continued throughout his

The Patriot - a Vision into the American Revolution. this essay is an explaination of the 2000 film the patriot it explains the historical accuracies and inaccuracies of the film

1112 words - 4 pages and did indeed interfere with the British communications systems and other British commodities . Other bases for Martin's character were Thomas Sumpter and Andrew Pickins, both of which had moderate roles in the Revolution. In our historical accounts, Sumpter was the main person Banastre Tarleton (the basis for Tavington's character) was chasing.Though not the main character in the film, Gabriel holds the namesake. It is a common misconception to

From a historical point of view, is the Reformation an act of religious reform or an act of political revolution?

854 words - 3 pages The initial purpose of the Reformation was to abolish the corruption in the Catholic Church. Eventually, due to the failure of that, a new religion was formed with a new theory upon religion, which the Catholics did not accept. However, this reformation did not only start a new religion with new ideas, it also started a political and economical revolution. It is acceptable to say that the Reformation was actually a political revolution rather

Haitian DBQ essay write an essay about the haitian document use all document - AHS - Essay

1160 words - 5 pages the enlightenment is an actual influence for the revolution. The Haitian revolution was a global event also because it shook the globalized throne of European supremacy, as shown in documents 3, 6, and 7. Europe during the late 1700’s had begun their legacy of imperialism, reaching out to all part of the world for their various reasons. The Haitian revolution had seriously disrupted and scared this European supremacy. Mark Almond (doc. 3) explains

Self-Government and Emancipation

1227 words - 5 pages Emancipation and Self-GovernmentBy: Bailey HicksNovember 12, 2014Question Number Three (3)Throughout history, there have been many accounts of rebellion as a result of unfair treatment or mistreatment of certain laws, but from a personal aspect, I do not think any have quite been like the Haitian. The Haitian Revolution was one not like any other rebellion. It was one that I believe really spoke out for the population of African Americans, but

Haiti Revolution

690 words - 3 pages The Haitian revolution is the only slave revolt that eventually led to the founding of state. This revolution that set thousands of slaves free was silenced for years and the understanding the reason for silencing this event will help to demonstrate its importance in world’s history. The Haitian revolution is most certainly a historical event of great importance and a lasting impact and the silencing that accompanied it shows not only its

Similar Essays

Analyzing Historical Documents: The Debate Of Valladolid

973 words - 4 pages The 1550 debate at Valladolid, Spain is considered to be one of the most important debate in the history of conquest of the New World because it questioned its legitimacy. The objective of the debate between Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda and Bartolome de Las Casas was to discuss the capability of the Indians to govern themselves. Juan Ginés de Sepúlveda was a humanist theologian, who served as Charles V official historian. In his book, On the Reasons

The Haitian Revolution Essay

1693 words - 7 pages . Martin's, 2001. Print. Hamilton, Tim and Sharma, Satish. "The violence and oppression of power relations" Peace Review: A Journal of Social Justice 9.4 (1997). 22 Mar. 2011 Knight, W. Franklin, “The Haitian Revolution” The University of Chicago press The American Historical Review, vol. 105, No. 1 (Feb., 2000. )

The Haitian Revolution Essay

2447 words - 10 pages The cause and effects of the Haitian Revolution have played, and continue to play, a major role in the history of the Caribbean. During the time of this rebellion, slavery was a large institution throughout the Caribbean. The success of the sugar and other plantations was based on the large slave labor forces. Without these forces, Saint Domingue, the island with the largest sugar production, and the rest of the Caribbean, would face the threat

A Historical Comparison Of The Haitian And American Revolutions

1123 words - 4 pages revolutions in both of these countries would have been unsuccessful were it not for the crippling problems faced by both opposing superpowers. The success of the Haitian revolution was due in no small part to the political turmoil brought about by the French revolution. This weakened the ability of the colonial administrators in Haiti to maintain order and caused the authority of colonial officials to no longer be clear; even the very legitimacy of